4 ms·
That's not mob rule, that's completely and absolutely how the legal US government operates. Overturning the electoral college would require a constitutional am
by dekhn 6y ago
That's not mob rule, that's completely and absolutely how the legal US government operates. Overturning the electoral college would require a constitutional amendment, which is no trivial task.
Mob rule is entirely different: it refers to rule imposed from outside the law, possibly by a large group.
Also, the "fewer votes" really only applies to the presidency, not the senate, house, or governors.
- baddox 6y ago> That's not mob rule, that's completely and absolutely how the legal US government operates. Those aren't mutually exclusive. Middle school civics class explanations of the electoral college are fine. You can understand the reasons the electoral college was created and still oppose the fact that there have been multiple recent cases where the electoral college went against the popular vote. And, not that it's particularly relevant, but I highly doubt the very people who designed the electoral college would approve of its use when it seems to routinely elect someone who lost the popular vote.
- saagarjha 6y agoOn the contrary, I think the electoral college was introduced precisely to ensure that the person who won the election was not who would win the popular vote.
- baddox 6y agoThat's certainly not the case. The electoral college was designed such that each state's legislature chooses how to attribute their electoral college votes. Many states in the first few presidential elections just had their state legislatures assign the votes. But still, I find it difficult to believe that the people who designed the electoral college would think it's okay that we held a national election, we got to see who wins the popular vote, and we still choose a different person for President.
- saagarjha 6y agoAs I understand it, many of the founding fathers explicitly feared that general populace would vote poorly and wanted people who were educated and had access to sufficient information to make a decision to do so on their behalf.
- waterhouse 6y agoI was also told the following rationale: If elections are decided entirely by popular vote, then candidates are incentivized to campaign in population centers, and have no incentive to ever visit sparsely populated states. (Like, bringing your margin from 70% to 85% of 4 million people is worth more than going from 0% to 100% of 400k people.)
- dlp211 6y agoExcept it's simply not true. Instead candidates focus on a set of fairly high-population swing states, Michigan, Wisconsin, Florida, Virginia, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania.
- baddox 6y agoThat only makes sense if you believe that land area is the appropriate unit to attempt to equalize political influence over, rather than people. If you think the people are who should have political influence in a democracy, rather than units of land, then it should be desirable that politicians campaign to as many people as they reasonably can.
- waterhouse 6y agoIt's not equalizing political influence between states (that is, bringing them into equality), just bringing them somewhat away from inequality. (Also, states don't have equal land area, it's more like political districts.) The electoral college gives votes as a linear combination of "per political district" and "per people", with 435/538 = 80.8% being "per people". Also, I guess it's the fact of "winner takes all within a state" that disincentivizes candidates from simply drumming up more support within states they've already won, more so than the distribution of votes per state.
- dekhn 6y agoOh, I'm personally against the electoral college (have been since I was a kid). However, it's still not mob rule, by the virtue of the fact that mob rule is necessarily non-legal, while the electoral college is the essence of "legal". And the people who set up electoral college (the authors of the constitution) explicitly added a mechanism to change the system via amendments (it's just very hard to get one passed). Clearly, the college was a compromise the authors of the constitution felt that had to make to create the US. I bet a lot of them didn't like it. When you say routinely: only 5 presidents have been elected without the majority of the popular vote, spread throughout a couple hundred years.
- baddox 6y ago> However, it's still not mob rule, by the virtue of the fact that mob rule is necessarily non-legal, while the electoral college is the essence of "legal". Okay. I'm not attached to the particular semantics of "mob rule," but if you define it deliberately such that it doesn't apply in this scenario, then of course it doesn't apply. I just meant, very simply, that it's rule by someone other than who the people expressed their desire to be ruled by.
- wutbrodo 6y ago> I just meant, very simply, that it's rule by someone other than who the people expressed their desire to be ruled by. That's not what the term means. It's practically the opposite of one of the meanings of the word, which is a pejorative for majoritarian rule. An absolute autocrat is about as far as you can get from mob rule, and yet it's "rule by someone other than who the people express their desire to be ruled by".
- catalogia 6y agoThe "mob" in "mob rule" does not refer to a mafia. Perhaps that's the source of this confusion?
- skissane 6y agoIndeed, it comes from Latin “mobile vulgus”, which means roughly “easily swayed common people”. “mobile” is of course the origin of the English word “mobile”, but the thing being easily moved here is the crowd’s feelings and opinions. “vulgus” is source of the English word “vulgar”, but less pejorative - the masses, the crowd, the common or ordinary people, the non-elite
- lefstathiou 6y agoIt could be argued the electoral college is designed to prevent mob rule by preventing would be presidents from getting elected just by pandering to the “mobs” of people living in high population states like California and Texas
- scarmig 6y agoThough it doesn't prevent Presidents from getting elected by pandering to the mobs living in Oklahoma and Kentucky. The issue with fighting mob majority rule with minority rule is that there's no reason a minority is itself any better or non-moblike than a majority. It's trivial for me to select a different minority whose votes are allowed to count that gives totally opposite results than what exists now. The one advantage of having government be determined by a majority of all people is that you can't slice and dice "all people" to be a particular biased subset of people to get particular outcomes.
- dahfizz 6y ago> I highly doubt the very people who designed the electoral college would approve of its use when it seems to routinely elect someone who lost the popular vote. That's literally why they invented the electoral college. To add indirection between the popular vote and the presidency.
- majormajor 6y agoNot the Senate? The Senate results in huge vote power discrepancies.
- dekhn 6y agoPower discrepancies and mob rule are different things. [edit: though it's correct that the Senate, like the EC, is not "popular", as every state has two senators, rather than a proportionate amount, like representatives]
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoThat point in your edit is actually a pretty big deal. We're already in a situation where a majority of the Senate represents less than 20% of the country's population. Some people will (correctly) retort that the Senate was never intended to be popular in the way you used the word, but -- just like the Electoral College -- the significant concentration of population in urban areas is something that the founders almost certainly didn't foresee. While "mob rule" may be an unfair term, not only did more people vote for the Democratic presidential candidate in 2016, there have been more votes cast for Democrats than Republicans as a whole not only in Senate races over the last decade but in House races, too -- the Republican majority there is protected by gerrymandering.
- dlp211 6y agoMaybe the mob is trying to rule because it finds the US government illegitimate because they're majority isn't being represented in the government. In order for Democrats to win the House they have to get more votes than 50%. Democrats received millions of more votes for Senate but don't control that chamber. Democrats received more votes for the Presidency twice this century and have been denied the power of that branch and as a consequence, the third branch, the judiciary, is currently controlled by Republicans as well.
- Simon_says 6y agoTrump is the president of the States, not the people. Anyways, he won 304 out of 538 votes, which is, in fact, a majority.
- dlp211 6y agoYes, we all know how an archaism in our system allows for what is now the most powerful branch of government to be controlled by the minority in this country.
- Simon_says 6y agoSorry, you said that he received fewer votes. I thought you might not know.