3 ms·
Have you had conversations with academics who are interested in decolonizing their fields? People are interested in decolonizing history aren't saying that we s
by UncleMeat 6y ago
Have you had conversations with academics who are interested in decolonizing their fields? People are interested in decolonizing history aren't saying that we should throw away all study of european history. They are saying that we should add more voices. This has been a project for decades, with more voices of women and poc being represented in historical analysis.
Necessarily, this means reducing the amount of time spent on "traditional western civilization" in the classroom, since there is only so much time. But go check out a renaissance history course taught by a young faculty member. White men continue to dominate the discourse. We've just added some more voices alongside them.
- marcosdumay 6y agoBrazilian here. Around here, it usually means adding low quality voices to the discussion. Although there are a few pushing for recognition of good local work, those few tends to be attacked from both sides of the discussion.
- UncleMeat 6y agoIf your opinion is that female and poc voices are "low quality" then I don't know what to say... This isn't adding voices for the sake of it. This is adding voices because those voices are an essential part of historical understanding and history suffers if you exclude them.
- marcosdumay 6y agoBad authors are bad, and good authors are good whatever sex and skin color they have. Individual author qualities are much more relevant than the social context they are immersed; if somebody doesn't understand they society they are talking about, reading them is worthless, it doesn't matter if it has an incredibly different and interesting culture. Around here there is plenty (but trending down) of pushing for authors on the basis that they are local, or non-white, or not male, or poor. There is also a lot (and trending up) of pushing for authors on the basis that they are from some "world-class" place/culture. Both approaches are classist/racist/sexist and plain stupid. Labels like "decolonizing" usually come from the first group, and anybody trying to judge local authors based on their own merits is quickly outed from that group with the argument that judging works done by such class/race/sex is classist/racist/sexist, so people using that label are almost never on the actually unprejudiced group. Besides, forcefully changing authors based on prejudice has the double effect of teaching locals that they aren't expected to create high quality work and delegating competent locals to a life of obscurity, because if you can't judge their work, you can't discover that it's any good either. But anyway, that says nothing about the subjects of study. It is always worthy to study the cultures that helped forming one's own.
- UncleMeat 6y ago> Bad authors are bad, and good authors are good whatever sex and skin color they have. Again, "voices" not "authors". And this is the whole point! People aren't elevating worthless voices for diversity sake. People are resolving a problem where valuable voices were excluded because of their identity. We are getting closer to a fair analysis, not further from it.
- marcosdumay 6y agoBy "voices" you mean diversity on the subject being studied? If so, I completely agree.
- ChristianBundy 6y agoCould you give an example?
- free_rms 6y agoThe Renaissance happened in Europe. What non-white voices are you adding to that? The Turks? There definitely was history happening in other places at that time, some of it very noteworthy, but it wasn't the Renaissance.
- UncleMeat 6y ago> The Renaissance happened in Europe. What non-white voices are you adding to that? This is a perfect example. People respond to even basic expansion of viewpoints with incredulity. First, I mentioned women. Gender analysis in mainstream history academia has developed a lot over the last 30 years. "There weren't any women" doesn't pass even a casual glance like "there weren't any poc" does for a renaissance course. Second, although white voices are obviously the dominant voices of the renaissance, it is important to understand that cross-national communication networks existed during the early-modern era. The story of the introduction of coffee to europe is a classic one where analysis has traditionally focused on the europeans involved but this failed to consider that both sides of the trade were essential to the story. Since it is the renaissance, obviously art and architecture play a huge role. But art and architecture travel between nations and you can't tell the full story of european renaissance art without considering the turks (and others).
- free_rms 6y agoI was mostly picking on your example -- the Renaissance happened in Europe, and it was specifically a time when there was relatively little trade between Europe and the east -- a big part of the reason Columbus's journey was funded was to find a way to access eastern trade routes that they'd been cut off from by the Ottomans. There were a whole bunch of interesting things happening around the world at this time, the peak of the Ming dynasty, ascendance of the Ottomans, the Malian Empire's displacement by Songhai.. they just aren't the Renaissance. An actual "expansion of viewpoints" would be reading more world history. College-pamphletizing the renaissance is lazy and inaccurate.
