9 ms·
If one party to a contract cannot reasonably expect (!) that the contract was read by the other party, the contract should be invalid. Period, end of story. Th
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
If one party to a contract cannot reasonably expect (!) that the contract was read by the other party, the contract should be invalid. Period, end of story.
This applies not just to Privacy Policies, but to just about every Terms of Service. You're telling me that when Apple updates the App Store's terms of use, they in good faith expect their customers to spend half their workday rereading the contract before clicking I Agree and downloading that new app? It's completely nonsensical!
Only high-level business software should be able to force its users to sign a contract, because that is the only circumstance in which it will be read.
- nickff 6y agoOne problem with your argument (from a political perspective) is that it undermines the entire system of mandatory disclosures (for drug warnings, investor relations, real estate, etc.). Accepting this argument means that all the (many) disclosure-based lawsuits and regulatory actions taken against companies are blatantly unjust, as they are based on the idea that consumers can and should read lengthy, confusing documents. I should add that despite what people here are saying, the complexity of the wording is usually driven by legal requirements, not a desire to confuse people.
- suifbwish 6y agoI think he is saying that terms of service and user end policy agreements in their current state are completely unacceptable. We need to simplify these policies and contracts if we expect people to be legally accountable for understanding their contents.
- nickff 6y agoThe problem is that the only reason they are complicated is because the courts require complexity. Each one of those complicated legal terms exists because of some lawsuit somewhere. Blaming it on the company, or saying that it's obfuscation simply misses the point. If we want to get rid of these complicated 'agreements', we need to change the way our legal system operates.
- throwaway_USD 6y ago>because the courts require complexity. No the Courts do not require complexity. The famous example in law school being writing a agreement on a cocktail napkin being an enforceable contract. The legal system may be in need of reforms, but in these instances the complexity and length of tech company TOS or PP is a direct result of these entities having an army of in-house and outside counsel looking after their own interests. There is simply a power imbalance between FAANG companies and even their most legally savvy and educated user. This has nothing to do with the courts, and if you don't believe me, then reach out to one of the FAANG legal departments and tell them you want to use their service but need to negotiate the TOS/PP first.
- nickff 6y agoHow many lawyers write their employment agreements, per-nuptual agreements, wills, or letters of engagement on cocktail napkins? Sure, it'd be enforceable, but almost worthless.
- throwaway_USD 6y agoPre-nups and wills are great examples of how simple agreements can be...prior to the internet you could pick up standard forms from stationary stores. Google "contract on a cocktail napkin", most of the top results will be for million dollar contracts on cocktail napkins...so maybe we just have a different opinion about "enforceable, but almost worthless."
- nickff 6y agoContracts are only important when there is a disagreement. When everyone is getting along (which is most of the time), the contract can be verbal, cocktail, form, or lengthy, and it doesn't matter. You can see this from the fact that the most contentious subjects (such as construction) have the most rigorous contracts. IANAL, but I have never heard of a lawyer writing a contract on a napkin, or advising a client to do so; and they say verbal contracts are worth the paper they're written on.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI actually don’t even think there should be contracts, unless they can be cut down to a few paragraphs. Because nothing longer than that will be read by 99% of consumers. Merely providing a bullet point summary of the contract (as I’ve seen some do, iirc GoG.com is one) is not enough—those bullet points would need to actually become the contract of record. There is no reason the absence of contracts should lead to a breakdown of the tech industry. Tech companies are already protected by extremely generous copyright laws. Maybe they wouldn’t be able to collect everyone’s data all the time, but that’s a good thing. I can’t speak as much to other industries because I know less about them. But I think e.g. landlords have a reasonable expectation that renters do read their contracts. I know I read my lease—that seems like a normal, reasonable thing to do. Reading a software ToS or Privacy Policy is, by contrast, exceptionally abnormal.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> But I think e.g. landlords have a reasonable expectation that renters do read their contracts. I know I read my lease—that seems like a normal, reasonable thing to do. I also imagine it was much shorter than a typical software ToS/EULA. > Reading a software ToS or Privacy Policy is, by contrast, exceptionally abnormal. Part of the cause here is path dependence - we've been conditioned to ignore EULAs in the pre/early-Internet era, back when software walked and quacked like a product, not a service.
