11 ms·
What I learned from writing for The Onion for a month (2015)
- cagenut 6y agoThe article is from 2015 but the actual story/experience is from 2010. FWIW, the onion has changed hands at least twice and the entire industry has cratered since then (hence them being owned by a PE firm now). The TV show mentioned is of course long canceled. I know this is kinda dragging a tangential thing in here, but it really can't be overstated how much Facebook hollowed out the sector. We're talking rockefeller rolling up oil refineries, except instead of cutting them in zuck just middle-manned their entire distribution chain and squeezed them to death.
- ghaff 6y agoI don't know how much of it is Facebook specifically. The decline of revenue coming into ad-supported sites generally has been happening for a very long time. Facebook is part of the reason but it's not the only one.
- cagenut 6y agoIt was a one-two-three punch. First it was Craiglist, then it was Google, now its Facebook. The main difference between google and facebook is that search optimizes for sending you on your way, so the destination sites could still do something with their audience. Facebook is extremely optimized to keep you on facebook, so in a raw attention-economy eyeball-minutes sense FB hurt much more than google. And yes, if you're looking for full spectrum technicalities here amazon and microsoft and yahoo all shaved a few % each themselves too. But the high order bit, in 2020, is unequivocally FB.
- lordleft 6y agoRE: creativity as a muscle, I think this is a powerful shift in framing. A lot of folks treat creativity as this lightening strike that you must passively wait for. And while some creative ideas are like that, many creatives, including some of the greatest artists in history, forced themselves to work for some unit of time with regularity, and were able to train themselves to be consistently creative over time. Sometimes a great idea feels like the firing of random synapses, but perhaps the priming of that firing happens through habit and dicipline.
- Swizec 6y agoIf it takes 10 at bats to hit a good article/picture/tweet/HN comment/whatever ... who’s more succesful? The guy who tries once a week or the lass who tries 10x per day? Nobody remembers the failed attempts because they likely never even saw them. The good shit spreads.
- ghaff 6y agoIt's also hard to know in advance what content is going to find an audience. I've written things that were really interesting to me but didn't get much pickup. And I've written things--usually on topics that are hot at the moment--I considered to be tossed off cookie cutter content that's gotten tens of thousands of pageviews.
- frereubu 6y agoThere’s a fantastic book called “The Creative Habit” by the choreographer Twyla Tharp if anyone is looking for a focused and clearly written “how to” manual for this. It became something of a bible for me when studying sculpture.
- pszndr 6y agoCreativity is illogical and chaotic. Things that work for one, won't for another. Trying to find reason in it might be pointless. Getting it down to a methodology might be ideal for some, but that's because they might be more logic-oriented than emotion-oriented Ideally you should find how you can extract the most out of your intellect and use that. There's a right way and a wrong way, but not on a collective level, only in an individual one.
- sitkack 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Against_Method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Against_Method
- scotch_drinker 6y agoThe Artist's Way would strongly disagree.
- notkaiho 6y agoI feel almost ashamed to say that I don't think I've ever read past the headline on an Onion article. They just absolutely nail the satire in that one-liner, time after time after time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TulliusCicero 6y agoYou're missing out then. What you're describing is true much of the time, but in others the content is just amazing: https://www.theonion.com/planned-parenthood-opens-8-billion-abortionplex-1819572640 https://www.theonion.com/planned-parenthood-opens-8-billion-... > "Although we've traditionally dedicated 97 percent of our resources to other important services such as contraception distribution, cancer screening, and STD testing, this new complex allows us to devote our full attention to what has always been our true passion: abortion," said Richards, standing under a banner emblazoned with Planned Parenthood's new slogan, "No Life Is Sacred."
- willturman 6y agoAgreed. They absolutely nail the headlines, but the content is top-notch as well. I'm regularly reminded of this one from 2013: https://www.theonion.com/jesus-this-week-1819574831 https://www.theonion.com/jesus-this-week-1819574831 > "WASHINGTON—Calling the last four days of American life just…I mean, talk about a goddamned punch in the gut, citizens across the nation confirmed today that, Jesus, this week. This fucking week, sources added. Christ."
