9 ms·
Millions of Americans Can't Afford Water
- bashwizard 6y agoMurica! Best 3rd world country in the world!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dreen 6y agoHow are we doing on desalination technologies?
- microcolonel 6y agoWe have heaps of fresh water in NA, I guess except in these areas (many of which seem to be in places where fresh water is scarcer). I think for many of these, it is still cheaper to bring water from a fresh water source than it is to bring it from the ocean, even if there is no desalination cost.
- gshdg 6y agoPretty sure lack of fresh water supply isn’t the problem in Philadelphia.
- pjc50 6y agoThere's a fundamental lower bound on the energy usage of desalination. The current state of the art - reverse osmosis - isn't perfect, but we should not expect factor-of-ten reductions in energy usage.
- whb07 6y agoSomewhere like Austin could definitely use solar energy to boil water couldn’t they? Not only solar panels but those mirror/reflective panels into a concentrated spot to shine?
- pjc50 6y agoAustin is ~150 miles from the sea, so you'd incur substantial pumping costs. Solar thermal "flash" desalination is one of those things that sounds obvious but is hardly ever done, so I suspect there are good reasons for that.
- jojobas 6y agoThere was (almost) never a problem running out of river water. Freshwater (i.e. river) treatment is peanuts compared to desalination. It's pumps and pipes that cost most, not filters.
- microcolonel 6y ago> Water bills that exceed 4 percent of household income are considered unaffordable. This seems extremely arbitrary. It's not that they can't afford water, it's that it's a relatively important expense rather than a trivial one. Most people in these income brackets don't even pay water bills directly.
- exabrial 6y agoAgree... There are plenty of items to cut from the budget first: tattoos, cigarettes, fast food, soda, energy drinks, Netflix, iPhones, or... Just moving to a cheaper area to live that's not an expensive coastal city.
- simonh 6y agoI think you're confused. This article is about people on very low incomes in places like Tucson and Detroit, not hipsters.
- gspr 6y agoEntirely regardless of any cuts made to the expenses side of things, can we agree that having to spend 4% of household income on water in a developed country is absolutely bonkers?
- onefuncman 6y agoIsn't everyone insolvent, in 2020?
- simonh 6y ago"Amid rising costs and diminishing federal dollars, the use of punitive measures—shutoffs and liens (a legal claim on the house linked to a debt which can lead to foreclosure)—is widespread. Just like mortgage foreclosures, water shutoffs and liens can force affected households to abandon their homes." and "In 2014, shortly after filing the largest municipal bankruptcy in U.S. history, the city launched a massive shutoff program and has since disconnected at least 141,000 households, according to records obtained by news website Bridge." Sounds like they can't afford water.
- mschuster91 6y agoThat truck driver guy with the 30.000 US$ bill - what? Let's generously assume he hasn't paid a single bill in 10 years to have that bill in 2013. That's 3.000 US$ a year or 250$ a month?! How is this possible? Here in Germany average water bill is around that in a whole year! What is the US doing with all the money? People pay a roughly thousand dollars on average based on the numbers in this article, and have abysmal service, no maintenance, and sometimes outright toxic water (Flint, the fracking areas where the water is flammable). Where is that excess money going? [0] https://www.t-online.de/heim-garten/energie/id_77342378/wasserkosten-in-deutschen-staedten-extrem-unterschiedlich.html https://www.t-online.de/heim-garten/energie/id_77342378/wass...
- christophilus 6y agoI can't speak for the rest of the US, but I have a family of 4, and we pay maybe $50/mo for our water bill, so maybe $600/year. More than the German average, but not egregious. Relative to a lot of other countries, the US is kind of more like strong union of a bunch of countries (states)-- each with unique environments and ecosystems-- than it is like a united, single country. So, you can say: "Americans are like ___", and you can almost certainly find a spot in the US where your statement holds true. As for costs, the US has wildly variable costs on most things, depending on where you live. For example, I pay $1.50 per gallon for gas, but one state up, it's above $2.00. I live in a comfortable house, and pay less for my mortgage + taxes than folks in New Jersey pay just in taxes on a smaller house. This variance is a side-effect of a more decentralized governmental system where states have a lot of power, combined with a wide variation in environments / scarcity across the country.
