10 ms·
>Visa blocked users from giving their money to political causes they decided didn't aligned with their view of the world. That is why I am absolutely against a
by ksec 6y ago
>Visa blocked users from giving their money to political causes they decided didn't aligned with their view of the world.
That is why I am absolutely against abolishing paper cash.
Edit: I know there are countries where you have a democratically elected representatives and every part of the government and even companies is held ( more or less ) accountable to the people and does not need to worry ( much ) about big business or government taking over some basic right. Yes cashless in that case is great. Is like utopian.
Unfortunately not everyone has that luxury.
- kabacha 6y agoAt one point abolishing paper cash is even remotely plausible? maybe in 100 years? So far cash rules majority of the world and I don't see it going away any time soon.
- hiq 6y agoAren't Sweden and China frequently used as counterexamples, to a certain extent?
- Shoue 6y agoI'd say Scandinavia as a whole. In Norway I had to use my debit card to access public toilets in train stations, with a small fee. I'd be surprised if Denmark wasn't similar to Norway and Sweden.
- ddkto 6y agoCentral banks are keeping a close eye on it, so I think we’ve crossed the ‘remotely plausible’ line: “Earlier this year, Deputy Governor Tim Lane spoke about the circumstances when it might make sense for the Bank of Canada to issue our own digital currency. This includes a situation in which most Canadians stopped using bank notes. We don’t believe that a digital currency is required at this time. But we are moving forward with contingency planning so that if we ever judged that we should issue a digital currency, we would be ready.” (https://www.bankofcanada.ca/2020/06/opening-statement-160620/ https://www.bankofcanada.ca/2020/06/opening-statement-160620...)
- bauerd 6y agoSupermarkets already exist that don't accept cash (in NL at least)
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoIsn't that the case for the Amazon stores?
- reaperducer 6y agoIn some states, not accepting cash at a public retail establishment is illegal. It's seen as a method of discrimination. The advent of Amazon stores has started a small wave of legislation in this direction.
- eythian 6y agoAH also doesn't accept credit card. Not sure what non-locals are supposed to do if they don't have a maestro card. I guess there aren't many non-locals at the moment, but it must be weird for cash-accustomed Germans visiting.
- bauerd 6y agoI'm German and was quite surprised indeed :-)
- oxfeed65261 6y agoAH?
- bauerd 6y agohttps://www.ah.nl/ https://www.ah.nl/
- vetinari 6y agoThat would depend on a country. Sweden? Probably easy. South-Eastern Asia? 100 years would be too optimistic.
- readarticle 6y agoI’ve never been nor kept up with SEA, but this is still surprising to hear! I would have assumed WeChat type mobile payments situations were well in place, is cash really that dominant or are there other factors?
- vetinari 6y agoOne reason is, that cashless transfers costs money; e.g. the card processing companies in their contracts disallow the vendors to increase the prices for customers using their payment system, compared to other means of payments. So effectively all the cash paying customers subsidy the electronic payments systems, while not having the convenience of not using cash. This part of the contract is not followed in SEA countries. If you want to pay with something that carries a fee, you are going to pay the fee on top of the price. Logically, most people will choose to pay cash then. The second reason is taxes. Most small vendors do not bother with taxing their incomes; they are too poor for that anyway, every coin helps. With electronic ledgers documenting all the transactions, that would be much more difficult. The local IRSes do not bother with chasing these people, they know that the price would be higher than revenue; so they check only businesses with significant enough turnover.
- mcv 6y agoCash payments also cost money. Not small interpersonal payments, but for larger shops, storing cash safely, transferring it safely to a bank to have counted and deposit it, costs significant money. Many shops prefer electronic payment for that reason, and voluntarily eat the costs associated with it, because it's still cheaper than cash. Of course that only works if electronic payment is cheap. This is not the case with US credit card companies.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 6y agoCash is already going away in some countries. Almost nobody pays for anything with cash in the UK anymore.
