12 ms·
Random Thoughts: 1. If it is shipping with Android 8 - an old version of Android. What are the chances that it will ever see any updates? 2. My wife would ha
by scarface74 6y ago
Random Thoughts:
1. If it is shipping with Android 8 - an old version of Android. What are the chances that it will ever see any updates?
2. My wife would have been the target audience for this form factor - pre Apple Watch. Her phone is her least favorite device. She will leave it in the car in a heartbeat. She won’t think twice if she leaves at home.
But now, she has a cellular Apple Watch and AirPods with a third party ear clip. She doesn’t have to carry any phone.
3. The battery life is atrocious. Even the Apple Watch has better battery life for normal day to day use.
4. I seriously doubt it has 16GB of memory - the cellular Apple Watch does. That’s more than enough for local music playback without using cellular.
5. This is the Zune of phones to me. But, yes I realize that the cheapest entry point to our setup - phone + Watch is $800 if we did get A cheaper headset. With AirPods it would be $959.
- jjeaff 6y agoThe zune of phones as in the best device made in both hardware and software quality but just too late to the game to get any traction?
- scarface74 6y agoThe Zune came out with a 30GB hard drive player when the world had moved on to flash based smaller players and three months before the iPhone The flash based Zunes similar to the Nanos came out at the same time as the second generation iPod Touch. The Zune HD came out with no apps around the end of 2009. Peak iPod - including the Touch - was 4th quarter 2008. The iPod was already losing steam and even then it was being propped up by the iPod Touch.
- unfunco 6y agoAnd it was brown.
- scarface74 6y ago<sarcasm> If you’re criticizing the Zune because it is brown, you’re a racist piece of crap. You should be Doxxed and reported to your employer </sarcasm> Yes this was a real argument made at the time.
- neodymiumphish 6y agoThese are all true, but the Zune was still awesome... Video support, awesome customizations, and a very fun interface. I had all 3 of the Zunes you mentioned. My least favorite was the original, because the spinning disc would sometimes hit buffering issues, but the rest of the device family was practically perfect.
- scarface74 6y agoPerfect as long as you didn’t care about third party apps - which were very much a thing by 2009 when the Zune HD came out.
- rapind 6y agoIt might be a generational thing but I couldn't care less about third party apps. All I use: email, browser, maps, phone, txt, calendar, camera (non essential for me).
- scarface74 6y agoNo it’s not a generational thing - it’s you. That’s like the old Slashdot meme - “I haven’t owned a TV in 10 years Do people still watch TV?”. Seeing that my first computer was an Apple //e in 86, I’m definitely not a young buck.
- nogabebop23 6y agoit's not just him, there is a sizeable contingent of people who focus on just these apps for all their uses, and I think it would be much bigger if mobile didn't promote separate apps for everything.
- jjeaff 6y agoOur customer base skews older and you wouldn't believe how many customer service tickets we field where they don't know what their apple account password is because they have literally never installed an app on their phone before. And these are people with brand new, most recent model iPhones that get a new one every few years.
- 013a 6y agoThe Zune 30, the first Zune, and the only 30gb Zune player you could be speaking about, was released in Nov 2005. By comparison, Apple's flash offerings in 2005 included the 1G Shuffle (1gb) and the 1G Nano (4gb). These were not large and complex enough devices to be considered competitors to the Zune 30; Apple's competitor to the Zune 30 was the 5G Classic, which came in 30/60/80gb hard drive sizes. I'm not sure how you got "three months before the iPhone" when the Zune 30 was released in Nov 2005 and the iPhone was released in June 2007. That's not 3 months, that's 19 months.
- scarface74 6y agoThe Zune 30 was released November 2006 (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zune_30 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zune_30). The iPhone was announced January 2007. It didn’t matter if they were “competitive”. The market had already spoken. People preferred the flash based smaller players to the larger players. MS went after the smallest part of the market.
- peruvian 6y agoLol. I had a Zune HD. Opening the calculator app took half a minute... and that was pretty much the only app available. It was a cool device but there’s no surprise it got trampled by iPod Touch.
- winrid 6y agoWow, you're only slightly exaggerating. I counted 11 seconds. https://youtu.be/iIj9W74Ju2E https://youtu.be/iIj9W74Ju2E
- skinnymuch 6y agoLoved the Zune. Not sure which I had. It wasn’t HD or anything though. It was also a launchpad for me to begin enjoying streaming and tracking things. I began tracking music listens with Last.fm and I used Microsoft’s music streaming service at the time. Usually (or always?) you’d download music onto your device and have to renew it every 30 days or so.
- jchw 6y agoAssuming you mean storage, this device apparently ships with 32 GiB of storage.
