9 ms·
It gives what percentage of the protestors were black in each city, 18% in Atlanta, 3% in Los Angeles, 11% in Minneapolis, and 14% in New York City. In all of
by tzs 6y ago
It gives what percentage of the protestors were black in each city, 18% in Atlanta, 3% in Los Angeles, 11% in Minneapolis, and 14% in New York City.
In all of those cities that's lower than the percentage of black people in the general population, so black people were underrepresented. But they were much more underrepresented in Los Angeles and Atlanta than in Minneapolis or New York.
Here's a table. First column is percent among protestors. Second is percent among general population. Third is first column as a percent of second column.
18 52 35 Atlanta
3 11 27 Los Angeles
11 19 58 Minneapolis
14 24 58 New York City
I.e., in New York and Minneapolis you had close to 60% as many black people as you would have expected if you just went by city demographics. In Atlanta it was only 35% and only 27% in Los Angeles.
I wonder if there is some factor, especially in Los Angeles and Atlanta, that discouraged black people from wanting to attend or some hardship to attending that disproportionately fell on black people?
- bzb3 6y agoOr maybe they simply didn't agree with the premise of the protests.
- stronglikedan 6y agoOf the people I've talked to in real life, most don't, so these numbers are not too surprising to me.
- brobdingnagians 6y agoSomeone interviewed white people in New York about abolishing police and lots of them whole-heartedly agreed. They interviewed black people in New York about it, and they said it was insane to want to do that. That would fit these statistics.
- anigbrowl 6y agoIt wouldn't explain the wide statistical variation between cities.
- DanHulton 6y agoLink?
- zpallin 6y agoInteresting, do you have a link?
- ghayes 6y agoNot OP, but this Vox article has some interesting information about race disparities in viewpoints of police. [0] https://www.vox.com/2020/6/3/21276824/defund-police-divest-explainer https://www.vox.com/2020/6/3/21276824/defund-police-divest-e...
- zpallin 6y agoNice. This is very interesting. I suppose it would be hard to make any assumptions about the reasoning here. At least Vox interprets this as black people "view inadequate protection and inadequate service levels as part of the larger pattern of mistreatment." That's entirely reasonable. If someone were to believe that the police institution itself is not racist, and it's just the individual cops who are the problem, then it's fair to come to the conclusion that more policing may solve the very real issue of crime in black communities. However, just like the author of the article, I agree that we would need to see a similar poll now after the George Floyd protests to see if the opinion still stands, but it's important to note.
- rayiner 6y agoHere is a post-George Floyd poll: https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/86ijosd7cy/20200611_yahoo_race_police_covid_crosstabs.pdf https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/86ijosd7cy/20200611_yahoo_race_p... A plurality of African Americans (38-31) oppose cutting police budgets. African Americans are split 50-50 in whether we need more or fewer police on the streets. A supermajority (64-33) believe that the current police departments can be reformed. A majority (51-17) support spending less on police and increasing funding for social programs, but try to reconcile this with the statistic above, where half want more police on the streets. (People might perceive this question as reduced budgets would hit management, etc., rather than beat cops).
- 6y ago
- sukilot 6y agoWho is "someone"? How many people did they ask? What were the questions?
- godelski 6y agoFrom my understanding "abolish the police" means to reorganize it and greatly reduced the funding. For example in L.A. the police budget is about $3bn and the next biggest item is public works at $1.5bn. That's kinda a ridiculous amount. I saw a reddit post in /r/dataisbeautiful [0] that broke it down and showed some redistribution. But of course "abolish the police" means a lot of different things to different people. I'm sure there are people that want literally no police but I'm also sure they are a minority. That's kinda the problem we have today. We turn complex conversations and topics into their most extreme forms and so we can actually discuss them. And we presume the other person has an extreme view that opposes ours but we ourselves are smarter and now nuanced than the person we're "discussing" with. There's lots of examples. For example here we're discussing "should police exist" instead of "what should police be doing" and often people are even divided on the topic because "police stop bad guys" and "police are to serve the community and uphold the social contract." [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/hflutt/reimagining_the_los_angeles_city_budget_oc/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/hflutt/rei...
- serf 6y ago>From my understanding "abolish the police" means to reorganize it and greatly reduced the funding. sort of just depends on who you ask. I have people within my social circle that want to literally abolish the police -- erase the concept entirely -- citing historical examples groups of people that had no such similar concept as a central policing group. Because of fringe opinions like that I tend to take care when I read or say things like "'X' means this", because that's the power of language, some folks really do mean abolish the police, while some simply use such language with a somewhat 'hyperbolic' or satirical meaning.
- nbardy 6y agoSeconded, The power of language is incredibly important. "Defund the police", "Abolish the police", the many different ways it's being phrased are radical demands. If the people saying these things mean something else they should use another set of words. Because there are plenty of people in this movement who really want to tear things down.
- narrator 6y agoBlack people are victims of crime that is perpetrated by people who are not police officers.
- foobarian 6y agoWithout the police would we have bands of marauding warlords tormenting the citizens that are much worse than the police? Maybe some people are less aware of what that would look like, and some are more aware. Especially when it comes to their families/loved ones.
