24 ms·
Is GitHub a hug part of what ICE ... does? Personally I wouldn't want to work for a company actually detaining people, but call me terrible but I'm not sure I'
by duxup 6y ago
Is GitHub a hug part of what ICE ... does?
Personally I wouldn't want to work for a company actually detaining people, but call me terrible but I'm not sure I'd feel the same about letting them pay to host some code...
- Fellshard 6y agoThere's a big strain of consequentialism running through the modern left - no neutral service is held as neutral if it permits the 'wrong' customers.
- vkou 6y agoHow does this square with people being angry at banks working with drug cartels, or at a Chinese cellphone manufacturer doing business in Iran? There are, in fact 'wrong customers' for the American right. It's just that their list of 'wrong customers' is different from that of the left.
- karpierz 6y agoSuppose that: 1. You provide tools to a group. 2. You believe (in a informed way) that the group intends to act immorally. 3. Your tools will make the group more effective at acting immorally. Do you have any responsibility for what happens?
- umvi 6y agoSuppose that I'm highly religious: 1. I make tools (wedding planning software) 2. I believe (in an informed way) that a group intends to act immorally (use my tools to plan a gay wedding) 3. My tools will make the group more effective at acting immorally Do I have any responsibility for what happens? Or (alternatively): 1. I make tools (highly specialized chemicals) 2. I believe (in an informed way) that a group intends to act immorally (use my chemicals to improve abortions) 3. My tools will make the group more effective at acting immorally Do I have any responsibility for what happens? ===== IMO, it's better not to attempt to be morality police. Focus on making great tools.
- joshuamorton 6y agoLot's of people seem to think so. Masterpiece Cake shop was a supreme court decision around, essentially, that question, that upheld the right for the private entity to discriminate. So yes I think everyone would agree you have some responsibility (otherwise no one would care about the outcome of the case, why request the right to discriminate if you don't feel that you have any responsibility for the resulting acts?)
- Fellshard 6y agoIt was more specific than that: a cake shop participates directly in the creative effort with the client in the way a software service provider does not.
- rhacker 6y agoIf the client is large enough, it does. Same as with a cake shop. Someone buying a slice of cake doesn't participate as someone asking for the design of a cake at a much higher cost.
- joshuamorton 6y agoSoftware service providers certainly do implement features requested directly by clients.
- Fellshard 6y agoFeatures, yes. Are those features directly connected to those clients' work, or is it a more general feature that has to do with the execution of the service? I will agree that it's dubious that that nuance is reflected in the rulings on the Masterpiece case. I'm trying to follow the same lines set there, though, in my argumentation.
- joshuamorton 6y ago> Are those features directly connected to those clients' work How can they not be?
- oh_sigh 6y agoIf you do have that responsibility, then a huge swath of open source developers in the world are guilty of abetting pedophiles, rapists, and terrorists.
- karpierz 6y agoDo these open source developers: A) Have a means of identifying which of their users are pedophiles, rapists, and terrorists? B) Have a means of selectively denying people access to the tools? C) Have a means of determining which of these users would using their tools to rape, produce child porn, and enact terrorism? If so, then yes, I would say they're guilty.
- oh_sigh 6y agoWell, in the past open source developers have attempted to put morality clauses into their licenses(ie You may not use this software in the development of nuclear weapons), but it was determined by the open source overlords that if a license puts a restriction on a specific usage, it is no longer Open Source. So everyone who chooses to license their software as open source is making a choice that intentionally limits their own ability to prevent others from using the licensed software legally. So no, open source software developers don't have the choice to restrict certain groups from using it - but that is because it was a choice they themselves made on how to license the software. Isn't that the ultimate hand washing?
- cmdshiftf4 6y ago"Here's our service, use it if you'd like, just don't do anything illegal on/with it" is a line that I'm almost positive the group you're referring to would deem to be "fascist" at this point in time.
- netsharc 6y agoIf we change the nationality of the police or immigration force (let's pick.. China), I feel like even people on the "right" will have the opinion that it's wrong to work with them...
- andromeduck 6y agoYeah collectivist and consequentialist views are not without merrit but without a very high threshold things quickly becoming unworkable. There needs to be a balance.
- krrrh 6y agoThere is also a huge generational split between those on the left holding liberal values, and the new progressive left, which has been demonstrated by the recent crackups at media organs like the New York Times (who saw it in their mandate to publish an op-Ed by Hitler in 1941, but the publishing of a sitting senator (Tom Cotton) resulted in a staff revolt and cost the opinion editor his job).[1] Anyone who was around when the OSI set out a basic definition of minimal requirements for open source licenses will remember that there were some arguments about whether a license could restrict use based on fields of endeavour. The idea that it couldn’t is aligned with universalist civil libertarian principles, and epistemological humility. > 6. No Discrimination Against Fields of Endeavor > The license must not restrict anyone from making use of the program in a specific field of endeavor. For example, it may not restrict the program from being used in a business, or from being used for genetic research.[2] The principles of open source are still very strong, and somehow more obvious than free speech or due process. The network effects could make it impossible for any significant change, but I expect we’ll soon see attempts at licenses that are otherwise free, but attempt to restrict use by certain domestic enemies of the maintainers. [1] Matt Taibbi - https://taibbi.substack.com/p/the-news-media-is-destroying-itself https://taibbi.substack.com/p/the-news-media-is-destroying-i... [2] OSI - https://opensource.org/osd-annotated https://opensource.org/osd-annotated
- flamble 6y agoNo reasonable conception of ethics is anything but consequentialist. Do you intend the word as a criticism? Do you have some alternate, deontological, view?
