7 ms·
People have stopped going to the doctor and most seem fine
- Kednicma 6y agoI can't speak for others, but I'm between jobs due to the pandemic and can't afford health care without employer-provided insurance. Most people are fine most of the time, which is why it doesn't seem like a problem. But I bet that it will eventually be a problem; chronic issues need to be taken care of, and everybody can benefit from a visit to the dentist now and then.
- Icathian 6y agoThis article seems to suggest that because no spike in short-term ailments due to lower frequency of care has been observed in a 5-month span, there is no damage to the quality of our society's physical health overall. That seems incredibly myopic to me. The real question is whether there there will be statistically detectable increases in severity or prevalence of chronic or emergent ailments in the long run. How many cancers are detected later, how many lower-back pain cases are allowed to degenerate further, etc etc. And further, do those (to my mind inevitable) subtler long-term consequences outweigh the societal gain from less healthcare spending? They may or may not, but this article doesn't even ask the question, let alone suggest ways to answer it. This feels like low-effort clickbait to me.
- pfkurtz 6y agoThis whole crisis has seen constant articles that, at least on the clickbait level which actually influences our discourse, present reasoning like "we didn't notice anything bad (yet)" -> "maybe nothing's ever bad again!"
- alistairSH 6y agoIn my mind, the missed cancers could be a problem. But, there's a lot of "health care" that doesn't really need to happen. A few of my family members have chronic health issues that require medication. These are typically prescribed 6-months at a time, requiring in-person bi-annual follow-ups. That's a waste of both parties time - patient and doctor - as 95% of the time, the result is "here's another 6 months" and 5% "here's the same drug, with an adjust dose". Those appointments should only occur if there's an issue that requires new dosing or a change of medication. The rest of the time, it should be either completely automatic, or at most a simple phone call. I assume this doesn't happen, either because it's a CYA maneuver by the physician, or because the physician wants to bill for the appointment.
- rightbyte 6y agoA less cynical analysis would be that there is a risk of changed conditions that it is good that the doctor notices.
- throwaway_jobs 6y ago> Those appointments should only occur if there's an issue that requires new dosing or a change of medication. But isn’t that a little bit of Monday morning quarter backing? In other words how does a doctor know if a therapy/Rx needs to be modified for a chronic condition without a doctor visit and in many cases blood work? In fact a 6 month therapy for a chronic condition would suggest The doctor has extreme confidence in the patient to adhere to their therapies...statistically about 1M hospitalizations occur in the US per year (Coating billions) because of lack of medication adherence (and these are only those cases resulting in hospitalization), how many more simply result in a sicker patient without a hospitalization event?
- alistairSH 6y agoThings like asthma inhalers don't normally require bloodwork. Just a quick Q&A, which could be done less expensively over the phone, if it's even really necessary. Or, annually instead of bi-annually.
- throwaway_jobs 6y agoEven in the case of asthma, I think a doctor would hopefully not treat it like cookie cutter Health care. Surely there are standards and best practices, but then there is also the actual practice of medicine. Standards might suggest 1 year is fine, but he Generally a doctor might want to see young (Kids) and old patients more often than a otherwise healthy adult, perhaps the doctor has reason to belief seasonal allergies/pollen may be effecting patients more in a given year, and (not to give doctors to much credit)again the idea the doctor has concerns with a given patient’s track record of adherence Issues and/or medication related hospitalizations.
- wincy 6y ago
- robbiep 6y agoI agree the longer term studies are going to be fascinating. Anecdotally, in Australia (where I work/practice and have many colleagues completing their specialist training currently) presentations for chest pain and total heart attack presentations are down significantly. No studies yet. Will be interesting to see if we will see deferred cases present later and with greater morbidity or just what the hell is going on, but my incoming assumption would have been that heart attacks would be something that someone is going to present with anyway. As an example of how COVID has changed our approach in hospital, telehealth clinics are now replacing many outpatient visits (your other commenter below hits on the wastefulness of this). 10 years of IT change came to healthcare in about 2 weeks. It’s been wild. It’s also caused us to get much more efficient with referrals. My colleague is a Plastics resident and had to trim his 500 patient referral list into must see and defer piles. He trimmed it to 100 by ensuring that, for instance, skin cancer referrals had tissue diagnoses before coming into clinic to be booked for surgery (something that the GPs should have done anyway) - so everyone is being forced to polish up their referral pathways and pull their weight along the healthcare chain, rather than what I often witness which is everyone just picking up slack wherever it lands. Will be interesting to see how far this holds as life returns to normal here
- fullshark 6y ago> Most Isn't the primary point of going to the doctor "anomaly detection" i.e. this thing is bothering me, will it go away on its own or do I need to do more? Most being fine is expected, doesn't mean losing doctors visits was not a big deal. I've heard lot of speculation that we've lost months of early cancer detections due to the lockdown for example. Future date statistical analysis will confirm the long term cost of sacrificing thousands of doctor visits.