- m0zg 6y agoAnd therein lies the main problem with all of this "abolish the police" bullshit. It's driven mainly by upper middle class whites who live in low crime areas and rarely if ever need police, and think everyone is the same way. Watch the protest videos carefully - there are hardly any black people there in a lot of cases. In fact last night I counted more high end bicycles in a protest video than black people. It's a common occurrence nowadays to see a self-righteous 20 year old trust fund kid "educate" a black police officer on how to be black. This is utterly idiotic. I interacted with the police exactly 3 times in 20 years I lived in my neighborhood. Once I got a ticket for the missing front license plate on my car (deservedly so, paid the fine). Once my mailbox was broken into, and a police officer stopped by to ask questions and see if I'd press charges if they found the thief (of course I would, but they never found the guy), and once I had to call police on a neighbor who thought it'd be a wonderful idea to blast music at full volume at 2AM in the middle of the work week. That's the extent of it. There's no crime in my neighborhood, violent or otherwise, by any meaningful metric. If I thought all neighborhoods were like this, of course I'd be in favor of simultaneously defunding police and abolishing the second amendment. Having seen total lawlessness first hand during the "wild 90's" in Russia, I don't have such illusions. I once saw a dude on his knees with a gun pointed at his forehead within 200m of the Red Square, with police officers watching but not intervening in the proceedings, probably because the mobster with the gun was above their pay grade. Don't know if the guy got shot or not, I couldn't do anything anyway, so I entered the nearby subway station and went home, but the image seared into my mind. Remember, this was in the very center of a large city. You can imagine what kinds of crazy shit went on on the outskirts. People in South Chicago or in the bad parts of NY have no such illusions either. That's why I support _gradual_ police reform and increased funding (you can't, as a rule, get better service by paying less), have a safe full of guns and ammo, and will vote strenuously against any politician, irrespective of party affiliation or just about any other views, who tries to "defund" the police or restrict 2A. I fail to see how such measures would be in anyone's longer term interest.
- throwAwayAcc88 6y agoSome sort of factor, that exists most strongly in large urban centers, that discourages black people from acting out of line? Perhaps, like, a racist police force?
- Forbo 6y agoI don't know why this is being downvoted, I think it's a perfectly valid point. The entire basis of BLM protests is about use of police violence against black people. If I were black and think I'm more likely to get the shit beat out of me (pepper-balled, rubber bulleted, tear gassed, etc.) at a protest I'm more likely to avoid it entirely. Edit: On reflection, maybe the downvote was more about the tone that it was presented in?
- dang 6y agoThe site guidelines ask people not to be snarky in comments here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dsp 6y agoAnother possibility: the Mobilewalla data is bad.
- mtalantikite 6y agoWell, it could also be about the sort of data the company is collecting. Here in NYC there have been smaller protests in neighborhoods that are predominantly PoC, and this company may be only collecting data on the main large events. Also, for a place like LA, there are systemic factors of poverty and homelessness in their Black populations that might make something like ownership of a permanent mobile number less likely [1]. Regardless, this practice of data harvesting should be illegal. [1] https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-06-13/column-african-americans-make-up-8-of-l-a-population-and-34-of-homeless-count-heres-why https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-06-13/column-a...
- teenbear 6y agoYou're assuming that their information is accurate which we have no real reason to do. From the article "It’s unclear how accurate Mobilewalla’s analysis actually is"
- godelski 6y agoMore specifically > Datta told BuzzFeed News that his company, on average, has access to location data for 30% to 60% of people in any given location in the United States. And getting down to it more: which 30-60% of people? I find it odd that when HN is talking about Covid they are so keen on finding the slightest bias in data/report and arguing over that, yet in posts like this most of the comments presume accuracy. I would expect the same scrutiny (which I think is good!) everywhere.
- ThrowawayR2 6y agoNot that I have an opinion about Mobilewalla's analysis but polling gets accurate results with far less than 30-60% sampling, so that, in and of itself, is not necessarily a problem.
- ashtonkem 6y agoPolling has random sampling. We don’t know if Mobilewalla’s sampling is truly random or not.
- godelski 6y ago> polling gets accurate results with far less than 30-60% sampling, so that, in and of itself, is not necessarily a problem. I'd like to refer you to the sentence after I quoted the article. >> And getting down to it more: which 30-60% of people? Polling works hard to ensure that their data set is a representative demographic. We don't know that here. Considering that there are socioeconomic correlations between race, it isn't out of the question that this data is not representative. You could have 60% but if your data set isn't representative, you aren't going to draw accurate conclusions.
- 6y ago
- dwiel 6y agoIt's also possible that people who felt most at risk were also most likely to turn off their phones or leave them at home. It's hard to know what kind of biases are in this data without access to it.
- greenie_beans 6y agoInteresting, but is it possible that it’s bad data? What app gave them permission to have this data —- is it possible that the app’s users are a similar demographic?
- PascLeRasc 6y agoJust like voting, attending protests is a privilege to those who can afford to not be working 24/7. Lower-income jobs don't even have the concept of "time off" or flexible schedules. Protests also have the risk of being wrongfully arrested or injured and not being able to get to work the next day.