6 ms·
This is the right move. This is how you do a V-shaped recovery.
by tomrod 6y ago
This is the right move. This is how you do a V-shaped recovery.
- brianwawok 6y agoWait, don’t we want ^ not V ?
- sfgweilr4f 6y agoSome would argue the economy is actually running O.
- notatoad 6y agoWe already had the crash - the \ side of the V is not negotiable. Our options are \/ or \_
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jussij 6y agoI surely hope this point in time does not turn out to be the best it's ever been.
- trollski 6y agoto the moon!
- gentleman11 6y agoThey are also starting to threaten jail time for people who collect but who aren’t supposed to. They should really just do helicopter money
- toomuchtodo 6y ago> They should really just do helicopter money Central banks should be delegated the authority to issue deposit accounts and debit cards to all citizens, but apparently the world hasn’t ended enough for us to do that yet (which would make helicopter money super simple).
- jariel 6y agoWow, no way. This is way outside the bounds of what central banks do. Remember that 'helicopter money' from central banks is not actually 'free money giveaway' it's just talked about like that. When the Federal Government gives away money like this to citizens, it's more literally free money and it has to come from somewhere: either taxpayers or from debt.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoThe US Federal Reserve is buying individual corporate bonds now (and has already put about $7 trillion [!!!] on its balance sheet). Bank of England is straight up printing pounds, directly financing the deficit, to pay for the U.K. economic support for the COVID response. Remember, fiat is an artificial construct, and we can change the rules and how monetary and fiscal policy works at any time. It’s just a complex spreadsheet and cell formulas with enormous impact. When a government gives away money, it’s borrowed or taxpayer money. When a central bank does it, it devalues the currency (behold the value of a reserve currency!). Regardless of the hangover, you still do it if it’s necessary. I digress; central banks can do whatever we need them to as a society. It’s their job to responsibly pull the macroeconomic levers to meet their mandates.
- jariel 6y ago"central banks can do whatever we need them to as a society." Not really, Central Banks are not part of the government and they can't do things outside the very narrow scope of authority we give them. Especially the Fed, which is a privately owned entity run by the banks themselves. The Fed is the last place we want to manage social security programs. That job is for the government. Now, it just so happens as you point out they have some magic levers such as the ability to take on stuff onto their balance sheet, but using that outside the scope of their policy is another thing altogether. So yes, we can make 'money, financing and banking' do what we want, but if we do - it will absolutely not be 'The Central Bank' - it will be some other new kind of entity, designed differently, with different power structures and different objectives.
- marketgod 6y agoThis seemed like a concept to please the Conservatives. The NDP were against it so it doesn't seem to be part of the new bill.
- clusterfish 6y agoHow do you think they will force many thousands of poor people to repay money that they don't have, neither in savings nor in income, while holding on to a minority position in government? They're just lying about being strict on TV to make everyone feel better about it. They don't have the capacity or political willpower to follow through. It's been months, it isn't urgent anymore, if they wanted to devise any sort of eligibility checks they would have done it already. But the only real eligibility requirement is being ballsy / desperate / yolo enough to claim it.
- imtringued 6y agoI always had the impression that with these programs that repayment isn't the goal. Yes, the government wants its money back but if say only 10% of the money was "wasted" then you can just consider that money a form of economic stimulus.
- clusterfish 6y agoIf it was a universal stimulus that's be great, but that 10% is a hundred-million-dollar subsidy to dishonest people and outright fraudsters. Such incentives affect people's behaviour and over long term this might even accumulate to a pretty damaging change in culture that will be very hard to fix. Some people like to complain about regular welfare programs being abused, but at least those have some controls, they're not just a web form with your bank details. Abuse rates will surely be much much higher for CERB, and that was largely preventable.
- katbyte 6y agoI’m ok with it - it allowed many of my friends to survive the pandemic with out too much fuss and any controls put it to prevent abuse would have delayed much needed help
- bregma 6y agoThis is correct. My wife works as a professional in the field. She says outright and obvious fraud is criminal code territory, and simple dishonesty (like what most amateurs do, just lying to a government official because they think they can get away with it this week and next week doesn't exist) just gets you a permanent denial of any future payments. That means you're cut off from welfare, for example.
- cycop 6y agoThis is how you do a W-shaped recovery , the economic fallout of giving money away will have a secondary recession effect. Can't just print money and give it to your citizens for an extended time, otherwise all economic theory should just be tossed out the window.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoMoney printer goes brrr - USA.