8 ms·
Bertrand Russell’s infinite sock drawer
- mchan889 6y agoI'm always happy to see solid philosophy show up here. Really, it's an under-appreciated field that gets written off as useless. Looking back at when I was in college, one of the courses that I still make use of was a philosophical logic class. Infact, the prof I had for that course sent me a link to the Open Logic Project, which has come in handy ever since. I also have a soft-spot for Russell and his student Wittgenstein. Tractatus is an incredible, though later redacted, work of pure axiomatic reasoning. While HN focuses mostly on tech, I think that the kind of reasoning found in Analytic philosophers can be a boon to anyone doing anything that requires the sort of logical design found in the technology field.
- corporateslave5 6y agoThe history of western philosophy by Russel is drivel. It’s full of his own personal biases
- pmoriarty 6y agoThe Tractatus is couched in language that make it seem like Wittgenstein is laying out a mathematical proof, but many of his conclusions don't follow from his premises. The Tractatus is much more a work of mysticism (in the religious sense) than of logic. Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must remain silent.
- ukj 6y agoWhy do you assume that premises-to-conclusions is the "right way" to go about stuff? Why can't we go from conclusions to premises? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_mathematics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_mathematics
- tsimionescu 6y agoEven if you go in reverse, finding premises for your conclusions, your conclusion must still follow from the premises you found. Saying that the premises don't follow from the conclusions means that, taking the premises as true, the conclusion is may or may not be true, so it is illogical to draw that conclusion from those premises. Or if you prefer the other way around, if, taking the conclusion as true, the premises could be true or false (or taking the conclusion as false, the premises could still be true or false) then the conclusion does not follow from the premises you found.
- ukj 6y agoYou aren't hearing me. The difference is the order/sequence in which the events take place. Regular maths starts with premises then looks for conclusions. Reverse maths starts with conclusions then looks for premises. So in reverse maths the premises follow from the conclusions - quite literally.
- OJFord 6y agoIn writing: > Even if you go in reverse, finding premises for your conclusions, your conclusion must still follow from the premises you found. GP means 'follow' in the sense of logical deduction, not follow in time. Having found the premise (after the conclusion), the conclusion (we started with) must then logically follow from the premises (we later found).
- ukj 6y agoWell, obviously! That's by design.
- Koshkin 6y agoProblem is, unlike conclusions, premises are usually sufficient but not necessary.
- ukj 6y ago
- noncoml 6y agoRelevant: “Let R be the set of all sets that are not members of themselves. If R is not a member of itself, then its definition dictates that it must contain itself, and if it contains itself, then it contradicts its own definition as the set of all sets that are not members of themselves. This contradiction is Russell's paradox” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_paradox
- seesawtron 6y agoSelf-reference in logic is named after the ancient symbol Ouroboros, a dragon that continually consumes itself, denotes self-reference [0]. I found out about this when reading about Russell's paradox [1]. The turn of the 19th century was an extraordinary time where logicians, mathematicians and philosophers "discovered" revolutionary ideas that we are still today trying to understand and find proofs [2]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-reference#In_logic,_mathematics_and_computing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-reference#In_logic,_mathe... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_paradox [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_mathematics#19th_century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_mathematics#19th_ce...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- IngoBlechschmid 6y agoThe circularity supported in programming, that programs ("quines") can refer to their own source code, illustrates the same issue at heart. Yusuke Endoh created a tantalizing Ouroboros quine cycling through 128 languages: https://github.com/mame/quine-relay https://github.com/mame/quine-relay
- seesawtron 6y agoThis is crazy!
- IvyMike 6y agoMy 29 member facebook group, "Reject the Axiom of Choice", will surely see a membership surge now.
- ukj 6y agoYou are going too far! Reject the Axiom of INFINITE Choice. Embrace the axiom of FINITE choice! Become a Finitist (can I interest you in some pamphlets to tell you more about my religion?) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axiom_of_finite_choice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axiom_of_finite_choice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finitism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finitism
- ukj 6y agoThe way ZFC navigates around Russel's paradox is by adopting the axiom of restricted comprehension [1]. Here's a thought experiment: What happens if we allow for unrestricted comprehension [2] ? What happens if we say 'Contradictions exist and they are empirical. What do they mean?' The upside is that you attain "unrestricted comprehension" (In the English, not Mathematical sense) with the miniscule downside of having to navigate around contradictions from time to time. Contradictions exist - if they didn't I wouldn't be able to contradict myself when I want to. I wouldn't be able to trigger exception-handlers in your brain when I want to. How you handle that exception is a matter of choice. I like the Dialetheist solution [3]. Basically the Axiom of Unrestricted comprehension is akin to practicing the Principle of Charity. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axiom_schema_of_specification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axiom_schema_of_specification [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axiom_schema_of_specification#Unrestricted_comprehension https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axiom_schema_of_specification#... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialetheism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialetheism
- magnio 6y ago> Contradictions exist - if they didn't I wouldn't be able to contradict myself when I want to. Huh, I haven't thought about it that way. Very interesting.
