7 ms·
I think tech people fundamentally misunderstand how the privacy-conscious features of Apple resonate with the non-technical public. The vast majority of the pu
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I think tech people fundamentally misunderstand how the privacy-conscious features of Apple resonate with the non-technical public.
The vast majority of the public do not care, at all, about the type of data tracking that gets HNers so up in arms. That may be a bit of hyperbole - they may care a teeny bit, but the second they have to do something that is even the slightest bit inconvenient in order to get more privacy ("Why do I have to log in here again?") they'll bail.
What Apple has done, though, is frame privacy-consciousness in terms of exclusivity and luxury. It's quite similar to how Tesla rebranded electric cars from dorky and stodgy to cool. Most people's experience with Apple's privacy-conscious features are Touch ID and Face ID. These felt really futuristic when they first came out. And the privacy messaging that Apple does is really great IMO: it's more along the lines of "With Google all your data is shared with crappy advertisers along with the rest of the unwashed masses. With Apple everything is safe and secure, and most importantly protected from their grubby little non-Jony Ive-approved hands."
This has real benefits to consumers (because the privacy advancements with Apple are not just marketing, they're real), but people should understand Apple is still based around exclusivity and luxury, and privacy is just a part of that.
- snowwrestler 6y agoThis is not supported by polling data. See for example: https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2019/11/15/americans-and-privacy-concerned-confused-and-feeling-lack-of-control-over-their-personal-information/ https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2019/11/15/americans-an... "Some 81% of the public say that the potential risks they face because of data collection by companies outweigh the benefits, and 66% say the same about government data collection."
- Icathian 6y agoAsking people whether they care and making them prove it by subjecting themselves to the slightest inconvenience may result in different conclusions.
- pier25 6y agoExactly. I only know two persons in real life (other than me) that care about data privacy and act on that. Of course if you ask most people they will say that yeah they care about privacy, but their actions tell a different story.
- kohtatsu 6y agoMost people simply haven't learned the hygiene yet. It can be as simple as showing them to open incognito for specific searches or topics, or to install a trusted tracker blocking extension like ublock origin and set it up for them. Managing app location privileges is a big one too, iOS is really good about nagging for background location permissions and I appreciate that a lot, but a lot of people don't realize if you give Facebook or another app "while using", you can bet money it will use it whenever you open the app. https://business.financialpost.com/technology/tim-hortons-app-tracking-customers-intimate-data https://business.financialpost.com/technology/tim-hortons-ap... The Tim Hortons app logged this guy's location 2,700 times in 5 months. He didn't find out until the iOS 13 background location warning. https://cdn.iphoneincanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/ios-13-location-data-apps.jpeg https://cdn.iphoneincanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/ios... People care, most of them just aren't as literate as the typical HN user so they either don't have a clue what's really happening, or simply throw their hands up in the air.
- sidibe 6y agoIgnorance was a stronger argument a few years ago, I think now it's just an optimistic take by privacy advocates. Vast majority of people today know Google/Facebook is Big Brother and that knowledge doesn't matter to them nearly as much as some hoped.
- jldugger 6y ago> Most people simply haven't learned the hygiene yet. There's an entire class of problems you cannot solve through 'hygiene.' Equifax, for example, collected data on you without your consent, and got in trouble for unintentionally giving it away when they're supposed to be getting money in exchange.
- parthdesai 6y agoHow many of those 81% are willing to delete facebook, messenger and instagram though?
- simonh 6y agoProbably very few if that’s what their friends use, but that doesn’t mean they don’t resent it. A billion people might use Facebook, but 1.3 billion use iMessage. I think this is a significant risk for services that don’t respect user privacy.
- parthdesai 6y agoI call bullshit on more people using iMessage than any of facebook related services. In this case, I feel like you've a very North American point of view. Majority people who have a smart phone has one of fb/whatsapp/instagram accounts, while iPhones don't even make up for the majority of market share when it comes to smartphone.
- simonh 6y agoHuh, that's interesting. I'm a Brit with a Chinese wife and spend a lot of time over there as well, so I'd hardly call my views America centric. There are a dozen countries I've spent more time in than the USA. It is possible I have a geographic bias, Facebook is barely a thing in China.