- nonce42 6y agoThe Onion headline I think about regularly is from January 2001: "Bush: 'Our Long National Nightmare Of Peace And Prosperity Is Finally Over'". It was supposed to be a joke, but was prescient, promising a "Gulf War-level armed conflict in the next four years" and a deep recession. https://politics.theonion.com/bush-our-long-national-nightmare-of-peace-and-prosperi-1819565882 https://politics.theonion.com/bush-our-long-national-nightma...
- logicNSci 6y agoGiven how many people shared Onion stories without knowing it's "satire" and the article mentioning "It was always some kind of dry, subtle joke"- I think The Onion is bad for society. It spawned numerous knockoff websites that would mislead people "because it's funny!". If you are scrolling through a website, do you click on every article? Read every detail? And research the root website? Or do you skim, read mostly headlines and occasionally deep dive? How many "satire" website headlines do you subconsciously believe? All for "humor", which is rarely found tbh.
- ceejayoz 6y agoI think people who fall for The Onion articles are bad for society. For example: https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/02/congressman-falls-months-old-onion-story-about-planned-parenthood-abortionplex/332189/ https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/02/congres...
- awillen 6y agoI don't believe any satire websites. Because I understand what satire is. The idea that satire is bad because people are lazy/dumb is much worse than satire itself, I assure you.
- logicNSci 6y agoYou wouldn't know. That's the issue. You read a seemingly innocent headline, and move on with your day.
- motohagiography 6y agoCongrats to the author, that's a huge gig. Let's say one were 90th percentile level good, what is the out/endgame for how much money a writer can make these days? Like if you're the writing version of the most entry level pro player on a hockey or basketball team - in the big leagues, but still bottom rung of a tall ladder, are you earning average software developer income at that point? Almost all the pro writers I've known (n=50) had one of a higher-earning spouse, independent means/inherited real estate, an editing/teaching job that they occasionally wrote through, or a grant funded position or fellowship. Assuming it's Pareto distributed where the top %20 of writers make %80 of writing income, how much can a good writer expect to make?
- cagenut 6y agomy understanding in "digital publishing" (news/blogs/magazines) is almost all the writers fall in the 60 - 120k range. and thats for a "commute into manhattan every morning" job, so you will have roomates.
- wolco 6y agoGood / great doesn't matter as much as you would think. How well you sell matters. Your subjects matter. Great subjects like a Michael Jordan interview talking about Scotty would superseed any average/good/great writing ability. I don't find the writing great in the 4 hour work week. But it sold well. A great writer wouldn't have added much in terms of income generated. Marketing matters more for income.
- motohagiography 6y agoI've published in mainstream publications, and while I see that point, arguably, the quality of writing is measured by how much it changes the mind of the reader, and not how it emulates prior art that may have been well-received by critics. I would even say that writing that doesn't change the mind of the reader is basically on a spectrum of porn. By that measure, the 4 Hour Workweek was a great bit of writing. I like triads, so I'd say it's a balance of Topic, Timing, and Talent. Three is best, but if you aren't a contender with two, you don't have a chance. I've been thinking about returning to it as a vocation, but don't think the economics of writing make sense right now, hence the question.
- user982 6y agoI can't imagine how much harder it must be now for Onion writers who have to compete with real-world headlines.
- ekianjo 6y agoIndeed reality is catching up faster than they thought.
- 082349872349872 6y agoSo instead of being comedy writers pretending to be a news room, they've become a news room pretending to be comedy writers? Now they just need to work on their embargo dates, because they've been clearly running their stories before the events.
- user982 6y agoYes, they accidentally posted this one a month early: https://local.theonion.com/man-just-buying-one-of-every-cleaning-product-in-case-t-1842493766 https://local.theonion.com/man-just-buying-one-of-every-clea...
