13 ms·
Avro Arrow – The record-breaking jet which still haunts a country
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tixocloud 6y agoSadly, this story continues to have a modern day version in the form of poor government support for domestic firms. Canadian education and talent is incredible and arguably world class but with greater opportunity in the south, many choose to leave. Perhaps some may have come back with the US politics but I doubt there's a mass migration back to Canada. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/ibm-shared-services-contract-1.4658682 https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/ibm-shared-services-contrac...
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoYou can say the same about Europe generally having a great and free education system but the best and brightest move to the US.
- gambiting 6y agoI honestly don't understand or know anyone who would move to the US now. I have a few friends who were considering it but it's a very firm no at this point, and they all had offers from the big firms in Silicone Valley. Sure, your compensation in UK or Germany won't reach the stratospheric levels of US programmers, but as a competent engineer you can easily reach very comfortable levels of living, buy a house, brand new car, afford to have a couple kids and save some money for fun. And you won't have to deal with the insanity of American healthcare, immigration or politics. I grew up thinking that my dream would be to move to US one day - nowadays there probably isn't an offer that would make me move there.
- ChuckNorris89 6y ago>[...]Germany[...]buy a house Unless you get financial support from your (grand)parents, you can forget about that as houses in the nice areas are closing in on the million euro ballpark and IC salaries there are a joke for such a purchase.
- gambiting 6y agoI don't know why people immediately assume that when I say "buy a house" I mean "buy a house in the middle of London/Berlin/Paris". Can your average SF programmer afford to buy a house in the middle of SF? I know people working for instance in Stuttgart - buying a house in the smaller towns nearby is not an issue at all according to them. I personally live in the UK and sure, London prices are insane - but we don't live in London. Me and my wife bought a house after saving just for a few months[0], the prices are very achievable for an average programmer. [0]mortgaged, obviously. But since the prices are lower it was "easy" to save for a deposit and get a mortgage. We're literally paying £600/month on a mortgage for a 3-bed house with a large garden and double driveway. That's an almost insignificant part of my salary.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoNo disrespect, but houses in Germany are a lot more expensive than in the UK. If you own a 3 bedroom house and two driveways in Germany you're basically a millionaire. And by "nice house" I didn't mean a house in the center of a major city but a house in the suburbs in a quiet, green area with good schools.
- tixocloud 6y agoAs a Canadian looking at how the UK government is willing to work with smaller, domestic firms for government services and how much is being spent to help with the startup ecosystem, it's no wonder Canada doesn't really have the same ecosystem. For Canadian businesses to be successful, they generally have to look elsewhere. Speaking to a Canadian AI startup, their business comes from Europe.
- rjsw 6y ago> looking at how the UK government is willing to work with smaller, domestic firms owned by friends of members of the government for government services FIFY.
- gabbo 6y agoNot exactly. There are fewer linguistic, cultural, and immigration barriers when comparing Canada/US vs. Europe/US.
- andromeduck 6y agoYup, this is especially bad in BC where at least half the CS/ECE grad moved to Seattle or SF the year they graduated. All the best talent leave unless tied down by family. It seems there just wasn't enough graft or cheap political points to be had nurturing anything complex. The payoffs if any aren't quick enough. It's much easier to go after logging, mining, casinos (money laundering for Chinese donors), film or some quick jobs program to appease unions and claim impact for the next election.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 908B64B197 6y agoMy understanding is that the current administration has made it easier for Canadians to come to the US since they started to be more strict on what's accepted for H1B. But I could be mistaken.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> The record-breaking jet which still haunts a country That's no exaggeration. For English Canada, the destruction of those planes was a trauma that lasts to this day because the Arrow represented the height of national pride, and their destruction the deepest low. Similar but lesser feelings for the A220, sold by Bombardier for $1 to Airbus because Boeing lobbied for a 219.63% tariff on it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_A220 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_A220 https://money.cnn.com/2017/09/26/news/companies/bombardier-boeing-cseries-delta-itc-ruling/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2017/09/26/news/companies/bombardier-b... Canadians are polite, but they can kick ass when they want to.
- deskamess 6y agoBased on the number (220) I thought this was some ancient Airbus model. Well.
- rsynnott 6y agoNot how airbus numbering works, in general. The A400 is older than the A350, for instance. The first was the A300, and at that point the number was supposed to mean the passenger number, though as it turned out there wasn't much demand for a 300 passenger wide body at the time and it was scaled down. After that, the numbers became more or less random.