- gowld 6y agoCopyright is a totally different dimension from what ToS/EULAs cover.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoThe only reason I mentioned copyright is, the classic thing all software ToS’s traditionally say is that you cannot create unauthorized copies of media. What else is in ToS’s that tech companies absolutely must be able to enforce?
- mijamo 6y agoI don't really agree. Disclosure for drugs is comprehensive and short. You can usually read the whole thing in 10 minutes and I always do because taking a new drug and I know many who do. For investor relation, real estate and such the value is such that those are also read, usually by multiple eyes. And most software user agréments are actually much larger and harder to understand than the real estate papers worth millions I've seen, or even shareholder agreements worth even more. Contrary to what you think it is very possible to have short legal agreements. The GDPR data policy basic template is quite comprehensive and rather short for instance, although it could get better. We could also imagine some informative shortened version with icons and standardized information in the same way you have for food components or drug warnings, or crucially apps permissions nowadays, that would cover 95% of the legalese in the user agreements.
- nickff 6y agoApparently the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States disagrees with you on the length of drug disclosures.[1] He said that "[p]roviding too much information defeats the purpose of disclosure, and since no one reads it", and that "the legal system obviously is to blame for that". [1] https://www.abajournal.com/news/article/chief_justice_roberts_admits_he_doesnt_read_the_computer_fine_print https://www.abajournal.com/news/article/chief_justice_robert...
- btilly 6y agoAs I commented elsewhere, all that it would take to fix this is a precedent or law saying that, "Any consumer contract with a Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level of over 8 shall be unenforceable because the average consumer cannot be expected to have understood what they were agreeing to."
- nickff 6y agoYou're really begging the question here. Why should we all follow your whim? Is there any reason at all, other than that it makes sense to you?
- kerkeslager 6y agoThere aren't legal requirements for many (most?) pieces of software. You can release a piece of software without any terms of use at all--that's perfectly legal. So I don't buy the idea that complexity is driven by legal requirements.
- nickff 6y agoThe legal problems come in when the software is discovered to have some flaw or an undisclosed interaction with some other system, and the class-action lawyers swoop in to eviscerate the publisher.
- 0xffff2 6y agoHas this ever actually happened? Particularly, has a software publisher ever lost such a case?
- fapjacks 6y agoClass action? Like, on behalf of consumers? I can't think of any off-hand. Cases on behalf of Larry Ellison, however...
- kerkeslager 6y agoLots of open source software has gone for decades with the following license, without the wrath of god falling on them: Copyright (c) <year> <copyright holders> Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom the Software is furnished to do so, subject to the following conditions: The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software. THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE. It seems to me like you could just cut the paragraph starting with "Permission" and the words "and this permission notice" from the next paragraph, and you'd have the same protections, but for a closed-source project. So yeah, I'm going to go ahead and continue to believe that these EULA's are definitely not written with the user in mind.
- paxys 6y agoBig difference between disclosing something and having people agree to a contract though.
- btilly 6y agoI should add that despite what people here are saying, the complexity of the wording is usually driven by legal requirements, not a desire to confuse people. I emphatically disagree. In https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23566627 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23566627 I take a sample from Apple's privacy policy that is written at a college reading level, and show how a rewrite can say more, in less words, while being readable at a grade 7 level. This is merely an example illustrating that the vast majority of complexity in legal documents is driven by lawyers trying to look smart and not caring how impenetrable their prose is.
- dbcurtis 6y agoWell, not quite. Certain phrases have been tested in court. That is why arcane word-strings appear on contracts. Courts have established meaning and precedent for that word string. Going rogue with more readable language is asking for a ride on the litigation merry-go-round again, and nobody wants to foot the bill for that.
- telchar 6y agoIf companies expected and wanted users to be informed, the standard "we've updated our privacy policy" would be accompanied with a detailed list of changes or some sort of friendly marked-up change log. I have never seen anything like that from any company, so I have a hard time believing privacy policies and TOS are meant to be informative.
