6 ms·
I actually don't understand the motivation behind these projects. Usually the games for which an open source engine is written for are quite old. Old enough tha
by imtringued 6y ago
I actually don't understand the motivation behind these projects. Usually the games for which an open source engine is written for are quite old. Old enough that emulation should be more than sufficient to play these games on something like a Mac with an ARM based SoC. It is also not possible to exactly replicate the game without straight up reverse engineering the game's binary which will open you up for lawsuits. The end result is a very similar game that is merely sharing the same assets but it just isn't the same. If the project was created with the intention of allowing a new experience that is different from the original game then it will be harder than expected because you still need artists, musicians and so on to create more content. Ultimately I think people should focus on making a very good and very faithful clone instead of replicating an old game that still requires you to own the original and proprietary assets.
Of course everything I'm talking about could miss the point of the project and the contributors are just doing this for fun because they like writing code for games but can't create game art on their own.
- gjs278 6y agothey can mod it and make their own version easier. the modding tools for these kind of games isn't the greatest. it worked for doom because it was a simpler game and there was a reference client provided, they are just trying to make the reference client.
- cobalt 6y agobeyond the obvious 'do it to show that i can' and similar reasons, one less obvious reason may be that often people want to mod these games and its easier than either making a reproduction or using hacks. Having the actual code the game runs (even if decompiled) allows you to both learn how things were done, as well as modify them and improve them. Many people starting out in games development often want to make games like RPGs to emulate a favorite game they play, but want to experiment with their own rules/mechanics
- marvin 6y agoThe point is obviously as an exercise to pick apart a piece of older technology, figure out how it was built and interacts with the original assets, and create a machine that works for doing that. If you've got a passion for software and the game in question, it's a rewarding activity in its own right, in addition to being an excellent avenue for learning new languages and tools. Not every instance of human effort needs to push the world forward in a way that's immediately economically rewarding.
- stefanchrobot 6y agoI started to write the engine for my favourite game in my favourite programming language and the experience was addictive and enjoyable beyond compare. Sadly I just couldn't justify to myself the amount of hours that I would need to spend to complete this project.
- pvg 6y agoThey can end up producing more convenient, better performing, better integrated, more moddable versions of the game. When it works out it's sort of an 'amateur/community remaster'. Of course that's piles of work so there's many more unfinished than reasonably finished ones.
- steerablesafe 6y agoHave you heard about openttd?
- waldfee 6y agoOpenRA states in the about section > This means that OpenRA is not restricted by the technical limitations of the original closed-source games: it includes native support for modern operating systems and screen resolutions... I think this is the most compelling reason - it opens up features that would be way harder to realize in the original engine. noteworthy - OpenXcom https://openxcom.org/about/ https://openxcom.org/about/ - OpenRA https://www.openra.net/about/ https://www.openra.net/about/ - OpenTTD https://www.openttd.org/about.html https://www.openttd.org/about.html
- crazysim 6y ago- OpenRCT2 https://openrct2.org/ https://openrct2.org/
- waldfee 6y agothank you, i'll need to give this a go
- Lariscus 6y ago- OpenMW https://openmw.org/en/ https://openmw.org/en/
- mikorym 6y ago> not restricted by technical limitations Yup, if you play Sacred Gold or Disciples II using open frameworks you get a game that looks much newer. But more importantly, perpetually playable. Disciples II has an edit that uses OpenGL that makes the game much faster and more playable, and gives widescreen. Sacred has numerous mods, such as giving 1080p HD (and more). The next question is going to be: "But why do you play those games?" To this I will ask, honestly, what is Fortnight anyway?
- heyens 6y agoDo you by any chance have a link to the "open framework Sacred Gold" you mentioned? It's been a while, but I sure would go look for my old disks to give it a try in FHD!
- rakoo 6y agoTo me it seems the point is to have an open engine to be able to create that kind of games; instead of starting completely from scratch, they wanted to emulate a base that is known to be working and actually fun to use, so the moment they reach feature-parity they'll have a solid foundation. After that anyone can create on top of the existing and make it even better. This feels like people who are passionate about the base game and would like to see it being open-sourced but they don't own the source code, so they do the equivalent
- rasz 6y agoThis might be more to your liking https://github.com/diasurgical/devilution#introduction https://github.com/diasurgical/devilution#introduction it is a faithful reconstruction of original Diablo source code from various debug builds leaked over the years.
- madmoose 6y agoScummVM contains almost 80 game engines (and a lot of sub-engines) supporting hundreds of games. Most of them are made by straight reverse engineering of the original executables. In the early days we did have a lengthy back-and-forth with a tenacious lawyer from LucasLegal but they backed off when we convinced them that we didn't support piracy. It is not uncommon for rereleases of older games to use the ScummVM engine instead of the original engine, see for instance the recent rerelease of Westwood's Blade Runner on GOG.com, which wouldn't have happened without ScummVM.
- anthk 6y agoScummvm compiled with --enable-all-engines supports a fuckload of games, even maybe, Microsoft Encarta. You can even run Ultima games.
- Kaze404 6y agoPeople ported Diablo I to the Nintendo Switch using a similar project.