18 ms·
Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing
- moksly 6y agoI wonder how much of it is Facebook being unwilling to be editorial and how much of it is then being unable to moderate a couple of billion users. Either way, they might not get a choice. The EU is going to regulate them more and more. My own country is passing a law to force platforms to remove child pornography within 24 hours of it being reported as an example of where it starts. Won’t be long before we make enabling nazi groups planning hate crimes illegal either.
- HeroOfAges 6y agoNo one has a problem with anyone making nazi groups planning hate crimes illegal. My biggest concern is Facebook deciding who is a "nazi" and what constitutes a hate crime. My belief (backed by scientific fact) that biological sex is real and immutable is enough to have me branded as a "nazi". The statement "males are not females" is enough to be considered hate speech. Saying, "males are not females" could be a hate crime.
- sneak 6y agoAs usual, context is everything in communication. "Males are not females" may be accurate when referring to biological sex, but in the context it is most commonly used (as harassment and as a neoconservative tribal signifier) it is referring to gender, and is roughly equivalent to saying "the gender you have now should match the gender you were assigned at birth, or your gender identity is illegitimate". It's similar to saying "all lives matter". Of course they do, but the context in which its said indicates that it's an opposition to the explicit statement about black lives mattering, a de-focusing and dismissal. "All lives matter" or "males are not females" are not incorrect statements, but in the vast majority of the times they are used on the internet, they are used to express hatred of a group and the active dismissal of that group's efforts to achieve equal human rights. The context in which they are used makes them hateful. Hiding behind the "but it's scientific fact!" is simply a deflection from the fact that it is an expression of hate in the context in which it is used. I shouldn't have to explain this, honestly. Please stop acting like a jerk to people online.
- HeroOfAges 6y agoSince when does the truth need context? If I tweet "males are not females" on Twitter with no context, they will ban my account. Also, if I want to say "the gender you have now should match the gender you were assigned at birth, or your gender identity is illegitimate", that's precisely what I'll say, but I tend to speak directly. Have you considered you might be projecting if you can read the literal words "males are not females" and conclude a person intends to say, "the gender you have now should match the gender you were assigned at birth, or your gender identity is illegitimate"? That seems like quite a leap.
- perl4ever 6y agoI'd say the truth value of any possible statement is entirely derived from context. Any possible statement could appear on a sign from nowhere in an infinite empty universe purely out of quantum fluctuations, but it would have no meaning without the context of a universe like ours. Every statement has a context in which it expresses the truth, and many others in which it is false. And people get into conflicts about the meta-issue of whose context is right. Mach's principle is kind of an analogy I'm thinking of.
- newsclues 6y agoI hope government gets on-board. I frequently see government of Ontario and Canada advertising on Facebook and its poorly targeted and it makes me mad
- donw 6y agoAfter the SSC debacle, NYT is likely to learn itself a thing or two about boycotts.
- intsunny 6y agoIf we punish respected organizations (of any kind) for every gaffe, we would not have any left. In an era where the journalists are more under attack than ever, we might want to remember it is easier to tear things down than build them up.
- throwaway_1512 6y agoThese are not journalists, mostly blogger and quite likely just twitter addicts.
- bzb3 6y agoNobody has talked about punishing respected organisations, just the New York Times.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- WillPostForFood 6y agoA “gaffe” is an unintentional mistake - oops, silly me. The New York Times outing people isn’t a gaffe, it is a hit job.
- Veen 6y agoWhat about gaffes like the 1619 Project, the shortcomings and errors of which the NYT steadfastly refused to correct in the face of criticisms from historians. At a certain point, when the gaffes all line up in one direction, one might reasonably suspect an underlying motive.
- ciarannolan 6y agoWhat were some of the issues with the 1619 Project?
- ecmascript 6y agoSo because Mark Zuckerberg won't censor people with different opinions he is complacent in spreading fake news and hate? Wow, that kind of rhetoric is dangerous imo. For once I actually think Facebook have made the right call. Censoring people is wrong and Facebook should refrain from doing it. Let me decide what is true and false, I don't need Facebook or other people to decide that for me. Good job Facebook, thanks for standing up for free speech.