- zaarn 6y agoGermany isn't that much different, the federal government has a bit more power but generally people from one state differ much from another. Compare Berlin and Bavaria, if you want an example. Bavaria is one of the more expensive states to live in and Berlin is somewhat cheap (other former ostblock states are even cheaper) and on the other hand we have the highest average income and pay into the other federal states the most. Cost of water, electricity and food differ between states. A Döner Kebab in Berlin costs around 3.50€ by my experience, in Bavaria a comparable one costs around 5-7€. You can't easily say "Germans are like ___", most of the international stereotypes are born out of the WW2 occupation of bavaria, not much else.
- yardie 6y agoOne of the things I noticed since moving back to the US is Americans are averse to spending money on anything that doesn't improve their social standing. Municipalities included. Brand new skyscrapers get built and the taxes and fees raised from it are spent on stadiums, arenas, and beautification. But that luxury skyscraper is still plumbed into tired, 50 year old infrastructure that needs replacing now.
- Shivetya 6y agoThe problem is best labeled as Ribbon Cutting. Politicians love to cut ribbons but spending money to maintain does not impart any name recognition. The second motive is anything that fills their campaign coffers. However it should be noted that one of the most major expenses in cities is paying their payroll and in particular their pension requirements as public employee unions pretty much have them over a barrel and politicians trade public money for political favor without regards to the costs. finally it also comes down to the penalties, fees, and such, of government services affect the poor far more than any other group. That twenty dollar renewal for your license might be nothing to you but it doesn't work that way when your poor. Throw in that municipal fees tend to be a lot higher and you can see the difficulty. Atlanta was only forced in fixing their sewers which of course exploded their service costs after they kept dumping into local rivers. PDF of city of Atlanta budget https://s3.amazonaws.com/saportakinsta/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/FY2021-Proposed-Budget-Book_Final-05032020.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/saportakinsta/wp-content/uploads/20...
- nervousvarun 6y agoExactly...the same reason many of our public schools are conducted in immaculate modern buildings (easily visible from the road/campaign commercials and identifiable as something the current politician spent on 'education') yet our teachers are paid a relative pittance.
- Exmoor 6y agoI would encourage people to actually look their local teacher's salaries, they should be a matter of public record. The "teachers make terrible money" talking point has been a talking point my entire life so I was surprised when my wife pulled up our local elementary school records and showed me that our child's kindergarten teacher made over $100,000/yr. Her school's PE teacher made $120,000/yr. This is in a county where the median household income is $66,000/yr so I wouldn't call it a pittance. I'm sure there are plenty of places in the country where teacher pay is lower than it should be, but teacher's unions have benefited greatly by the perception that they're universally underpaid.
- rabanne 6y ago>Austin, Texas, where the average annual bill rose from $566 in 2010 to $1,435 in 2018 How can anyone justify people paying more than $110 for water and sewers? I pay $20 and even that seems a lot to me.
- bluedino 6y agoI live about 3 blocks from a friend of mine, I'm in township, he's in the city. His water bill is $120/month, mine is $90 every quarter. We get the same water/sewer from the same place.
- quickthrowman 6y agoYour neighbor either has huge water needs for watering/a pool or he has a leak/leaky fixture in his supply lines. $120/month where I live would be 33,200 gallons a month. That’s nearly a gallon a minute.
- MrFoof 6y agoRates are vastly different depending on where you live, and can greatly increase depending on separate sewer charges. For example, many areas in Massachusetts have separate sewer fees assessed which is primarily paying back bonds for new infrastructure. So for me, my rates are approximately: * Water - $6.75 per 100 cubic feet * Sewer - $14.25 per 100 cubic feet Or, $21 per 748 gallons, which is $0.028 per gallon, and is ~7.75x as expensive as your water rates. I have about an $18/mo water bill, which is for ~640 gallons a month. 33,200 gallons would cost ~$930 a month.
- danaris 6y ago> I'm in township, he's in the city They're in different municipalities, so the rates are different. They could easily be using the exact same amount of water each month.
- virmundi 6y agoHow about garbage? We pay about $100 a month for water, sewer, and garbage. We get biweekly pickups and large trash hauled for free once a month. They even take fridges no question.
- AuthorizedCust 6y agoPart of high water costs are certain cities charge increasing per-gallon rates the more you use, to discourage lawn irrigation. This isn't just a drought measure. Dallas's predatory water-pricing scheme is permanent, even when our reservoirs are so overfull that we're just dumping excess water into the rivers, which is a surprising amount of the time. It's been years since there's been any legitimate need for pricing to discourage water use.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Scoundreller 6y agoIn the electricity world, things are divided between production, transmission and distribution. You might have tons of generation, but insufficient capacity to get it to markets. Then there’s the discharge/storm water issue. Farmers may not contribute to that, but urban/suburban usage does. A well-watered lawn doesn’t hold much water when a storm rushes in.