- truth_seeker 6y ago> If it is shipping with Android 8 - an old version of Android. What are the chances that it will ever see any updates? Android 8.1 to be precise. As long as google is releasing security updates it should be okay. https://developer.android.com/about/versions/oreo/android-8.1 https://developer.android.com/about/versions/oreo/android-8....
- cheesecracker 6y agoHow long will that be, is that known?
- maltelandwehr 6y agoI am not aware of any official numbers. But security and basic compatibility should be covered for a few more years; based on how long previous versions continued to receive support/updates.
- cheesecracker 6y agoThanks!
- scarface74 6y agoWhy is it okay to ship a new device with an operating system that is two versions old? Neither Windows, Mac, or iOS users have to worry about that.
- ChrisLTD 6y agoFor sake of argument, the most important thing is app support, not the operating system. I’d happily run Windows 7 or Mac OS X Snow Leopard if I could still access all the apps I use now.
- scarface74 6y agoNot entirely related to phones, but it is nice that my iPad that I bought in 2016 has gotten operating system support for external hard drives, Ethernet (long story), good support for external pointing devices, better multitasking support, etc. My wife’s iPad that is a year newer will get much better operating system wide support for the Pencil.
- numpad0 6y agoThis device is out for few years by now. Interesting but maybe worth adding (2018) to title.
- scarface74 6y agoI thought this was a newer version. However, if I pick up a 2 year old Windows/Mac computer or iOS device, I can still run the latest OS.
- elken 6y agoCan you? http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-42615378 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-42615378
- Kye 6y agoYes. My 4 year old Windows laptop and 5 year old iPhone have the latest operating system versions. The latter will get iOS 14.
- scarface74 6y agoWell, seeing that the update you cited in the article allowed the phone to continue working at a slower speed instead of shutting down entirely when the battery was old - yes. I never said that Apple could defy the laws of physics and prevent battery degradation. Also, if I bought a brand new phone that was released in 2018 and even if it did have an old operating system - but a new battery, I could update to the newest OS. If it was a used phone with an old battery - I could replace the battery for $70. My son just replaced an iPhone 6S that I bought in 2015 late last year. I replaced the battery before giving it to him. It was and still can run the latest OS version. It will be running the latest OS until at least September 2021.
- j45 6y agoIt may be news to you but Android manufacturers are generally not as honest as their intent, follow through and track record of providing up to date security patches for their phones, let alone OS updates. I switched to an Android from iPhone when Galaxy Note 1 came out. Apple did not have the audacity or innovation to release a phone with a large screen. Over time, every Android manufacturer except Google and BlackBerry proceeded to let me down with out of date security patches, if any at all. Samsung makes some of the very best devices, but pushing 6 month old patches as a current update doesn’t fly. Projects like LineageOS have made inroads too. I'd buy a Galaxy Note in a heartbeat if it ran Android One. My hope is every manufacturer uses Android One distribution, Android has come far enough that the UI modifications/customizations aren’t as critical as they used to be. I’ll only consider a Pixel or Android One device moving forward if I don't end up on an iPhone. Still, I’m typing this on an iPad, and have been on Mac for over a decade.. maybe it is time to look at an iPhone again. Part of me is exploring leaving Mac and head to Ubuntu. A palm phone with a great camera could be interesting if lineage might work on it. Edit: Typos
- rkul 6y agoDoes she reply to emails/tweets/texts via her smartwatch + airpods combo? Did she use her phone to read articles on the go? If yes, how is she getting this done with this setup?
- scarface74 6y agoNeither would I want to do that on a phone the size of the Palm. The entire idea of this phone was initially to be a companion phone just for simple things. Email isn’t really used that often anymore for personal, immediate communications. If someone is emailing you, culturally it’s really not considered urgent. Read articles on the go? Sure you can read news snippets on the Watch using the News app, but if she is leaving her phone behind, it’s specifically in a context where she doesn’t want to be distracted but does want to be able to communicate with people. I have an Apple Watch just because, but I really don’t get that much usefulness out of it. I work from home now. I haven’t gone inside a gym in years where the idea of having a phone with me all of the time was irritating - I have a fully equipped workout room at home. Besides, women often wear clothes without pockets. Men usually don’t - except maybe at the gym or while running. As far as texts. Siri’s voice recognition works surprisingly well for responding to them.
- MiddleEndian 6y agoThe Palm Phone does work as a standalone device (except maybe on Verizon). Swipe text is a little less accurate, but overall still plenty usable. Honestly not sure why they wanted it to be a "companion" device so much. One of the huge benefits of using the Palm Phone is not carrying a gigantic brick in your pocket.
- scarface74 6y agoThis was introduced at a time when there was both exhaustion at increasingly larger phones and people started complaining about “screen time” and distractions. This was suppose to address both of those issues.