- parthdesai 6y agoBut China is an exception. This link says Whatsapp has 1.5 billion active users! https://www.businessofapps.com/data/whatsapp-statistics/ https://www.businessofapps.com/data/whatsapp-statistics/
- prewett 6y agoThat's a bad metric. I find Facebook a privacy disaster (and user hostile and i am less happy when I use it). But am I willing to delete it? No, because if I meet someone I can friend them on FB later, and it's my only means of communication for some people. If a better communications network were available I would switch, but since there isn't, I can't.
- arkades 6y agoExpressed Preferences vs. Revealed Preferences >19% of the public uses google and/or facebook services.
- Jtsummers 6y agoI think more non-technical people care than you realize. The problem is that many of them care about the wrong things (misunderstanding what the systems are doing) or don't understand how to regain their privacy. They also largely distrust Apple because "It's just another company and they're all alike". As an example of misunderstanding: Apple attempts to guess at pairs of phone numbers, email addresses, and names based on the data on the phone using analysis on the phone. So someone emailed a colleague a phone number (From: Bob, Body: "Hey, call me at 555-555-5555"). They get a call from 555-555-5555 and "Bob" comes up in the caller ID. It freaked them out, "I haven't added them to my contacts! Apple is reading my email!". This misunderstanding of what the systems are doing and how they're doing it creates an appearance of something "wrong" happening, even when it's not. The inability to distinguish these things leads to "they're all the same" and other perspectives that cause the non-technical people (especially, but even many technical people) to give up. They care, but they don't know how to overcome it (short of getting a dumb phone or a feature phone and moving off grid).
- wuunderbar 6y agoI think they care, but they don't necessarily equate using Apple over Google as to be being more secure and private (the premise in this thread). They likely see both as secure enough.
- Nicksil 6y ago>The vast majority of the public do not care, at all, about the type of data tracking that gets HNers so up in arms. That's a hell of a claim. What's your source on this?
- adamsea 6y ago> What Apple has done, though, is frame privacy-consciousness in terms of exclusivity and luxury. That's an interesting point. Without delving into the rest of your comment, I'd like to expand on that one bit and add that part and parcel with exclusivity and luxury, part of Apple's brand has been simplicity, quality, and joy (or pleasure in use). Like many luxury brands ; ). Or high-end brands. It's a mix. And I think that Apple is using it's privacy features to enhance the "quality" and "simple" part of their brand in addition to the other aspects you mentioned.
- ummonk 6y ago“Slightest bit inconvenient” is hyperbole. People are busy; don’t blame users if privacy features are built to be too inconvenient for users to adopt. This is where Apple helps too by making privacy easier, e.g. Apple SSO.
- reaperducer 6y agoThe vast majority of the public do not care, at all, about the type of data tracking that gets HNers so up in arms That was true maybe five years ago, but the HN meme is no longer true. I interface with a lot of wetware for my job, and I've seen a shift. People have learned to care about privacy. Some of the education has come from the mass media. Some of it from the creepiness of seeing a product you viewed on one web site follow you around to all the other web sites you visit. Some of it has come from the privacy alert boxes on Apple devices. Some of it from the thousands of TV commercials for privacy services. The notion that "nobody cares" is simply not true anymore. If it was, then there wouldn't be a demonstrated market for all of the privacy tools out there.
- spideymans 6y agoAccording to the article, 30 percent of iPhone users have turned off IFDA tracking > Notably, Facebook has declined to even show app install advertisements to the 30% of U.S. iPhone users that turned off their IDFA of their own accord — and now it is opt-in, instead of opt-out. That is a massive proportion. Especially when you consider that the IFDA setting is buried three or four screens app in the settings app. 30 percent of users went way out of their way to turn tracking off. That tells me that a lot more users care about their privacy than we might assume
- matwood 6y agoI agree. The layperson may not know the ins and outs, but most people say they want privacy. Apple doing privacy things, marketing said things, and getting news coverage of said things does eventually filter down to the average person. So while few outside tech may really understand IDFA, all the privacy moves Apples makes in aggregate do make it out to the regular person. Unfortunately, as you touch on, privacy is yet another thing that only people with money get to have.
- yalogin 6y agoThis is not how the tech hype works though. Chrome was hyped up by tech people who despised IE and desperately wanted an alternative. They sold it enough to the non tech crowd. Similarly the privacy conscious tech crowd will sell it to the rest of the bunch. At the end of the day even if people don’t care about privacy it’s still something they can feel good about and it matters.