3 ms·
That's what in fact what they're doing. SMIC is in 14nm risk production, and aggressively working on EUV.
by monocasa 6y ago
That's what in fact what they're doing.
SMIC is in 14nm risk production, and aggressively working on EUV.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoWe're also rapidly hurtling towards the end of transistor scaling, full stop. When "start of the art" stops being a moving target, how long before everybody has it? We're still several years from that, but probably not several decades from it.
- monocasa 6y agoI'm actually pretty curious to see what happens then, and don't have a great answer. Where I'm at currently is that I imagine anyone who wants a leading edge fab for geopolitical reasons will have one, but not much beyond that except the legacy cases like Samsung and TSMC. It'll still be in the ~$20B to create a fab, and for what at the end of the day? Slightly better (probably single digit) margins for what has essentially become a commodity anyways? Beyond militaries that can foot the massive bill to be assured that they're getting the chips they certified, nearly everyone else will have better options to invest in to differentiate themselves. For instance a great question is if the EU thinks a fab is worth the effort? Probably not in today's climate, and would most likely be a sign of the end of US geopolitical domination if they do feel the need.
- SomaticPirate 6y agoBryan Cantrill has a great talk on this and the end of scaling https://youtu.be/TM9h89Vo_Qo https://youtu.be/TM9h89Vo_Qo It really seems like we are going to see new architecture paradigms emerge and start seeing more powerful compute in smaller places.
- ChuckNorris89 6y ago>For instance a great question is if the EU thinks a fab is worth the effort? Most EU countries have fabs, even small countries like Switzerland and Austria although they're not as cutting edge as TSMC.
- notriddle 6y agoBecause fabs are so expensive to build and run, yet each individual chip built is so cheap, it's always going to be more economical for a single fab to service lots of customers than to have a fab that only serves the military. The military will probably fund a lot of new fab construction, but they will not be the sole customer. Like the Interstate Highway system, basically.
- monocasa 6y agoSure, I'm not saying that the military would own their own fab, just that (like we see with TSMC opening a fab in Arizona) a properly motivated military would heavily subsidize the creation of fabs where they can be assured physical security more than they possibly could on foreign soil.
- mcqueenjordan 6y agoHasn't this been the argument for decades? "Surely we're at the end now," etc.
- mdorazio 6y agoNo? The argument for decades from non-sensationalist sources has mostly been that there are physical limitations that current methods can't bypass around the 1nm scale, and that getting successively closer to that size requires exponential increases in investment with corresponding decreases in yield. And this is pretty much exactly what's been happening.
- taneq 6y agoWhen it's "us" that's on the catch-up side of this equation we call this "democratisation" and we're all in favour of it.
- sitkack 6y agoAnd if they can make a 14nm wafer for 1/4 the cost of the competition, it has the same economic advantage as 7nm.