- 6y ago
- moralestapia 6y ago>This is the Zune of phones to me. The Zune was a great device yo.
- scarface74 6y agoProbably as was the last Walkman in the age of the iPod...
- vinceguidry 6y agoDevices are still released under the Walkman brand, I bought one last year. They’re a great intermediate between phones and audiophile kit.
- scarface74 6y agoHow are they actually doing in the market?
- vinceguidry 6y agoWell enough they keep coming out with them every year.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoAndroid update? Happens all the time. I'm helping a client upgrade their device to 9 right now. Why the delay? The chipset manufacturer only recently came out with the BSP for Android 9. So, cost.
- scarface74 6y agoDoes Microsoft wait on the chipset manufacturer to release drivers for their operating system?
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoMaybe not. But Microsoft has 100,000+ employees. These chipset manufacturers may have 100+. So there's that.
- scarface74 6y agoMicrosoft is the operating system vendor as is Google. I’m sure Google can spare a few “smart people” (tm) to better manage the Android ecosystem.
- objclxt 6y ago> If it is shipping with Android 8 - an old version of Android Blame Qualcomm. If you’re a OEM with comparatively low volumes there is very little leverage you have to get your SOC vendor to give you the latest updates. When I worked on Android HW, Qualcomm were basically a year behind whatever the latest Android was, because our volume was so small we weren’t a priority.
- scarface74 6y agoAgain, this is a solved problem with Windows - Microsoft writes drivers for popular hardware. Like I said below - Windows 7 supported my 2006 Mac Mini hardware - USB, FireWire, gigabit Ethernet, and it even recognized the IR sensor for the remote. I couldn’t find a way to use it. If you as a PC OEM, no matter how small, if you used popular components, Windows would support it.
- arsome 6y agoI mean if random people on XDA Developers can figure out how to port AOSP or Lineage to everything, often in the span of a few days then surely you'd think device manufacturers could too without relying on Qualcomm to do it for them.
- close04 6y agoMicrosoft has a vested interest in getting Windows to run on hardware going as far back as possible, within reason. They mainly sell the OS and legacy support is a huge selling point. Phone manufacturers are at the other end of the spectrum. They sell the hardware and it's their vested interest to sell as much as they can. Making it obsolete by not offering software updates and taking advantage of the free work from XDA works perfectly for them. Being able to blame Qualcomm is even better since it's a "boogieman" that doesn't need to look good for consumers.
- scarface74 6y agoI’m not blaming the phone manufacturers - I am blaming Google. Apple definitely didn’t go out of its way to make sure that my 2006 era Mac Mini worked with Windows. But since back then, Apple used mostly standard PC components, MS supported it.
- schwartzworld 6y ago> zune of phones nobody who owned a zune would consider that a negative comparison
- memsom 6y agoDepends on the Zune I think. If it was a V1, there is a lot to hate. Also, try using it today - this guy did and it seems like he seriously struggled: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hG3Jud-829A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hG3Jud-829A
- smoe 6y agoI wonder how bad the battery life is in practice. They seem to be selling an always on battery saving mode as a quality of life feature. Which is fine for me having do not disturb activated 90% of time on my phone. All the smartphones I had in recent years I had to charge overnight. Not because they were depleted completely, but enough so that they usually run out some point the next day. And I prefer to just plug the devices in at home insted of carrying around cables and charging banks. And related question: How well does the apple or other smart watches do with audio interactions only? I have been playing with the tought of instead of having a phone, using a smart pocket watch. So not even wearing on the wrist. But just take it out once in a while and use headphones, for things like accepting call, dictate messages/notes and chose spotify playlist.
- codazoda 6y agoThat "pocket watch" idea is kinda neat. Maybe someone could bring back the pocket watch form factor. Come to think of it, that's how I used my phone before I got a smart watch.
- j45 6y agoBattery life horribleness on Android is often tied to the screen size too.
- scarface74 6y agoI wonder how bad the battery life is in practice. Third party reviews have said that it could last 18-24 hours All the smartphones I had in recent years I had to charge overnight. Not because they were depleted completely, but enough so that they usually run out some point the next day. And I prefer to just plug the devices in at home insted of carrying around cables and charging banks. That’s the same reason I bought my iPhone 8 Plus. At the time it had the best battery life of any iPhone. Now the iPhone 11 Pro Max can easily last two days on a charge but that phone is ridiculously large. How well does the apple or other smart watches do with audio interactions only? We tested ours when we first got them. I had my watch on, arms down, no headphones and we couldn’t tell that you weren’t on a phone. Of course with a headphones you couldn’t tell the difference. Apple Music works well with voice interaction. I’m not sure if Spotify has been updated to take advantage of the new APIs and Siri integration Apple introduced last year. Text messaging using voice only works well. But, if I know my wife is out and about. I try to ask simple questions in text where she can just use a quick reply - yes, no, etc.