- kitteh 6y agoThe A220 was the plane that not many folks wanted. Purely due to union / regional scoping rules. It was too large for regionals, too small for mainline. For example many airline union scoping contracts require planes with more than 70 or 100 pax go to mainline which means it will cost more to operate. Airlines don't want to do that. If it's going mainline, they want more seats (think 737/a320 ranges) which the A220 doesn't have. There's a somewhat famous post from a Bombardier product manager on the internet detailing the history of the aircrafts evolution that played out like the Bradley Fighting Vehicle in The Pentagon Wars. Despite marketing data and customer feedback saying don't build this they kept pushing ahead and the Quebec tax payer footing some of that bill.
- jariel 6y ago"but they can kick ass when they want to. Obviously not when it comes to Arrow, Bombardier, and getting salary parity with US workers. I say this unsarcastically as a Canadian.
- ajuc 6y agoIf you get paid 20% more but spend 20% of your salary on services you wouldn't need to buy otherwise - isn't it parity already?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> If you get paid 20% more I think you are possibly massively underestimating how much it is possible to get paid as even an average software developer in the US. Like literally off by an entire order of magnitude. I would guess it's more like 100%-400% more for equivalent jobs, and many people at. Plus your US job covers your healthcare etc.
- Spooky23 6y agoThat's really about location and specific skillsets. An "average" developer can be hired in 2nd tier cities for $70-90k salary. Long time ago I worked in the US company based out of the Toronto area that ended up with IT ops people in call centers all over the US and Canada. It worked really well -- the Canadian developers were awesome, and IT type people are easy to train. They seemed to be able to attract well educated graduates with locally competitive salaries that were below average by US standards. Over the years I've dealt with a few smaller Canadian consultancies and they always seemed to punch above their weight. If you can provide good work, there is alot of Canadian talent that wants to work in Canada.
- DFHippie 6y agoLikewise there is a lot of US talent that wants to work in some place that isn't the Bay Area.
- cheez 6y agoCanada is a joke and will continue to be a joke until the economy collapses under the weight of a government run by sissies. (Edit: to be clear, that's all of them. Not just the current one. The culture of Canada's government is to be a leech.)
- dang 6y agoYikes! Please don't post like this and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23537637 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23537637 here. I'm well acquainted with the effect that the Avro Arrow has on Canadian feelings, especially Canadian engineering feelings. But let's not go overboard.
- cheez 6y agoProof is in the pudding :-)
- jabl 6y agoInteresting to contrast with Sweden, a country of 10m people, having a domestic fighter program to this day. Though at least the current Swedish fighter, the JAS-39 Gripen, uses a lot of 3rd party components like the engine and most of the armaments. Still, an impressive achievement from such a small country. Will be interesting to see whether they will create a follow-up to the Gripen, or will instead opt to participate in some next-generation common European thing. Also similar to the Avro Arrow story is the British TSR2.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoNo disrespect to Sweden or the Gripen but the UK makes 30% of its parts(mostly electronic warfare) which is a leverage it used to ban its sale to Argentina.[1] If a foreign country owns such a major part of your domestic fighter then your fighter is on a very short leash. [1]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saab_JAS_39_Gripen https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saab_JAS_39_Gripen
- detritus 6y agoHuh, I had no idea, thanks. I guess that goes some way to explaining the announcement last year that Sweden might join UK/Italy to develop a 'sixth Generation' fighter, the so-called 'Tempest'. Not knowing any better, I simply assumed it was Brexit-related and we in the UK expected to burn bridges with our French and German industrial partners.
- jabl 6y agoI think the reason is they're realizing that developing a high end next generation jet fighter is incredibly expensive, and is only getting more so. So partnering with allies (even if not formally in the sense that Sweden is not part of NATO) makes all the sense in the world. As to why there are two next generation European fighters planned (the Tempest you mention, and then there's another French/German/Spanish(?) effort), no idea. It doesn't make sense.
- 6y ago
- cheez 6y agoCanadians are stupid. They should drain the Canadian economy of workers, but instead they are sold on the promise of "we're better than the US"
- tromp 6y ago> told to destroy the blueprints What on earth compelled them to order that? That's just so barbaric. As if they were trying to destroy evidence of a crime. Surely it makes more sense to preserve them?! You might even try to sell or license the design to recover some of the $250m invested?
- kstenerud 6y agoWhen you live next to a giant, you do what the giant says.
- TMWNN 6y agoYou didn't read the article, which explicitly disclaims against conspiracy theories of the US ordering the Arrow's cancelation.
