3 ms·
The lump of labour fallacy is a result of human nature and how we organize work. Because each person can only work at a single job the loss of the job is devast
by imtringued 6y ago
The lump of labour fallacy is a result of human nature and how we organize work. Because each person can only work at a single job the loss of the job is devastating.
If you were to model a country as a single person but with the productivity of 1000000 people working 20000 different jobs then that person would complain about spending way too much time on a handful of jobs. e.g. "Too much time is spent on farming! I don't have enough time to work on my boat!" Decreasing the time spent on farming will free up time and that time can be spent on building a boat. It's clear that increasing productivity will always benefit the entire society.
The real problem is that inequality keeps growing. Especially since modern productivity improvements are often not tied to the experience or skill of the worker but rather they are dependent on investments in tools and machinery. Those tools are not owned by the worker, they are owned by the company. However, competition eventually reaches a point where the industry loses its profit margins and most of the revenue is passed onto workers or at least the workers that built the machinery and tools. But the reality remains that first mover companies make a killing with automation and acquire lots of capital.
Another factor is full employment. As we get closer to full employment the consumer inflation index will rise and capital will lose its value compared to income.
There are mechanisms that slowly erode the negative effects of inequality but right now things are happening so quickly they have trouble catching up.