7 ms·
Recently, I was so frustrated with some folks poor reading comprehension that I was thinking about an imaginary communication system that would allow for decisi
by duxup 6y ago
Recently, I was so frustrated with some folks poor reading comprehension that I was thinking about an imaginary communication system that would allow for decision making where there were some rules:
- No responding from mobile devices. The poor response rate is just too high.
- The reader is quizzed on the the contents of the communication before they can respond (randomly generated quizzes might be amusing).
- The reader has to retype the original communication themselves before they can respond....
- Timeout value, if no responses that pass the above tests in a given time frame, whomever asked gets to complete the task with no input and nobody can change the outcome for ... a week or so and everyone has to live with it.
- Anyone who wants to change it after the timeout value better explain why they didn't ask before hand... no idea how this would work, yeah we're getting into the weeds here.
Of course, these are all unworkable in a modern business environment but man ... I can dream that some folks would who make demands or provide input at least put a minimum amount of effort into things before they throw their given wrench into the works.
- yazaddaruvala 6y agoFWIW, it doesn't have to be a "new communication channel", you just documented some best practices for email. > No responding from mobile devices. The poor response rate is just too high. If something was left implicit or de facto re-ask for it to be explicit or de jure. > The reader is quizzed on the the contents of the communication before they can respond (randomly generated quizzes might be amusing). > The reader has to retype the original communication themselves before they can respond.... A simple "What's you're rationale?" or if you're less confident "Sorry, I understand the action items and can execute them but I didn't follow the motivation. So I can do an even better job (or so I can make this decision without you next time), could you walk me through your thought process?" > Timeout value, if no responses that pass the above tests in a given time frame, whomever asked gets to complete the task with no input and nobody can change the outcome for ... a week or so and everyone has to live with it. > Anyone who wants to change it after the timeout value better explain why they didn't ask before hand... no idea how this would work, yeah we're getting into the weeds here. This is the most important email best practice that trips up junior workers. Make the default of your email your desired outcome. Instead of: "Does everyone approve?" then if people respond asking "Ok, when should I do it? Thursday?". Try it like this: "I'll make the change on Thursday. Please let me know if there are any concerns.". 1. Make the default response (i.e. no response) in your benefit. 2. Ensure there is a timeout value attached. None of this is difficult or theoretical, its just a set of best practices you can get your self and others used to.
- cutemonster 6y agoSo, don't end the email with "Does everyone approve?" Start with "Unless you disagree, I'll ..." Instead :)
- yazaddaruvala 6y agoMaybe a nit, but I think it’s very valuable: “I’ll ..., unless anyone disagrees” 2 changes: - Starting the sentence with a doubt can highlight doubts so I’d avoid that. - “Anyone” distributes responsibility, because https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffusion_of_responsibility https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffusion_of_responsibility
- cutemonster 6y agoThanks! Those are good points. I've read about diffusion of responsibility before but didn't think about it now
- ponker 6y agoYou could only have such a system in an environment with a huge power imbalance between the sender and recipient, like Tim Cook sending a message to an Apple IC engineer. But with that kind of power imbalance all of these things happen anyways -- if an individual engineer gets an email from Tim Cook he definitely isn't firing off a poorly-thought-out reply from a mobile device.
- kubanczyk 6y agoNo, actually the opposite is true. The whole idea of any policy is to give artificial "power" to one side to straighten out the situations where the balance of power is unclear. An exec (the remote-only version of Tim Cook if you like) can use their leverage to change the existing email flows between all managers and all engineers. Because it's more scalable than micromanaging one engineer. In other words, some people are good at organizing through setting policies (the better sort of politics) and it's a good place to discuss such ideas. Parent's formulation doesn't look convincing though :)
- abhayb 6y agoI sort of see what you're saying. When a person with Great Authority says that Something Needs Doing, I need to think through what I'm going to say about what I'm going to do. But the single best response is to spend those fifteen minutes seeing if there's an obvious solution. If there is, you can be quite terse and just say: "done". Do that five times and even Tim Cook has your attention.
- BeetleB 6y agoBullets 2 and 3 combined are actually recommended for spoken communications as well. As the listener, before responding, it's a good habit to say "This is what I understand about your proposal" and proceed to summarize and give the original speaker an opportunity to correct you. Probably over half of the communications problems I've seen at work are because people don't follow this basic practice. They respond based on what they understood, not based on what the speaker was saying. As one book I read put it: You should be able to reflect their world view back to them as if you yourself are advocating for it (even if you completely disagree). When you do this, they'll believe you understand them. For many people, only then will they listen to your critiques.
- infogulch 6y ago> They respond based on what they understood, not based on what the speaker was saying. Lets say there are three main steps in responding to communication: 1. Comprehension of the original communication. 2. Mapping that communication onto the reader's priors. 3. Crafting a response that communicates the results of that mapping. The problem seems to be that the first two steps are typically left implicit indefinitely. As a result, there can be discontinuities lurking hidden in or between any of those three steps and it's a hell of a lot of work to pry those discontinuities up to the surface.
- BeetleB 6y agoWell, the whole point of repeating back their world view is to prevent implicitness and reduce hidden misunderstandings. It's really not hard to do. You'll never get there 100%, but getting to 80%? It's easy.
- dmos62 6y agoThere's also a subtlety where if you focus too much on what someone said, you might lose why he said it and how it pertains to the situation. I've gotten through some communication problems by focusing on how I understood the person's position, instead of what the arguments he brought forth. When you do that you get this funny situation where it almost seems like each person is participating in different conversations, but at the same time the discussion is progressing effortlessly. I think of it as letting yourself be free to frame and reframe the issue at hand however you like.