- gandalfian 6y agoWhat on earth compelled them to order that? To stop someone trying to reverse the decision and restart the program? Guns or butter, it may have not been the worse choice.
- andromeduck 6y agoYup, same reason why all the plans and tooling was torched for the Saturn V.
- Sanzig 6y agoThe Saturn V plans were not lost. NASA still has them at Marshall. https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/20302/were-the-saturn-v-construction-plans-destroyed https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/20302/were-the-sat...
- rurounijones 6y ago> told to destroy the blueprints Same thing happened to the British TSR2; a program that shares a lot in common with the Avro Arrow. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BAC_TSR-2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BAC_TSR-2
- polskibus 6y agoFor a moment I thought this is about some combination of Apache Avro and Apache Arrow for data serialization purposes.
- cangencer 6y agoexactly!
- sungam 6y agoInterestingly the cessation of Arrow development presented a huge opportunity for the Apollo program which actively recruited these highly trained engineers for the moon landings (this is discussed in detail in Charles Murray's fascinating history of the Apollo program).
- smichel17 6y ago> In a move which shocked Canada, the cutting up of the Arrow prototypes took place in front of the silent factory. The moment was captured in a grainy black-and-white photograph which continues to haunt Canada. Is it just me or was this photo not included in the article? I tried a quick search but didn't see anything obviously it, either.
- arvinaminpour 6y agoI remember our high school history teacher taking us to an aviation museum in Toronto. They had a section of the plane out on display and it was a beautiful piece of work. But I'll never forget the way the tour guide described the story of the arrow and the hurt in his voice as he recanted the decision to scrap the plane. For that generation of Canadian aviation geeks, it was truly a gut punch.
- catalogia 6y agoThere's currently a full-size Arrow replica on display in Toronto, at the Canadian Air and Space Museum. I haven't gotten a chance to go there yet, but the Canada Aviation and Space Museum in Ottawa currently has an original nose section on display, which I believe is the largest surviving piece. I can attest to the later being a very good aviation museum all around; I recommend it to anybody who's interested in that sort of thing. The nearby Diefenbunker museum is also very cool if you're interested in cold war stuff.
- gandalfian 6y agoThey still have their own CANDU nucleur technology which is impressive for a country their size. Britain basically have up on theirs.
- goalieca 6y agoWell actually, we started selling that off to SNC and it's rotting now.. https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/aecl-sold-for-15m-to-snc-lavalin-1.985786 https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/aecl-sold-for-15m-to-snc-la...
- andromeduck 6y agoat least we still have a few SMR startups like Terrestrial https://www.terrestrialenergy.com/ https://www.terrestrialenergy.com/
- SuoDuanDao 6y agoThere are no military applications to CANDU (heavy water allows it to use less-refined uranium fuel), so I imagine America wouldn't have felt the need to interfere.
- g8oz 6y agoNot exactly true...India used plutonium produced by its CANDU reactors for the development of their first nuclear bomb. http://www.ccnr.org/india_press.html http://www.ccnr.org/india_press.html
- mymythisisthis 6y agoCancelled in 1959. Many of the Canadian engineers moved to the States and worked on the space program.
- dmix 6y agoAs is tradition.
- tolien 6y agoSee previous discussions, e.g. [1, 2]. The Arrow was extremely ambitious and many of the technologies it used didn't exist and wouldn't for decades (e.g. fully active missiles, pulse doppler RADAR). The era of high-and-fast bombers was followed by low-level nap-of-the-earth flying and ICBMs, so the Arrow might have been an incredibly expensive white elephant if it had even been finished. 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21989392 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21989392 2: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15256068 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15256068
- hn_check 6y agoRussia's nuclear strategy still relies upon flying Bear bombers to the launch box and deploying cruise missiles. NORAD still sorties fighter aircraft to intercept these bombers somewhat regularly. Obviously not bombers actually launching cruise missiles, but ones doing test runs of the same. It would have had a critical role for decades.
- tolien 6y agoCool, but the Tu-95 now carries missiles like the Kh-55 with a range of 1600 miles while the Arrow was expected to have a range of 360 nmi. The Bear could have dropped its missiles and been long gone before the Arrow got anywhere close to it, never mind that the Sparrow II never worked.
- hn_check 6y agoThe Arrow was circa the late 50s. You claimed it would be a white elephant when finished, yet now the measure is that it wouldn't be relevant today, sixty years later? The Arrow was specifically built as a far North interceptor aircraft, a role later filled by a variety of aircraft over the years (which in a probable war state would effectively rotate in constant sorties to the far North) -- the F106, F15, F16, F18, etc. It's a sled to move a missile closer to a target and not much more.
