5 ms·
The more interesting thing here is the "controlled digital lending" test case that will almost certainly come of all of this. If they somehow prevail on that a
by jedberg 6y ago
The more interesting thing here is the "controlled digital lending" test case that will almost certainly come of all of this.
If they somehow prevail on that aspect and set a legal precedent there, that would resolve a lot of issues for a lot of companies.
For example, Netflix could stream every movie ever, as long as they bought enough DVDs for peak demand. Or those companies that would set up 1000 TV antennas in a datacenter and then stream the signal.
I just hope the IA doesn't get CDL shot down because of this and ruin it for everyone.
- wriq 6y ago"Or those companies that would set up 1000 TV antennas in a datacenter and then stream" I believe Aereo tried just that and failed - https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2014/06/25/325488386/tech-firm-aereo-performs-an-illegal-service-supreme-court-says https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2014/06/25/325488386...
- jedberg 6y agoThey did. But this could set a new precedent.
- JoshTriplett 6y agoThey didn't fail, they were sued out of business. They had a good, innovative product that people wanted, and they got killed by a lawsuit. This is the tradeoff we're making when we grant more exclusive privileges over works: we kill innovations like these, and we get...probably not any more creative works than we would have gotten otherwise.
- MR4D 6y agoBut they did fail. The Supreme Court ruling is here: https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/13pdf/13-461_l537.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/13pdf/13-461_l537.pdf
- ghaff 6y ago>They had a good, innovative product They had a product that involved giving away other people's stuff. Yes, copyright terms are too long. But I'm pretty sure that a vanishingly small amount of that stuff they were giving away would be out of copyright even with a copyright term of 20 years.
- TaylorAlexander 6y agoWell I really take issue with the idea that IP is "other people's stuff". I might say they were giving away copies of data that the government had granted others a monopoly on. I am being intentionally pedantic because copyright is much more harmful than people give it credit for. The internet archive is desperately trying to give people free books and others are trying to stop them.
- behringer 6y agoI'm sure if you wrote a book you would be a bit annoyed.
- TaylorAlexander 6y agoI have published a small book which I licensed CC0 and put a free copy online. I have also been designing a robot for the last two and a half years and I have licensed the entire thing as CC0 so anyone can benefit from it. I also regularly publish youtube videos which I license CC0, and in fact all of the writing on my personal website is also licensed CC0. Even at my workplace I am leading the push to become a non-profit so we can raise money via donations and make our product open source (with a CC0 license). So no, I would not be annoyed. Intellectual property restrictions increase the cost of everything and stand in the way of providing a better world for all.
- sonofaplum 6y agoNothing is stopping the IA from buying books and giving them to people, or paying authors to write books and then giving them to people. What they are suing is to prevent IA from scanning books and giving those copies to an unlimited number of people, which is, no matter what your moral feelings about the matter, quite different!
- ghaff 6y ago>Or those companies that would set up 1000 TV antennas in a datacenter and then stream the signal. Aereo lost their case at the SCOTUS level. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aereo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aereo IANAL, but I have trouble believing that the number of antennas matters. (And I assume Aereo tried every workaround they could think of. Although I believe there's another case at the moment with another organization trying a non-profit loophole.) But, yes, at the moment it seems as if the IA has let the genie out of the bottle and may well force a ruling on something that the publishers were willing to let slide given the limited impact.
- OldHand2018 6y agoAereo lost their case because they received a signal, decoded it, saved the video to a hard drive, and then streamed the video from the hard drive to the customer. Their business model clearly depended on them offering DVR capabilities to customers, deduping videos, etc. - why else save the videos to disk and then stream from disk? If they simply streamed the undecoded TV signals to their customers, they would have been fine. The Supreme Court decision constantly compared the Aereo service to previously litigated cases involving "antenna on top of hill really far from house as a service" (deemed to be legal).
- ghaff 6y agoI think I read the judgement at the time. I should re-read. Though CDL would seem (IANAL) to be more analogous to the DVR in that it's transforming the original product in some manner rather than just boosting a signal. ADDED: Would it actually be fine to stream an OTA channel? I don't actually know. I'm not sure it would be a business model for anyone but would that be considered a public performance?
- csharptwdec19 6y ago> Would it actually be fine to stream an OTA channel? I don't actually know. I'm not sure it would be a business model for anyone but would that be considered a public performance? The answer is no, and that's why Aereo lost their case. It is important to note that Aereo lost their case under a specific carve-out for broadcast transmission. Back in the 70s there were a few cases around CATV operators doing the exact same thing Aereo did. The end result was a series of regulations that made rebroadcasting in the fashion you describe an act that required licensing from the original broadcaster. This is also why the Slingbox back in the day survived legal challenges (if there even were any.) The Customer had to have their own physical hardware at the location receiving the signals.
- Retric 6y agoThere are several presidents in the older direction. Legally, if the copy is not stored in a location you own it counts as a public performance and needs specific licensing. An interesting work around might be leasing physical shelf space, playback hardware, and then having someone physically move the disks. But I seriously doubt that would work.