- nickff 6y agoOne potential problem is that any error in the markup might be the basis of a class-action suit; it's safer just to provide the full text, and there is no benefit to providing the markup.
- gpderetta 6y agoAt least in the UK, banks and utilities do send human readable deltas of their contract changes. I assume there are laws that force them to.
- londons_explore 6y agoIn the UK, far more companies are making contracts for end users that fit on one screen of a phone as 3 bullet points... Eg. To use this service, you agree: * You have no criminal convictions * You have only 3 donkeys. * No family member has ever owned a kazoo. [ I agree ]
- blaser-waffle 6y agoDiscrimination against kazoo owners is a thing in the US and US-based EULAs too :(
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> One problem with your argument (from a political perspective) is that it undermines the entire system of mandatory disclosures (for drug warnings, investor relations, real estate, etc.). A key factor here should be the complexity of the agreement compared to the value of the transaction. If you're buying a house, you're laying out at least six figures and can be reasonably expected to read the fine print or hire somebody to do it for you, even if it takes multiple hours or several hundred dollars. If you're buying a $1 app or using a free service, expecting the same thing is facially absurd. Meanwhile if you're buying a $5 bottle of drain cleaner, it's ridiculous to expect someone to read 20 pages, but 20 words is not so unreasonable. This also bodes ill for "we may update this agreement at any time" because that's imposing the burden of re-reading the agreement every time you change it, which is pretty unreasonable for anything where the other party isn't paying you (or getting paid by you) hundreds or thousands of dollars a year.
- specialist 6y agoI love this line of thinking. Trying to paraphrase: Transaction costs should be proportional to value of transaction. Such inquiry will help daylight the value these hoarders derive from our data.
- Retric 6y agoThat’s a reasonable idea. One issue is cheap real world products like painkillers can be useful and dangerous.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoIf the danger is too complicated for people to reasonably understand in the amount of time they ordinarily spend trying to understand it, you already have a bigger problem. If the danger isn't that complicated and can be easily explained, you don't actually have this problem.
- coopsmgoops 6y agoWell what is reasonable for a $5 bottle of ibuprofen? How about: "Misuse of this product is dangerous and may cause death. Advil is not responsible for damages caused by misuse. Read and follow instructions on back of bottle" That's a bit wordy but it indicates who is responsible (you) and what the gravity of the situation is (possible death). With that established, it means the onus is on the user to do more reading. IANAL but I would like to belive something like that would satisfy all parties.
- SkyBelow 6y ago>One problem with your argument (from a political perspective) is that it undermines the entire system of mandatory disclosures (for drug warnings, investor relations, real estate, etc.). Is this a bug or a feature? >as they are based on the idea that consumers can and should read lengthy, confusing documents. The resolution of such lawsuits are based around the notion that consumers should be able to read such documentations. The law suits themselves are about a deeper issue of consent. I would see this action as nullifying the resolutions but not the problem. It is unjust, but to the consumers.
- monadic2 6y agoWhy is that a problem? That seems like a decent argument this is necessary to resolve passing liability onto the customer.
- abecedarius 6y agoFurther, it's routine for these long documents to make you 'agree' that they (alone) can alter the 'agreement' at any time, and that it's up to you to keep coming back to reread it and see if you notice any change. They might as well conclude with "Also, fuck you." I wouldn't blame any particular company for not departing from this equilibrium we're in. But it makes a "meeting of the minds" so absurd it's a mockery of the ancient meaning of a contract. Edit: I may be thinking only of terms of service; I don't remember how routine that term might be in privacy policies.
