15 ms·
Facebook establishing a venture arm to invest in startups
- ChicagoDave 6y agoI wouldn't take a penny from Facebook. You know they will lock down any patent you create and steal your IP.
- fheilz 6y agoWould you take a penny from Softbank?
- amitutk 6y agoA penny from Softbank? Didn't you get the memo? Softbank requires you to take at least 1 billion.
- fheilz 6y ago:|
- hackingthenews 6y agoand if you don't they will force your competitor to take $1B.
- cosmodisk 6y agoGetting funding from Softbank is like foie gras: they'd literally stuff dollars down your throat.
- andy_ppp 6y agoYes, it might end up making your startup sick too...
- stu2b50 6y agoSoftbank is not a software company and probably isn't trying to copy and undercut your business in the future
- TeMPOraL 6y agoNah, they'll just fund your competitor as well, and pit you against each other to see who survives :).
- stu2b50 6y agoEven if that happens, that's fine. Softbank has no incentive for your business to fail. The company that dies, is more money out of the visionfund. On the other hand, FB does have an incentive. Sure, they lose that investment, but they gain their own internal company that they own 100% of which has eaten your marketshare.
- tfehring 6y agoI wouldn't take a penny from either. It's a wide world with an unprecedented amount of capital in the hands of wealthy investors. There are plenty of funding sources that are neither surveillance monopolists nor government administrations that torture and murder journalists.
- toast0 6y agoDisclosure: I worked for WhatsApp, including while owned by Facebook, and Facebook is assigned my twoish [1] patents. Has Facebook done anything with their patents? I know they had an early spat with Yahoo and got access to a bunch to help with that, and have since put more effort into building a portfolio, but I don't recall seeing anything in the way of litigation. I know there's been issues with clauses in licenses, though. [1] I've read both patents, I'm the only inventor, and I can't tell the difference between the two.
- jedberg 6y agoI also have three identical seeming patents. I was also confused, so I asked my patent examiner friend, and this was his response. I assume the same applies to you: "You have one patent family with three patents in it. The lowest number is the parent, it was first to grant. Before it was granted a continuation was filed - they wanted to claim some shit that you disclosed in the parent but didn't claim, and it got granted. Before that one got granted a second continuation was filed to claim some shit that was disclosed in the first continuation. Sometimes that comes from realizing something else in the patent specification was also really important and deserves protection, or something comes up in prosecution and the easiest way to get around a rejection is to file a continuation. All the claims in the patent family are unique."
- toast0 6y agoThanks, this makes a lot more sense now, especially this part: > they wanted to claim some shit that you disclosed in the parent but didn't claim, and it got granted Also, thanks to your friend!
- raverbashing 6y agoAnd? You'd probably walk away with at least 6 digits in your bank account. 7 or maybe 8 if you're lucky. This is the kind of money I wouldn't say no except for a very good reason.
- scollet 6y agoMoney > ethics in your worldview? This is compounding the issue and creating a toxic incentive.
- missedthecue 6y agoMoney is objective while ethics are not
- scollet 6y agoThis is a meaningless comment. You can mark assets on a spreadsheet, plot profits on a graph, and the result is simply a representation of the abstract concept: finances. When you factor intent, then money becomes objective. When you factor the ethics of the entity using financial influence, then the result is objective because it affects the real world. I don't know how else to explain this, and maybe I can't convince you, but real people are affected by these choices. Profits are never a meaningful metric precisely because they can't be divorced from ethics.
- smabie 6y agoEveryone has a price.
- raverbashing 6y agoNo, but ethics should be on your business model not so much on who's financing it.
- hogFeast 6y agoSo will this use data harvested from their malware apps (Onavo)?
- jasonvorhe 6y agoI wasn't aware that installing something by yourself that provides you with a promised benefit could be considered malware. Your accusation even conflicts with the basic definition of malware: > Malware is any software intentionally designed to cause damage to a computer, server, client, or computer network. I know what you're getting at, but why chose such a loaded term that doesn't fit?
