9 ms·
I have a big problem when people talk about Google only having "a third of the market", and counting total digital ad spend as that market. For example, I bet t
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I have a big problem when people talk about Google only having "a third of the market", and counting total digital ad spend as that market. For example, I bet that if you looked at certain industries of people selling things online (for example, plumbers, attorneys, hotels, etc.) you'd find that nearly 100% of businesses spend money on Google. Sure, they may spread ad spend around (e.g. lots of businesses uses Facebook for brand awareness and Google for targeted search marketing), but these businesses don't see not spending on Google as an option. If there were real competition, these businesses would have a choice to spend these dollars somewhere else, but the fact is that Google is so dominant in search that for most companies the options are "pay the Google tax" and "go out of business". That doesn't feel like a market with healthy competition.
- smallnamespace 6y agoIf you cut any industry finely enough, you will find a monopoly. The pizza restaurant next door is a monopolist in the pizza category on my street. So if you don’t want policy to be completely arbitrary, you’ll need some principles to follow when drawing industry boundaries.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> The pizza restaurant next door is a monopolist in the pizza category on my street. That's ridiculous. Sure, it may be easiest to order from the guy next door, but if you don't like the pizza next door, you can easily call the guy 3 blocks down the street. My point is you have options when it comes to pizza. There are many types of businesses that simply do not have any options besides Google. Don't believe me? Ask literally anyone who works in digital advertising. If you were planning any kind of digital ad campaign that relied on search, and you said you weren't going to spend on Google, they'd think you were insane. "Oh yeah, I've decided to put all my search ad spend on Bing." It sounds ridiculously laughable just writing it out.
- aaronAgain 6y agoI work for Bing. Awwww, man. ;-)
- cageface 6y agoBy this logic Apple is a monopoly in the mobile space since nobody can afford to ignore them when building apps.
- ethbro 6y agoYes.
- sudosysgen 6y agoPeople absolutely can afford to ignore Apple in the mobile space, except if your app is 100% reliant on the US market. iOS is only about 20-25% of the global market.
- cageface 6y agoWe're talking about US antitrust law and its enforcement in this thread. And in the US market iOS is the priority for app developers.
- sudosysgen 6y agoVery few US companies operate only in the US as far as app development, and none of the statistics I've seen so far concern solely the US. In any case, if you're making a social media app or other international app, an Android version is likely more important.
- bananabreakfast 6y agoYou're kind of completely missing the point you're responding to. There is no such thing as international anti-trust. In this conversation the US market is the only thing that matters since we are talking about US law. Hence, android does not really matter much for revenue.
- smnrchrds 6y ago>If you cut any industry finely enough, you will find a monopoly And inversely, if you cut any industry coarsely enough, you will never find any monopolies. "Don't break us up! Sure, we may own the entire telephone service, but we do not have a monopoly. See, you should be looking at total human communications. People talk in person, send letters, etc. We own a teeny tiny slice of total human communications." "Don't break us up! Sure, we may own the entire rail network, but we do not have a monopoly. See, you should be looking at entire human travel. People walk, ride horses, travel by ships, etc. We own a teeny tiny slice of total travel industry."
- dantheman 6y agoThe only monopoly is the government granted monopoly, ma bell was one.
- smnrchrds 6y agoSo if Verizon manages to, through mergers and acquisitions and like, get a 100% market share in the US, it would still not be a monopoly, because it is not government granted?
- nyx_ 6y agoOf course not. If you don't like paying the monopoly prices, you can just, uh... you can just start your own backyard wireless telecommunications service provider.
- wbl 6y agoMCI was created to compete with Ma Bell and did so.
- akiselev 6y agoIn Verizon's specific case it would be a government granted monopoly either way. Between infrastructure easements to wireless spectrum to state laws banning municipal competition, that industry is government granted through and through.
- summerlight 6y agoWe already have a framework to define markets, called hypothetical monopolist test. It's conceptually simple; given a market definition, can a hypothetical monopolist impose significant increases in price without customers turning away? If not, it means there's competitors so it's not monopoly. In this definition, Google's not going to be a monopolist as advertisers can easily reallocate their budget to alternative options (FB, Amazon, etc) to improve their ROI if Google decides to increase their fee significantly. Publishers don't have much options other than AdSense to sell their ad slots so it's monopsony(=single buyer controls the market). Not sure if the US antitrust law can handle this situation. If so, then this is going to be a landmark case.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> In this definition, Google's not going to be a monopolist as advertisers can easily reallocate their budget to alternative options (FB, Amazon, etc) to improve their ROI if Google decides to increase their fee significantly. That is the point I 100% absolutely disagree with. Ask any digital marketer, most of them see FB and Amazon as serving different purposes than what targeted search ads do. If you put 'Bing' or 'DuckDuckGo' I would agree with you, but in that case you'll find that the way Adwords bidding work that Google pretty much already takes a huge portion of potential margin - in many areas with deep-pocketed investors who think they'll eventually turn profitable Google actually takes more than 100% of potential margin.
- summerlight 6y ago> Ask any digital marketer, most of them see FB and Amazon as serving different purposes than what targeted search ads do. I'm very well aware of this, but this doesn't necessarily mean that budget planning will be done completely independent across multiple different channels. We already have observed a significant fraction of search advertisements budget has been moved from Google to Amazon as Amazon becomes a more effective ads platform. In fact, nowaway this becomes a much more attractive option since Amazon now owns literally everything from advertisements, auction, optimization and measurements in a single platform. > in many areas with deep-pocketed investors who think they'll eventually turn profitable Google actually takes more than 100% of potential margin. Most of the Google's largest advertisers are big, conventional companies with a strong cash flow, not those burning the money from investors. They really care about incrementality, efficacy, measurement and performance. Sure, you can probably burn a few million dollars without a good reason but you cannot spend x100 like that.
- harpratap 6y agoYou can make similar arguments for many other industry titans too. If you don't cater to Apple you will lose out on major chunk of high paying people, if you don't cater to Amazon you will miss out on a lot of e-commerce sales, if you don't cater to Instagram you will miss out younger audience.
- paganel 6y agoIt has been mentioned before on topics like this one, but lots of people commenting in here are directly financially involved in this type of discussion (i.e. breaking up Google or FB), as in they're probably employees of those companies and as such their relatively big compensations depend on these companies' operations remaining pretty much the same.
- ankit219 6y agoThis is the worst of all possible market definitions. That the market is the thing which only this company does. Most of the companies are choosing google (or forced to choose google) because of the reach and the traffic it gets you. They are free not to spend on Google, use Facebook, Amazon, or any other network (many exist but people arent so aware), the returns are very very low. Its a moat for Google given that their targeted marketing is very very accurate compared to other networks. Same goes with Facebook. If you limit them, you are not improving your ROAS or even efficiency. For most of the companies, they would end up spending higher per qualified lead compared to what they get from Google. This is very hard to break and side by side ensure that the advertisers (and publishers) are not harmed in the process. Facebook has its own audience Network, but that is really bad in terms of returns. There are others like Taboola, Smarty Ad and so on, but all of them end up not delivering enough returns, and as a publisher, you end up going to google.