6 ms·
The most obvious fact is that Mr. Durov is not walking with a hole in his head, as a double digit portion of anybody who had balls to be audacious about their o
by baybal2 6y ago
The most obvious fact is that Mr. Durov is not walking with a hole in his head, as a double digit portion of anybody who had balls to be audacious about their opposition, and is not known to have an extensive security detail.
The mob has sent hitment to people whose offences were way lesser than that.
Their ways are unyielding, and uncompromising. Putin has a record killing people who grieved him more than a decade ago, keeping trying for years on end. People he killed some times survived 2-3, even 4, assassination attempts over years, just to be eventually killed by yet another one.
Knowing that, it's hard to explain how Telegram kept maintaining an office in Russia.
- dgellow 6y ago> Knowing that, it's hard to explain how Telegram kept maintaining an office in Russia. Telegram has an office in Russia? Do you have sources? I cannot find one to confirm, and as far as I know that's not the case.
- baybal2 6y agoIn Russian https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-41310615 https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-41310615
- fuoqi 6y agoHave you even read this article? Because it contains dubios allegations from a single person and an explicit denial from Durov.
- thesz 6y agoI took a time and read it and also read much more. It is a good example of "he said she said". But Igor Ashmanov considers Rosenberg a good source on Durov brothers and lets say information above is correct. That means that Durov is used a part of the real estate he had access to to help development of Telegram. It does not mean that Durov is (not) affiliated with Russian government it just means that for Durov it is useful to use Russian real estate he knows and adores and to use Russian talent. It looks like Telegram servers are somewhere in Europe, BTW.
- thesz 6y ago>The most obvious fact is that Mr. Durov is not walking with a hole in his head, as a double digit portion of anybody who had balls to be audacious about their opposition. I think you are talking about Clinton Foundation, aren't you? A joke, of course. Can you help me to access statistics from which you inferred "double digit portion"? Not that I am pro-Russian-government, I am not. I just sense here something that is not completely right with my view of the world and I want to get better in that regard.
- tw04 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Soviet_and_Russian_assassinations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Soviet_and_Russian_ass...
- thesz 6y agoAnd now I'd like to see a list of living Russian people who oppose Russian government. The problem, for me, was the claim about double digits part (I think it was about percentage - the double digits thing).
- mv4 6y agoOpposing is not enough. Opposing while being popular (or wealthy), now that puts one at risk. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_journalists_killed_in_Russia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_journalists_killed_in_... https://www.rferl.org/a/nemtsov-murder-russia-political-killings-putin/28586632.html https://www.rferl.org/a/nemtsov-murder-russia-political-kill...
- thesz 6y agoYou keep presenting a list of homicides and/or contract killings. Going by exemplar logic in your answer to gdy above, you are either paid by, say, Navalny or you are a troll. Okay then.
- gdy 6y agoIt also lists Chechen terrorists. The same kind of list for the US would include thousands of people killed by drone strikes.
- fuoqi 6y agoGreat collection of propaganda bull*t, bro. Is it Nemtsov "an audacious opposition" in your opinion? As much as I don't like the Putin rule, Nemtsov popularity was really minor to influence anything. If anything it was the "non-systematic opposition" who won most from his death.
- ZoomZoomZoom 6y agoSorry, but you managed to write both grotesque and extremely simplified description of Russian political practices. There's absolutely no point in making any physical moves against Durov even if he was openly anti-Putin and supported opposition in any way. It's never done like that. He's already forced out of the country and is not considered a direct threat. He or his remaining actives may be considered a future asset, on the other hand.
- brnt 6y agoBut isn't it remarkable that Telegram after all of these years still doesn't do E2EE by default, Telegram rolls its own crypto (of which the first version had significant problems) and still Telegram is used so much in Russia?
- tryauuum 6y agoMinor correction. Telegram does not use its own crypto, it uses well-known cryptographic primitives. (However community criticised telegram for the poor choice of those well-known primitives)
- akater 6y ago> even if he was openly anti-Putin and supported opposition in any way This implies he does not support opposition in any way. This is not true. He does support opposition rallies—when they are held to support his cause, true, but such is political climate in Russia that publically supporting those who vocally oppose the state policy is a domain for very few and quite brave. When Libertarian Party of Russia was organizing a rally in 2017 to protest Telegram ban, Durov contacted the Party himself. (I'm a member of LP RU.) I don't count on Telegram security but Durov's public image and actions are certainly noticeable and appreciated by opposition.
- ZoomZoomZoom 6y ago> This implies he does not support opposition in any way. This is not true. It implied just that I don't know for sure and it does not change a lot. Even Khodorkovsky is not considered a threat worthy of eliminating - he much better serves the cause being a propaganda target. Durov has even more to offer to Russian gov't (digital technology is the new arms race) so he has even lesser chance of bodily harm.
- golergka 6y agoIt's not that you're wrong; it's that that I wouldn't be so sure that you're right about it. Russia's leadership is not monolithic, and it's decisions are not rational. Some critics are killed even though they do not pose a significant threat. Some are able to continue their fight. Some have allies on the inside; some are said to actually be controlled by the government. If anything, history of such politics teaches me that it's chaos all the way down and almost no one has the full picture, neither knows what he's doing.
- fivre 6y agoThis is the most important thing to understand: non-Russian media loves to persist a never-ending charade that the whole of the Russian government is a direct limb of Putin and controlled wholly by him, which is quite far from true. It makes for a good narrative though, and since the Russian government is perhaps closer to that model than others, passes by readers unnoticed. There are very much parts of the Russian political elite that will use violent and coercive means outside their official mandate to silence individuals. Roskomnadzor isn't really one of those, and is mostly limited to spewing more things onto blocklists to the chagrin of ISPs and people who actually understand the internet. More likely Telegram is unblocked because someone higher-up finally got around to telling Roskomnadzor to fuck off and stop being a nuisance here, since its order never succeeded in actually blocking Telegram and mostly served to disrupt access to cloud service providers (breaking other, non-Telegram applications) as RKN ineffectually tried to issue block orders for entire AWS and GCP network ranges. Other parts of the government clearly didn't care much about the order (they continued to use Telegram for official business after the block), and it seems like it was either RKN attempting to flex its muscles to impress higher-ups or an unsuccessful attempt to put pressure on Telegram that the government has finally given up on.