- UncleMeat 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gotoeleven 6y agoIn practice this usually turns into affirmative action for ideas, where marginal scholarship is promoted for no reason other than the color of the author. Is it too much to simply ask that ideas stand on their own and be judged on their own merits, divorced from the identity of the author? I do not think humanity will be better off going down this path. It seems like in a lot of cases just a cynical way to needlessly inject politics into some arena.
- UncleMeat 6y agoHistory isn't the study of secondary sources. Decolonizing history doesn't mean reading secondary sources written by poc historians. It means considering non cishet white men as primary sources. Nobody is kicking Braudel off bookshelves.
- areyousure 6y agoYour final sentence is an oddly specific claim, but nonetheless, I must admit I was surprised how uniformly people seem to like Braudel. And yet, https://twitter.com/aamandascottt/status/1266765438136049667 https://twitter.com/aamandascottt/status/1266765438136049667 https://twitter.com/aamandascottt/status/1266768148063236097 https://twitter.com/aamandascottt/status/1266768148063236097 https://twitter.com/aamandascottt/status/1257807522712432641 https://twitter.com/aamandascottt/status/1257807522712432641 https://twitter.com/HinchyJessica/status/1164796620879220736 https://twitter.com/HinchyJessica/status/1164796620879220736 https://twitter.com/arjun_jayadev/status/959596380137447424 https://twitter.com/arjun_jayadev/status/959596380137447424
- UncleMeat 6y ago> Your final sentence is an oddly specific claim Only among people unfamiliar with history. The Mediterranean is among the most famous works of all time and was written from memory while he was in a concentration camp. Historians love him, though his later work on economic history garners mixed opinions. He is the archetype of "famous white historian from the 1st half of the 20th century". His geographic history and macrohistory approach is no longer in vogue but that doesn't destroy the work. One tweet suggests an alternative for undergrad work (not removing Braudel from the field). One is outright critical (though not incorrect - geographical determinism is a huge part of his work and it merits criticism). Your last tweet is lamenting that people don't know Braudel anymore... which is just whinging. Go look at a qualifying exam booklist for anybody working in a remotely adjacent field. It's there. So across all of twitter we've got one historian with harsh words. Not exactly evidence that the field is throwing out great scholarship foolishly.
- int_19h 6y agoIt really depends on which field, and who you ask. The biggest problem is that a lot of the "decolonize" crowd intersects with post-modernists - and the latter, rather than providing more perspectives on facts, seek to push the idea that perspectives should replace facts (since facts are "not really a thing"). From there, it quickly descends into "mathematx" [1], "feminist glaciology" [2] etc. [1] https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/7fe5/558eff8e24f1b3824df5c38b210c42cdef13.pdf https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/7fe5/558eff8e24f1b3824df5c3... [2] https://aquadoc.typepad.com/files/prog_hum_geogr-2016_.pdf https://aquadoc.typepad.com/files/prog_hum_geogr-2016_.pdf
- UncleMeat 6y agoThis is both an incredibly uncharitable representation of postmodernism and also using it as a whipping boy for no reason. Postmodernism is not the same thing as gender or racial analysis and it very much does not declare that facts are "not really a thing". So you say it depends on who you ask. Who have you asked?
- int_19h 6y agoI didn't say it's the same thing. I said that they intersect a lot (in terms of people involved in both), and thus postmodernist rejection of positivism is widespread in those fields, which directly leads to bad science. And yeah, it's not a charitable representation of postmodernism. That's because I don't have anything charitable to say about it - it's epistemological cancer, simple as that.
- UncleMeat 6y agoIt's a plain false representation of postmodernism. I'll ask again, who have you asked? Popular criticism of the ivory tower is filled with complete and utter misinformation.