- roenxi 6y ago> Nina Lakhani is an environmental justice reporter with Guardian US, where she's reporting for the Our Unequal Earth project. I'm not really up to date on American water politics. Is this article presented with a partisan slant or is it fairly neutral? Job titles like that were a fair signal of things being partisan pieces a few years ago but the style might be changing.
- DanCarvajal 6y agoAt the very least the sample size of cities they use is 12, which seems insufficient. The mention they they are diverse selection but half the cities on the list are in desert or near desert climates, where water scarcity comes into play. I'm not saying that water can't be expensive, and that in some places agricultural uses are just downright wasteful (we grow a lot of food in irrigated deserts), but all of my bias flags have gone up in this article.
- justin66 6y agoThey spend a few paragraphs on Cleveland, which is pretty close to the opposite of a desert city. Rebuilding the sewers is an expensive, multi-decade project here that needs to be paid for, and water treatment and pumping isn't free anywhere. They're quite right that rising water and sewage costs are a concern here, but it would have been interesting for them to spend a little more effort and explain how the guy they mentioned accumulated $30k in debt to the water company, which is a bit extreme even for the area. (googling the guy revealed a separate story of him being foreclosed on because of taxes: https://www.news5cleveland.com/news/e-team/warrensville-heights-man-could-lose-his-home-over-25-cents https://www.news5cleveland.com/news/e-team/warrensville-heig...)
- igammarays 6y agoPartisan bias notwithstanding, the plain facts presented in the article seem to indicate pretty objectively that there is a major nationwide problem with water infrastructure. Denial is blindness. - "Nationwide, the rising cost of water has significantly outstripped the consumer price index over the past decade." - Federal funding for water systems has fallen by 77 percent in real terms since its peak in 1977. - The U.S. is the only country in the industrialized world without a regulatory system, responsible for monitoring rates and performance, according to Stephen Gasteyer, professor of sociology at Michigan State University.
- williesleg 6y agoWater is the new Global Warming
- splitrocket 6y ago"Late Stage Capitalism" really starts to make sense when you realize that profit is literally the measure of inefficiency in a market. edit: A perfectly efficient market has no profit margin. As a market increases in efficiency, the profit margin of all participants approaches zero. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_competition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_competition
- nickik 6y agoLate Stage Capitalism is a nonsense concept. Perfect competition is a very simplistic assumption from unrealistic late 19th century economic model by Walras. That is fine for econ 101 but its clearly not what economists have understood for a long time. Also, water markets are inertly political for the most part, so political economy actually gives you far more insight into how they work then Walrasian micro economics.
- abstractbarista 6y agoProfit is the carrot on the economic stick, driving productivity and innovation.
- driverdan 6y agoNone of this makes sense to me. Water is still extremely cheap. Prices should go up in drought-prone regions they mentioned (eg Austin) to help incentivize reduced water use. If you're paying $100/m it means you're using too much water. If you can't afford that use less. Excluding laundry I currently use less than 5 gallons a day between myself and my dog. It's not hard to do.
- Scoundreller 6y agoI’d prefer tiered billing. The first X gallons/day cost $x, then it goes up. That way you subsidize sanitation, but charge for washing your car or watering your lawn. Many places have complicated programs to do that in reverse (get this credit for removing your lawn or this tax credit for a new washing machine). California lets you run your washing machine drain into your backyard without a permit, that’s one regulatory way to reuse gray-water. If gray water reuse requires $hundreds-$thousands in permits and plumbers, people won’t bother.
- nickik 6y agoI totally agree, that is the way to do it. However, we must realize that, specially in California, its actually agriculture that uses most water. Standford university turning of their fountains and other 'publicity' stunts will not fix anything. You need to fix the pricing in the broader water market, change the intensives for California farmers so they plant things that require less water, or have more intensive to limit water consumption.
- Scoundreller 6y agoRight. It also depends on geography. Sometimes water is easy, but sewerage capacity is the limit, so gray water reuse makes sense to encourage where possible. Water is measured, but sewage discharge isn’t. I’d like holding tanks for gray water re-use for toilets. Apparently still gray water becomes septic after a day, but if it’s your toilet, shouldn’t you assume the water in there is septic anyway??
- driverdan 6y ago