- btilly 6y agoThat is assuming that they CAN read the contract. The median US adult reads at a grade 5 level. That's a problem in and of itself. However when I paste Apple's privacy policy at https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/en-ww/ https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/en-ww/ into https://readabilityformulas.com/freetests/six-readability-formulas.php https://readabilityformulas.com/freetests/six-readability-fo... it comes out with a Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level of 14.4. There are a variety of readability measures at that site, and for this document they varied between grade 12 and college graduate. It is therefore demonstrably impossible for the average American to read that policy. EVEN IF THEY WANTED TO. Now another poster claims that this is because of what is legally required. That is nonsense. It is because nobody cares about making it readable. Let me demonstrate. Here is a sample paragraph from the document with a reading level of grade 13.4: You may be asked to provide your personal information anytime you are in contact with Apple or an Apple affiliated company. Apple and its affiliates may share this personal information with each other and use it consistent with this Privacy Policy. They may also combine it with other information to provide and improve our products, services, content, and advertising. You are not required to provide the personal information that we have requested, but, if you chose not to do so, in many cases we will not be able to provide you with our products or services or respond to any queries you may have. Here is a rewritten version that is significantly shorter, more readable (grade 7.3), and actually says more: When you contact Apple or its affiliated companies, we may ask you questions about yourself. Examples that we commonly ask for include your name, age, address, and credit card number. You do not have to answer us. But if you don't, we may not be able to answer your questions or provide you with our services. Your answers can be shared between Apple and its affiliates as long as we follow this Privacy Policy. We can also combine your answers with other data that we have. We do this to provide and improve our products, services, content, and advertising. I could easily improve the readability more, but my point is made. The hardest part of the exercise was making the rewritten version long enough to get a readability score. I think it would be very reasonable to pass a law saying that any consumer contract with a Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level of over grade 8 should not be enforceable. The reasoning being that there cannot have been a meeting of minds when few consumers are even able to understand the language which the contract is written in. And if there were such a law, I guarantee that lawyers would quickly learn how to put their thoughts in plain writing instead of legalese.
- addHocker 6y agoCompanys should be forced to pay the user for the time spend reading.
- justapassenger 6y agoWhy should that apply only to people vs corporations? How about people vs government? Should I be expected to read all the laws, and if not a reasonable expectations, laws are invalid?
- dvtrn 6y agoShould I expected to read all the laws Somebody is sure as hell trying and I'm honestly impressed by the commitment and content produced from their effort, behold: @crimeaday https://twitter.com/crimeaday https://twitter.com/crimeaday
- kube-system 6y agoYou might not have consented to anything a company does, but the government operates under your consent: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consent_of_the_governed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consent_of_the_governed
- banads 6y ago>Should I be expected to read all the laws Congress is not even required to read the bills they vote on https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Read_the_Bills_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Read_the_Bills_Act
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoBecause laws apply to you whether or not you agree to be bound by them. Your consent is not required. (I do agree it would be great for our laws to be more readable, but I don’t see how society could function with as low a limit on legislation as you’re suggesting.)
- Proziam 6y agoI'm not sure about where the upper bounds of legal complexity should be, but I do have at least one thought on how to limit the overall complexity, at least for the average citizen. Eliminate all victimless crimes in their entirety. If no third party is harmed or unreasonably endangered, there shouldn't be any reason to fine or incarcerate someone. This basically eliminates all 'possession of' crimes that are so often misused by police to inflict all kinds of harm. (Good example being getting arrested for some marijuana in the car leading to car impound and ludicrous fees to get it released.)
- pwdisswordfish2 6y agoIs a "policy" is a "contract"? What does the user agree to by reading a policy? Why is the privacy stuff separated out into a "policy" instead of being part of the Terms of Service? How does the user (cf. the company) "enforce the policy"? Do companies ever violate their own policies? Do they announce this to the public when it happens? How do we determine when a company has violated their own policy? These are meant to be rhetorical questions but I am curious how people would answer.
