6 ms·
I guess the taxpayers are also the people who buy stuff from China so by and large they're just subsidizing themselves? Given how ubiquitous ordering stuff fro
by Barrin92 6y ago
I guess the taxpayers are also the people who buy stuff from China so by and large they're just subsidizing themselves?
Given how ubiquitous ordering stuff from China is these days I'm not really sure the first impression of this being some good deal is accurate.
In fact subsidizing transport to a degree might probably have a progressive effect because low wage earners are more likely to order cheaper foreign goods.
- lenkite 6y agoThere were a truckload of articles on this published over the last several years, even during the Obama administration, on how this "international China shipping" being cheaper than "domestic shipping" destroyed small businesses and was also responsible for hundreds (likely thousands) of American deaths thanks to cheap fentayl shipments. This was the most nonsensical self-destructive American policy that strangely never caught much mainstream media attention.
- xzel 6y agoWith the potency to weight ratio Fentanyl has, do you really think the shipping being slightly more expensive will make it cost prohibitive? "A kilogram of heroin is purchased for approximately $6,000 and sold for appropriately $80,000." [1] Paying a few more dollars for shipping, which would be the case, doesn't make a dent in profitability. 1. https://www.affirmhealth.com/blog/word-on-the-street-fentanyl https://www.affirmhealth.com/blog/word-on-the-street-fentany...
- lenkite 6y agoI am truly disappointed at the downvotes and the complete lack of research done by down-voters. The answer to your question is "Yes" not because of cost prohibition - but because most fentayl imports are less than 700 grams - which get lost in the massive flood of UPS e-Packet shipments and thus near impossible to inspect. I beg you to carry out your own research before expressing such disbelief. Please read this briefing by the US trade commission https://www.usitc.gov/publications/332/executive_briefings/ebot_george_serletis_fentanyl_from_china_pdf.pdf https://www.usitc.gov/publications/332/executive_briefings/e... "The illicit trade follows the standard e-commerce model of small-scale shipments and B2C and B2B distribution channels. The trade is SME-focused, with small-scale Chinese suppliers primarily exporting to individuals and small independent U.S. criminal networks.China was the source of 97 percent of inbound shipments of high-purity fentanyl during 2016 and 2017" "Given the high purity of Chinese fentanyl, most illicit imports are less than 700 grams (1.5 lbs.) per shipment. "
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> I am truly disappointed at at the downvotes and the complete lack of research done by down-voters. The answer to your question is "Yes" not because of cost prohibition - but because most fentayl imports are less than 700 grams - which get lost in the massive flood of UPS e-Packet shipments and thus near impossible to inspect. So what? 100 grams would be bought, by the numbers above, for $600 and sold for $8,000. If shipping cost $200, no one would care. That would add $2,000 in shipping costs to the full kilogram, but, again, no one would care. It's just not significant. Do you have an argument to advance that isn't ludicrous on its face?
- lenkite 6y agoIt is not a matter of the shipping cost. Can you please state which statement do you find ludicrous ? 1. Chinese fentayl shipments do not need to have high weight due to purity. Mentioned explicitly in the trade commission report linked above. 2. Due to 1), it is convenient to leverage e-packet shipment as inspection of massive volume of e-packet shipments is near impossible. 3. Small-scale US businesses were adversely affected by e-packet rates https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/10/trump-changes-terminal-dues-and-epacket-rates/573337/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/10/trump...
- close04 6y ago>> There were a truckload of articles [...] on how this "international China shipping" being cheaper than "domestic shipping" destroyed small businesses > It is not a matter of the shipping cost. Seems like your original point was centered on shipping costs destroying domestic businesses. In light of the downvotes it became mostly a matter of drug imports in small, cheap packages: > most fentayl imports are less than 700 grams - which get lost in the massive flood of UPS e-Packet shipments and thus near impossible to inspect Which is irrelevant, shipping costs (within reason) won't change this.
- lenkite 6y ago"Seems like your original point was centered on shipping costs" I made both points right at the beginning, though the thread got focused around one of them. 1. e-packet shipping cost adversely affecting US businesses 2. e-packet being used to hide fentayl shipments thanks to massive volume and delivery convenience. (cheap and fast) "Which is irrelevant, this will be the case regardless of the shipping costs, within reason." I fail to understand this statement. How will reduction of e-packets - one of the major causes of the bloat of international packages not help in inspection ? If you reduce the total number of e-packets by removing the subsidy, then it becomes far easier to inspect which packages have fentayl and which do not. EMS shipments apparently quadrupled after the e-packet scheme was introduced which adversely affected all inspection procedures as agencies could not cope with the volume. Reduce the volume by removing the subsidy - the inspection agencies can then manage their job.
- imtringued 6y agoI'm not sure if you read the article you linked. It clearly refers to easier smuggling. If it was possible to just "ship" heroin then those profit margins wouldn't exist. The heroin would be bought for $6k and sold for say $6.5k. The reason why it sells for that much is because a substantial portion of the margin is spent on smuggling.
- arcticfox 6y agoI think the point is that part of the reason the goods are cheaper foreign is because they can't be made here at all, when shipping is 5x more expensive than importing from China.