- demygale 6y agoMost reputable media outlets will not run ads, especially political ads, that contain false information. There’s enormous latitude in this area. It hasn’t stopped attack ads or misleading information from entering political discourse. Facebook is refusing to apply any standard of editorial control over these ads. It’s their platform, their decision. I think it’s harmful to society and will happily talk shit about Facebook because of it. They control ever byte if content on the platform and censor and surveil their users with alacrity. Choosing to allow deceptive campaign advertising does not make Facebook a leader in free speech.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoLiberal society is ending, and you must swear allegiance to the People's Party, comrade. Otherwise, we will publicly denounce you, and will not permit you to engage in any business activity. There will be an ideological examination. Study hard!
- ecmascript 6y agoIt surely feels like it at least when every single major javascript framework has a #BLM header. Nothing that don't matter or are relevant to me since I live in northen europe.
- durkie 6y agodefinitely no history of racism there.
- avernon 6y agoMaybe I'm cynical, but I would think this has more to do with the cost of ads going up so much. If you were already thinking of reducing spend on FB, why not get a little PR out of it? Also, since the cost of FB ads has been going up over the last several years, that means there is no shortage of demand for ads on FB.
- admn2 6y agoYeah, pretty much all the big DTC brands (Allbirds, Away, Warby, OV, etc.) all have retail store fronts and "showrooms" now across the US. I always just assumed if they were spending $1mm+/month on FB ads, it wasn't a very difficult decision to move $20k/month to a store in a big city and see what kind of lead gen and brand awareness that yields.
- 8ytecoder 6y agoPersonal anecdote - stores resulted in a much better conversion but not a huge uptick in acquisition.
- jonathanpeterwu 6y agoCan you explain this a bit further, long tail which was better ROI
- gfo 6y agoPossibly, but advertising is one of the first things companies cut in a down economy. I want to believe these companies have good intent, but it could also be construed as opportunistic: "we were already cutting our advertising budget, so this just gives us a way to capitalize." To show they believe in what they're doing, they should donate what they would have spent on Facebook ads to causes which promote voter registration and improving minority representation in tech.
- williesleg 6y agoNobody cares. All grandstanding. Like Ben and Jerry's BLM movement. Where's the diversity at Ben & Jerry's? All white people in Vermont.
- rootusrootus 6y agoWhile it might affect Facebook’s bottom line for a short while, until users start moving away from FB nothing really will change. Advertisers will come back.
- aphextron 6y ago>"While it might affect Facebook’s bottom line for a short while, until users start moving away from FB nothing really will change. Advertisers will come back." Counterpoint: users already have moved away, and that's why advertisers are able to do this without hesitation now. FB is still growing in the third world, but I don't know a single person in the US under 30 that still uses it.
- piokoch 6y agoYes, but they use another "social app" that happen to be owned by Facebook the corporation. Even though I don't like Facebook and its founder, I have to say he was clever enough to avoid the fate of MySpace, which just stopped to be fashionable and died. Even if Facebook.com will start going down there is still Messenger, Instagram, WhatsApp that are still "cool".
- jjice 6y agoAs a Uni student, I still see people use Facebook, but it's a select group of people. It's the same < 5% of the people I interact with regularly. Most people I know use Facebook just for events so you can invite someone to a fundraiser or party. On the other side, I see Instagram doing fantastic among my friends, and it gets way less hate from them, despite being very openly owned by Facebook (it says it on the splash screen).
- flattone 6y agoSpeculative: Before enough users start moving away maybe Facebook will figure out how to make it a legal requirement for us citizens to have a Facebook. You laugh now ... you can buy me a drink in 10 years or so.
