11 ms·
Temporary National Emergency Library to close 2 weeks early
- shervinafshar 6y agoAlso discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23485182 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23485182
- jMyles 6y agoFiguring out how to move projects like IA to a configuration where they are beyond the reach of the state, but still universally accessible, is one of the most important open issues of the internet today.
- ghaff 6y agoWhich also means they would be beyond the protection of a state and its laws. That doesn't strike me as an obviously preferable situation. Nothing that needs to be accessed via a network and requires human interaction is really truly beyond the reach of nation states. Just because you're on an offshore platform in the North Sea [1] doesn't mean you're not exposed to having your network and supply lines cut off at a minimum., [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principality_of_Sealand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principality_of_Sealand
- aspenmayer 6y agoI don’t follow. Sites on IPFS are still copyrightable. They aren’t mutually exclusive concepts legally.
- pkaye 6y ago> The Archive has data centers in three Californian cities: San Francisco, Redwood City, and Richmond. To prevent losing the data in case of e.g. a natural disaster, the Archive attempts to create copies of (parts of) the collection at more distant locations, currently including the Bibliotheca Alexandrina[notes 5] in Egypt and a facility in Amsterdam.[8] The Archive is a member of the International Internet Preservation Consortium[9] and was officially designated as a library by the state of California in 2007.[notes 6] Maybe start with more funding to have copies in more countries.
- geofft 6y agoSince we'd be moving from legal protection to technical protection, would we also figure out some technical means whereby this would be accessible by Internet Archive only? Or would all of us be given a way to publish anything we want in a way that makes it accessible to the whole world but no government can impede? Would that then include sealed court records, intimate photos, performance reviews, credit card numbers, and so forth?
- generationP 6y agoWe have such havens already, and if the choice is between the Internet Archive plus everyone's naked pics or none of the two, I'd still vote for the former.
- marcinzm 6y agoPresumably you're not part of any group that could be abused, targeted or traumatized by such a system. For example, underage rape victims who have videos of their rape forever available to any pervert online. Along with their contact info since nothing helps with trauma like continual harassment about it. That, btw, was a true example from my social media feeds although the site in question was pornhub so there was some recourse.
- geofft 6y agoAnd I'd vote for the latter - but since we're talking about moving things beyond the reach of any government, it's not like I'm actually able to vote on it, am I?
- mulmen 6y ago“What you post on the web lasts forever” is a warning, not a promise.
- mellosouls 6y agoNot necessarily - an alternative approach is that "public service" projects like IA are supported by the state - but this will only happen when they are scrupulous with respect to the law. This happens already in the US and other countries with various digital preservation initiatives that have legal mandates for their missions.
- userbinator 6y agoSciHub/LibGen might be a good start. (...which, if this announcement is any indication, should probably be mirroring the IA if they haven't already done so. I believe they used to avoid that, under the assumption that the IA would always be accessible, but maybe not now.)
- fsflover 6y agoI2P can be the solution here. It has been working for years, although slow by design.
- 12xo 6y agoLawyers...
- geofft 6y ago> We moved up our schedule because, last Monday, four commercial publishers chose to sue Internet Archive during a global pandemic. Did this come as a surprise? Did Internet Archive not expect publishers to sue? The Archive launched the emergency library during a global pandemic. Lots of people, myself included, said that this was a risky move because they would obviously get sued and it would put not only the Archive but the existing idea of Controlled Digital Lending - which hasn't been clearly established as legal in caselaw - at risk. They're trying to imply that the publishers are somehow bad people for suing in a pandemic, and sure, the publishers may very well be bad people in general, but IA launched this effort on the grounds that, more or less, the law doesn't matter any more in a pandemic. > However, this lawsuit is not just about the temporary National Emergency Library. The complaint attacks the concept of any library owning and lending digital books, challenging the very idea of what a library is in the digital world. That's precisely why we said they shouldn't have done this. Controlled Digital Lending matches the existing operations of a physical library - there is one paid physical copy per loaned title. Publishers and authors alike like physical libraries because when more people check out books from libraries, more copies get purchased. It stands to reason that they shouldn't mind digital libraries that follow the same principle. Internet Archive said, the same legal analysis that makes Controlled Digital Lending permissible also makes uncontrolled lending permissible when we decide the world needs it. We can give people unlimited electronic copies of books for one physical copy. The more people who read our books, the fewer purchases happen. That challenges the very idea of what a library is in the digital world - it breaks the balance that has historically governed how physical libraries work. If I go to my local library and the librarian says "Actually don't bother checking this out, I'll just photocopy the whole book for you and you can keep it," I'm not sure I'd call that a library. It's a useful service for me, of course, at least provided I figure out some way to make sure that the people who write the books I want to read keep getting paid, but it's now something entirely different from a library.
