6 ms·
It's exactly that attitude to policing that's the root of all this. Yes, we all want our loved ones coming home at the end of the day. But when you go out with
by jfengel 6y ago
It's exactly that attitude to policing that's the root of all this. Yes, we all want our loved ones coming home at the end of the day. But when you go out with the assumption that everybody is trying to kill you, everybody treats you with suspicion and fear. If you're looking for a place to break that cycle, it's gonna have to start with not reflexively defending police who have clearly committed murder.
Those Baltimore riots were sparked because a man who was in custody suffered injuries that could not have been caused any other way except by the police who held him, and all of them were acquitted. When people see that the system is intent on protecting the police, that means a lot of people aren't going to care whether that woman's husband makes it home or not.
Crime has been falling at the same time as police misconduct (not just the actual abuses, but the protection around them) has become more visible. Somebody needs to de-escalate it, and that would be a great place to start.
- wayoutthere 6y agoYeah, this is probably controversial but I think the police should basically be the bullet sponges for the rest of society. Right now they endanger more lives than they protect, and they’re not even particularly good at dealing with violent crime (you have better than a coin flip odds of getting away with murder in most cities). The vast majority (around 95%) of police calls don’t involve violent crime at all. I believe most police should be unarmed. If someone attacks them, their job should be to run away and call for backup. Use body cameras to collect evidence to track violent offenders down later. And in order to be armed, an officer should have a 4-year degree that includes a whole lot of training in criminal law. US troops operating in Kandahar had far more restrictions on use of force than US police do. And people there were actively hunting them. We treat our own citizens worse than foreign enemies, which really needs to change. A big reason for this is that the perceived “enemy” (read: black people) cannot just blend in with the rest of society because of their skin color. That’s pretty fucked up IMO.
- Trill-I-Am 6y agoHow are rural communities with low budgets going to meet that hiring standard?
- shadowgovt 6y agoIdeally, state funding paid for by taxes on the more wealthy cities.
- ben_w 6y agoThey could try copying rural communities in other countries that don’t have such a big problem with “bad apples”. For a country which, from the outside, likes to boast about how rich it is, America doesn’t seem to be very good with money.
- VRay 6y agoIt's really mind-boggling to me that anyone in the USA can hop online and talk to people from all over the world, yet we still think that stuff they take for granted elsewhere is impossible.
- hef19898 6y agoJust get rid of all these small Sheriffs and police departments. One ploice forse for state and one federal works well, most other developed countries have around 2 to 3 main police forces (depeding on how you count). Limiting the number of police departments also makes hiring and common standards a lot easier.
- aerostable_slug 6y agoThere are some issues with that approach. Example: the county (and surrounding areas) where I'm typing this has significant enough issues with agricultural & rural crime that they set up a dedicated task force to fight it (this is unfortunately now common with counties like ours in CA). It's not just equipment or product either (i.e. stealing trucks filled with almonds), but there are methheads who actually steal dairy calves up in the central valley. Sacramento doesn't really care. The dollar figures are relatively low when you consider the size of the state, there aren't a ton of voters in those areas, and a fair bit of those voters tend to lean further right politically than present leadership. So, the locals have to take care of it. It is roughly the same argument as the (gulp) electoral college: if the coastal megacities make all the decisions, who sticks up for the person in Idaho and their needs? Also, Sheriffs are almost always elected positions, so the public gets an opportunity to directly influence leadership of their local law enforcement. That said, I'm not a huge fan of our local PD, and enforcing standards is a fair point.
- rs999gti 6y ago> Yeah, this is probably controversial but I think the police should basically be the bullet sponges for the rest of society. Don't forget police are the FORCE in law enforcement. Want Universal Healthcare, social programs, speed limits, voting rights, etc.? There has to be force to enforce those laws. Otherwise, toothless laws mean nothing.
- relaxing 6y agoJust what percent of broken laws in the US do you think end up being enforced with guns drawn? And given that subpopulation, have you considered any of current proposals making the round for nonviolent conflict resolution by specially trained, unarmed mediators?
- skellington 6y ago100% of all enforced laws are BACKED by the THREAT of guns drawn. That doesn't mean it gets there most of the time, but the THREAT is what backs all laws and the reason why people give in most of the time. ALL laws are ultimately backed by the threat of death because ultimately if you don't comply and refuse to ever comply and work your way up the violence ladder, it all ends in death. It amazes me that people don't understand this (though given the current state of education I shouldn't be surprised.) I laugh at the authoritative far left/right who want to disband the police. Who would oppress the population with their policies if there were no police?
- seanhunter 6y agoHere in the UK few police have guns and they have to have special training if they want to be licensed to use firearms. Even then, the weapons are kept in a locked safe most of the time rather than being carried by default. There are many other countries that have a similar regime. The idea that you have to constantly threaten deadly force in order to enforce the law is not at all born out in other countries.
- rs999gti 6y ago
- macspoofing 6y ago>It's exactly that attitude to policing that's the root of all this. You mean, humanity? >Yes, we all want our loved ones coming home at the end of the day. But when you go out with the assumption that everybody is trying to kill you Exactly true - but that's why the crime rate being so high rises the stress levels and enforces these views. Patrolling a Oslo, Norway, which has a murder rate of 0.5 per 100k, is different than patroling Atlanta, Georgia with a murder rate of 17 per 100k. Right? >Crime has been falling at the same time as police misconduct (not just the actual abuses, but the protection around them) has become more visible. I think I saw some stats that showed police misconduct has been falling as well - but as you said, visibility has been increased. Maybe this is all being solved, it just takes time. Having said that, I do think police standards should be high, including admittance, and continual training on de-escalation drills and handling of high-stress situations. That should be simple to implement, and all it costs is taxes (and I think, given the current situation, that cost is worth it)