- duncanawoods 6y agoSmall shops with card fees is the last remaining hold out for me. Payment systems should be nationalised and run by a country's central bank. It's a very boring infrastructure equivalent to roads. There shouldn't be a private company taxing every single transaction someone makes. Do that and the small stores can drop the fees.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoI’m not sure I see your logic here. Do you think the payment networks will be cheaper to operate if they’re run by the government? Or would you prefer an actual tax to the fees you’re comparing to taxes? Do you expect banks would drop their transaction fees? Do you think payment gateways would drop their fees? Do you think payment terminals would become free, and their networks free to use?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- artifact_44 6y agoYeah, that is the purpose of a functional government.
- mcv 6y agoBanks have already dropped their transaction fees. Simple bank transactions in the EU are free. iDeal payment is either free or costs about 25 cents.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoIn the EU it’s illegal for a merchant to charge a different price based on payment method (iirc), but merchants are most certainly still charged transaction fees for card payments. SEPA transfers still incur fees too. There is a huge number of service providers involved in every single card payment, and that service infrastructure only exists because people pay to use it. It absolutely wouldn’t be strange for the 2-3% fee a merchant is charged for processing a transaction to be divided up between more than 10 service providers.
- scandox 6y agoIt is I'm afraid. Covid has greatly accelerated this process.
- usr1106 6y agoI have not used any cash since beginning of April. Normally I use more cash than the average person in my situation here. But since corona using cash is often seen as being anti-social, disrespecting other's health, so I did not want to be provocative. Last week libraries fully opened and I took a couple of photocopies for 30 cents/page. They have stopped accepting cash, so I paid by credit card. This is Finland, YMMV.
- cultofmetatron 6y agobitcoin and other decentralized zero-trust cryptocurrencies are perfect for this.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI could not agree more. I use credit cards a fair amount ( streamlined dispute process came in handy a few times ), but I can see first hand what kind of future is being pushed from various circles along the lines of "We can do it ( block a transaction that meets some criteria ; why are we not doing it ? ). Yeah. If we want any semblance of actual freedom left, cash is a part of the future.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoI'm in Denmark, I believe this is pretty much the best example of the kind of country you are talking about, unfortunately I have some personal problems along various spectrums that mean I am not good at keeping track of things that I cannot control through a computer, anyway Denmark went nearly cashless for a bit and because of my personal problems I did not have a credit card for a portion of that time. A cashless society would mean a society where some neuro-atypical people might periodically have to worry about starving to death.
- pc86 6y agoThe is no disorder that causes you to be disorganized unless you're using a computer.
- Aeolun 6y agoMaybe not a formal disorder, but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t happen. Mental issues can be pretty much anything you can dream off.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoNo, but there are things that cause you to be disordered, and then you learn to cope with it in different ways and one of the ways that a lot of people learn to cope with it is to retreat into a computer which is a world that can be controlled in different ways than the real world and thus ordered differently. But thanks for correcting me.
- bsder 6y agoThe world is a wide place. If someone has a system and it works for them, it is not my job to take that system away simply to make things a little more convenient for myself. You never know when you, personally, become the non-mainstream person.
- pmiller2 6y agoIf you could see my apartment and my credit report, you'd eat those words. My finances are on autopilot. My apartment is a mess, because it is not.
- sschueller 6y agoPaying with cash also helps small restaurants and cafes. Instead of having to pay 3% and wait 3-5 days until they get the funds which might get charged back they have the money on the spot. No need for all these middle men taking a cut. Same goes for Uber eats etc. Call the restaurant directly, don't be a dick.
- mcv 6y agoOr you pay the restaurant through direct bank transaction. Credit cards are needlessly expensive, but not all electronic payment systems are.