- nordsieck 6y ago> Publishers and authors alike like physical libraries because when more people check out books from libraries, more copies get purchased. I don't think they like libraries per se, they've just made peace with the first sale doctrine. On the upside, libraries are a stable source of demand for new books. On the downside, libraries' collection are generally used more intensely than private collections - each book in a library displaces more than one private sale. > It stands to reason that they shouldn't mind digital libraries that follow the same principle. Maybe. I don't think the first sale doctrine really covers Controlled Digital Lending, so I guess we'll see how things pan out in court.
- DecoPerson 6y agoThe Internet Archive is so incredibly important. There’s a lot of different views about the purpose of life or lack thereof, but for all except a few beliefs, having access to past writings is very important. Humanity is only at the very beginning of its existence. The success or failure of projects like the Internet Archive will drastically change our future. If you think the loss of the Internet Archive won’t significantly current day activities, you’re wrong. Besides the fact that the IA holds the only easily accessible copies of many websites from the 90s and early 2000s, there is the “my legacy” factor. Do you think people would have commissioned statues of themselves if they knew they were going to be vandalized and torn down in a protest 100 years later? Even though we may try to stop our egos affecting our decisions, they still play a huge role. Mathematicians don’t just write papers to further the field, they also do it to gain notoriety and leave a legacy. I know that if I write a blog post, it will be unavailable from its original source within 20 years. But that’s OK! The Internet Archive will store a copy and someone many generations from now will be able to read my humble writings. Oh... but the IA was shut down because its leadership decided to be philanthropic during a period of human history that lacked freedom of information. I’m going for a walk instead. Perhaps the “my legacy” effect has only a marginal influence on how many authors decide to put pen to paper, but it’s still something. It’s hard to measure, so if it’s plausible that it could be significant, we should act appropriately.
- jawns 6y ago> the IA was shut down because its leadership decided to be philanthropic during a period of human history that lacked freedom of information Philanthropic by massively infringing on copyright. Giving away something you own and have a right to give away is one thing. But critics of the emergency library allege that because the IA doesn't own the copyright to these books, they don't get to make and lend unlimited copies. Under the first sale doctrine, they can only lend out as many copies as they own.
- ghaff 6y ago>Under the first sale doctrine, they can only lend out as many copies as they own. TBH, even that is not established as a point of law (if the lending is digital copies of physical books) but it seems a reasonable position and publishers/authors weren't pushing on it.
- andrewmunsell 6y agoAre there any technologies today that would enable a distributed backup of IA? Something like BitTorrent, but where I can specify I want to host XXX GB of data, and all the nodes in the swarm would provide a redundant, distributed backup in aggregate? I realize things like IPFS exist, but as far as I'm aware those require manual file pinning. I want to just donate storage and bandwidth to back the files up, not have to specify which ones to back up.
- jmeyer2k 6y agoIPFS works based on files visited. I wonder if you could write a script that crawls randomly until it hits a certain threshold stored...
- andrewmunsell 6y agoJust a cursory look at the CLI, it looks like you have the ability to get stats on each block (including size, https://docs.ipfs.io/reference/cli/#ipfs-block-stat https://docs.ipfs.io/reference/cli/#ipfs-block-stat), and pin them (https://docs.ipfs.io/how-to/pin-files/#three-kinds-of-pins https://docs.ipfs.io/how-to/pin-files/#three-kinds-of-pins). I'm betting someone could create an open source project to traverse the Merkel tree, choose random blocks, and pin them... It could be made smarter by also checking the number of peers per block and prioritize the least pinned blocks. Edit: And a related discussion I found: https://www.reddit.com/r/ipfs/comments/b4he2m/idea_partialselective_pinning/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ipfs/comments/b4he2m/idea_partialse...
- ashleysmithgpu 6y agoOn a related note (Yes crypto, sorry) Filecoin is encouraging people to help backup certain large data sets: https://filecoin.io/blog/intro-filecoin-discover/ https://filecoin.io/blog/intro-filecoin-discover/
- gpm 6y agoIf you're donating storage and bandwidth to backup "files" up without specifying which ones, you're going to be backing up random peoples personal encrypted backups which are useless to anyone who doesn't have the key. In the end you need a decision layer to decide what to back up that decides what based on some standard of what's good for society. But maybe you don't need to centralize the storage, I could imagine a distributed IA which mostly piggybacks on other people's storage.
- linuxhansl 6y agoIs it just me or are DRM controlled ebooks a complete scam?! Consider: 1. Ebooks go through great length to make the information behave like a physical book. 2. Libraries have to buy as many licenses as they can plan to lend our concurrently 3. Licenses will even expire after a bit, because that's what real book do, they wear of. So far so good (if your goal is to simulate real books). But now: 1. Wanna give your ebook to a friend? nada 2. Wanna lend your ebook to a friend? nada 3. Wanna use the book after companies decide to disable their license servers? nada 4. Imagine a few hundred years from now. We can still look at old books because they exist and their content is not controlled. That would not be possible. Of course it is always possible to remove the DRM protection, but that is illegal. We've been duped. Edit: Layout.
- m4rtink 6y agoYeah, the idea of enforcing such artificial limitations on an digital book are disgusting not to mention dangerous, as these can very easuly be missused to surpress undesired works.