- spinossa 6y agoBecause neckbeard hyperbole is the only way to talk about privacy on the internet
- normalnorm 6y agoYou forgot to include some more details from the Wikipedia article (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malware https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malware) from where you borrowed your definition: > A wide variety of types of malware exist, including computer viruses, worms, Trojan horses, ransomware, spyware, adware, rogue software, and scareware. It specifically mentions spyware, so let's take a look at that definition: "Spyware is a type of malware that aims to gather information about a person or organization, without their knowledge, and send such information to hack another entity without the consumer's consent."
- p49k 6y ago> Your accusation even conflicts with the basic definition of malware The very source you pasted this definition from (Wikipedia) goes on to list spyware as a type of malware, and the page for spyware lists Onavo as an example.
- cryptica 6y agoThese kinds of articles about VCs and companies offering to invest big funds used to give me hope, but now that I've participated in bootstrapping a startup, I see these articles as bad news. They're going to fund my competition... Give them easy money and keep funding them until they get that big corporate exit and I'm out of business because my margins are too small and I can't afford bulk discount on Facebook advertising like they can with all that free money they got. You know that someone else is going to get that funding, but it's not going to be you. It's more likely to help your competitor than it is to help you (the reader of the article). This is bad news for the typical reader of this article.
- __s 6y agoThis makes sure we continue having startups post about their incredible journey once they've established a good product
- cryptica 6y agoHaha, so true... and even the word "journey" sounds tacky in that context. You can send free money straight to my bank account at regular intervals and I could write all about my incredible journey; an inspiring story of struggle against all odds. ...The odds of not being able to afford a yacht within 5 years.
- MattGaiser 6y agoIn a world of easy VC money (granted that may be over), how viable is bootstrapping in a competitive market?
- throwaway_1512 6y agoIt’s not about viability anymore, if business takes a VC funding but if you honestly (and brutally honestly) think you can bootstrap then you have won the battle. VC funding is not a reversible step.
- gen220 6y agoIt’s very viable. You just need to target a niche that’s too small for VCs to care for. You wouldn’t be able to bootstrap Uber or AirBNB, because the markets they’re selling into are huge. However, there is an abundance of <10Bn-sized markets/industries out there that a VC wouldn’t think to invest in, where bootstrapped companies with a tech focus can grow and take over.
- riazrizvi 6y agoNaturally. How else are they going to monetize the data they have on business traffic? Just think twice about turning down a deal from them, no matter how bad it seems, because they probably know a lot more about your market and their alternatives to your services than you do. And the strategy in monopolistic situations like this is join us or suffer. Surely this how Alphabet has grown so big.
- tyre 6y agoIf you're competing in any way, building in any part of the social media space, this is an invitation to have your product copied as soon as you see any traction. Facebook doesn't need the money. It's looking for you to do the R&D.
- thirtythree 6y agoIs it worth the ride though? If your goal is to spend your time building something you love then it's a win.
- kgraves 6y agoThat's fair, looking forward to your 'incredible journey' with Facebook. I'm sure they can't wait to see what your startup will come up with. /s
- ergocoder 6y agoWhy the sarcasm? Most of the times, acquirehire by these top companies is probably better than being a regular senior FAANG engineers. Not sure why that is bad. It's probably not the top of the world (e.g. billionaires). But it's definitely a great situation to be in.
- gentleman11 6y agoThere’s more to it than money, as the regretful WhatsApp founder showed by leaving a fortune on the table to escape
- ergocoder 6y agoSure, it's not the best situation that a human can ever imagine. But let's not exaggerate. It's not bad for whatsapp founders. Better than 99.9999999999% of the population (maybe add a couple 9s at the end). For me, I don't even wanna make a single donation because I need to save every dollar. I can't join any protest or get involved in any politics because I'm already busy enough with my own life. Whatsapp founders now have 6,000,000,000 USD to power the change they want to see happen. Ok, maybe 5B, as they might want to keep 1B for living cost.
- kgraves 6y agoFacebook is the modern day internet gangster cartel, they are not even trying to hide it any more. This is an obvious trap that is easy to avoid. Sadly, I doubt there is any company that can take them on.
- a13n 6y agoHow does investing in startups make you an internet gangster cartel?
- wolco 6y agoInvest/purchase/block new competitors from ever reaching scale. Cartel doesn't apply. Facebook, Google, Apple coming up with an agreement to keep workers salaries lower is. Gangster.. that term applies.