- mdlman 6y agoI don't have a lot of time to comment to this, unfortunately, because I think it is a really important discussion. However, whenever I see these issues arise on Hacker News, I rarely see much said in defense of Terms of Service and Privacy Policies. Speaking only about Terms of Service right now, the problem is that if things are not laid out at the beginning, the business takes on all liability (or at least runs the serious risk of that liability). While that may sound reasonable initially, that means that nearly all of the amazing services we have would be impossible from a business perspective. The problem is, we have an extremely litigious society, and lawyers are asked to think through and address all of the risks. The lower the dollar amount, the lower the liability that a company can reasonably take for the transaction. Do you want to have an account? Great, but we need to be clear about who is responsible for use of the account and its credentials. We also need to clarify when it can be suspended or terminated. Do you want to submit content? Cool, but we should confirm that what you submit is your own responsibility, and we need to add some language about ownership and licensing to avoid copyright and other IP issues. We should also confirm that certain types of activities are not OK (e.g., pornography, harassment). Do you want to provide feedback? Awesome, but you cannot sue if it is used. Do you want to use APIs? Sweet, but there are things you can and cannot do so you don't break or abuse our system. Are you paying for things? We need to be clear how that works. And through it all, we need to have key provisions about warranties and limitations of liability so the business is not on the hook for millions when the account is worth $10. And all this is for a simple service. There are countless ways to add complexity to a service. I still agree with a ton of points here about the dangers of one-sided agreements, limited options for services, complex legalese, etc. But I will say that this is a trickier issue than people seem to give it credit. It may be nonsensical to say that a consumer read and understood a contract, but it is also nonsensical to say that companies should risk bankruptcy for free or cheap services (unless we are OK with free or cheap services no longer existing).
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoYou sound like you know a lot about this, and I'm basically a layperson, so please excuse me for asking what are possibly stupid questions--but I still feel like I have to ask them. > Great, but we need to be clear about who is responsible for use of the account and its credentials. We also need to clarify when it can be suspended or terminated. Do we, though? I purchased a membership at an ice skating rink last winter, which gave me unlimited entry and access to a private locker. I didn't sign a contract[1]. Is my skating membership any different than an online account, and if not, why are contracts only seen as necessary in the digital realm? > we need to add some language about ownership and licensing to avoid copyright and other IP issues. Isn't this stuff laid out in Section 503--the service provider isn't responsible for what their users upload, as long as they take action when they're informed of a violation, or some such? If that's US law, why does it need to get restated in the Tos? > Do you want to provide feedback? Awesome, but you cannot sue if it is used. I'm not sure what "if it is used" means, but if, say, someone goes ahead and reuses my review in promotional material without my knowing consent, I think I should be able to sue! That's exactly the problem with agreeing to a contract you don't realistically have the ability to read. > Do you want to use APIs? Sweet, but there are things you can and cannot do so you don't break or abuse our system. If someone is abusing your API by, e.g. making too many requests, you should cut them off--why do you need a contract for that? If it's a private API for businesses, I actually think a ToS is fine. Professionals can reasonably be expected to read business-critical contracts. --- As I acknowledged at the jump, these are probably dumb questions. But--and I'm trying to anticipate your answer here, so maybe it's off base to begin with--if the issue is that a Twitter spammer could sue Twitter for being banned, then we need broader legislation to address that, in a way that applies universally to all companies. Because, clearly you should be able to ban people who spam, contract or no contract. Although, since restaurants can kick me out for holding up pornographic posters, and I can enter a restaurant without signing a contract... I have to wonder, again, why this is really necessary. --- [1] I did need to sign a waver before stepping onto the rink, in which I acknowledged I might fall and injure myself. However, this wasn't related to my membership, and it was two paragraphs long.
- koheripbal 6y agoIsn't that already the way it is? These privacy policies are almost always thrown out in court as evidence of any sort of consent.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoThat's news to me. So why do companies still spend money writing them?
- ilyagr 6y agoLegislating in this direction might lead to there being a quiz at the end of every privacy policy. This doesn't seem like it would be great outcome to me. Perhaps a better way would be to legislate what privacy policies can contain, so that they are more like Creative Commons licenses.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> Legislating in this direction might lead to there being a quiz at the end of every privacy policy. This doesn't seem like it would be great outcome to me. As much as Google wants your data, there is no way they're going to actually make customers spend hours wading through dense legal speak before allowing them to use their service. No one would do it. They'd just go to duckduckgo. Alternately, if getting access to your data is really so important to Google that they're willing to put users through so much pain, maybe users really do need to go through that pain, so they know what they're agreeing to.