- braymundo 6y agoIatrogenesis. Nassim Taleb explains a great deal about it in Antifragile: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iatrogenesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iatrogenesis
- 7177Y 6y agoMost people were also stuck at home, living a much lower impact lifestyle.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoI wondered about that - the cost to the environment (is that what you mean by 'impact'?). I guess this is off topic. But not travelling - check. Ordering all the stuff online from different vendors, consuming more (because, more idle leisure), doing more home projects cost something. Heck, construction is booming. That's an impact too. I wonder what it'll all add up to.
- eyerony 6y agoIf I could get antibiotics for strep or sinus infections without going to them, I'd pretty much never go. Those visits are really dumb because I already know what's wrong, and just need them to say "yep, it's the thing you already knew it was, here's a prescription and a bill for doing nothing useful" ... actually on reflection already knowing what's wrong and just needing a doctor to say it so treatment can proceed is the norm for interaction with doctors generally among friends and family. Including having to gently walk the doctor to the correct diagnosis so they don't waste a bunch of time and get you in for more visits and tests than you need.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThe doctor can check for problems with similar symptoms. The simple act of looking up your nose and into your throat tells a lot. Simply thinking "I hurt, like I hurt the last time I got strep" isn't a diagnosis. Its witchcraft essentially.
- robbiep 6y agoWhilst I can’t speak for your particular circumstances and will assume you know exactly what is wrong with you and what you need, this assumption cannot be applied more broadly. In many respects the family practitioner’s role as gatekeeper to further medical care is anachronistic; perhaps we will be able to solve this with better technology. Until then, it provides a important centre for coordination of care and the prevention of unnecessary care (however imperfect this is at present)
- ryandrake 6y agoAs someone who rarely goes to the doctor (unless it's very serious) and when he does, does extensive "internet research" of his symptoms beforehand to come in knowledgable, I agree that for me, GPs gatekeeping medicine is unnecessary. BUUUUT, I have a family friend who is basically a hypochondriac. She goes to the doctor ridiculously frequently, and is always trying to convince them (and everyone else who will listen) that she has all these undiagnosed medical conditions that she needs constant treatment for. Usually she's just sent home, where she does more and more "internet research" to find even more things that must be wrong with her. And it's not substance addiction: She's not going in there seeking abusable medication. She just wants validation that she has all these terrible conditions that she's dreamt up, and someone to finally tell her she's right. So, I guess at the end of the day we do need the gatekeepers, as anachronistic as they seem.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThe postponed dentist visits will have their fallout (!) eventually. Delayed annual visits to check for skin cancer, colon cancer etc will statistically hurt us. Mammograms put off, should have a definite downside in terms of early detection. Heck, even delaying car maintenance will cost folks hard cash later. The bill will definitely come due, for the slowdown.
- sixothree 6y agoI am scared of having any sort of dental issues. The few times in the past I've had any issues, they felt... urgent.
- Sevrene 6y agoSometimes being too cautious can cause harm too. It's not so clear cut as you might think. For instance, pushing mammograms earlier in life causes over diagnosis (around 20% in one study), leading to invasive surgeries that were not actually required, and they're not without risk. It can be pretty intense having a cancer scare, too. So if we spend more money on these and we do them more often yet they don't actually improve mortality, is it worth it? There's a trade up there which your doctor should be making.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoHm. 'Getting scared' vs 'missing a cancer and dying'. There's a disparity in the cost of those two false results. I know which side I'm on.