- freedomben 6y agoOh man, I hear you. The amount of sad encounters (especially lately) that I've had as a result of people not understanding what I'm saying because they don't actually read what I wrote are enraging. I almost quit one client over it because their IT guy is the worst. He will decide ahead of time what your email probably says, and that's what he reads into it even if I wrote the opposite. I try to blame myself first for poor communication, but I asked some mostly independent people to help mediate and they basically came back and told him to read better and review past messages if he couldn't properly remember the context.
- cperrine 6y ago"I know that you believe you understand what you think I said, but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant."
- Aeolun 6y agoCan be shortened to “Hey! Listen!”
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mattcwilson 6y agoNot without loss of several significant subtextual channels: respect, clarity, and intent to name a few. Communication is a discipline; verbal shorthands like these are analogous to copy/paste laziness over thoughtful, intentional code.
- QuantumYeti 6y agoI'm just starting to dip my toes back into the freelance web development world, after deciding indie game development wasn't for me. My main problem with clients has always been 1) They don't really know what they want, beyond "a website", and 2) The reading comprehension of pretty much everyone I interact with is surprisingly low. I've mostly dealt with small-business owners, whose personalities seem to veer towards the eccentric. With my current client, I'll send out emails requesting clarification for certain features that need to be implemented on the site. If I'm lucky, I'll get an email back with at least one of the issues having been addressed. There's been emails where the response was in no way relevant. At one point I even got a photo of someone's backyard sent to me as a response. I've learned to only send him a single line of text if it requires a response, to increase my chances of getting something I can act on. I really like making web sites, and programming in general... It's just the frustration of poor communication that makes the job so frustrating. I think if I were more of a salesman/people-person, I would probably be better about figuring out what they really need, and offering solutions to them... rather then just getting upset that they don't what they want.
- SJetKaran 6y ago> - No responding from mobile devices. The poor response rate is just too high. For me, the tendency of slack to let users write very short sentences/phrases is the issue. Etiquette for slack allows very IM like messages, whereas Emails are generally required to be more verbose.
- dzhiurgis 6y agoI hope I never have to go back to using email for work. Long messages for tickets, slack for near real time chat. Email for transactional spam and emailing old friend once a year.
- abalashov 6y agoIt's probably a question of personality, custom and habit, but I tend to write like I speak (some would say "no, you speak like you write" :-) in any forum, including Slack, sometimes in defiance of the cultural norms of the audience. It leads to something of a reputation for verbosity, but never the accusation of ambiguity or excessive terseness. I don't think anyone's ever said to me, "What did you mean by that two-word reply?"
- Leherenn 6y agoIt can be quite useful when replying to each point though, you can quote each one independently since they're not merged into one big blob of text. Not saying it's impossible otherwise of course, just slightly more convenient.
- u801e 6y ago> I was thinking about an imaginary communication system that would allow for decision making where there were some rules: > [...] > - The reader has to retype the original communication themselves before they can respond.... In email (not following Outlook/conversation style) and newsgroups, people would trim the original quoted material down to what they were responding to and then type their responses inline. While that would, in a way, meet that requirement, it could still lead to people responding to selected parts of your message while missing other parts. But, that would allow you to reiterate the points they didn't address in your subsequent response.
- abalashov 6y agoYeah, it's really unfortunate that inline replying effectively died out, replaced by top-posting. I think inline replies, while lending themselves to the selective quotation problem you mention, nevertheless force more careful consideration of the original text.
- Talanes 6y agoI'm not even sure selective quotation is really a problem. Selective replying happens regardless of whether they are quoting or not, but is just more explicit when they are documenting which parts they reply to.
- sdoering 6y agoI agree. I still do this. But nowadays lot of people feedback that they do not understand my way of replying. Compared to many of my early digital acquaintances I was socialized quite late on the internet starting in 97. Compared to my colleagues I often feel old and out of sync with my style of long form written communication.
- u801e 6y ago> nowadays lot of people feedback that they do not understand my way of replying. Some clients, like Outlook, will actually collapse the original email and only show the top-posted reply. An inline reply would appears as an empty email in their client.
- ec109685 6y agoThis is why Amazon takes the first 20 minutes as time for reading their written communication before big decisions.
- dkersten 6y agoI hate this approach (even more so when I was involved in writing the written communication) because it usually turns into idly waiting for others to finish reading, while I get distracted, bored and just plain could be doing something more productive. I understand the concept and some people must find it useful and valuable, but I’ve personally never got anything of value out of it other than making sure everyone has read the content before the meeting proper starts. Personally, I find asking somebody to attend a meeting, where 20 minutes is just silently reading, rather disrespectful of their time.
- cutemonster 6y agoWhat about everyone reading the material before the meeting, and a computer aided individual quiz to find out if they did? Unless (all for the meeting really important ppl did), meeting cancelled
- dkersten 6y agoThat would be great!
- bottled_poe 6y agoThis sounds like a typical engineers approach to solving a social problem. Just hire better staff and pay them what they are worth.
- vackosar 6y agoHi! I recently opened my quiz generation service to public. Would you try out the quiz AI assistant at https://QuizRecall.com https://QuizRecall.com and let me know what would you need to be added to make useful also for your use case?
- vackosar 6y agoGive the quizzes at the end of the blog posts a shot: - https://vaclavkosar.com/ml/starspace-embedding https://vaclavkosar.com/ml/starspace-embedding - https://quizrecall.com/rack/Cynefin-Framework--Making-The-Best-Decision-In-These-5-Contexts.html https://quizrecall.com/rack/Cynefin-Framework--Making-The-Be... I use the service for personal training, but it is opened for others now as well.