4 ms·
Safari has been this way since 2014. I've never seen any pushback on Apple doing it over the past six years. It's genuinely a benefit for the vast, vast majori
by crazygringo 6y ago
Safari has been this way since 2014. I've never seen any pushback on Apple doing it over the past six years.
It's genuinely a benefit for the vast, vast majority of users, where the only important piece of information really is the domain name, to check which site you're actually on. And for more info, you can just click. Copying the URL becomes no more difficult.
The URL path beyond the domain is as useful to most people as an IP address, in other words not at all -- it's just noise. And displaying noise is bad UX. Pretty much only website developers and administrators and SEO people care about the full URL. Granted, there are a lot of those people here on HN, so I understand the pushback, but we're not most users.
But at the end of the day, I don't understand why people seem totally fine with Safari doing this, but not Google?
- karmakaze 6y agoThe people who use Safari is exactly the demographic that this change targets. Chrome users includes most developers who are the ones to complain.
- amerine 6y agoI’m a developer. I use safari/WebKit for 95% of my browsing. You can enable the full address among a bunch of other excellent developer settings and move on with life with a browser that works great.
- soared 6y agoDevelopers are <1% of users - anything outside of dev tools is not changed with them in mind.
- chooseaname 6y agoIf I recall there was some grumbling, but Apple being Apple, they do what they want.
- on_and_off 6y agoAs long as you see the full url when you hover/click on the bar, I am all for it as well. If find some of reactions on this ridiculously hyperbolic "biggest attack on the web in years" ? seriously ? I get it, Google is a gigantic monster that does not necessarily act in its users best interests, but that does not mean we need to bring the pitchfork each time they launch an app update.
- dhms 6y agoOn that note, I noticed recently that Google search result links (on Firefox?) get rewritten. That is, you see the actual page URL when you hover over the link, but it's changed to their own redirect URL as soon as you click it. I'm sure they've always been tracking these search result clicks, but I think this is a somewhat new behavior, and I find it highly deceiving.
- propogandist 6y agoChrome sends back your click 'behind the scenes', whereas Firefox does not, so Google forces you to click through their link so they can track your activity (and if you hit the back button, you also jump through their redirect) Ublock Origin can block this behavior. Here's a posting with links to more resources on hyperlink-auditig https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/Dashboard:-Settings#disable-hyperlink-auditing https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/Dashboard:-Settings#d...
- hobofan 6y agoIf recent history with AMP has shown anything, it is that yes, we need to bring our pitchforks every time. And also precisely because of AMP, this might be a very dangerous step towards blurring the lines between original and AMP pages.
- divbzero 6y agoI’m in favor of full URL, but frankly didn’t notice until just now that I haven’t enabled Safari’s Show full website address preference.
- tmpz22 6y agoBut why can't this be a toggle or user setting like in Safari? Why is it a 1-true-google-way of doing things when clearly there are users who want to keep it (even if its just web developers)?
- crazygringo 6y agoHow do you know it won't be a toggle? Right now it is a setting to enable in Chrome. What makes you think that once it becomes default, the switch won't remain to be able to turn it off? Chrome is built by developers. Presumably, they pay attention to what developers need from it. Which is why their debugging tools overall are so amazing. Perhaps you should withold criticism of what you assume they'll do until they, you know, actually do it.
- feanaro 6y agoI strongly disagree. Ordinary users I interact with either understand the basic concept of the URL or understand it after an initial explanation. It becomes empowering to them in ways I often do not anticipate.