- Sevrene 6y ago22% unnecessary surgeries following mammograms[1] is not just 'getting scared' these are invasive surgeries with real risks. Are you strawmanning my point or just being hyperbolic? Again, I ask, hoping for a less flippant answer; if we spend money, time, effort on increasing mammograms that doesn't actually improve overall mortality and has it's own risks, should we still do it? I'm not saying this because I think we should never investigate or search for cancer, I'm just stating that it's not as clear as 'mammogram always good'. We must weigh the risks with the benefits and we cannot just ignore the harm because we're scared of the possibility of death. [1] https://www.bmj.com/content/348/bmj.g366 https://www.bmj.com/content/348/bmj.g366
- burkaman 6y ago> In a recent survey, only one in 10 respondents said their or a family member’s health had worsened as a result of delayed care during the pandemic. That's 30 million people. And in a fantasy world where going to the doctor in America was cheap and easy, I imagine most people would be happy to go regularly if they knew there was a 10% chance it would make them healthier. Also, how are people answering this survey? One of the main points of going to a doctor is to detect problems or risky behavior that you don't know about. You cannot replace going to the doctor with answering the single question self-assessment "Has my health worsened?"
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoAnd younger people's health is going to be generally better right now just because they're not getting colds all the time.
- r00fus 6y agoYeah, like we had few colds/flus in the past year or two for our large-ish family, but now it's gone to zero for the past 4 months which is... impressive. So does that mean when things come back on that we can expect a flurry of illnesses going around?
- votepaunchy 6y agoIf the average family size is three, then to account for the "or a family member's health" would mean something on the order of 10 million Americans adversely affected.
- burkaman 6y agoThat's true. But again, how could people know? My parents are not going to mention some minor health problem on the phone with me, especially if they can't go to the doctor to confirm there's something wrong.
- throwaway_USD 6y agoThis is like a cruel joke...its like saying if you are not diagnosed with a disease you don't have it. All anyone need to look at is the incidences of people getting a chronic condition as soon become medicare eligible. Its like magic people are healthy, then they receive Medicare and they get chronic conditions...no they had the chronic condition they just weren't diagnosed and treated until Medicare eligible. Medicare Patient Chronic Condition Statistics: Over one half of beneficiaries less than 65 years had two or more chronic conditions compared to: Sixty-three percent of those 65-74 years, • Seventy-eight percent of those 75-84 years and, • Eighty-three percent of beneficiaries 85 years and older. If people were covered and had access to care then the incidences would dramatically go down, instead we all but ensure by the time they hit Medicare and the taxpayers pick up the bills they have multiple expensive chronic conditions that have gone undiagnosed and untreated for years.
- bjarneh 6y ago> .its like saying if you are not diagnosed with a disease you don't have it. But most "seem fine" :-)
- OldHand2018 6y agoI'd love to go to the doctor, but I don't have a pressing emergency; no-one is willing to schedule an appointment. I'd love to do to the dentist; the very few I've found willing to do routine teeth cleaning have a reservation system that requires winning the scheduling lottery. I guess that superficially, I'm fine. For now, at least. At least I have an HSA; most of my health insurance money is sitting in an account instead of being lost forever.
- xnx 6y agoNYT also has the counterpoint: "Vaccine Rates Drop Dangerously as Parents Avoid Doctor’s Visits" https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/23/health/coronavirus-measles-vaccines.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/23/health/coronavirus-measle...
- gridlockd 6y agoNecessary or not is subjective. For example, at the collective level, lung cancer screening costs outweigh the benefit. At the individual level, early detection gives the best chance for survival.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- op03 6y agoNot leaving home much probably minimizes exposure to all the usual threats. Reminds me of my grandaunt who rarely left the house after the death of her husband. But she was very active, and had family members around to help out. She was quite healthy till the end and outlived her siblings/peer group by a big margin.
- ianleeclark 6y agoThe more I think about the healthcare problem in the United States, the more it appears to be a Gordian knot. The author doesn't explicitly call for any policy proposal, rather he wishes some medically informed patient into existence. This effectively turns the doctor-patient relationship on its head, but, unfortunately, it seems reasonable to do so, given the opioid epidemic. I don't want to have to know as much as my doctor, I just want them to tell me how to fix it, and I am willing to bet most people largely feel the same. On the other hand, I can hardly imagine that decreased consumption of healthcare isn't going to cause corporations to recoup lost profits elsewhere, so I'm not sure if the long-run is particularly different from the author's suggestion. In short: indecision.
- silveroriole 6y ago“Only” 1 in 10 respondents said their health had worsened due to delayed treatment? That seems really high to me! There’s a very obvious ulterior motive we could ascribe to papers publishing anti-healthcare pieces. e: and note this is only people whose health WORSENED. People like me who have a condition which has stayed the same, but have not been able to receive further tests and treatment, are not accounted for in that figure.
