7 ms·
You paid $1000 knowing that you couldn’t install arbitrary software. You had a choice. You could have bought an Android like 85% of the world.
by scarface74 6y ago
You paid $1000 knowing that you couldn’t install arbitrary software. You had a choice. You could have bought an Android like 85% of the world.
- actuator 6y agoSo, if Apple had 85% market share this would have been not fine then? At what marketshare do we decide it is fine for them to not do this? We can always ask the user to look for an alternative. Honestly, this whole think has stunk for a long time. iOS is a platform and it is dominant. It severely reeks of monopolistic behaviour when they use their leverage on one platform to gain advantage in a new one. Apple Music doesn't have to pay the 30% tax while also getting free product placement from Apple as compared to something like Spotify.
- scarface74 6y agoYes. Users have choices. You don’t have to have the nanny state to protect you from buying devices that don’t meet your needs. Apple Music doesn't have to pay the 30% tax while also getting free product placement from Apple as compared to something like Spotify. Spotify hasn’t allowed in app payments for years and don’t pay the 30% “tax” either. Are you also against every grocery store having store brands and “slotting fees”?
- actuator 6y agoWell, Spotify doesn't allow it to so that it doesn't have to pay the tax. Everyone wants to make the signup flow as easy as they can, do you think they would not want to increase their userbase. If we didn't have nanny state to protect us probably Microsoft's dominance would have went unchallenged and you won't have the plethora of different services that we see.
- scarface74 6y agoRight because after the ruling , Microsoft became a shell of its former self, lost its position as one of the five most valuable companies in the US and lost its dominance in the desktop operating system and office productivity market.....
- actuator 6y agoIt just becomes speculative now but many would argue that did help the other big companies in that group you talked about to grow. https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2018/9/6/17827042/antitrust-1990s-microsoft-google-aol-monopoly-lawsuits-history https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2018/9/6/17827042/anti...
- scarface74 6y agoGoogle was dominant way before Chrome existed. Apple never did gain significant market share on the desktop and became profitable first with music and then mobile - MS tried to compete in both. Facebook success had nothing to do with the anti trust trial and neither did Amazon.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoA similar ruling did work to increase browser diversity in Europe with the ballot. I wouldn't argue that the US's wrist slap is evidence that anti-trust is worthless. Consider if Standard Oil, company towns, or child labor were still common in the US. Without regulation it's possible we'd still live in that nightmare once called 'normal'.
- scarface74 6y agoThat was a Pyrrhic victory. “Browser diversity” paved the way for dozens of profitable companies releasing profitable competing products. In the real world, Microsoft and almost everyone else threw in the towel and just used Chromium because they realized there was no point in trying to make a browser engine. Firefox is only barely hanging on while most of its revenue comes from a competitor (Google) and Apple just went its own way after supporting Safari on Windows for awhile. The legislators - as usual ignorant of tech - didn’t do anything to curb MS’s power or control over operating systems and office productivity apps. Where they made and continue to make much of their money.
- whatever1 6y agoWhat about scarface74’s new fancy music app with negligible market share and no legal team? Will Apple show any mercy and not collect their duties?
- scarface74 6y agoYou mean like Tidal?
- actuator 6y agoYeah, exactly the kind of thing he was talking about. Tidal had the backing of Jay-Z and several other artists.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- perl4ever 6y ago"Are you also against every grocery store having store brands and “slotting fees”?" I don't have any insider knowledge of the industry, but since COVID has been a thing, I've noticed that there are brands appearing that are local or regional, that look way better that what I'm used to, and so I'm asking myself if maybe there was something messed up or even corrupt about the distribution system before. If these brands can step in in a crisis, why didn't the store carry them before? I don't have a really well-formed point, just a vague sense of vindication that yeah, markets (like an app store) are run by people, and maybe they're not run in the best manner and it isn't obvious. I think markets are valuable, just like computers, as tools to solve optimization problems. But like computers, they can fail to solve your specific problem, or have uncompetitive performance. Like computers, they're complex and you can easily be snowed about how well they're functioning if you're not immersed in details.
- Despegar 6y agoThere's no requirement in law that all technology businesses need to hew to any particular philosophy or ideology of computing; no one has to be "open". This has always chafed a lot of tech people because Apple is successful while being "closed". The only thing that would change this is if Apple was found to be "dominant" or have "monopoly power" in a "relevant market" as held by a court.
- actuator 6y agoBut aren't they a dominant power already. Android can have 80% market share but the app store revenue reality is 2:1 in the favour of iOS.[1] Isn't it anti competitive for a new service like a movie streaming app to be at a competitive disadvantage financially than if Apple decides to launch their own. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/4/21121558/google-80-billion-android-developers-apple-155 https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/4/21121558/google-80-billion...