- 6y ago
- tomp 6y agoNice. I like that companies are putting their money where their mouth is, and not just doing cheap virtue signalling, like posting a black square on Instagram. I think, and hope, however, that Facebook will come out victorious; (1) freedom of speech is important, (2) it's not up to Facebook to be the arbitrer of what's allowed or not (it's up to the law), (3) advertisers need Facebook more than Facebook needs them, and (4) sooner or later companies will learn that SJW-ing is at worst negative (each company could easily come under attack itself) and at best irrelevant (did Pepsi suffer any long-term consequences for the backlash against it a year or 2 ago? Did Gillete gain a lot for publishing its anti-toxic masculinity ad? I doubt it.)
- ketzo 6y ago> (4) sooner or later companies will learn that SJW-ing is at worst negative and at best irrelevant I think this is pretty plainly untrue. If you mean at best irrelevant for the company, that’s certainly not true — friends of mine (and myself!) absolutely make purchasing decisions based on the moral reputation of the company. If you mean for the world, this also seems patently false to me. You can’t tell me that constantly seeing ads featuring gay couples as happy families doesn’t have a measurable impact on normalizing and aiding acceptance.
- dash2 6y agoIf you mean at best irrelevant for the company, that’s certainly not true — friends of mine (and myself!) absolutely make purchasing decisions based on the moral reputation of the company. Sure, but people like you may make up a small or negligible part of total revenue. And, like the Hollywood actress who was astounded that Nixon won because "nobody I know voted for him", you may overestimate how many people are like you. I've heard the phrase "go woke, go broke" thrown around.
- tzs 6y agoHaving the law as the sole arbiter of what is allowed or not would be terrible for free speech. The problem is that we have an overwhelming amount of information being produced, so that people have a hard time evaluating all they are exposed to. Furthermore, we have a lot of people who are just too trusting, or too naive, or too gullible, or perhaps just even stupid. Finally, on top of that we have many information producers who are trying to cause harm ranging from people just doing it for fun to countries trying to undermine each other's stability. A society must find some way to prevent or at least limit those who are intentionally trying to harm people from taking advantage of the overly trusting, naive, gullible, and stupid. The law is a monopoly. Using it to try to address that problem will tend toward overly broad restrictions on speech, with little or no recourse for those whose speech should not have been included. It's far better for it to be handled by Facebook, Twitter, and the rest. If Facebook won't let me talk about some particular topic I do have alternatives. They might not reach as far so I might have to go to some serious effort to contact like minded people and get them to agree to discuss my topic on some other platform--but I can.
- eanzenberg 6y agoWishful thinking from the nyt
- buboard 6y agoMaybe instead of trying to damage fb directly, nytimes could instead write about the countless social communities that facebook destroyed abd sidelined over the years. It s not long ago that nytimes was writing praises about facebook, we remember. Unfortunately these days it doesn’t seem that nytimes holds itself to a higher moral standard than fb https://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/12/business/smallbusiness/12guide.html https://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/12/business/smallbusiness/12... https://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/08/technology/08class.html https://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/08/technology/08class.html
- creaghpatr 6y agoGiven what they are trying to do to Scott Alexander, it's hard to take NYT's reporting angle seriously.
- slavapestov 6y agoI’ve never read “Slate Star Codec” and I didn’t even hear about it until this week but I’m guessing it’s a blog about James Damore-style biological determinism. Can someone explain why this kind of material is so popular with San Francisco app developers?
- EForEndeavour 6y agoIf you were going to comment on the general style of the blog, why wouldn't you take any time at all to gather data beyond literally "guessing"? What does this guess-based comment actually add?
- umanwizard 6y agoYour guess is wrong
- jp_sc 6y ago1. You are guessing wrong. The blog wasn't about that and Damore said nothing about "determinism" just "average preference". 2. You seem to be under the impression that this site is visited by "San Francisco app developers" and you.
- manuelabeledo 6y agoYes, it does indeed have some articles about that, but more focused on race and upbringing than gender. > Can someone explain why this kind of material is so popular with San Francisco app developers? It is not. But for those who identify themselves as "libertarians", it is definitely appealing to think that nothing but themselves have influenced in their success, of which being a highly paid engineer is part.