- Silhouette 6y agoThis has the added benefit, assuming both parties are happy to do it, that the business does not incur the overheads of handling cash, which is also not really free once you take into account things like security and bank fees. I am firmly of the view that cash is essential as a safeguard and something people should have the option to use, but as we've seen recently here in the UK, modern alternatives like contactless payments using a bank card or one of the phone-based systems can be quick and convenient, and they do not seem to have resulted in a devastating wave of fraud.
- pc86 6y agoThere is no means to do this in the US, debts cards have the same fees as credit cards (maybe more?).
- mcv 6y agoThis is the core of the problem. In the US, credit card companies have an effective monopoly on the payment infrastructure, and there's not cooperation among banks, and not enough political will, to propose a better system. In the EU, there's been a lot of regulation over the past couple of decades to improve payment infrastructure. Before that, international payment within the EU used to be awful, and even transferring money from one bank to another within a single country could in some circumstances be bafflingly complex.
- hoorayimhelping 6y ago>That is why I am absolutely against abolishing paper cash. Ah, took me a second. You don't mean paper cash in reference to fiat money vs the gold standard. You mean hard cash being replaced by plastic account balances in a sort of cyberpunk vein. Totally agree, great point.
- mcv 6y agoThe problem isn't digital cash, the problem is having payment infrastructure that's controlled by only one or two companies (like Visa and Mastercard). Payment infrastructure needs to be neutral with multiple payment providers on it, so when a bank is being unreasonable, you can just switch to another. Of course this is also an area that requires government regulation in order to prevent banks from taking advantage of their customers. And that requires a government that actually cares about this sort of thing.
- chooseaname 6y ago> The problem isn't digital cash, the problem is having payment infrastructure that's controlled by only one or two companies (like Visa and Mastercard). Payment infrastructure needs to be neutral with multiple payment providers on it, so when a bank is being unreasonable, you can just switch to another. But we know this isn't going to happen. At least not in the US. We have seen a massive consolidation of power in nearly every sector of the economy. That's not going to change. Nobody in our government seems to think it is a big enough problem to do anything useful to stop it.
- mcv 6y agoNot until the people rise up against their government and demand better payment infrastructure. I mean, it's finally working with police brutality after a century of protesting it. If enough people care about this, you might actually get it in a century or so.
- Silhouette 6y agoI mostly agree, except that I think for the foreseeable future it is still essential to have an individually-held, government-backed currency so transactions can't be blocked by any third party (including the government itself) arbitrarily and without notice. However, I think the principle goes beyond just money issues. All of the examples mentioned by BiteCode_dev have at least three things in common. 1. The company in question is in a dominant position as a provider of some product or service. 2. That product or service is important or essential to a lot of people. 3. The company is not significantly regulated by law. Many of them could be dealt with by regulating all financial services and communications services companies. I think there is a lot of merit in offering a "common carrier" principle in these sectors, where a business provides a service but does so strictly neutrally, with neither any control over how people then use it nor any responsibility for those people's actions. I also think there is a lot of merit in saying that if a business wants to take a more active role than that, it must also accept a corresponding increase in liability. In particular, it should then be subject to not only legal actions by individuals but also regulatory actions by an independent, government-backed agency with sufficiently strong statutory powers that a business can get stomped if it persistently and knowingly abuses people. The other thing that IMHO we need but don't currently have in many cases is sufficiently strong consumer protections (and this should extend to small businesses dealing with much larger businesses, or any other situation where one side is effectively in full control of the terms of any deal). The danger is having dominant businesses, whether monopolies or otherwise, providing important or essential services but then having powers to damage others, whether wilfully or simply through negligence, because of the control they retain over those products or services. Under the umbrella of what is important or essential, I do include things like operating systems for PCs and phones, or hosting email, or providing almost any kind of large-scale digital marketplace facility; these are technologies that have become essential to living a "normal life" and participating actively in society. It's not just about the ability to conduct financial transactions or communicate, vital as those also are.
- rbecker 6y ago> I know there are countries where you have a democratically elected representatives and every part of the government and... At the moment. All those things can and do change, and then what will you do?