12 ms·
Microsoft Defender ATP for Linux is now generally available
- ecf 6y agoPrevious startup I was at had deployed the MacOS version of this and the entire Eng department had to petition to get it removed. It randomly picks files to send to MS for analysis and hijacks 50%+ of the CPU to do it. I legitimately don’t understand what it’s trying to accomplish other than another being a telemetry vacuum for MS.
- mrath 6y agoVery nature of this kind of software. Over years I have never seen a proper antivirus software work without coming on my way. Of course I have not used all of them but only the most popular ones. Locking files, 100 percent cpu usage, false positives are some known issues. In the last 5-6 years I have never seen it correctly report a threat, but that is just for me. I am sure it is working fine for some.
- lukevp 6y agoWe use BitDefender, and it once deleted the main .exe of an internal website (after several months of no issues with the same exe) mid-day. It also flagged that exe and made it nearly impossible to restore, even with the quarantine feature.
- oweiler 6y ago> Very nature of this kind of software. Over years I have never seen a proper antivirus software work without coming on my way. Of course I have not used all of them but only the most popular ones. Locking files, 100 percent cpu usage, false positives are some known issues. In the last 5-6 years I have never seen it correctly report a threat, but that is just for me. I am sure it is working fine for some. We use https://www.crowdstrike.com/ https://www.crowdstrike.com/ and never had any issues so far. Very low CPU usage, no false positives. Not sure if it actually does anything ;).
- ubercow13 6y agoDoes anyone know how it works with such low overhead? What's it doing differently?
- nix23 6y agoTrend Micro is really good, we had to use it and i was quite impressed on Linux and Windows (for a Antivirus), for the MS-Antivirus, just disable 'Automatic sample submission' EDIT: But to be honest, Antivirus is just Old-school protection, it never detected anything outside 'already known viruses', Snort/Suricata on the other hand detected quite often that something is going on. EDIT2: With "quite impressed" i mean, the performance was not much worse
- kchr 6y agoSnort/Suricata (and other IDS solutions) also depends on signatures/patterns. It's not different in that sense - you still need to define what to look for.
- nix23 6y agoYes but not file based signatures, the big difference are Network behavior analysis and Anomaly detection...and the biggest plus, its not on the device that is under attack/infected. >It's not different in that sense - you still need to define what to look for. Absolutely correct, i said nothing else, just that i found much more this way than with a locally installed Antivirus, there is just one measurement for a real secure connected computer..that is cable out ;)
- mc32 6y agoThey pretty much all do that if you want the full functionality. They’ll tell you if you disable that that you’re little better than having no product at all.
- m0xte 6y agoIt deleted my freshly code signed MSI the other day as well. This is irritating but as mentioned a not unusual side effect. A good thing is they have sample submission that was fast and efficient.
- nix23 6y ago>A good thing is they have sample submission Wait...you think that is something good, they criticized Kaspersky exactly for that.
- mynameisvlad 6y agoBeing able to submit samples and have them verified as known good or bad seems like a fantastic thing, especially when the default is reputation-based and not based on the code signing itself. Why do you think it's not?
- nix23 6y agoBecause you upload files (maybe private ones) to a 3rd party?
- mynameisvlad 6y agoI mean, you don't have to if you don't want to. Disable automatic uploads, and don't upload them yourself. There, your problem is solved. Those that want to contribute their samples in order to have them white/blacklisted can, but just because a feature is there doesn't mean somebody is forcing you to do it, nor that it's inherently bad because you're willingly uploading files to a 3rd party. How, exactly, would you expect AV/security companies to be able to analyze samples that are actually relevant to their customers if they're not submitted? They would never be able to find nearly as much malware on their own.
- cordite 6y agoThis requires a “Microsoft Defender ATP for Servers” license. But it isn’t clear on how to obtain that
- unsignedint 6y agoAs far as I know, it's a corporate tier of the Defender only available to corporate volume license customers. I guess it's similar to the way many vendors have a "EDR" version of the malware protection as opposed to the consumer version, which often reserve Linux protection for the former.
- mrits 6y agoYes, AT in itself is going to be shelf-ware soon. The data collected from Defender is much more useful in some of their other offerings such as in their newer SIEM.
- trollied 6y agoI swear Microsoft are slowly putting all of the pieces in place for Windows LX, which will be a Linux distribution.
- tw04 6y agoIf they truly wanted to go that route I think they’d just acquire canonical.
- jedieaston 6y agoWhy do you have to jinx it?
- shaan7 6y agoNow we has. We're all doomed.
- mikece 6y agoWhy acquire Canonical when they can just create a Redmond Linux distro and cherry-pick the best aspects of RHEL, Debian, or Gentoo -- or just plain fork something out there now and add the option of Microsoft corporate support for any manager wanting to buy a throat to choke in case there's a production hiccup? Or better yet: a Windows-like or Windows-compatible desktop that can run on any number of systems (and maybe corporate support is available for Debian, CentOS)? Let's not forget that the co-founder of Gnome has been working for Microsoft since 2016.
