4 ms·
Once again -- Apple will do what the entire industry without Apple couldn't do. In this case, force a migration to ARM-based servers, so that prod is running on
by bitwize 6y ago
Once again -- Apple will do what the entire industry without Apple couldn't do. In this case, force a migration to ARM-based servers, so that prod is running on the same architecture as the developer's machine.
Apple is finally killing x86.
- tjoff 6y agoHooray, we have successfully fixed the mistake with an open platform and will now be relegated to incompatible hardware without any competition. At last, the future will surely be bright!
- duskwuff 6y agoHow was x86 any more "open" of a platform? If anything, x86 is a far more "closed" platform, as there are only two remaining manufacturers of x86 parts, and there is no licensing process to join them. Meanwhile, there are hundreds of ARM licensees, and the process for becoming a licensee is all documented online [1]. [1]: https://www.arm.com/why-arm/how-licensing-works https://www.arm.com/why-arm/how-licensing-works
- tjoff 6y agoHow? It is absolutely inconceivable how much more open it is. Also, the CPU is but a minor part of the puzzle. But still that is still twice as many as apple (good luck exchanging that apple-arm with any other brand). Please let me know how open you think the next apple ARM platform is when you try to boot any OS not written by apple. Please compare that with a computer built from AMD/Intel with a motherboard out of dozens of manufacturers etc. Any ATX power supply etc. Pretty much any PCI-E graphics card etc.
- duskwuff 6y agoYou are confusing the x86 CPU architecture (which is closed) with the PC platform (which is relatively open). > Also, the CPU is but a minor part of the puzzle. But still that is still twice as many as apple (good luck exchanging that apple-arm with any other brand). Even on x86, interchangeable CPUs are the exception, not the rule. Intel and AMD CPUs haven't even used the same socket since the 1990s, and even within those manufacturers, socket incompatibilities are common. Software interchangeability is more of an operating systems issue than an architectural one. With appropriate software shims, though, there is no reason to suspect that (for example) Linux ARM software could be run on an Apple ARM CPU. In fact, it's quite likely that tools like the Android emulator will do exactly that. > Please compare that with a computer built from AMD/Intel with a motherboard out of dozens of manufacturers etc. Any ATX power supply etc. Pretty much any PCI-E graphics card etc. Server-class ARM hardware generally does use similar parts as x86 servers, including power supplies and PCIe peripherals.
- tjoff 6y agoI am not. But also, how many x86 processors are sold outside of the PC platform? They have a symbiotic relationship. The foundation of everything we have today. > Software interchangeability is more of an operating systems issue than an architectural one. Not if the architecture is designed around keeping others out. But just not telling anyone how to do it is enough in 99% of cases. Some hacker might post a buggy proof-of-concept for an obsolete device that no one will run. > Server-class ARM hardware generally does use similar parts as x86 servers, including power supplies and PCIe peripherals. Wanna place a bet on what apple is going to do?
- klelatti 6y agoPrecisely. And the fact that you can run ARMv8 on both a Raspberry PI and the Fujitsu Fugaku which is now No. 1 on the Top 500 says something about what is possible as a result.
- josephcsible 6y agoIt's more open in terms of what software you can run. And if you cared about hardware being open, RISC-V is where you'd have to go. ARM certainly isn't open hardware.
- imtringued 6y agox86 might be a platform with few vendors. ARM isn't even a platform. Most SoCs are meant to run a single OS and that's about it. Not exactly what I'd call a platform because platforms let their users build on top of them. That includes running whatever OS you want to run on that processor. What you might be worried about is a duopoly which has nothing to do with whether something is a software platform or not. For example Microsoft has a monopoly on Windows. That doesn't stop Windows from being a platform for which you can write arbitrary software. Apple has a monopoly on iOS but it's not possible for users to write their own software, they have to join a developer program that can always exclude them. This is what one would call a closed platform. ARM is closer to the iOS model than to Windows.
- pjmlp 6y agoActually the original mistake was IBM's to make.
- tjoff 6y agoYes, that was my point, we are still "suffering" from it.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThere isn't really any advantage to ARM compared to modern x86. Closed ARM is IMO worse than x86. Now, if someone made the x86 license more open that would be cool, but so far it's all downsides at least for me.
- klelatti 6y ago> Closed ARM? Is there any suggestion that the architecture that Apple is using is any different to what is being used by lots and lots of other licensees? If not then it's much more open than x86. If you mean that you can't buy an ARM CPU today to plug into your own motherboard then understood but that's probably now a matter of time. At least making such a CPU is possible - no-one is going to make x86 more open.
- sudosysgen 6y agox86 is already relatively open, there's more than four companies developing x86 chips, though for now they are mostly focused on very low power outside of Intel and AMD. There is no indication that I'll ever be able to buy an ARM CPU and plug it into motherboard with the feature set I choose and plug into it peripherals that follow a standard and open interface with good performance. The only companies that make ARM CPUs that could at all be useful in such an open platform don't make CPUs fast enough. I don't think Apple or Amazon will ever sell me a socketable CPU with high speed PCI support and XMP memory support.
- klelatti 6y agoARM has 250 licensees for application processors with 8 licensees (including AMD and Nvidia) who can develop their own architectures around the 64 bit ARM instruction set. You can buy socketed ARM CPUs today that are likely to be more than fast enough - from Marvell for example. You're 100 % right that there isn't an ARM ecosystem at the moment in the way that there is a PC ecosystem with all its flexibility. But that's not a feature of the ARM architecture or what ARM as a company does - it's because x86 has historically dominated the desktop.
- imtringued 6y agoIf it takes a dictator to force a platform upon everyone is it really that great of a platform?