- fsflover 6y agohttps://www.defectivebydesign.org/guide https://www.defectivebydesign.org/guide
- ketzu 6y agoThis is not limited to ebooks, it is present in all modern digital distribution, especially in software.
- rblatz 6y agoThe internet archive was an interesting experiment, too bad they made such a reckless move. Hopefully they don’t get shutdown, but they risked their very existence on this silly move.
- pawelk 6y agoI don't think it was silly, but it was probably too rushed. As I said when it was announced, there is a valid, IMO, line of reasoning: as a digital library you can lend one digital copy per one physical book you have in your inventory. Before the lock down people could choose if they want to go get a physical copy or a digital one, but now they don't have a choice: their local library is closed and there are only so many options to borrow digital. This is where IA steps in and says: we will act as a proxy between you, and the physical copy of the book that is locked in the library you lost access to. When I say it was rushed I mean they could have implemented a system where any closed library would be able to submit their physical book inventory asking IA to act as a proxy, extending the number of digital copies backed 1:1 by physical ones. But instead of that Interned Archive decided that the locked down supply is effectively limitless, so let's just lend as many as people demand.
- rblatz 6y agoMassive public copyright infringement was silly, and it put their whole very important operation at risk. If they at least went through the motions, and signed up the libraries like in your example that’s at least defensible in court.
- awtawtwat3aw 6y agoi love the archive for what the have done, but they seem to think laws don't apply to them because they are a non-profit and helping spread information, etc. that's fine and dandy, but they still have to play by the rules. you can see people like "hopfscotch6" and "differentguy" in this thread saying people should basically be giving things away, because that's the right thing to do. not sure how anyone can support that. commies who think life will be unicorns and candy if everyone gets everything they want for free. lmao. can't wait til we purge these radicals.
- efiecho 6y agoA big part of the books in NEL are out of print and no electronic versions are available elsewhere, and never will, so had it not been for Internet Archive, it would have been impossible to read these books and many of them had been lost forever. If it's impossible to buy the book, why is NEL a problem for the publishers? Would they rather have that no one ever read the book again?
- arkades 6y agoBecause plenty of them aren't out of print. Publishers may or may not give a shit if you put forward a book in a fashion that does not impact them monetarily. They give a shit if you do. They definitely don't care what the ratio between the two is; they care that the latter is non-zero.
- peterburkimsher 6y agoWhat's the best way to help? Is it better to donate to Archive.org, or the EFF? I know that Brewster Kahle is involved in both, and I imagine that the defence team will be staffed by EFF lawyers. I think both the Internet Archive and EFF are good causes, I just want to know which way will cause less paperwork for them to receive a donation.
- techntoke 6y agoIf companies, including movie companies, don't want their content getting out for free then don't mass market it. Stop advertising it. Don't sell it in every retail store in America and put out displays with the characters. Don't create billboards. Otherwise these companies are trying to psychologically manipulate you and your kids and pay for something before seeing it usually with negative messages about how alcohol, affairs and violence will somehow make your life better and more exciting.
- wideawake 6y agoOf all the times for this to be happening. Now is not the time for this.
- Aeolun 6y agoI think it’s sad that it comes to this. It’s not as if they were distributing perpetual licenses to these books, and anyone getting a book off the internet archive almost certainly wouldn’t have bought the book anyway. Large publishers are the worst. And the writers aiming to profit off off the fact people cannot go to a normal library can be dumped in the same bucket. I’d like to see some numbers from a writer that actually lost income due to this, and maybe I’ll reconsider. As it is, I just see them screaming bloody murder over something that’s completely theoretical.
- iJohnDoe 6y agoThis might be an unpopular opinion, but here goes anyways. I know there are some on HN that share this unpopular opinion. The IA treated this situation and decision like they’ve treated all their decisions. They archive data without permission. They share this archived data without permission. They have no official instructions on how to remove data from their archive. There are some flimsy instructions about robot rules, but it’s not clear if they work. Not everyone agrees to have their old forum posts, yahoo posts and other info from the early days of the Internet still available in an archive that’s searchable by the government, employers, etc.
- a1369209993 6y agoYes, that's what a library is. We don't give book-burners a pass just because they pressured the author into agreeing with them. Why should we make a exception just because it's a website being destroyed rather than a book?
- walterbell 6y agoIf the "library" division of Internet Archive is engaging in book-related activity that puts the 501c3 non-profit donation-funded web and public domain ARCHIVE at risk, perhaps IA should be legally separated into two organizations. There is no reason for humanity's digital web of Alexandria to be burned for a dispute with book publishers who have no legal claim on the contents of the Wayback machine. The many people who donated to Internet Archive were doing so primarily to preserve materials that were unavailable elsewhere, e.g. lost websites. They were not primarily donating money to enable lending of currently published books, which are widely available via multiple channels.
- jl2718 6y agoI’m inclined to admit the possibility that the library model doesn’t work in the electronic world, and maybe it’s a bad idea. Perhaps money for community spaces should not be used to pay for electrons.