4 ms·
The essay makes some astute observations, advances some interesting theses, and then bloviates all over the place, making judgments of questionable provenance.
by Apocryphon 6y ago
The essay makes some astute observations, advances some interesting theses, and then bloviates all over the place, making judgments of questionable provenance.
More interesting is to see what aspects of it can fit the HN milieu. How does the bureaucrat and the corporate genre fit the startup scene and the tech industry?
- csa 6y ago> How does the bureaucrat and the corporate genre fit the startup scene and the tech industry? I think the Gervais Principle answers this question nicely. There was a series of essays based on GP that was written by someone formerly active on HN that can only be found on the way back machine that ties GP into modern Silicon Valley. I’m intentionally leaving out this former HNer’s name because he took down his blog for reasons of professional discretion. I don’t think it’s that hard to find, though.
- non-entity 6y agoGP is a very interesting read, albeit one that left me mildly depressed after reading it. I'll have to try and look for this.
- csa 6y agoYou can find the person and dead links to their blog in this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5574429 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5574429 I think that’s a sufficient hint while not piercing the blogger’s veil of anonymity Please respect his/her desire for a modicum of professional privacy if you figure out who I am referring to.
- jalgos_eminator 6y agoI think an interesting business question is: when does a startup shift from being highly customer/usability focused to focused on making money? We've seen many companies start off by creating innovative products, and now they all just seem like cash grabs. Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Apple, Nike, etc. Do they start to become constrained by marketing? i.e. their actual innovation won't earn them many more sales, and only by marketing more they can increase sales? Do all companies that get big enough (in revenue) do this?
- zozbot234 6y agoWhen you can't innovate anymore and your userbase is as large as it's ever going to be, what's left to do other than monetize? The problem with startups is not that they all seek to "cash grab" at some point, but that they often do so in highly non-transparent ways, sometimes even actively abusing a monopoly position. The reason you'll see them try to grow via marketing is that this is cheaper and safer than trying to innovate.
- jalgos_eminator 6y agoI guess the followup question is: is this inevitable? The cynic in my says yes, but I don't want to believe it. Many people want to make the world a better place (including myself), but then just become a marketing manager or some other cog in the money making machine. Maybe we've been sold a narrative about society that doesn't hold with the economics of society.
- Apocryphon 6y agoI think it's inevitable if your business operates under specific environments that force you in that direction- for instance, often when a company takes VC funding and is required to make certain returns.
- Orou 6y agoMy take, and I'd love to hear any contrasting opinions, is that this is due to shareholder supremacy. Once a company has shareholders, it is beholden to them. The purpose of the company isn't to innovate, or do good in the world, or make their customers happy. It's to make money for their shareholders. Now, in order to make that money for shareholders, they're going to need customers that are satisfied with their product. They might need to innovate to stay competitive. They might need to actually make the world a bit better in order to stay solvent. But at the end of the day, they aren't going to sacrifice shareholder rewards for their customers, innovation, the betterment of the world at large, or for anything else. It's simply not their modus operandi.
- Barrin92 6y ago>How does the bureaucrat and the corporate genre fit the startup scene and the tech industry? like a glove. Tech today is dominated by basically two forms of business. The Googles and Facebooks and so on, which fit the Weberian bureaucracy that the author addresses, arguably even more than actual bureaucracy because they're rabidly trying to codify everything in software, which is in a sense more technocratic than Weber himself could have ever dreamed of, and the startup culture which is basically performative entrepreneurship, consuming a certain lifestyle to signal being part of a certain class, with the products being created performing essentially no meaningful social function and don't constitute any sort of technical progress.
- rsync 6y ago" ... and the startup culture which is basically performative entrepreneurship, consuming a certain lifestyle to signal being part of a certain class, with the products being created performing essentially no meaningful social function and don't constitute any sort of technical progress." OK, maybe - but only because you say tech today is "dominated" by these two tropes, not "consists only". There are exceptions. Obviously I have one self-serving example in mind, but let's skip that. As I brainstorm, the first one that comes to mind is NextDNS which is such a fantastic and simple idea (and one I wish I had thought of). github, too, was a very substantive and progressive model that has really changed the tech world.
- Apocryphon 6y ago> performative entrepreneurship, consuming a certain lifestyle to signal being part of a certain class The Veblenian Entrepreneur, as they say https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3479042 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3479042
- api 6y agoThere are plenty of startups providing useful functions and technical progress. They are almost universally underfunded. The money goes mostly to what you describe, especially the unicorn chasing money. Unicorns, or at least the ones that post date the coining of that word, are mostly gambling vehicles.
- 1MachineElf 6y agoThis aspect touches upon it, although I don't believe the point he is making specifically is meant to level criticism at tech startups themselves: >A Harvard Business Review study of common traits among CEOs found that the leaders who rose to that position fastest were those who had a “catapult experience”—a bold and potentially risky career move. Perhaps the same traits that lead to this type of bold action might also lead to very poor outcomes on a college campus. Perhaps hyper-permissiveness actually ends up promoting a form of timidity. We’re left with Silicon Valley dorks who microdose LSD in order to create hookup apps where users exchange sex puns on the toilet. That last dig pointing out the absurd mix of hyper-permissiveness (hookup culture) and timidity (texting) just highlights how contemporary innovation is the often twisted nexus of these two extremes, and it is the continuation of this pattern being described that makes up the neo-bureaucrat culture's cognitive dissonance.