- Barrin92 6y agoaccording to statista[1], the average weight of cross-border packages is about 1 lbs or so, so according to that table shipping from China would be about 1$ cheaper. As the article itself states "You can see from the above anything under 4 ounces is actually cheaper to ship from China. From 4 ounces to 8 ounces the rates are pretty comparable. Once you start hitting about 2 lbs, the prices from shipping within the U.S. start to get comparatively cheaper and cheaper than shipping from within China." I seriously doubt this was ever an existential in the sense of the shipping cost itself destroying a business. China is simply able to produce cheaper things because they have lower labour cost and so on, and that is actually good for American consumers. It's simply free trade. If anything I see a much bigger threat in the ability of the US to raise the prices, because given the current administration it may be used as a protectionist tool. [1]https://www.statista.com/statistics/974065/cross-border-delivery-package-weight-worldwide/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/974065/cross-border-deli...
- queuep 6y ago> It's simply free trade. How can it possibly be free trade if one side is subsidized and one side is not. This is a good thing, I hope same thing will happen in Europe, if it haven't already. The law/agreement in europe is to help people send hand written letters across the globe, and to help people from poor regions send letters ro the more developed regions on earth. This was the case back then, now, the same agreement is used so that you can send stuff worldwide without any fee. That is NOT free trade. https://www.svenskhandel.se/contentassets/5db334c2740b4b7ebec178fb96f94b8e/nordic-commerce-sector-submission-regarding-distortion-of-competition-from-3rd-country-online-platforms-and-terminal-dues-002.pdf https://www.svenskhandel.se/contentassets/5db334c2740b4b7ebe...
- 6y ago
- pochamago 6y agoIt's basically a reverse tarriff, placing a market barrier on your own industries for no good reason.
- roenxi 6y agoIf people had to make an explicit choice between ($1 shipping cost and $2 taxes) vs ($2 shipping cost and $0 taxes) they'd choose the unsubsidised option. "they're just subsidizing themselves" -> they are spending money that they wouldn't choose to spend if they had fine grained control over the taxes they paid.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoFor lots of things, though, that really isn't the clear cut choice. You pay health insurance so you don't have to pay the full cost later on. And it could easily be that the shipping cost + taxes generally means that the system stays afloat. And besides, if you tax correctly, it wouldn't be the same rate for everyone (income taxes should be higher for those making more, for example) nor would it be more than the flat shipping costs so long as the tax money actually went to the postal service. In both cases, are the employees getting paid fair wages? Does the tax mean I'm not getting charged for receiving packages? Are there hidden costs to the lower amount?
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> You pay health insurance so you don't have to pay the full cost later on. When you buy health insurance you pay more than the expected value of the full cost, both as a result of the cost of providing the insurance and the over-consumption as a result of insurance making patients price insensitive. The reason you buy insurance is in case your medical bills are more than average and you can't afford them. For the average person the insurance is a net loss but the cost savings of not having it aren't worth the risk. > And it could easily be that the shipping cost + taxes generally means that the system stays afloat. If the system is worth more than it costs then it will be able to charge prices that allow it to stay afloat. We generally don't need systems that cost more than they're worth. > And besides, if you tax correctly, it wouldn't be the same rate for everyone (income taxes should be higher for those making more, for example) nor would it be more than the flat shipping costs so long as the tax money actually went to the postal service. Everybody always wants somebody else to pay for it. But it's the people in the middle and not at the top who actually pay for stuff, because they're the only ones numerous enough to do it. > In both cases, are the employees getting paid fair wages? That sounds like a question for the employees and not the customers. Naturally if they're getting paid below market rates they should consider seeking other employment. > Does the tax mean I'm not getting charged for receiving packages? You can already get charged for receiving packages. It's called COD. Nobody really uses it because it's much more convenient to charge up front than have the carrier try to collect payment from the recipient.
- unishark 6y agoBoth the seller and the buyer benefits from the subsidy, while only the taxpayer pays for it. So the net benefit is to the chinese seller and net loss is to the taxpayers, which only partly mitigated if they are buyers too.
- dx034 6y agoThe environment suffers though. Shipping it in bulk to the US and from there to the customer is more efficient and allows for returns to be reused, creating less waste.
- megous 6y agoI don't think individual Chinese are rafting your goods individually over the pond.
- drdec 6y agoFYI, the US Post Office is an independent agency with its own budget. It does not receive taxpayer money. So really what was happening is that other people or companies sending mail or packages were subsidizing overseas mail and packages.
- asciident 6y agoI would make the case that they do receive taxpayer money. They have a legal right and monopoly to show ads in your mailbox. Without that, they would not exist. Imagine if Facebook were legally allowed to drive by your house and play recordings of ads over a loudspeaker every morning. Facebook would pay the government for that privilege. The government is selling your attention daily (worth billions, if anyone company were to have the ability to charge for it the same way), and giving it to the post office for free.
- mcv 6y agoIf you want cheaper products with lower shipment costs, why not subsidise them locally? Why pay to make buying abroad cheaper while making your local products more expensive?
- megous 6y agoIf you're creative, you can have free local shipping too, or just pay $2-4 to get shipped pretty much anything. It's just sligtly more expensive than standard aliexpress shipping, which is $1.5 or so. The major thing compared to local stuff is lack of VAT on cheap foregin goods. Noone locally can compete with that. Also most of the stuff I buy on Aliexpress (electronic components, SBCs, ...) simply isn't available locally, or is simply bought there and resold locally (because the manufacturer's main shop is Aliexpress).