- johncena33 6y agoThis is a genuine question. I want to immigrate to USA, but currently there is no easy way to immigrate to USA. On the contrary Canada has a fair immigration system that allowed me to stay, work and eventually be citizen. Why don't people push for a fair immigration system in USA instead of abolishing ICE? What exactly am I missing here?
- duxup 6y agoPushing for legislative and political changes would very much be the right path to go. As far as ICE goes I think people are understandably shocked by ICE's actions that have been extraordinarily cruel under the current administration, so ICE gets a lot of attention.
- Fellshard 6y agoYears and years of messy and disingenuous arguments, with a lot of straw men involved, so politicians can generate a continual moral high ground.
- protomyth 6y agoBecause there is a rather large disagreement on what "fair immigration" looks like, plus, if I'm being cynical, its an amazing issue to raise money on. These days, neither party is all that stable. There are many voices trying to redefine both and the reasonable people in the middle are not being listened to. I honestly don't know the final resolution.
- ls612 6y agoFunny enough many on the right in the US want to change the US immigration rules to be more like Canada or Australia’s rules, ie admission is based on work and skills criteria more so than family ones. The left leaning people oppose this because of how it would de facto change the ethnic makeup of immigrants.
- coolreader18 6y agoICE only was founded after 9/11, and given that in their short history they've caused so much suffering, it's not unreasonable to demand that the agency be shut down.
- protomyth 6y agoConsidering they are the agency also tasked with stopping modern versions of slavery (human trafficking), it does make for some moral arguments.
- diN0bot 6y agoMaybe it's a spectrum thing, and everyone has a line they don't want to cross. There are people and organizations that don't align with my beliefs, but sure, it's cool they use my tools. However, would you be ok with Hitler hosting code on your service if it contributed in some small way to genocide? That _does_ make me feel ick. Tacit support by large numbers of "not really effected" people is what made the holocaust and slavery and jim crow, etc, possible. I'm not comparing ICE to Violent White Supremacy... but it's worth staying informed and revisiting our own boundaries as the situation changes. Skin color, nationality and ethnicity are playing a huge role in how we're treating people right now, and the spectrum of human<>inhumane is getting wider and wider with tacit support :-(
- umvi 6y agoNorth Korea/China/<insert oppressive regime> uses Linux. Does that make Linus feel ick and want to take some sort of measures to prevent it? I hope not. Focus on making great tools. Don't worry about who might use them. That's someone else's job. If Craftsman starts trying to vet customers so nobody buying their hammers can use them to build KKK meeting houses, they will now be pressured to deny their tools to whomever the capricious demands of the internet mob dictate.
- dastbe 6y agoIf your government isn't willing to compromise with you but desires something from you, it's pretty straightforward that you should withhold as much as you can until they decide to compromise.
- duxup 6y ago>If your government isn't willing to compromise with you I'm not sure I see a reason that the government must compromise with a give company. If Boeing decided that ICE should behave even worse, would we cheer on ICE for compromising? I think we'd argue that the right place for that sort of thing is at the ballot box.
- dastbe 6y agoYou're conflating the end result and the means. I wouldn't cheer on any company doing that, just like I don't cheer on companies when they donate to campaigns for racists or people who vote for racists. The government also doesn't have to compromise. Maybe there's a competitor who is less particular about who they do business with or in fact thinks the cruelty is actually cool and good. gitlab is 100% neutral on who they do business with, for example.
- duxup 6y ago>I wouldn't cheer on any company doing that, You would cheer on Boeing for asking that ICE be more cruel?
- dastbe 6y agoYou said > If Boeing decided that ICE should behave even worse, would we cheer on ICE for compromising? I said > I wouldn't cheer on any company doing that, emphasis on the "n't" in "wouldn't". And to be specific, I would not (<- that not is load bearing) cheer for Boeing advocating for more cruelty, nor would I cheer on the government for acquiescing. If you want to compel private companies to do work for an unprotected class like a federal law enforcement agency, then yes at that point you should probably go and vote to make sure that happens.
- iphone_elegance 6y agoit gets really weird microsoft/github now owns npm, I don't think core service providers should be able to make discriminate based on politics it makes for a very slippery slope
- e12e 6y agoWell, there's the people putting people in camps, the people tattooing numbers on those folks' arms, and the people developing the software and hardware to keep track of those people. Now this isn't quite the IBM nazi connection - but the government snatching up people, then paying private corporations to intern them, in turn apparently using them for forced labour... Is pretty bad. I'd be surprised if software isn't essential to keeping the machine going - and I'd not hesitated to call taking money for tooling "being a collaborator". https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/coronavirus-ice-detention-soap/ https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/coronavirus-ice-d...