- nickff 6y agoThe KH-22, with a range of 300 miles would be a more fair example, as it would have been a contemporary of the Arrow (1960-1980). The KH-55 was first produced in 1981.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- andromeduck 6y agoOne of my profs used to say that when it came to science Canada had a bronze medal mentality. We also cancelled a supercollider program in because it was more politically expedient to spend the modest grant required on low income housing for the more politically influential eastern provinces and did absolutely nothing to protect Nortel as they were slowly picked apart by Chinese intelligence. https://www.bcbusiness.ca/ubcs-particle-accelerator-what-couldve-been https://www.bcbusiness.ca/ubcs-particle-accelerator-what-cou... https://nationalpost.com/news/exclusive-did-huawei-bring-down-nortel-corporate-espionage-theft-and-the-parallel-rise-and-fall-of-two-telecom-giants https://nationalpost.com/news/exclusive-did-huawei-bring-dow...
- csours 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconducting_Super_Collider https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconducting_Super_Collider The US has one too.
- valuearb 6y agoHey cancellation of the Supercollider enabled me to hire my best engineer ever. So not a total loss.
- csours 6y agoStory?
- valuearb 6y agoHe was a Japanese nuclear physicist working in the SSC, who had written some amazing graphics filters in his spare time. We hired him (cost $25,000 in legal fees to get him a work visa IIRC) and he instantly became one of our most valuable engineers. His products sold millions of dollars and supported probably a dozen of our employees. Funny part is his English wasn’t very good, so I never even had a full conversation with him. Great guy tho. Makes me want to tell my republican friends, do you want super talented people making things in Asia, or here?
- martythemaniak 6y agoYou know what haunts me even more? That 60 years later, we still spend time and effort talking about this instead of doing anything. Sadly, Canadians don't have the appetite for ambitious projects, whether military, civilian, terrestrial, space etc. Even when costs are reasonable (think of putting up $1billion in prize money to spur private investment X-Prize style) people will not tolerate attempts at risky things.
- drchiu 6y agoYup. Another good examples are Nortel and BlackBerry. The government in Canada needs to be supportive about developing global leaders in expertise. Healthcare, once considered a world’s top, isn’t really today, but many Canadians still retain to the idea it is.
- wenc 6y agoAs a Canadian living in the U.S., I noticed a subtle thing that comes up when we Canadians lament the lack of global leaders in business. We often instinctively say "the government ought to do this or that" (I do this too). Whereas Americans tend not to bring up the government at all -- they go straight to private capital and get it done. I'm a big government person (especially for society-wide services like healthcare, public health, education) but in business, I've come to realize that it's not helpful to have the mindset of relying on the government. (exception: defense, which almost always needs government funding. But almost everything else does not.) I had a friend who was running a nascent high-tech commercial business and he spent a large chunk of his time writing proposals for government grants. Money is money, of course, but it's a little strange to me that even business people in Canada rely so much on the government instead of just going to the capital markets. And what's worse, a lack of government programs in a particular area is interpreted as a constraint. This should not be. The 2nd largest company in Canada by market cap right now is Shopify, and it succeeded with no significant government support. We need to shift our people's mindset to not default to invoking the government -- instead we need to encourage non-risk-averse capital investment into bluesky projects from private parties. It is true that we are not awash in capital, being a small country and all, but we have enough (we're 16th in the world in GDP/PPP). Much smaller countries in northern Europe with smaller GDPs have done better than we have in establishing global business leaders.
- Theodores 6y agoAmy of YouTube 'Vintage Space' fame was who the BBC went to for the nuts and bolts of the article. She is Canadian and more into space than aviation. She is not a fan of the Space Shuttle so that isn't 'vintage Space' as far as she is concerned. Her YouTube channel and book are recommended.
- Nimitz14 6y ago> “The Arrow was an extremely high-performance, hi-tech fighter,” says Coles. “Its designers had made very few compromises to keep its costs down, and it was very much the 'gold-plated' solution.” Sounds like this is a cautionary tale of what happens when you do what some people here suggest; doing everything the 'right/best' way, instead of realising that being engineer means making compromises.
