4 ms·
The issue with 'military-grade' is that anyone in the military will attest it translates to: Cheapest possible thing that gets the job done. Audiophile grade a
by dijit 6y ago
The issue with 'military-grade' is that anyone in the military will attest it translates to: Cheapest possible thing that gets the job done.
Audiophile grade at least has roots in high fidelity.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y ago3DES is still military grade.
- user5994461 6y agoNo it's not. It stopped being approved for usage by NIST a few years ago.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y ago112-bit keys are still allowed precisely because of 3DES.
- Twirrim 6y agoReally? 3DES still appears here, https://csrc.nist.gov/projects/block-cipher-techniques https://csrc.nist.gov/projects/block-cipher-techniques, with DES and Skipjack being called out as deprecated.
- user5994461 6y agoThat page says that 3DES is prohibited from usage in new applications and is prohibited for encrypting more than 1 GB of data, since 2017. The attached documents have additional information on implementation and (non) usage, including deadline to migrate legacy military systems. It's sadly quite cumbersome to go through the tens of PDF to find the relevant information.
- Joeboy 6y ago> Audiophile grade at least has roots in high fidelity. Does it though? Audiophiles generally seem to eschew fidelity in favour of something that sounds subjectively nice, including the psychoacoustic effects of spending a lot of money. Eg. they seem very fond of "warmth". If you asked me to make something sound "warm", I'd be applying some soft clipping and dampening the top end, not eliminating sources of distortion. Edit: If you actually wanted high fidelity, you'd use studio headphones / monitors, which are designed to be "unflattering", so you can be confident you'll hear any issues when mixing / mastering. People don't normally listen for pleasure with those, because they become fatiguing after a few hours. Choosing equipment because you like the sound is a very reasonable thing to do, but it's not the same as pursuing fidelity.
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoYou've never listened to audiophile equipment have you? If apply "some soft clipping" it will sound bad, I guarantee you, no audiophile would like it.
- Joeboy 6y ago> You've never listened to audiophile equipment have you? You're saying that I ought to judge the merits of audiophile equipment by the subjective measure of whether I like the sound of it. Which is the metric I said audiophiles would favour. > If apply "some soft clipping" it will sound bad Soft clipping often sounds nice, which is why it's very commonly applied to music. You're saying that eg. the sound of a classic Vox amp is bad, which I guess you're free to believe if that's what your ears tell you, but it's certainly not an objective truth.
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoBecause what you are describing is a simplistic picture, describing whole class of people as stupid simpletons who cannot tell low THD and low IMD audio from "soft clipping which sounds nice". If you are referring to vacuum tube amps, soft clipping is only partially the reason why they sound the way they do; in fact most of the time amps are not clipping and are outputting close to 1% of their their total power. Reasons why tube equipment sounds better/different from the solid state amps are a lot more complex than the "common wisdom" of soft clipping.
- Macha 6y agoSimilarly "medical grade" = "single use" in many actual medical contexts.