- frutiger 6y agoCan you provide an example of you contradicting yourself?
- ukj 6y agoI don't exist. Or the Philosophical cliche... I freely believe in the absence of free will. Scott Aaronson has discussed this in more detail: https://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec18.html https://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec18.html
- frutiger 6y agoIs that a contradiction or a lie? Genuine question: is there a difference between the two? Edit: I read the article (and I’m not sure I was able to follow it completely) but it seemed to mostly be about free will, and not people making contradictions (or lying).
- cjfd 6y agoI do not really understand why the Banach-Tarski paradox is such a big deal. It does not seem any different from the paradoxes of the Hilbert hotel. If one has two filled hilbert hotels one can fit all hotel guests in one single hilbert hotel by letting guests from one hotel take even numbered rooms and from the other hotel odd numbered rooms.
- magnio 6y agoThey are both counter-intuitive. The difference is that proving Banach–Tarski paradox requires the axiom of choice.
- cjfd 6y agoYes, but I think the basic cause of both is that one assumes there are infinite sets. The Banach-Tarski paradox to me seem to be little more than a three dimensional variation of the hilbert hotel. Therefore, if one wants to implicate any basic axiom for being the cause of the counter-intuitiveness of that theorem the infinity axiom seems the more sensible candidate. Therefore, to me, it seems the argument against the axiom of choice from the Banach-Tarski paradox does not make any sense.
- ukj 6y agoYou are disagreeing over the meaning of the word "the" in "THE axiom of choice". It's not only one - there are multiple formulations. There are the axioms of finite choice; and the axiom of infinite choice. Broadly it's the philosophical distinction between Finitists and Infinitists.
- cjfd 6y agoI don't really think so. I am arguing that whatever axiom of choice one uses is basically an implementation detail of the banach-tarski paradox and that because of the similarity to the hilbert hotel paradox the cause of the paradox should be sought in the infinity axiom and not in whatever axiom of choice one prefers or doesn't prefer. Edit: or to put it more sharply: after one has seen the hilbert hotel the BT paradox is not surprising anymore.
- IngoBlechschmid 6y agoThe article provides a nice introduction to the subtleties surrounding the axiom of choice. The last paragraph briefly mentions that there are other flavors of mathematics in which the axiom of choice doesn't hold. For people who are intrigued by the idea of different flavors of mathematics, but all still set-based, a couple months ago I wrote an expository summary of the so-called "multiverse philosophy in set theory". You can find it at https://iblech.gitlab.io/bb/multiverse.html https://iblech.gitlab.io/bb/multiverse.html, and I'm happy to answer any questions or comments you might have. There are also even wilder flavors of mathematics which are not set-based. In those we can have various dream results which directly contradict the mathematical canon (but are internally consistent and have a certain precise relation to the ordinary mathematical world). For instance we can have that every function is computable by a Turing machine, that every real function is continuous or that the reals include infinitesimal numbers. An introduction to these flavors, aimed at philosophers of mathematics, can be found here: https://rawgit.com/iblech/internal-methods/master/paper-filmat.pdf https://rawgit.com/iblech/internal-methods/master/paper-film...
- AnthonyAguirre 6y agoThat was a fascinating read; thank you. Not every day that I learn about a whole new important multiverse!
- enriquepablo 6y agoAt the beginning of "multiverse.html" you say "In the beginning of the 19th century..." I think you mean 20th.
- whatshisface 6y ago>The only caveat of Theorem 1.3 is that toposes generally only support intuitionisticreasoning, not the full power of the ordinaryclassical reasoning. Why is intuitionistic reasoning blessed as the "universal reasoning," when there are other ways of doing logic that permit even fewer inference rules?
- IngoBlechschmid 6y ago
- iambrj 6y agoLogicomix[0] is an interesting graphic novel which talks about Russell's work and life in case anybody wants to learn more [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logicomix https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logicomix
- IngoBlechschmid 6y agoLogicomix is the best. I strongly second the recommendation. This novel not only discusses the logical aspects of self-referentiality, it also goes strongly meta on it. At one point in the novel, you see the authors of the novel debating on how to best present a particular story.
- mikorym 6y ago> Even today it’s regarded with suspicion in a way that most mathematical axioms aren’t. This is a common misconception. You either use it as an assumption, or you do not, as is the case with the parallel postulate. There need be no controversial sentiments. In the same way complex numbers were briefly "controversial", but as mathematicians we shouldn't bring too much opinion into the matter; we should only follow the argument. In the last paragraph the article seems to admits that the approach is you either assume it or you do not.
- sukilot 6y agoIt's controversial in the way addition is not. It's controversial as to which axioms should be the common default in the language, and where research funding should be spent.
- morninglight 6y agoSorry Bertie, but the "sock drawer" paradox has been resolved. https://youtu.be/_AOeL-QgDco https://youtu.be/_AOeL-QgDco