- whatshisface 6y agoScott writes long thinkpeices about things like SSRI effectiveness and the role of neutrality and enlightenment values in healing America's cultural divide. As far as we know the NYT was not even planning to knife him, the issue is that they want to threaten his patient-doctor relationships by publishing his full name in a place where his mental patients could read it. (He's a practicing psychiatrist with hundreds of patients.)
- hprotagonist 6y agoI wonder how much of the elephant in the room, which is "ad-tech kind of doesn't work so great", people are going to be willing to say out loud.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mattlondon 6y agoBased on some personal experience from perhaps 7 or 8 years ago, it can work for driving sales. However it required quite a lot of effort. It wasn't just throw some money into the ads and wait for the returns - you needed to basically spend a full-time job pulling levers and prodding buttons to find out where the "sweet spot" was and then make sure you keep up with the moving target over the following days weeks and months. If you were lucky and your business was selling the "right" things (i.e. large margin items) you could do quite well. E.g. it might cost you $15-20 in ads to make one sale - that is net-positive if the margin on your items is large. So some fashion, furniture, holidays etc a $20+ Cost-per-acquisition is a bargain as you just paid $20 to make a $150 profit. If you are competing for common ad space/keywords and you have a low-margin business then you're probably not going to do so well since you might be paying $20 to sell something that costs $9.99 or whatever. Of course, there is then the question of would you have made that $150 profit without spending the $20? Or did you actually make more than one sale from those $20 worth of ads (e.g. in-store sales etc in addition to purchases made online). I am not involved in online advertising now, but at the time that was the trillion dollar question that everyone was trying to answer... no idea if it is solved now.
- throwaway_jobs 6y agoIt seems the pandemic and unemployment is finally causing voodoo economics (trickle down economics) to reverse course and perhaps cause trickle up economics, where the multi-billion dollar corporations and rich alike will begin to feel the pinch of poverty on a massive scale trickle up. Unfortunately while taxpayers got their $1,200 Checks they were robbed blind of over $4T to the FED which went directly to stabilize the publicly traded companies. If it weren’t for that, we would have already seen bankruptcies on a massive scale from publicly traded companies...instead the markets are back where the were pre-covid. But at some point they will have to admit there can’t be a recovery when there are no consumers left.
- camillomiller 6y agoI'm frankly flabbergasted by what's going on with the markets. If anyone thought stocks were still somehow a projection of reality and an indicator of expectations on the future of a company's performance, well, that's clearly not the case anymore. I am really scared that a real devastating collapse is still looming, but I frankly have no clue of when that could happen and what could actually trigger it.
- jfengel 6y agoIt is baffling, and I've been expecting a crash for a decade... which is the problem. The market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent. Right now it's kind of persistently slightly irrational. A quick-and-dirty measure of its sanity is the P/E ratio: how much money are the publicly listed companies actually making? Right now, the number is around 22[1], meaning a dollar invested in the market takes 22 years to pay itself back purely in terms of corporate profits. That's a return of about 3%. Numbers over 20 are generally considered a sign that the market is overheated. They peaked at around 45 and 65 right before the 90s and 2000s crashes. So there is revenue there, and not entirely out of line with stock prices, but not entirely line with them either. None of that takes coronavirus into account; that's current price with last quarter's earnings. But if you assume that coronavirus is only temporary (it may not be, but let's be optimistic for a second) it means that long term the numbers are calling for a crash... eventually. One of these days. Longer than you can remain solvent while shorting it. Probably. In other words, I've got no idea what's going on. The markets have been weirdly stable (in price-to-earnings terms) for the past decade, at a number that's too optimistic, before coronavirus. Surely the inevitable at-least-short-term loss of earnings should have corrected that, but it hasn't. So either people are thinking very long term, or they're just nuts. [1] https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio
- tech-historian 6y agoSerious questions: Are the people that work at Facebook proud to work there? What is morale like inside that place? When someone asks you what you do, and you say "I work for Facebook," what is their typical reaction? Not trying to be snarky. I'm genuinely curious how these perceptions/feelings might have changed over the past few years.