- m23khan 6y agoYes, as Canadian, Avro Arrow does leave a "What if..." thought in my mind but having said that, I am proud of my countrymen as we have achieved quiet a lot since then (given our tiny population and difficult logistics): Canada Space Arm, Blackberry (RIM), Bombardier aircrafts/subways/streetcars/trains, de Havilland aircrafts as well as other aircrafts (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_aircraft_of_Canada%27s_air_forces https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_aircraft_of_Canada%27s...). As to why was Avro Arrow scrapped - sure there are explanations and the leading ones tend to indicate external political pressure coming from USA but I am not bitter at the reasons behind it because it is one thing to be cross at the decision but I don't have any clear idea as to actual reasons and the thought process of our leaders at the time.
- pjkundert 6y agoWhat haunts Canadians is that we developed world-leading aerospace capability, which was discarded in an instant. These engineers and technicians scattered to the wind, becoming leaders in dozens of successful aerospace projects, worldwide. Canada returned to being hewers of wood an drawers of water. The specific details and capabilities/problems of the Avro Arrow are secondary.
- jabl 6y agoI think a small (in terms of GDP) country developing major weapons systems is an impossibly difficult position to be in. The R&D costs are stupendous, so you need to sell a lot of units to make the per-unit costs bearable. Since you're a small country, domestic demand isn't enough. Superpowers buy lots of gear, but they also very strongly prefer their own domestic technology. So you basically have to sell to a lot of other small countries, in competition with the superpowers who are also eager to get export income and political influence.
- valuearb 6y agoIt’s like saying the US lost when it canceled the Space Shuttle. Both projects were massively expensive failures that never met operational requirements. at least Canada canceled theirs before it drove the cost of space access through the roof and killed 17 people.
- nikitaga 6y agoThe difference is, US is replacing the shuttle with (privately made) US rockets. The transition is not complete yet, but ultimately both the manufacturing capability and profits are staying in the US. Can't say the same for Canada.
- valuearb 6y agoI can capture all the wild stallions I want, but as soon as I open the pasture gate they will be gone. The idea isn’t to temporarily feed them with some completely uneconomic project. You want to give them reasons to stay long term. So why is Canada such a poor place to build technology companies?
- kelvin0 6y agoOh, and let's not forget about Hydro-Québec's innovation with an all electric motor-wheel(early 90's!). Way ahead of it's time, and canned for suspicious reasons. https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=fr&u=https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moteur-roue_d%2527Hydro-Qu%25C3%25A9bec&prev=search https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=fr&u=https:/... https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moteur-roue_d%27Hydro-Qu%C3%A9bec https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moteur-roue_d%27Hydro-Qu%C3%A9...
- jacobush 6y agoThe usual problem with wheel motors is unsprung weight, and the 90s was before batteries had decent energy density. It sounds like something like a Prius, but with serial hybrid instead of parallel hybrid like the Prius was.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThis is not true. Wheel motors have a ton of advantages in applications where unsprung weight isn't a big issue - electric bicycles and motorcycles for instance. Wheel motors can also be surprisingly light as they can use the rotation in order to create cooling, and reduce a lot of rotational inertia which can be almost as bad as unsprung weight. The prototype was also a plug-in hybrid, which was very doable at the time. There is a reason why hub motors are so amazing in so many applications right now.
- coryrc 6y agoThe context was clearly conventional automobiles. Nothing going over ~30 mph will ever be economically competitive with wheel motors instead of inboard motors. The physics are such that this will forever be true. Any materials advancement will improve both technologies and wheel motors can never catch up.
- sudosysgen 6y agoI really don't understand where you're getting that from. For economy cars up to ~130kph hub motors are a very feasible alternative. There are hub motors+rims right now with which you could build a ~150hp car, that will weigh less or comparably to old-fashioned steel rims, including axles, rotors and superfluous suspension components (around 30-40kg). For example, the QS Motor 273 with a power of 28kw (per wheel) given appropriate cooling, at a mass of 43kg. This is for a mass market, aluminum motor/rim. I assure you that with magnesium wheels and glycol cooling you can get this down under 43kg. These motors have a wholesale price under 2000$, too, and have been run at 180v 600A for short periods of time. Here is also an actual study with data about the feasibility of hub motors in four-wheel vehicles: https://www.proteanelectric.com/f/2018/04/protean-Services3.pdf https://www.proteanelectric.com/f/2018/04/protean-Services3.... Yes, hub motors will always have a disadvantage as far as unsprung mass as improvements affect both sides of the equation. However, hub motors have very significant handling advantages that you cannot feasibly get any other way, such as per-tire regenerative braking, a perfect fully dynamic differential, perfect torque vectoring, optimal weight distribution, allows far superior suspension design, and so on. As a result, hub motors are still a very serious contender, and as the gaps narrows and investment ramps up we might see very high performance hub motors become a reality. Another technology that will have to be evaluated is fully active suspension, which eliminates almost all of the disadvantages of hub motors and keep all of their advantages. Indeed, fully active electromagnetic suspension is entering limited mass production right now. But yes, in the 1990s hub motors could not have made for anything more than an economy car with a top speed around 130-140kph economically. Which is exactly what they were meant for.
