7 ms·
I don't work for Amazon, but a similarly giant tech company, and I idiotically signed the non-compete because I was excited to work for one of the brand-name co
by tombert 6y ago
I don't work for Amazon, but a similarly giant tech company, and I idiotically signed the non-compete because I was excited to work for one of the brand-name companies.
The non-compete specifically says that I am not allowed to open source any software, and until very recently, I wasn't allowed to even open a Github issue. The wording specifically says that they own anything I conceive of while working for them.
I shouldn't have signed it, I'm always working on personal projects and it's kind of depressing that I only realistically have the option to either donate my project to my corporation so that, at best, they own all rights to it and probably never open source it, OR not-release anything so that I have plausible deniability if/when I quit.
- rhn_mk1 6y agoWhat makes you stay there?
- tombert 6y agoRight now I'm basically just waiting for some more stock to vest. After that I'll probably try and find a job where their non-compete isn't insane.
- jrockway 6y agoWhich company is this?
- tombert 6y agoActually mentioning that publicly is against the policy. I can tell you via email if you promise not to post it publicly. (Address in profile)
- jrockway 6y agoNah, if you can get in trouble I don't want to know.
- wccrawford 6y agoThat's nice of you, and nice of the parent for not taking you up on it, but it could have been someone from the company asking you that.
- tombert 6y agoThat's a valid point; didn't even consider the possibility of a trap. Thanks for the warning for the future!
- sukilot 6y agoIt's Jonathan Rockway. He's not an Apple spy.
- riquito 6y agoIs it "mentioning it publicly" if it's a private conversation? Or is it meant to be "don't tell anyone"?
- tombert 6y agoPrivate conversations are fine, they just typically don't like you posting about it.
- bonzini 6y agoGoogle and LinkedIn are your friends.
- rabidrat 6y agoOracle has this clause. It's the main reason I chose not to work there.
- geerlingguy 6y agoIt seems like the majority of the top 50 or so tech companies do.
- bootloop 6y agoApple
- miken123 6y ago> The wording specifically says that they own anything I conceive of while working for them. That's quite normal, at least under Dutch labour law. It prevents IP discussions if an employee does anything outside of the 9-5 working hours, or anything they were not directly instructed to by their manager. Of course there can be exceptions, e.g., we exempt open source software by default, and are open for any discussions on other side projects the employee may have. But the concept that all your programming work belongs to the company is not that strange. Also note that this is not a non-compete, but simply an IP clause.
- eropple 6y ago"Not unusual" and "not cretinous" are not the same thing.
- miken123 6y agoI don't see the problem with it. Think of this scenario from the perspective of an employer: - You hire someone and they create something and use it as part of your software. - They leave. - Then they sue you because they say you are using their software that they created in their spare time. Or any of the other 999 IP disputes that can arise from not being very clear about who owns the IP of things your employees create.
- sidlls 6y agoThis is specifically in the context of programming work done outside of the work for the company. These onerous clauses attempt to lay claim to that work. For example, if a I work at Widgetron writing Widget APIs this clause might be used by Widgetron to lay claim to, say, a game engine I’m writing at home during the evening.
- syshum 6y agoI see a problem with it, Think of this scenario I work as a programmer writing a boring LOB application, in may spare time I write sci-fi fiction stories the company falls on hard times, cuts my pay but I happen to submit one of my books to a publisher, it becomes a HUGE success and now the company claims to own the right to that book (the money they need to save the company) because they own everything that comes from my mind under these unethical and immoral provisions
- dbuder 6y ago>>not-release anything so that I have plausible deniability if/when I quit. This, obviously. You're basically supposed to.
- 762236 6y agoIt's hard to imagine moving away from California and its moonlighting law. With it, I own everything I conceive of and work on during my own time, as long as it doesn't conflict with what I do at work. I'd imagine that if you relocated here (your company probably has an office in Silicon Valley), many of your restrictions would be lifted.
- saagarjha 6y agoI worked for a large company in California and the law prevented me from doing just about anything because it could be plausibly construed as conflicting with the company's business.
- gnopgnip 6y agoThe law is much more favorable to employees, and the legal definition of conflict of interest is more narrow than the company would like you to believe.
- saagarjha 6y agoOh, I'm sure it is. The problem is that they could sue me anyways.
- pas 6y agoThat can happen any time anyway. But they would have to show damages. And even though you'd be on the hook for legal fees - at least initially, defending such a simple civil suit isn't that big of a deal financially. Or ... just do open source under an alias.
- codemac 6y agoAgreed, they'hen I looked into something similar I found that while companies will fight tooth and nail to not sign away rights to a specific idea/effort, the law is very much on the employee's side as long as you don't use corporate equipment to do it.
- 6y ago
- _puk 6y agoI had a similar one that claimed all IP to the full extent of the law, and anything beyond that extent, they reserved the right of first refusal to purchase it if sold. Of course, it also required arbitration of anything around that area. They seemed surprised when I brought it up as onerous! Edit: This was in the UK where these seem to be becoming the norm.
- rlpb 6y ago> They seemed surprised when I brought it up as onerous! Careful on that one. A good negotiator will always want you to think that what you want in your favour is surprising, onerous and that nobody has asked for that before.
- fishywang 6y agoThe open source part you described is different from non-compete, and is way more common (and makes more sense). https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2016/12/09/developers-side-projects/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2016/12/09/developers-side-pr... offers a good explanation why this is needed from employer's point of view. (disclaimer: I linked that article mainly for the explanation part. I don't necessarily agree with all its advises) I don't know which giant tech company is your employer. But at least Google has a very streamlined internal process you can apply for to let Google release the copyright of your side project to you. (disclaimer: I worked for Google, and in particular worked somewhat close with the people reviewing those cases for a few years)
- tombert 6y agoI don't work for Google, and sadly, while there is a process for getting approval to open-source something, it involves a lot of emails and waiting. I have been waiting since December to submit contributions to the TLA+ model checker.
- saagarjha 6y agoSounds very familiar ;) Processes like these make it very, very difficult for employees to work on open source; at most they might have approval for one or two projects that are directly used by the company.
- fishywang 6y agoI do agree that your employer's clause are far more restrictive than the common ones seen around the valley and unnecessary.
- ghaff 6y agoIt seems a lot of people hear about non-competes being not generally enforceable in California and assume that means it's a nirvana with respect to personal IP/moonlighting/etc. Or even that it means there are never non-competes that will cause a potential employer to walk away, enforceable or not. Lots of California-based companies have strict policies about ownership of projects that you do on your own time. And there are certainly companies outside of California that don't have non-competes and which have liberal policies about open source contributions.
- Keverw 6y agoI heard of this stuff before, sounds insane companies try to claim everything you make as their own even if working on it at home using your own funds and equipment. As much I don't like the politics of California, I feel like this is something they got right. Wonder if maybe this is why some companies are expanding in other places like Austin, Texas or Salt Lake City? Like for example Apple is going to the largest employer in Austin, yet Texas doesn't offer as many employment protections... Maybe as things grow, Texas and other states will look into the issue more... I do think in general tech spreading throughout the country instead of being centralized in California is a pro though.