- scarface74 6y agoThat argument is going to be a winning one. Apple achieved market dominance by charging three times as much for the same product - those bastards. It’s not Apple’s fault that the entire Android ecosystem is a commoditized race to the bottom.
- actuator 6y agoI didn't quote the revenue of iPhones, I quoted the revenue of app developers from the respective stores being 2:1 in favour of iOS.
- scarface74 6y agoSo now that evil monopolist not only convinced people to pay three times as much now they convinced those poor more affluent consumers to give developers twice as much. Cry me a river....
- Despegar 6y ago
- matwood 6y agoActually yes. Instead of thinking that you're buying an iPhone, you're buying an ecosystem that includes the app store, iMessage, iCloud, etc... If you don't like that option, there is Android. Consumers go in knowing that is the ecosystem they are buying into. Developers also go in knowing the same. Neither are forced, and have other options that are relatively comparable.
- actuator 6y agoWell, Apple also benefited from those apps being there, it is not like only the app developers benefited. The biggest complaint against Windows Phone used to be the app ecosystem and eventually that's what killed it as well. Phone market being essentially a duopoly, I don't want a independent service developer to be financially disadvantaged to compete and eventually the platforms owning all the big money making services.
- wayneftw 6y ago50% in the USA. And next to nobody releases apps for Android only precisely because of that number. The problem has way more to do with how this affects developers then how it affects consumers. The amount of control that Apple has over the US market is the reason why they should be targeted by an anti-trust investigation here.
- nojito 6y agoGood luck proving antitrust with such a small marketshare. You also fail to share that iOS developers are paid much much more when compared to android and they only have to target fewer devices and versions which makes developing much much easier than the fragmented cluster in android.
- scarface74 6y agoGoogle Play also has a 30% fee. The only prominent app that I am aware of that tried to get around the fee is Fortnite by releasing outside of the store. Nintendo, Microsoft and Sony also get a cut of every game sold - even physical games. US monopoly law has never been about producers. It’s been about consumers. Are consumers really better off with the insecure by design desktop operating systems? How much malware, ransomware, and viruses have there been on Windows? I’m not excusing Macs. The only thing that makes them safer is few people bother about writing malware for them.
- notatoad 6y agoWhat google play does not have is a ToS that requires you to use the Google Play billing and forbids you from talking about other ways to pay for the app. (Google play does have a lot of restrictions around this, but it's not quite as draconian as apple's. what basecamp is doing here would be allowed on the play store)
- scarface74 6y agoSo Google Play should be bringing in a lot more money if Apple’s policy is hurting developers. Obviously, it’s not.
- whatever1 6y agoMicrosoft was fined for just shipping an OS with a default browser. You were still allowed to install any browser you wanted. If Microsoft was found guilty, I don’t see why Apple is innocent.
- scarface74 6y agoMicrosoft also had 95% market share and was fined for not allowing third party OEMs to ship alternate browsers and even charging them for PCs shipped without their operating system.
- hn_check 6y agoThe was quite literally no alternative to Microsoft in many scenarios, and windows enjoyed a >95% marketshare. You simply couldn't run a business if you weren't running Windows. iOS has <15% marketshare, and millions of people transition back and forth across platforms regularly. I was on Android, now I'm on iOS, and tomorrow I could be on Android if there was a compelling case. Apple is abusive, and needs to be reigned in, but comparing iOS to the late-90s Windows situation betrays a misunderstanding of the situation in the 90s.
- zakki 6y agoI don’t think it is fair to count iOS market share by comparing it to all androids devices. Should be between iOS and total android flagship devices. Also, last I read 2-3 years ago, Apple profit crushed all android makers profit. Maybe we should use this for market share?
- scarface74 6y agoSo now we are going to make a carve out for “all devices over $x”. Users have a choice between Androids “open ecosystem” and Apple’s “walled garden”. The consumers made a choice to spend more on Apple’s devices using their own free will. Do we really need the government to tell them that they made the wrong choice?
- 6y ago
- deeblering4 6y agoOr a $399 iPhone SE
- harpratap 6y agoThat number is old and outdated. iOS is 26% right now - https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/worldwide https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/worldwide
- dilap 6y agoSure, I had a choice, but I would have a better choice if we legally compelled Apple to open its platform.
- scarface74 6y agoWhy don’t we just have the government come out with “Five Year Plans”?
- realusername 6y agoIt's just basic consumer laws like any others, no need to bring out the red scare.
- scarface74 6y agoWhy not just keep it simple. Why not have a government run cell phone company that meets the need of the people?
- realusername 6y agoOr why even have regulations anyway? Why not allowing cars to be sold without seatbelts or products without warranties? I think you can find the answer yourself.
- scarface74 6y agoYes because car safety is comparable to a few geeks whining about Apple’s “walled garden” when their are literally hundreds of phones running Android.
- realusername 6y agoThat's just missing completely the point, user rights needs to be there whether you care about them personally or not, like any other right.