- alasdair_ 6y ago"I'm gonna make him an offer he can't refuse..." "... one billion dollars in cash and stock."
- Fezzik 6y agoI mean, that’s a bit of the stretch. The implication in “an offer he can’t refuse” is that the mob is going to kill you if don’t accept the offer, not that they are going to drown you in more dollar bills than you can swim through.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alasdair_ 6y agoThat was the point of the joke :) I don't mean this impolitely - the fact it wasn't clearly obvious as a joke means I should have tried harder.
- 6y ago
- a13n 6y agoIt's pretty interesting that FAANG doing venture capital is basically like legal insider trading. They clearly have data on web traffic, consumer usage, advertising spend, etc. that other VC firms and investors generally don't have access to. They can use this to understand entire markets, see who the incumbents are, estimate revenue/users, see who's up-and-coming, etc. Obviously within some margin of error. I wonder if this is how Facebook identified that Instagram was on the path to success, and knew $1B was a great deal. Meanwhile everyone at the time thought they were crazy for spending that much. Since startups aren't publicly traded, I don't think insider trading laws apply to trading their securities. FAANG is legally allowed to use their access to information to make better investing decisions than other companies are able to. (IANAL) It seems like they have a high chance of getting a great ROI. Once you're a big tech company, this is just another way of monetizing the vast troves of data you have.
- malux85 6y agoYeah, and Google has this with Google Analytics. Is Google Analytics free out of the kindness of their heart? NO. It's free because you can spot up and coming winners.
- ThrustVectoring 6y agoGoogle Analytics is free because it is a complementary good to advertising spend. If the director of marketing tell the CEO "this $1000 campaign on Google drove $50,000 of sales at a 10% profit margin", the CEO is going to okay a lot more advertising spend. This winds up in Google's pockets. The same logic applies to why Amazon develops open-source software that makes developing cloud applications easier.
- Mikeb85 6y ago> They clearly have data on web traffic, consumer usage, advertising spend, etc. that other VC firms and investors generally don't have access to. I mean, this wouldn't be insider trading since anyone can do their own legwork to get this information. Insider information would be things that aren't (yet) disclosed to the public, not things that can be ascertained through thorough research. > Since startups aren't publicly traded, I don't think insider trading laws apply to trading their securities. Yup. Insider trading laws are designed to prevent the public from being at a disadvantage. Private firms don't need to disclose anything publicly, they can choose their investors, etc...
- zacharycohn 6y agoI'm actually more surprised they didn't already have a venture arm.
- hvaoc 6y agoThis will not work. If they are that good with information, they must be building products after products that people will love. Tell me one last known successful launch by Facebook in the last 2 years, outside tweaking their existing products. Only way it could work is if they share their wealth in other areas / people which must be invested in and will not get enough capital if not for them. Ex: Google Venture - Solar City, Tesla. But founders have to be fiercely independent and the companies must be independent. Like Elon Musk as founder and Larry / Sergey as investors. Facebook DNA doesn’t allow that, they are predatory in nature. Trying to diversify by external forces since internal options simply failed. Founders of the companies they acquired, left with very unpleasant experience. Take their money, if you are ready to be as independent as Elon Musk were and ready to say NO to Zuck when and if you have to.
- ericflo 6y ago> Tell me one last known successful launch by Facebook in the last 2 years Oculus Quest
- shostack 6y agoAnd that's just them getting started. I watched the entire video of last Oculus Connect and it was jaw dropping what they are going for and how much progress they've made. Like, Rainbow's End made real.
- ta17711771 6y agoThey...bought Oculus. No?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoLong time ago. Quest was developed way after that acquisition.
- Traster 6y agoFacebook did the same thing they did with Instagram, they bought the company, kept it essentially independent with the founders continuing to run it as an independent management team. As with Instagram, Oculus is now big enough to actually matter to facebook, and so Mark proceeded to fuck with the successful management team until they quit. It's almost the perfect example of Facebook failing to innovate internally.
- juanbyrge 6y agoThis makes sense to me. Facebook knows that consumers are finicky when it comes to social networks and they need to stay on top of the latest fads. Once new social networks catch fire Facebook needs to do anything possible to gain control of them, and venture investing is one way to do that.