- smitty1e 6y agoPoe's Law is a right mother. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe's_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe's_law
- volkk 6y agoA few years ago, my friend and I launched our own publication on medium because we were very into comedy/satire. The Onion was the pinnacle. For a couple of months we met every morning in a coffee shop before the start of our respective jobs, around 7;30am and just brainstormed. The biggest thing to me was that I learned that motivation was something that could come after you force yourself to wake up early and just get started. There were many days where we decided to not show up and skipped the days. The rest of the days that we did show up, I never ever regretted them. We came up with some hilarious ideas (at least to us) and would just sit there laughing like idiots in the coffeeshop. We eventually launched our "publication" on Medium, and it of course fell flat because there needs to be a level of marketing and consistent effort for years before you have a dedicated following. But, those few months were some of the most creative months I've ever had in my life. I loved it. Was it a huge success? Not in the least. Was it even funny? No idea, our friends thought the articles were pretty funny, but other than that, it made it nowhere. If anybody wants to check it out -- https://medium.com/thedailylemming https://medium.com/thedailylemming After reading this article, though, I think what OP wrote is sort of not what I imagined. Sitting at home alone churning out ideas to some faceless email for a name on your resume is not my idea of creativity, I guess. I like the concept of sitting at a table and just sort of ping ponging ideas until you get something that is amazing. Of course I can say that since I'm not an actual writer and I can do this on the side and be picky and choosy as much as I want.
- andrewmcwatters 6y ago> The biggest thing to me was that I learned that motivation was something that could come after you force yourself to wake up early and just get started. This is such a great reminder. Thank you for sharing!
- alexpetralia 6y agoNot to detract from your interpretation, but I do wonder to what extent the "social commitment" motivated you to actually start working. I personally have found that, despite considering myself fairly disciplined, fixing my social environment has been the best way for me to accomplish my goals (e.g. exercising, writing, learning, etc.). Obviously this is not always feasible, but it's always I something I explore now as an initial solution.
- secondcoming 6y agoI love the Onion. There's also an old BBC comedy called Brass Eye that was quite similar. For example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7IEwBrJzhlg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7IEwBrJzhlg
- jjgreen 6y agoMorris is a genius, if you like his stuff, do check out Blue Jam, very strange indeed
- thom 6y agoThe video embed wasn't working for me, but if I'm reading the article right, the sketch the author got produced is the first segment here: https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6sw420 https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6sw420 (It is indeed funny, and still relevant).
- smitty1e 6y agoConversely, as a BabylonBee subscriber, they let you pitch headlines. And see the other submissions. Heart goes out to whoever is wading through that mess.
- yonran 6y agoThe broken embedded video that he says he had the idea for has been moved here: “Judge Rules White Girl Will Be Tried As Black Adult” https://www.theonion.com/judge-rules-white-girl-will-be-tried-as-black-adult-1819594949 https://www.theonion.com/judge-rules-white-girl-will-be-trie...
- kohtatsu 6y agoOh gosh that was a good one.
- djmips 6y agoI distinctly remember this one. Very good.
- kgwxd 6y agoPretty sure that was on the front page a reddit just a few days ago.
- forgotmypw17 6y agoHere is a link which doesn't require DRM and works with youtube-dl: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84phU8of02U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84phU8of02U
- dkdk8283 6y agoThe onion from 2010-ish is the onion the world needs today. The onion now is neutered and just not what it was. Babylon Bee is fantastic, I absolutely love it. They are as close as you will get to a 10 year old onion.
- Finnucane 6y agoI don't know if neutered is the right word, but perhaps diluted, with a lot of effort going into many projects. Also, moving from New York to Chicago c. 2012 caused a lot of staff changes. I was a little surprised they were able to remain pretty consistent after moving from Madison to New York.
- tzs 6y agoThey haven't published a new issue in 10 years, but if you haven't seen it before a trip through the archives of The Watley Review [1] might amuse you. It ran from 2003 through 2010 and some of the items are a bit dated, but many work just as well now as they did then. [1] http://www.watleyreview.com/ http://www.watleyreview.com/
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoWhat's impressive to me as a non-westerner about the satire media in US/Canada is the wonderful exhibition of free speech at a time when reporting factual news can get a journalist into extreme trouble, even in countries wearing 'democracy' banner. I highly recommend Onion's new podcast - The Topical[1][2] as a detox for real news by the EOD; Ironically some times Onion's news contain more truth than real(air quotes) news! [1] Google Podcast - https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5tZWdhcGhvbmUuZm0vdGhldG9waWNhbA https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5tZWdhcGh... [2] Apple Podcast - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-topical/id1494600747 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-topical/id14946007...