- mark_l_watson 6y agoGood point about the Apple Watch being the truly minimal "phone." I also very frequently now leave my iPhone at home. This takes a little planning in the form of having an audio book and a few podcasts on the watch. Apple Watch + AirPods makes me feel set free when I am hiking or out of the house with family and friends. It is so easy to ignore the light vibration notification for incoming text messages or emails, and easy to ignore calls.
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoSorry this may sound stupid but does this mean the Apple iWatxh now has cellular? Oh ok - yes it does. And wi-fi ! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Watch https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Watch
- myvoiceismypass 6y agoYes, but streaming over cellular is mostly limited to support from Apple apps, not third party apps. Spotify might be the kind exception for that right now.
- Crazor 6y agoNope it‘s not.
- scarface74 6y agoThe API was added last year to allow third parties to stream and a Siri intent was added for third party music apps to work as well as Apple Music. After years of whining, Spotify took (has taken?) forever taking advantage of it.
- asciimike 6y agoIt's just streaming from the phone though, not actually over cell? I know they don't have offline, which is the main reason I've held off buying a watch and airpods for running: I only need a few hours of music, GPS, and HR, and it feels like this should be a good combo.
- jessewmc 6y agoI really like the idea of the watch instead of a phone, but it seems like they've explicitly designed it so that it will never be a stand-alone device. I don't mind buying the watch and the airpods, but having to buy a phone AND two data subscriptions (thanks Canada telecoms)? Not worth it.
- scarface74 6y agoIn day to day use, you never need the phone if you have the watch. Just for the initial setup and to pair with your data plan. But as far as cost you’re right - even with T-Mobile I pay $40 plan and $10 for the Watch data plan.
- skinnymuch 6y agoI began rambling since I’m trying to have same practices as your wife. Moved my questions to top of comment; Which Apple Watch cell version does she have. Do you happen to know the third party ear clip? I hadn’t thought of getting that. I just ordered AirPods arriving today. — This is the perfect post for me to see. I am in my second deep dive in trying to make the Apple Watch a major priority, possibly upgrading to a cellular Watch if this proves to go well. Your wife is another key point for me to push this attempt. I fit the same demo where a minimalist sort of phone like this would have been right for me. But there is no perfect and the Watch is as good or better than any other option. Especially with my lack of passive phone usage discipline. Another time I might waste a lot of time contemplating getting something like this. But I’ve finally gotten over a few remaining “needs” for always having phone on me: (1) detailed location history logging —- don’t think there’s an alternative to this. Won’t have it without a phone. (2) Siri isn’t very good at dictation on the Watch —- just have to deal with it (3) Not enough apps on the Watch —- same pattern of just deal with it. I am starting to use a few apps to put stuff into and later I can organize the info. Drafts App and Things are two main ones. Some chat/messaging apps lack proper/any Watch support. Again deal with it :p.
- scarface74 6y agoHer clips are something like these. https://www.amazon.com/New-EARBUDi-AirPods-Slides-Earhook-Amazing/dp/B06XX1Z7K9 https://www.amazon.com/New-EARBUDi-AirPods-Slides-Earhook-Am... She uses them when she is teaching online fitness classes and they stay in her ear so they are pretty good. If I were still an outdoor runner I would probably get the PowerBeats with the over the ear clips. I haven’t had any problems with Siri doing decently well for voice dictation and I have a southern accent.
- eugeniub 6y agoThe Apple Watch Series 5 has 32 GB.
- softwarejosh 6y agoit has a custom ui, aside from security which can be patched, why would they update its android version
- forgotmypw17 6y agoI think having the latest Android version is overrated. I'm using an enterprise Android 7 device that, afaik, has never gotten any firmware updates. It now sells with 8.1, but I haven't been able to find any option to upgrade on their site. All the apps I want to use are still available, F-Droid works great, I have the latest Chrome (which I use as Bromium). I've been able to disable most of Google apps, though I'm a bit sore that most of the OS breaks down when I disable Chrome.
- theshadowknows 6y agoHey man I had both a Zune and a ZuneHD. The Zune was fun and funky right when the iPod was starting to turn into a serious gadget used by Wall Street traders. I had the brown one! Now, the ZuneHD that was a sexy piece of hardware. And the screen was brilliant! I think the ZuneHD was Microsoft starting to finally get hardware right. But of course the software was terrible. Well, the client was. The “twisted” interface for the ZuneHD was actually much easier to use than music app or Spotify even today.