4 ms·
I used to work on rockets and I'm very confused by the author's opinions. > No evidence a working starlink network can offer lower latency This is weird. Even
by godelski 6y ago
I used to work on rockets and I'm very confused by the author's opinions.
> No evidence a working starlink network can offer lower latency
This is weird. Even if we pretend that these satellites are directly competing with terrestrial based systems, their orbits put them in range for a latency that is at least competitive with terrestrial systems. It's unproven that they get those latencies, but there's clear evidence.
Note: we're talking about like 50ms (IIRC 20ms - 100ms depending on which constellation). Geostationary satellites (which is what they are competing with) are like 250ms (these numbers are off the top of my head so correct me if I'm off). Starlink is competing with geostationary internet satellites AND places that have no internet at all.
> lower prices
Seems to me they can service a lot more people. Isn't this "scale?" Aren't they targeting something like a billion+ users? I know plenty of people with boats and RVs that are excited about this because the terrestrial solutions just suck (and generally aren't terrestrial based solutions).
> Impact on earth based telescopes has not been discussed
What? You're literally discussing it. It is pretty easy to find articles from astronomers getting upset [0][1]. I can tell you that everyone in my community (which includes astronomers and astrophysicists) is aware of this issue. The fact is that most people just don't care. They see greater utility so it is worth the cost. Of course, there are also plenty of people that disagree.
> Starlink is a play for pentagon funding to keep SpaceX launch schedule busy?
Little bit of this, little bit of that. Having worked at a rocket company I can definitely tell you that, like every other manufactured product in the existence of products, flights are cheaper the more you do (especially true for reusable rockets!). Sometimes this is called the "launch chasm." I'm not sure why you're mad at SpaceX here. If you have an issue with this, it is with Pentagon funding.
Look, I'm not the biggest fan of Musk or SpaceX either, but these aren't great arguments. The things to dislike are a little more nuanced whereas this just comes off as hating SpaceX to hate on SpaceX.
[0] https://www.sciencealert.com/elon-musk-s-starlink-satellite-train-looks-amazing-but-astronomers-have-real-concerns https://www.sciencealert.com/elon-musk-s-starlink-satellite-...
[1] https://www.wired.co.uk/article/spacex-starlink-satellites-astronomy https://www.wired.co.uk/article/spacex-starlink-satellites-a...
- shaklee3 6y agoTheir latencies are not at least as competitive as anything if they're not proven. With low orbits, they need multiple hops to get to most destinations, along with queuing and network delays. Propagation delay may not even be the dominant factor. The cost will need to be very expensive, relatively speaking. See this quick math for why: https://mobile.twitter.com/quirkyllama/status/1272748894380634113 https://mobile.twitter.com/quirkyllama/status/12727488943806...
- bryanlarsen 6y agoYour link does calculations on $50 a month. That's crazy cheap, not expensive. Your link's math says that SpaceX is marginally profitable selling 220GB of internet at $50 per month using 2016 bandwidth levels, which is pretty impressive. Those numbers are from the original 2016 FCC filing, they've got a lot more bandwidth out of the satellites now because 4 years is a long time in technology. Musk says 3Tbps per set of 60 satellites. That's 50gigabits per satellite, not 20. Shotwell has indicated a price of $80 a month, not $50. And you know that's going to be the low price, not the high one. So let's assume that includes a 100 gigabyte cap, which is still about 10X as much as you get with the base plans from the geostationary satellite providers. Those new numbers increase the subscribers per satellite from 7000 to 38000. Revenue per satellite per month jumps from $35K to $300K. At 60 satellites per launch over a lifetime of 5 years, that's gross revenue of $1.1B per launch. Re: your other point about latency. They've already got 28 base stations in the US. That's enough to cover the continental US without any hops.
- shaklee3 6y agoI think you're going to need to explain how a satellite at 550km in the sky with a low elevation covers the US without any hops. That's contradictory to what every technical piece of information about Starlink says. You have to hop between base stations. That's a hop, regardless of whether it's through networking equipment or a gateway.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoThey'll use the internet backbones for communications between their base stations rather than satellites. To be more explicit, before they sell you service at a location, they will ensure that they have enough base stations close to you that both your terminal and a base station are both always visible to a single satellite. The base station is connected to an internet backbone. So the signal goes from you to the satellite to the base station to the internet backbone. The reply goes in reverse. So yes, this means that they need to have a similar number of base stations as satellites in a minimal constellation. They've said that a minimal constellation for full US coverage is 1000 - 2000. They have 28 base stations in the continental US, 2% of the globe's area. Yup, 28 is about 2% of 1000 - 2000.
- kanox 6y ago> > Impact on earth based telescopes has not been discussed > What? You're literally discussing it. It is pretty easy to find articles from astronomers getting upset. I can tell you that everyone in my community (which includes astronomers and astrophysicists) is aware of this issue. The fact is that most people just don't care. SpaceX plans modifications to reduce the impact on optical astronomy: https://www.spacex.com/updates/starlink-update-04-28-2020/ https://www.spacex.com/updates/starlink-update-04-28-2020/