7 ms·
Why "even"? Why are we still pretending that Silicon Valley has the answers to everything, that tech in general is an all-purpose panacea?
by pavel_lishin 6y ago
Why "even"? Why are we still pretending that Silicon Valley has the answers to everything, that tech in general is an all-purpose panacea?
- ixtli 6y agoIt’s part of the myth. The brand.
- infinity0 6y agoI just read it ironically, lol
- ggregoire 6y agoAlso, Silicon Valley is all about making money. How do you make money solving homelessness?
- convolvatron 6y agotradeable morality credits
- fortran77 6y agoThere's money in homelessness, just like there's money in for-profit prisons. A great many people are employed in San Francisco working for publicly funded homeless programs. > Between 2011 and 2012, SF spent $157 million on homeless services. By the 2015-2016 fiscal year, it was up to $242 million. In the most recent 2019-2020 budget proposals, the figure hit more than $364 million. But the consensus remains that more is needed. (Source: https://sf.curbed.com/2019/12/19/21027974/san-francisco-homeless-decade-2010s-kositsky-navigation-center-friedenbach https://sf.curbed.com/2019/12/19/21027974/san-francisco-home... ) That money's not going to the homeless people. It's going to the people who run the services to support them. You think they'd want to see homelessness end? And, indirectly, the Police make money from homelessness because they can use it to get their budgets increased.
- flashdance 6y ago> That money's not going to the homeless people. It's going to the people who run the services to support them. You think they'd want to see homelessness end? Yes, I think those people want to see homelessness end. Why else would you want a career in that field? Climate scientists also want action to be taken to fight climate change, even if it might put them out of a job. Folks who work for the UN to tackle world hunger want world hunger to end, even if it puts them out of a job. I don't think rank-and-file workers are psychopaths.
- fortran77 6y agoDo you think the Police would like to see crime go to zero?
- eeZah7Ux 6y agoHN is downvoting you for saying that some people honestly want to improve the world.
- kortilla 6y agoIt’s hard for “honestly wanting to improve the world” to scale to organizations of thousands of people.
- eeZah7Ux 6y ago> Climate scientists also want action to be taken to fight climate change, even if it might put them out of a job The parent is talking about individual's good intentions. And look at that, I'm getting downvoted as well.
- dang 6y agoWould you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stop breaking the rules when posting here? We've had to ask you multiple times before.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- eeZah7Ux 6y agoIf anything is the opposite: you make money by inflating the cost of housing, and homelessness is a product of inequality. Give free or extremely cheap housing to every homeless person and the lucrative real estate companies and investment funds will disappear.
- loco5niner 6y agounfortunately, you will also end up with destroyed houses.
- pengaru 6y agoIt's the vulnerable populations that get taken advantage of the most. There's obviously huge opportunity potential in solving homelessness. But the money might have to come from the government. Private prisons don't seem to mind.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kiliantics 6y agoRight, homelessness is a consequence of structuring society around the accumulation of wealth, concentrating it into the hands of the few at the expense of the many (and at the serious expense of some very unfortunate people, leading to issues like homelessness). And Silicon Valley has proven itself very good at concentrating wealth. How can they act in a way that avoids this consequence without completely overturning their raison d'etre? This is very closely related to the idea of reform vs. revolution. Sometimes you just need to burn the whole thing down to get the outcome you want.
- wuxiekeji 6y agoWhy? It creates clickbait, commentbait, and sharebait for computerhistory.org, which is good for them.
- corysama 6y agoNo need to argue extremes. The title makes it clear that lots of groups have failed to solve the problem. And, that SV puts it self out as the source of solutions for the world. Yet they have to step over homeless to get into their offices in the morning. What I wrote is a bit long for a headline. What they wrote sums it up nicely.
- dathinab 6y agoThe thing is SV fails to solve a lot of peoples. It tends to be so detached from the reality a lot of people live in that any problem specific or more common for such people tend to be fundamentally mishandled by SV. E.g. the idea that you can handle fundamental social problems though purly technological solutions if absurd but exactly that idea is commonly pushed by SV.
- twblalock 6y ago> E.g. the idea that you can handle fundamental social problems though purly technological solutions if absurd but exactly that idea is commonly pushed by SV. Really? Which SV companies are pushing that idea?
- pacala 6y agoOne reason for 'even'. Silicon Valley contains some of the richest zip codes, richest corporations and highest paying jobs in the country. Yet all this monetary wealth doesn't seem to help with a major humanitarian crisis unfolding on its doorstep.
- proc0 6y agoBecause it's an area with a lot of rich companies, presumably they have more money to solve the problem. I don't agree with that, the solution is moral and pragmatic in nature, not monetary.
- closeparen 6y agoHousing more people is an engineering problem: materials, construction techniques, density, cost. It’s the aesthetics and social justice crowd insisting that the engineering techniques we have must not be used (for example demanding onsite union labor at prevailing local wages instead of trucking in prefab components from a cheaper labor market).
- toomuchtodo 6y agoNo. Housing more people is a people/politics/wealth distribution problem. The engineering portion is trivial. Even if you truck in prefab, where will you put it if no one will zone or sell you the land to place it on? Everyone wants to be upwardly mobile, and many signal status with their housing. Would you live in a trailer park with your kids? Would you invite your coworkers over for game night to the double wide? No one wants to live next to trailer parks, I know because I try to buy and build them. Existing trailer parks are valuable because zoning for new ones is incredibly difficult, and the cap rates (return on investment) are higher than single family homes or smaller multi family. Perhaps you'll argue that prefab isn't a trailer. Fair. People still want to live in the best neighborhood with the best schools their money can buy, which is rarely a prefab or inexpensively constructed community (see: signaling, with a dash of entrenched interests such as taxing authorities and builder profits). Remember white flight? Very similar. Humans are tribal, will always seek status, and always measure themselves against others. These are deep rooted socioeconomic problems to solve. It's not just a matter of spitting housing out of a factory Gigafactory style.
- closeparen 6y agoI think we are in agreement here. The technical solutions exist but are excluded for emotional reasons.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoAgreed.
- darksaints 6y ago