- mikece 6y agoI can see only one scenario where it makes sense for Microsoft to buy Canonical: to prevent Amazon or Google from acquiring them and doing something anti-competitive (or as much as can be done legally in that respect) and making life difficult for customers using Ubuntu on Azure. The comparison of relevance is Github. Microsoft was using Github so much already that the prospect of someone else buying them was an issue (not to mention the joke that buying Github was cheaper than paying for Microsoft's growing use of the platform). In practice, has Microsoft done anything to Github that has limited them in any way? The biggest change is that Github has a super-rich benefactor and they can offer free accounts to everyone now... and their budget for hiring/retaining top talent has been boosted as well. Microsoft has more than enough money to do the same with Canonical and if they do I think it will largely be a matter of making sure Canonical doesn't need to worry about finances anymore and can hire whomever they need to build and deliver features. And yes, it's possible that Azure Linux applications might be available on Ubuntu first but extending and extinguishing Ubuntu would be massively opposed to making money on Azure -- I don't see Microsoft doing that.
- ancarda 6y agoIs it open source? I can't find a GitHub link so I'm guessing it's not
- aewens 6y agoAn open source antivirus program is a bit oxymoronic. Sure, people can contribute new means of stopping more attacks, but it also shows attackers exactly how to evade it. So you'd be losing more than you'd gain in that situation.
- vuln 6y agoDang. I guess they better shutdown clamav. https://www.clamav.net/ https://www.clamav.net/
- RMPR 6y agoSecurity through obscurity (or security by obscurity) is the reliance in security engineering on design or implementation secrecy as the main method of providing security to a system or component. Security experts have rejected this view as far back as 1851, and advise that obscurity should never be the only security mechanism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security_through_obscurity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security_through_obscurity Edit: Link
- skinney6 6y agoI'm at a loss trying to capture the absurdity of this, but I'll try.. Smith finally escaped Oceania and made a nice home for himself in a free land with free peoples. One day agents from Oceania show up at his door. "No hard feelings bud. In fact we brought a gift. We think it will help you. We want to install these little black boxes all throughout your home." Smith is all ... "ok".
- detaro 6y agoIt's probably more "Our customers have policies/certifications requiring they have antivirus software everywhere, even if that's stupid. We could tell those customers that we can't offer a solution and they'll go somewhere else. Or we could make the thing they 'need' and get their business". Not very absurd at all.
- ancarda 6y agoCan those customers not install ClamAV? Does that not count as anti-virus?
- tw04 6y agoCan I buy an enterprise support contract for it? I honestly don’t see an option on the site. That’s usually a hard requirement in the enterprise.
- greedo 6y agoCisco AMP is just re-badged ClamAV.
- tgtweak 6y agoFun fact that doesn't actually pass on pci-dss1 audit. You need a commercial antivirus with active subscription and centralized monitoring of that. Also I'm guessing it's easier for admins of mixed infra to have a single threat definition (ie. So your storage server catches the same threats as your endpoints)
- jksmith 6y agoIf MSFT figures out how to make this uninstallable on Linux, I will stop using computers.
- smcl 6y agoYou mean non-uninstallable?
- mrits 6y agoNo, he's a HUGE Microsoft fan :)
- msla 6y agoDo people think Microsoft owns Linux now?
- jksmith 6y agoNot own, but assimilate. Own the attention. GPL will have new perspectives after this is over with. For those of you who don't use Windows, try to uninstall the AV on windows 10. MSFT AV uses about 400 mb of ram on my Lenovo Flex 11 running windows 10. A bit of memory can be saved if you open admin powershell and run "Set-MpPreference -DisableRealtimeMonitoring 1"
- art4ur 6y agoMaybe, just don't install it?
- nix23 6y agoNice that a proprietary software firm can stop you from using Computers...that is the wet dream of Apple ;)
- cik 6y agoWhilst I've never been a Microsoft user, it's refreshing to see these moves. For decades they've been an opponent of anything being OSS, let alone running on OSS. While the move isn't for everyone (heck, not me) it's still a very positive step, pretty much in line with Nadella's underlying strategy vis-a-vis Microsoft's newfound growth. Security mandates such as PCI mandate running anti-virus and friends on a per host basis. They demand a 24-hour event review, FIM, etc. If tools like this come to Linux, it'll make it significantly easier for many organizations to start complying with these mandates. To be clear - these organizations already take security at best as a suggestion - these tools help reduce the barrier to entry so that at least the basics can be addressed. I'd imagine that well over 95% of Linux users would never run Microsoft tools on Linux. At the same time, for those Windows shops that are experimenting with Linux, or need to support a few workloads, can't afford the dedicated expertise (yet) this is definitely a step forward to help them.
