5 ms·
Agreed. We should just be allowed to run native apps. Yes, yes, I know that I can jailbreak my phone even today... But store apps didn't solve the malware prob
by raxxorrax 6y ago
Agreed. We should just be allowed to run native apps. Yes, yes, I know that I can jailbreak my phone even today...
But store apps didn't solve the malware problem, it just handed large companies a near monopoly for software distribution. That is far worse than the threat of malware. That MS tried to release an OS where only store apps are allowed wasn't really due to security concerns. They wanted to push their ecosystem.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> But store apps didn't solve the malware problem They do a lot better than just trusting .exes from the web.
- krapp 6y agoDo they? App stores are literally just trusting executables from the web with extra steps. Unless you're downloading the source code, reviewing it thoroughly and compiling it, you're blindly trusting someone.
- MattGaiser 6y agoYou are trusting a company in Apple or Android to review it as they have a reputation to protect with you. It isn’t perfect, but you are trusting someone you share a mutual interest with rather than a random stranger.
- raxxorrax 6y agoDidn't seem to have worked with TikTok and I don't trust either to make the decision for me. Be that as it may, it should still be normal to run your own programs without anyone needing to sign them off.
- nl 6y agoNot really - you see the permissions requested by the app when it executes and are promoted to allow it. That is a better model than older OSes which give access to anything that user has access to.
- krapp 6y agoThe random stranger has more to lose than the big corporation, though. Apple or Mozilla can weather a security breach or exploit because and suffer minimal loss, whereas the random stranger's entire reputation might be destroyed in a few bad forum posts.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- moreira 6y agoYes, they do do better. There is no need for conjecture; there is a wildly popular OS that runs apps exclusively from an App Store, and there is virtually no malware for that platform. There are also OSs where you can run random .exes from the web, and those OSs are indeed more susceptible to malware. You do still need to trust someone, but the parent never said you didn't. They said that store apps do better than trusting random .exe's from the web, which is true.
- nl 6y ago> App stores are literally just trusting executables from the web with extra steps. The fine grained permissions system (giving camera permissions on a temporary basis etc) is something executables don't have, and PC operating systems are only retrofitting now. The sandboxed data storage model on mobile apps is stronger than the default PC model.