- zeroonetwothree 6y agoI could ask the same about working for the NYT. https://slatestarcodex.com/ https://slatestarcodex.com/
- 0xy 6y agoNew York Times: Lied about Iraq WMDs and helped get tens of thousands of people killed. Facebook: Won't censor your political enemies enough.
- bzb3 6y agoWhy would they be unhappy or ashamed? Not everybody shares your views of politics.
- tech-historian 6y agoFacebook is in Silicon Valley and I'm willing to bet most of its ranks are very liberal.
- Enginerrrd 6y agoBecause ethics =/= politics and I think it's a pretty universal judgement that Facebook has done some ethically dubious things in the past, and not much has changed from the policies that led them there in the first place.
- bhupy 6y agoOkay but ethics isn't universal either. There is no objective moral framework. "Not everybody shares your views" == "Not everybody shares your ethics". Let me try and steel-man this for you: if you believe in classical liberal principles of free speech, then you might probably be "proud" to work at FB, as well as of Zuckerberg's stance. Here's a better articulation of that: https://stratechery.com/2020/zuckerbergs-choice-zuckerbergs-power-zuckerbergs-conviction/ https://stratechery.com/2020/zuckerbergs-choice-zuckerbergs-...
- admiralspoo 6y agoThe NYT is no longer credible
- mesozoic 6y agoWow they're in trouble. Both the left and right are not happy with them. The left cause they won't censor enough and the right because they sensor too much and put in a likely bias review committee. The Project Veritas video was pretty exposing and will likely fuel a senate investigation.
- djohnston 6y agonyt will never waste an opportunity to paint their usurper as a failing company.. i am highly confident that this will all amount to nothing
- mintym 6y agoIt gives them political cover to ban content and act as if they are "responding to pressure" but still "striving to be neutral".
- code4tee 6y agoFor better or worse money talks. Advertiser pullouts have been an effective change mechanism in many other cases. TV personalities doing controversial things were typically done in when the advertisers pulled their money. Until then nothing happened. Facebook does a lot of cool things but it’s only sustainable as a business if the advertising dollars keep flowing. Shut that off in any appreciable quantity and things will get ugly there real quick.
- 1235711 6y agoOne thing to consider is that this is largely a self-correcting problem for Facebook due to the auction model for ads. As money leaves the pool, price per conversion will tend to go down automatically for everyone else. If you think other advertisers will leave money on the table to make a point then you haven't worked in business very long.
- franze 6y agoI wrote about it here and I stand with it "Paid Ads are a Trap" https://medium.com/@franz.enzenhofer/ads-are-a-trap-80df01d2fbaf?source=friends_link&sk=ed2680c921a7bb5a0b147b44a9a14b1e https://medium.com/@franz.enzenhofer/ads-are-a-trap-80df01d2... (Medium free to read link) The ad system of Google and Facebook is obviously not created to benefit the businesses which book ads, but Fb and G. The business should be at best held at minimum but viable profit, highest cost for ads. At worst "burn through all your money with us". I by now came to eh conclusion that "paids (ads) growth" is scheme with only Fb and G as the profiteers.
- salimmadjd 6y agoAm I the only person who has a problem with this headline, "Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing" am I overreacting here or others feel the same? For me at the face of it's not incorrect, but it feels to me a certain deliberate wordsmithing is used to create a sense of growing momentum. What we don't know if these advertisers represent 1%, more or less than x% of Facebook's ad revenue. I do understand FB will not provide that info, but some real journalism and follow up from said companies could have gathered us the amount this boycott means. After all this suppose to be NYT. They do touch on this number, "smaller businesses that make up the bulk of its eight million advertisers have been considering their options" However, again they are carefully crafting their words in a way that it's not inaccurate but showing a larger problem. Instead of saying "one agency that manages 20 clients", or "we have heard from some advertisers" using "one agency", or "some advertisers" they are saying "advertisers" which to some readers will read as a lot of advertisers or a universal movement among advertisers.
