7 ms·
I'm probably going to get downvoted to hell for saying this (again) but this still doesn't solve the problem of whether Apple themselves are abusing your privac
by dheera 6y ago
I'm probably going to get downvoted to hell for saying this (again) but this still doesn't solve the problem of whether Apple themselves are abusing your privacy.
Also, the closed-source OS means it's impossible to see what things are doing under the hood, or modify the behavior of the OS itself to be more privacy friendly.
For example, on Apple if you aren't happy with an app snooping on your IMU data, you're out of luck and can only just choose to not use the app. On Android (by modifying the OS) you can actually send back fake IMU data to make the app think it got the permissions it wanted but really didn't. Or you can let access to your photos, but only let it see a walled garden of a few select photos.
- Skunkleton 6y agoYou're right, but you are also missing the point. Consumers in general have access to one of only a few options for computing tasks. To date, of these mainstream options, only Apple is taking a meaningful stance on privacy. Is it self-serving, sub-optimal, or otherwise broken? Probably. Is it the best thing for privacy currently widely available? Probably.
- meesles 6y agoHomebrew software and hacks aren't feasible solutions for the general population. You can't expect a tech-illiterate person to put up with all of that to protect their right to privacy. Like it or not, solutions like Apples' are much more efficient at protecting 1 billion (exaggeration) people at once.
- jdxcode 6y agoI'm not even sure how something like T2 could be done with an open platform
- bobthechef 6y agoNot just illiterate. How many people here have the time or desire to inspect every app they use? It's a ridiculous proposition. We all have better things to do.
- andrepd 6y agoObviously the onus isn't on every single user to single handedly verify themselves that the software is correct. Do you check your government's finances yourself? So why should they even publish it? By your logic, that is. The answer is that if it's open then multiple people with differing interests, such as competitors, or even independent organisations such as non-profit auditors, can check the code.
- realusername 6y agoThat's like saying that freedom of speech should be banned because most people have nothing to say. User rights needs to be there for the people who need it. The iPhone is currently a black box where it's very hard to know what is happening in it, that's a big issue in terms of privacy and accountability of the platform, not to mention the anti-competitive behaviours.
- rootusrootus 6y agoIs there a practical solution that isn’t a black box? For the general population, not enthusiasts.
- realusername 6y agoYes, there's a whole market for Android devices which are both opened and very secure.
- czzr 6y ago> On Android (by modifying the OS) I’m genuinely curious how you can imagine this is a realistic solution.
- shawnz 6y agoDevelopers could create a third party ROM with the privacy enhancements which users could install.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoHow is users having to trust third-party developers about privacy features in a ROM different to users having to trust Apple?
- lwhi 6y agoAndroid is open source, iOS is not.
- rootusrootus 6y agoThe Android almost everyone uses is not open source.
- lwhi 6y agoThe iOS _everyone_ uses is not open source.
- shawnz 6y agoIndependent audits could be conducted on those privacy enhanced ROMs, if there was enough interest. I'm not saying this is the most practical solution to this problem but at least it's a possibility.
- realusername 6y agoAnybody can have a look at the ROM to see if it makes sense whereas only Apple can realistically audit the iPhone.
- unityByFreedom 6y ago> this still doesn't solve the problem of whether Apple themselves are abusing your privacy Eventually you have to trust someone. This added transparency from Apple is commendable. I support open source for publicly funded software, but if it's privately owned and funded, you can choose to buy and use it or not. Private companies are not under any moral obligation to open source their code or methods. Some people are successful while open sourcing everything, and that is commendable too.
- lwhi 6y agoWhy do you have to eventually trust someone?
- kingnight 6y agoBecause you would need to write and/or audit your entire technology toolchain — software, build tools, operating systems, hardware, etc — which isn't feasible for anyone.
- the_gipsy 6y agonot a single person, but the sum of all people looking at the different parts. that's how open source works.
- dkonofalski 6y agoSure, but then you're putting your trust in those people. The point was that an individual can't possibly have the time or resources to do it themselves and so, at some point, they have to put their trust in someone else.
- baddox 6y agoAnd thus you would need to trust those people.
- gggmaster 6y ago
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoI hate how our options are "Choose apple and blindly trust them" or "Chose android an see in the open that your data is being abused"
- andrepd 6y agoYou forgot option 3: use Lineage+microg and enjoy the most private and secure platform available on a smartphone today. But if you chose the first one then you can't, because apple won't let you choose the software that runs on the equipment you bought.
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoI used to use linageOS no gapps and I loved it but then my nexus 5x died and I got a pixel 2 and linageOS support stopped at the pixel 1. It seems to me that the age of custom roms is over. Android got good enough that the only reason for a custom rom was privacy and extended updates. Since the pixel 2 is still updated there is no reason other than privacy and I guess no one was willing to put in the work for just that.
- efreak 6y ago> Since the pixel 2 is still updated there is no reason other than privacy Features. - The ability to run Android without Google. - The ability to change the location of your clock. - The ability to have some apps open with the status bar and navbar and some not. - The ability to change your WiFi network without opening settings (yes, I'm still upset they removed that. I use an Android 8 tablet daily, so I'm unlikely to forget). - Adding invisible left/right dpad buttons and a menu button in my navbar. - Change the number of quick settings. - Change the screen dpi (this is implemented these days, I think, but only with 3-5 settings available) - use adb without first plugging into a computer. Maybe I'm going somewhere and I'll need to restart my phone. - run Linux in a chroot (far better than proot) - install Fdroid privileged extension without losing access to security updates. You can say full well that you don't care about these, you don't have to care. However, these are all things that you can't do without an alternative ROM (or without rooting, which loses access to updates).
- danielpyon 6y agoI don't understand why this is controversial: companies will continue to abuse us so long as there is a profit incentive to do so.
- arkades 6y agoApple’s approach improves privacy in most contexts for all of its users, enough to shape market practices. Your approach works for a tiny, tiny sliver of people - which, by the nature of population-level snooping and marketing, are irrelevant.
- RandomBacon 6y ago> I'm probably going to get downvoted to hell It's a self-fulfilling prophecy. Don't bring it up next time. Reverse psychology (in an attempt to not get downvotes) doesn't work here, it just pisses people off (and is against the rules to complain about), so you WILL receive downvotes for mentioning it.
- dheera 6y agoIt happens whether or not I say that actually. Every time I disagree with Apple I get downvoted to oblivion. There are just too many Apple fanboys here who believe Apple is the be-all end-all of everything privacy.
- sbuk 6y agoOr what you’re saying doesn’t add to the conversation. Simply blaming ‘fanboys’ isn’t useful. I don’t think any of the responses to you post believe that Apple are the “be-all end-all” of privacy, but they are arguing that for the typical consumer (something that is too often overlooked) they currently provide the best solution available. The critical bit there is typical consumer. If you’re a “power user” (what a horrid expression) and want to go another route, have at it! You have a choice.
- threeseed 6y ago> Or you can let access to your photos, but only let it see a walled garden of a few select photos. iOS 14 has this now. And any access to sensitive data always prompts you. And if you deny the request it sends empty data back to the app. Exactly like what you describe.
- dheera 6y agoYes but you could do this on Android since version 1 because it was open source. You could always modify the OS to spit out fake sensor data and appease apps that would otherwise not run if you didn't give them permissions. My privacy shouldn't depend on Tim Cook's product management timeline.