- zuhayeer 6y agoNo good co will actually take money from the incumbent they're trying to uproot
- asdff 6y agoMozilla is funded by google.
- zuhayeer 6y agofair
- ta17711771 6y agoBut Mozilla is no longer trying to uproot Google. Their job now is to keep Google from getting an antitrust lawsuit/similar sentiment etc.
- gregory194 6y agoIt has also tied up with yahoo in 2014, Microsoft in 2004 and with IRS audits too.
- nopzor 6y agointel invested in broadcom. microsoft invested in apple.
- uptownfunk 6y agoI am surprised they have not started this sooner frankly
- ponker 6y agoSurprised that this didn’t exist already.
- beager 6y agoA lot of people are rightly concerned here that Facebook will run this arm in a cutthroat way so as to stifle innovation and competition. Though they might, I have no reason to believe that’s because they want to usurp and control every technology they invest in. I think Facebook knows that their core products and business lines are under threat of attrition, and the margins on ad revenue will get tighter. A venture arm, coupled with one of the world’s beefiest analytics muscle, will probably return more than their core businesses, and insulate them from a potential turn away from social media as a profitable vertical. That’s what I thought they were doing with Oculus originally. Same with WhatsApp, then they started to commingle the branding.
- shoo 6y agoIf you were an investor in Facebook, instead of Facebook investing excess cash, wouldn't you prefer Facebook to return the excess cash to investors? Then if you agree that investing in startups is a winner, you could reinvest the cash through some venture fund? Or if you disagree and feel that there's a better use for the cash, such as investing in index funds or paying off your student loans or buying a yacht or whatever, you could do that instead. One of William Bernstein's Efficient Frontier articles summarises some research on this: > In the December issue [of Journal of Finance] Jarred Harford found that cash-rich firms destroyed 7 cents of corporate value for every dollar of cash reserves held. How does this happen? Let’s take two firms, both of which are considering a project or acquisition of marginal value. The first firm is cash-poor, and must obtain the capital from a bank, or a stock or bond issuance. This necessitates scrutiny of the project from the outside. The second firm is cash-rich, and thus requires no outside scrutiny—they can simply cut a check. Clearly, the cash-rich company is much more likely to make this potentially unprofitable investment. > Rajan, Servaes, and Zingales look at the performance of large conglomerates, and find that investment capital tends to flow most readily to its least productive divisions. The more highly diversified the company (i.e., the less related its component businesses) the more dramatic the effect. What is most interesting is that Harford's research found that cash-rich companies are more likely to make diversifying acquisitions—in other words, to turn them into the same companies that this paper shows are the least efficient. > [...] the February JoF contains an absolute gem from La Porta, Lopez-de-Silanes, Shleifer, and Vishny on dividend policy around the globe. Their primary finding is that in so-called "civil law" countries, such as most of Latin America, Scandinavia, and southern Europe, where investor protection is the weakest, dividend payouts are low. In so-called "common law" countries—basically the world’s English-speaking nations, where investor protection is excellent—payouts are high. Which gets back to Graham’s basic premise; investors prefer dividends and take them whenever the law and culture allow. The authors reinforce the points made by Graham and the other pieces; "failure to disgorge cash leads to its diversion or waste, which is detrimental to outside shareholders’ interest." > But what is most remarkable about this piece is its tone, which is almost Menckenesque in its description of modern corporate ethics. They describe a Hobbesian world in the kind of plain English rarely seen in academic finance; "Firms appear to pay out cash to investors because the opportunity to steal or misinvest it are in part limited by law, and because minority shareholders have enough power to extract it." -- http://www.efficientfrontier.com/ef/700/agency.htm http://www.efficientfrontier.com/ef/700/agency.htm
- hi5eyes 6y agomy (stupid) theory is fb/goog/youtube are now trying to help small businesses as much as possible on their platforms to drive more traffic and revenue since expansion is tapping out at some point
- gentleman11 6y agoI don’t think that’s stupid at all. When you are as big as a small country, you legitimately do benefit from a strong, lively economy
- gentleman11 6y agoI would dread having Facebook on my board. I intend to treat my future users very well and wouldn’t want somebody with 1-2/5ths ownership in my company pushing me to chase their data
- moogly 6y agoLet's spread the cancer!