- castratikron 6y agoIMO a great example of this freedom is the Stephen Colbert character roasting Bush in person at the 2006 White House Correspondents' Dinner. This was when 9/11, Iraq war, Guantanamo Bay, Katrina, etc. were on peoples' minds at the time. https://youtu.be/6ZnuYKKtpxg https://youtu.be/6ZnuYKKtpxg
- ric2b 6y agoAll that's special about it (and not that special) is that the president is there in person, there are lots of countries where comedians can roast the government all day long.
- ShamelessC 6y ago>All that's special about it (and not that special) is that the president is there in person I cannot fathom how you think this is "not that special". Of _course_ it's a bigger deal to be allowed to roast the president to his face and an audience consisting of his strongest supporters than to be critical of the government to a (probably smaller audience) of people who already agree with you. If this happened in the current administration it would be met with a severe character assassination by the president, Fox News, OAN, etc. His ego is simply too fragile to handle any sort of criticism. Of course the only way it could happen in the first place would be to trick them into thinking it wasn't going to be a roast in the first place.
- typon 6y agoTwo reactions to this blog: 1. What does it feel like to work a job that's pretty morally unambiguously doing good? (Making people laugh) 2. Their interview process sounds a bit like tech take home assignment. If they reject the interviewee, do they get to keep all their ideas? At least they don't make them do improv in front of an interviewer in real time... (equivalent of a white board leet code interview?)
- bryanrasmussen 6y ago> Their interview process sounds a bit like tech take home assignment the worst are the Fermi Comedy questions; How many mimes slip on bananas in Paris If you fill the Empire State Building with helium how many people in New York will sound like dorks? stuff like that, awful.
- deadmik3 6y agoThe "Jobs page" that's linked to in the article just goes to a page of all the onion articles that are about "jobs". Is that the joke?
- sharkjacobs 6y agoNote that this article is from 2015, which predates the Gawker redesign. That's almost certainly a broken link.
- honkycat 6y agoThey did a big re-platform from a Django site to the Kinja platform. Probably just a bug/moved link
- pchander 6y agoArticle was from 2005. New link is here: https://www.theonion.com/careers https://www.theonion.com/careers
- rwmj 6y agoA bit OT: Back in the 70s/80s there was a national weekly radio show called Week Ending where anyone could turn up off the street in the writers' room and contribute. The results were a bit mixed, rather tame by today's standards, but it nurtured a lot of people who would go on to do great radio and TV comedy in the UK. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Week_Ending https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Week_Ending
- maverickJ 6y agoInteresting. Writing and creativity is indeed a muscle. The author should not disqualify themselves from being funny from just 4 week experience. Creating funny content for the onion at that time required that you be in the 95th percentile. The author could have been in 90th percentile for funny people in America. I just started writing my newsletter at https://leveragethoughts.substack.com/ https://leveragethoughts.substack.com/ and I am currently building my writing muscle.
- hatmatrix 6y agoThis American Life had an episode, Tough Room, in which Act One [1] was chronicling how jokes get whittled down. This was from 2008 - don't know how freelancers' jokes fit in but here the writers' jokes weren't submitted over email but read out loud, one after the other, in a room where your coworkers unemotionally approve or ask you to move on. It's worth a listen. [1] https://www.thisamericanlife.org/348/tough-room/act-one https://www.thisamericanlife.org/348/tough-room/act-one
- anonytrary 6y agoI think an AMA on Reddit from someone who wrote/worked for the Onion would be really cool. The Onion is one of those companies that is just really good at what it does and has found an incredible fit in a niche market. I always love organizations like that who choose art over profit.