- TheRealDunkirk 6y ago> If tools like this come to Linux, it'll make it significantly easier for many organizations to start complying with these mandates. You said a lot more than you probably intended. Microsoft created the Microsoft-loving, Linux-hating trade press in the 90's. Consultancies fell into line, and started pushing the theory to uncritical IT management that if you had a computer connected to the corporate network, it had to run a virus scanner. Period; full stop. Regardless of operating system. I've never met anyone in corporate IT who actually does the math, and determines whether a particular threat vector is worth the cost of the preventative measure. The philosophy in the 3 Fortune 250's I've worked for has been: if it exists, it must be purchased/used/applied. In the 90's, yes, every WINDOWS computer connected to the corporate network needed the corporate AV running on it. Linux? Mac? Not so much. Even if they managed to get compromised, the chance that they would infect a neighboring computer were very small. These odds didn't justify the expense or the hassle of needing them to slaved into the corporate AV solution, no matter how much Microsoft diverted attention away from the very special problem that Windows has always posed from a security standpoint, how much they paid the trade press to paper over it, and how much they partnered with consultancies to push that line. They didn't care about the mainframe, did they? They didn't care about the Unix workstations, either. But Linux? It was the devil. We have come full circle. Microsoft is trying their hardest to astroturf the message that WSL enables a lot of development workflows for which Windows has been a poor choice of late, and this requires them to "love Linux." So now Microsoft MUST release their Defender product for Linux, in order to be taken seriously BY THE VERY CULTURE THEY CREATED. As a guy who run Linux on the desktop for 19 years, and got my corporate IT (in the 90's) to consider Linux all the way to the point of them looking into a virus scanner for it (finding that Symantec didn't support it, and dropping the idea), the irony here is both delicious and sickening at the same time. As I keep saying, I'll believe Microsoft "loves" Linux they day they create Office and an AD client for it.
- nix23 6y agoTrying to bring the performance from Windows to Linux...love it ;) EDIT: For the down-voter that was ironic, try copy lots of files from one Disk to another (in Windows) and during the copy-progress disable Defender...huge "performance" gain
- fmakunbound 6y agoWell, I downloaded the .deb file for MDATP, and right off the bat in the installation scripts, it's posting telemetry (literally, LogTelemetry in the scripts) to https://x.cp.wd.microsoft.com/api/report https://x.cp.wd.microsoft.com/api/report Then poking around in the giant .so and executable front end, you find a ton more. What's it sending? Fucked if I know. I figured they couldn't help themselves, though.
- deadso 6y agoI don't think people ITT understand what Defender ATP is supposed to be. It's not just an AV, but rather also has the ability to do threat protection across all your assets in the company. It can analyze an attackers moves within your network, figuring out what files they accessed, ways they pivoted, and other stuff. So not only would it detect that you got compromised, but the display will show you likely paths, names of users that are also compromised, mitigation steps, deployed persistence measures, etc. So for Defender ATP to work optimally in a deployment that leverages linux nodes, or has users using linux as their daily driver, you need to support linux.
- mistrial9 6y agofixed it -- the product claims say "It can analyze an attackers moves within your network, figuring out what files they accessed, ways they pivoted, and other stuff."
- mrits 6y agoYour statement would have been valid a few years ago. But now all AV providers also offer what you are talking about. AV+EDR with advanced threat hunting UI. So when you say AV today you should really think the other stuff as well.
- deadso 6y agoThanks for the info. Yeah, I'm not up to speed on the latest in the defense world. Good to know. I just felt like I had to bring it up because (at the time of posting) people were exclusively discussing the merits of an AV on linux (which is debatable) vs the value of EDR in a corporate environment.
- TA43 6y agoThey provide it but often not in the same product capacity, a common structure would be Sophos & CarbonBlack - two separate products by different companies. Additionally they'd need a third product to cover the *nix estate. Defender, in its current state, rolls all of the above into one at a relatively competitive price point. Additionally, it receives new detections built off all the telemetry they get as a result of Windows Defender existing on almost every Win10 OS on the planet. This leveraging of data on such a scale is letting Microsoft quickly become the market leader for threat detection & response.
- 1MachineElf 6y agoSeems like offsetting the potential for one kind of spyware in exchange for another.
- microcolonel 6y agoWhat does this actually do? The marketing material is decidedly vague.
- mike503 6y agoFeels ironic for Microsoft to announce security tools for Linux. Have always thought MS should turn Windows back into a window manager, not a fully-fledged OS, and use Linux as the base under the hood.
- MintelIE 6y agoWhat is this even? Like Snort? I haven't been knowledgeable about the Windows ecosystem since the Web 1.0 days.