- votepaunchy 6y agoThe quote is "only one in 10 respondents said their health or a family member’s health had worsened as a result of delayed care". You may still think this is high, but it's not "1 in 10" when accounting for family size.
- thecloudball 6y agoI have realized doctors don't do much good, except for very extreme treatments for life-threatening conditions (surgery, powerful medications etc). I'm not saying they never help, just that 99% they do either useless or actively damaging treatments that don't take side-effects into account. They are biased towards unecesserary action. Overuse of antibiotics is just one way this manifests itself, but it is true for most treatments.
- cephaslr 6y agoThere is an (admittedly controversial) idea within the medical community of Specialist induced demand. I have heard it quoted to me that studies have shown that when a medical specialist moves into an area that they then generate more demand for related procedures. Personally I am not in the medical profession but am wondering if anyone more knowledgeable can speak to this. Specially what percentage of procedures could be considered in this category or is this just ridiculous? As a personal example, I received a nose surgery once that opened my nasal area so I could breathe better but it only lasted a few months and after that it seems to have reverted so it appears to be an unnecessary procedure at the end of the day. I have just decided to live with the difficulty as the recovery was awful. Potentially relevant link: http://www.mit.edu/~erinmj/files/PID.pdf http://www.mit.edu/~erinmj/files/PID.pdf
- h2odragon 6y agoLast time I went to a doctor, I was concerned about intestinal blockage; they gave me a prescription for a drug that slows intestinal motility. And told me I couldn't afford any tests to confirm my notions of what my actual health issues might be. I've never been one of those who delegates the responsibility for my health to a doctor; but at least they used to be valuable consultants. Today I cannot imagine a circumstance that would make me want to be a customer of a health care provider. I can only hope to find a alternate source for any treatments they keep exclusive to themselves if i ever need one.
- C1sc0cat 6y ago"seem fine" covers a lot of situation for example your having an ultra sound and they say "oh that looks a bit small" you go from fine to not fine very quickly
- dcolkitt 6y agoThis isn't that surprising. Healthcare economists have known for a very long time that medical spending, on the margin, has precious little impact on actual health outcomes.[1] Basically there's a "core" set of medicine that constitutes basic care and is essential to health. But even during deep budget cuts or quarantine, very few people are avoiding vaccines, not setting broken legs, and letting appendices explode. In contrast an enormous amount of healthcare is very expensive and of dubious effectiveness at best. For example it's not uncommon for courses of certain chemotherapy to cost $400,000 and have no statistical effectiveness.[2] Overall nearly half of medical procedures are unsupported by evidence[3]. Even procedures we take for granted, like routine mammograms[4], have no actual impact at reducing mortality at the population level. This is what economists call "on the margin". These are the treatments that get cut first during rationing. [1] https://www.cato-unbound.org/2007/09/10/robin-hanson/cut-medicine-half https://www.cato-unbound.org/2007/09/10/robin-hanson/cut-med... [2] https://freakonomics.com/2013/10/22/the-unsustainable-economics-of-cancer-drugs/ https://freakonomics.com/2013/10/22/the-unsustainable-econom... [3] https://www.vox.com/the-big-idea/2017/12/28/16823266/medical-treatments-evidence-based-expensive-cost-stents https://www.vox.com/the-big-idea/2017/12/28/16823266/medical... [4] https://theconversation.com/routine-mammograms-do-not-save-lives-the-research-is-clear-84110 https://theconversation.com/routine-mammograms-do-not-save-l...
- hackeraccount 6y agoMy impression is that at a Public Health level most forms of medicine don't make much of an impression. Antibiotics would probably be an exception. Vaccinations if you choose to call them medicine. At the population level though most of the things that affect health and life expectancy are life style choices of one type or the other that Doctors have not show an ability to control. My Dr. might be able to tell me that my smoking is bad. That I need to lose 10 lbs. That getting black out drunk every weekend isn't doing me any good. All of that and more. But Dr's aren't any good about doing anything about those things. You could add clean water and clean air in that pile. Compared to that cancer detection and extending the lives of people with cancer is a drop in the bucket. Of course if you fall into that category then it's a huge difference but overall I don't think it makes a huge difference.
- mymythisisthis 6y agoA good time to advocate for telehealth, remote visits.