3 ms·
It would certainly be beneficial if we could reduce our needs for human teachers by means of a tool like Khan Academy. As a nation, we spend more one education
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
It would certainly be beneficial if we could reduce our needs for human teachers by means of a tool like Khan Academy.
As a nation, we spend more one education than the military ($972B as of 2007 according to wikipedia, vs about $725B for the military including wars). A 1% increase in efficiency would save a little less than $10 billion, and a 16% increase in efficiency (using 2007 numbers) would be sufficient to balance the federal budget deficit [1].
If the Khan Academy is not striving to reduce our need for human teachers, we should create an organization that will.
[1] Edit: I should note that education is paid for primarily by the state and local governments, so it wouldn't be directly possible to reduce the federal budget by such savings. I was solely trying to make an order of magnitude comparison.
- joebadmo 16y ago"As a nation, we spend more one education than the military..." You say that as if it's a bad thing. I spent four years in the military and can tell you that there's a lot of waste there. Your last sentence could very easily be applied to the military, or at least to military personnel. I think a better way to think about teachers might be as force multipliers. There are parts of teaching that can be relegated to technology, but there are other (arguably more important) parts that probably can't or won't be for a long time, and KA seems like a great way to free up those resources for uses that are most effective.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI didn't mean to suggest it's bad that education is bigger than the military, I was merely trying to describe the scale of our spending. The military is a popular example of a a big wasteful government agency, so I thought a comparison was illustrative. I spent four years in the military and can tell you that there's a lot of waste there. Your last sentence could very easily be applied to the military, or at least to military personnel. I'd love to reduce spending in the military as well. If a manufacturer of military robots said "we aren't trying to replace soldiers", my first question would be "why not?"
- joebadmo 16y agoI guess my point is that robots/tech are good at certain things, and people are good at other things. It's great for tech to take up the things that they're good at to free up people to focus on the things that they're good at, and that's what I understood TFA to be advocating, i.e. they want to augment teachers, not replace them.
- VladRussian 16y agoin both cases you're thinking only about bottom line. Imagine it from the other end - what new opportunities would it open. How the military or educational powers (the US has benefited so far from being "super-" for both powers ) can be even more amplified, especially when other super-countries are emerging. from your post above: >and a 16% increase in efficiency (using 2007 numbers) would be sufficient to balance the federal budget deficit [1]. that means anywhere between cutting 16% of cost while maintaining the same educational result and increasing the educational result by 16% while maintaining the same cost. I'd argue that in modern world (i mean today and the next 30 years at least) increasing the educational result would be much more important than cutting the cost.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI'm focusing on cost because I don't see how a video lecture can be dramatically better than an in person one, but I can easily see how it could be just as good. This could be a failure of imagination on my part. A model I'd like to see attempted - 2 hours of lecture (video) + 1 hour of recitation (human supervised), in lieu of 3 hours of lecture+recitation by a human. Now a single human can teach 3x more classes. That's a massive reduction in costs, but I don't see how it can significantly increase educational outcomes. There is one caveat - I expect lecture quality would improve a bit. If only the best teachers record videos, then lecture quality will be better than average. By definition, human-delivered lectures can only be average.
- whatusername 16y agoFor me the killer thing about Khan's lectures is how broken down into small chunks that they are. If you don't get it -- you can watch the 10m lecture again. Not to mention you can pause/rewind, there are theoretically no distractions (like disruptive members of class), and then the point you made about lecture quality. I really like Khan's model of doing lectures/learning at home -- and using the classroom time for exercises // with the teacher (or other students) mentoring those who are stuck on a problem set.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- absconditus 16y agoThe federal portion of the education budget is quite small.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoVery true, education is paid for primarily at the state and local level. The comparison to the federal deficit was mainly for the purposes of an order of magnitude. I've edited my post to clarify this.
- steveplace 16y ago>As a nation, we spend more on education than the military That's an incredibly misleading claim. Consider this graph: http://www.johnstonsarchive.net/policy/edgraph.html http://www.johnstonsarchive.net/policy/edgraph.html So we see that funding for public k-12 is roughly the same as defense, but let's consider the funding sources. IIRC, defense spending is funded solely by the federal government, whereas public school spending is sourced from federal, state, and local-- property taxes taking a big chunk out of it. So if we compare apples to apples-- which is federal spending between the two, we see a very wide disparity. This of course is exacerbated by the military occupations currently taking place by the US gov't. I could also argue how spending in education will have a better effect on GDP relative to defense spending, but I'm a little tired of googling things. [edit] Here's a much clearer picture of the spending distribution: http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/us_education_spending_20.html http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/us_education_spending_20... Compare edu to defense and you'll see my point.
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoI don't get your point. Why does it matter where the money comes from? It all comes from us. That we spend more on education that the military is still true, right?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWhy is it misleading to look at total cost or total government cost rather than simply federal government cost? What makes the federal government special? Now, as for my numbers: 2007, $972B total, the government portion of it was $809B. If you restrict to K-12, it is indeed slightly less than the military ($493B vs $653B). Government expenditures on education are still $150B more than the military as of 2007, the year I originally cited (including higher education and "education not definable by level"). For 2009 (the last year for which full data is available), the gap between government spending on the military and education is $50B (in favor of education). Regardless of whether spending on education is better for GDP than defense spending, it would be better still to provide the same education for less money. When you spend this much money, small gains multiplied systemwide yield huge gains. A 1% increase in efficiency saves you $8.5B in gov spending and $9.7B in total spending. Or, to put it another way, every teacher we replace saves $50-150k/year directly and removes a massive unfunded liability (their pension/future health care costs) from the government balance sheet. If Khan Academy isn't ambitious enough to try to do this, hopefully someone will step up and do so.
- rayboyd 16y agoI think the last thing that needs to happen is the dehumanization of the education system. What the Khan Academy seems to demonstrate so far is that the careful application of technology in the classroom has a positive effect on young students to understand and digest information. A middle ground should be sought, it should be complementary and help drive innovation in education - but definitely not replace humans.
- ghshephard 16y agoRe: Replacing Humans Depends on what level you are talking about. There is close to zero advantage to having a lecturer explain first year calculus to 450 students. That practice should be eliminated immediately and replaced with Khan (or Khan like technology). It's embarrassing how many higher level education institutions haven't cracked that part of the puzzle. Save the budget and populate the Math Labs with (reasonably paid) Grad Students where the students are doing exercises, instead of paying (a typically horrible at presentations) mathematics professor to "Teach".
- rayboyd 16y agoAgreed. A major benefit that seems to be recurrent in the pilot schemes is the data the Khan system provides, and how that allows teachers to interact with students in a more personal and efficient maner. The net result being less kids fall behind. However that also shows the need for the human interaction.
- jasonrr 16y agoThe really misleading thing about these statistics is that the budget is not 100% teacher salaries. I am guessing, it's not even close. That means to get your 16% savings you are going to have to cut a lot more than 16% of the staff.
- tokenadult 16y agoStaff compensation (and it is an error to assume the compensation consists solely of "salaries") is in fact the major part of the expense of running any school system.