- johnmarcus 6y agoJust me, or is that Starscream?
- aidenn0 6y agoI don't remember any pure delta-winged Starscream, but that doesn't mean there wasn't one. All of the Starscreams I remember have prominent horzontal tail surfaces (the one I owned as a kid was very F-15ish but he's also been patterned after the Su-35, the F-16 and the F-22.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- scottlocklin 6y agoThe Avro Arrow was a cool plane, but contra my Canadian aerospace nerd pals, it really wasn't all that impressive. It was a pretty typical interceptor design of its day; interceptors basically fell out of fashion for obvious reasons -the Soviets never really developed a proper intercontinental bomber fleet, let alone a supersonic intercontinental bomber fleet, and the ICBM and SAM kind of made bombers expensive and irrelevant anyway in comparison. The last US designed interceptor ... arguably the A-5 Vigilante[1] (otherwise the F106 Delta Dagger[2]), and arguably pretty equivalent to the Avro Arrow. The F108 Rapier[3] concept was also interesting; many of its guts ended up in later planes like the Vigilante or SR-71. It's amusing that the Soviets kept development of the interceptor for their PVO-Strany; coming up with very impressive aircraft which have no equivalence class in the West. Anyway too bad Canadian aerospace didn't continue, but had they developed the thing, it wouldn't have been very useful. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_A-5_Vigilante https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_A-5_Vigilante [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convair_F-106_Delta_Dart https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convair_F-106_Delta_Dart [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_XF-108_Rapier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_XF-108_Rapier
- jcun4128 6y agoThe Dart showing that tapered area rule bottle body
- ashtonkem 6y agoThe biggest contribution by interceptors was arguably the MiG 25 which was badly misinterpreted by western analysts, prompting the creation of the F-15 to counter the perceived threat.
- DuskStar 6y agoWouldn't the last US interceptor be the YF-12? Even if it was cancelled, it at least made it through flight and missile testing... (The YF-12 took the missile and radar developed for the XF-108 and stuck it into the CIA's new recon plane, the A-12, which worked well enough for the USAF to ask for a production run) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_YF-12 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_YF-12
- aerostable_slug 6y agoSomething I'm not seeing a lot of mention of was the fact that the Canadian aerospace program was absolutely riddled with Soviet spies. I don't have references in front of me unfortunately, but if you choose to believe me, a good amount of the American resistance to the Arrow program had to do with direct technology transfer to the Soviet Union via their thorough penetration of the Canadian aerospace program. The Arrow represented a conduit of American aerospace knowledge directly to the Soviets, and had to be stopped.
- stevofolife 6y agoSource please
- aerostable_slug 6y agoBut until then his assignment was to become Soboloff so convincingly that nobody would ever suspect he was a Soviet spy. Eventually, he was given responsibility for managing five recruited agents, including a Communist Party of Canada member from Toronto who worked for the company developing the Avro Arrow and provided its engineering schematics to the KGB. https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/the-spy-named-gideon-book-tells-story-of-russian-illegal-sent-to-canada-and-betrayed https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/the-spy-named-gideon-bo... That said, as noted I don't have references I can share for what I learned. Believe it or not.
- mzakharo1 6y agoHow about Canada funding Geoffrey Hinton's research in machine learning. https://www.thestar.com/news/world/2015/04/17/how-a-toronto-professors-research-revolutionized-artificial-intelligence.html https://www.thestar.com/news/world/2015/04/17/how-a-toronto-... Arguably, one of the most improtant breakthroughs of recent history, funded by Canadian citizens/taxes. This has much bigger social/economic impact, especially since we can outsource the job of overspending on military to our neighbours, and attempt to build a more socially just society on money saved.
- Lio 6y agoThis story reminds me of the British space programme which Tony Benn cancelled because he couldn’t see the point of it. ...that was just before people started launching communications satellites.
- rkagerer 6y ago...a lot of the people who made the critical decisions in the Apollo-era were Canadian. Was it easier for non US citizens to work in Aerospace in those days? e.g. I hear people gripe SpaceX can't hire internationally.