- skewart 6y agoWhat’s more, the NY Times has a strong business interest in convincing advertisers not to advertise on Facebook. I’m a bit skeptical of anything they publish these days about Facebook, Google, and other companies that could potentially threaten their access to clicks, just given their financial incentives to weaken these companies as much as possible.
- rossdavidh 6y agoMy thoughts exactly, they have a clear conflict of interest when covering this story. Although, to be honest, all of mainstream journalism seems way more biased and blatantly slanted than I recall from 20-30 years ago. Perhaps I am just better at noticing it now?
- _curious_ 6y agoGood to see more people calling out the sensationalism and manipulation tactics that publishers deploy...not just the Times either. I've gotten to a point where if my spidey sense is tingling, I won't even click on link or read the content, the time to reward that behavior has passed.
- wayne_skylar 6y agoI find it so funny that Facebook hides behind "freedom of speech" when in fact what they do is the exact opposite. When everything you saw was cronological, you could make that argument. I write a message on my wall and everyone who follows me can see it if they scroll down far enough. Most importantly, the only criteria used was the time it was submitted which I think everyone can agree is fair. By prioritizing certain posts based on what the algorithm thinks will make you stay on the site longer, they are prioritizing, thus interfering with free speech. When I post something, my message will have a lower chance of reaching some of my followers. How can facebook justify tipping the scales for one type of message over another and call it free?
- sneak 6y agoThe (legitimate) argument is that freedom of speech extends to facebook getting to decide what, and in what order, information is displayed on facebook.com. To dictate a chronological order, or to demand that they publish every single thing that is submitted to them, is a restriction of their freedom of editorial expression on their own website.
- satokema_work 6y agoThe (also legitimate) argument is that freedom of speech should extend to privately-owned de facto commons, and is a concept beyond the enumeration in the American Bill of Rights.
- ethbro 6y agoAs clear a way to put it as I've heard. But all companies seek to become monopolies for purposes of profit, while avoiding being seen as monopolies for purposes of responsibility.
- phatfish 6y agoI agree there is a problem with private corporations that control publishing platforms with such a large reach. Twitter and Facebook are really the only ones at the moment with that power (in the "anglosphere" at least). However, for laws to be created that force them to publish posts that fall under "free speech" their algorithms must be fully open and auditable. Otherwise they still hold the power to sensor, or their algorithms could be covertly gamed by those in the know. Otherwise your speech might not be the same, or as free as mine, but who would know?
- naringas 6y agoI for one am thankful that thanks to facebook there's not only google.
- avsteele 6y agoThis is a poor article. It mixes up several different issues and lumps them together as if they were one thing. Strongly ideological companies aren't going to behave like the bulk of their customers. I read this as yet another shot from the NYT against tech in general. It's propaganda.
- acd 6y agoI boycott Facebook as a platform for privacy reasons.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- globular-toast 6y agoI have mixed feelings about Facebook. I was one of the first people in my friend group to boycott Facebook back when it really wasn't cool to do so: back in 2008 or so. I did so for reasons of privacy. As someone who works with data for a living, I know full well the risks people are taking by using Facebook and I also see how little the general public understand about this. So I boycotted them. But nobody talks about privacy any more. The current backlash against Facebook seems to be due to them not wanting to censor the platform in quite the way that users want them to censor the platform. It seems everyone is happy with the censorship---because like anyone who has ever been happy with censorship they don't believe the readership is intelligent enough to read certain words---but they are unhappy that the censorship isn't being conducted in a way that benefits them. Back in 2008 I thought it was simple: just don't use Facebook. Maybe it was that simple back then. But not now. This internet thing really seems to be turning into the great problem of our time and I fully expect it to cause several major crises before we figure it out.
- 0xy 6y agoThis is amazing, because it means less competition and my business will get better marketing ROI. I fully support other businesses reducing advertising.