7 ms·
America is losing the stomach to fight Covid-19
- samizdis 6y agoEdited to add: Original FT piece syndicated in the Irish Times, no paywall: https://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/us/the-united-states-has-lost-the-stomach-for-the-coronavirus-fight-1.4276520 https://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/us/the-united-states-h... Non-paywalled article based on the linked FT piece: The US is losing the ‘discipline’ to fight coronavirus and is ‘leaving the battlefield before the war is over’ https://www.rawstory.com/2020/06/the-us-is-losing-the-discipline-to-fight-coronavirus-and-is-leaving-the-battlefield-before-the-war-is-over/ https://www.rawstory.com/2020/06/the-us-is-losing-the-discip...
- diffrinse 6y agoI mean let's be at least a little real here, and I identify as Left, but for a lot of people the protests and upheaval were a cure for boredom, conveniently packaged in a morally indignant reply to "What about the viral pandemic we have no cure to?". I really don't see much difference in people going after direct Right wing protest to the lockdown itself and people saying the lockdown is somehow superseded by moral virtue: in either case you are saying some higher principle overrides your duty to your fellow human beings (in keeping the curve low...). This "letter of the law over all"/legalism is, in my experience, the basis for modern all American ethical negotiation and it has to be changed. Just earlier this week the CDC chose not to admonish protesters for the worthiness of their cause: that should be orthogonal to the CDC's duty!
- mywittyname 6y agoI think it's fair to say Cause A is worth the risk of spreading the pandemic while Cause B is not. Especially when Cause A is linked to the murder and maiming of so many people while Cause B is a bunch of complainy-pants people complaining.
- noobaccount 6y agoThat appears to be the opinion of our impartial health officials, yes.
- yellowbuilding 6y agoIf you don’t comprehend that the protests were a result of the historically unprecedented economic collapse, you don’t have a politically left bone in your body.
- diffrinse 6y agoOf course they were but that's not what any of the popular public discourse has been about.
- gnusty_gnurc 6y agoAgreed. Doctors and scientists should be disseminating knowledge about the spread of coronavirus. Instead they're offering policy endorsements about political activity. The whole "racism is about public health" line is blatantly dogmatic political activity and I shudder to think of what this would look like on the right.
- esyir 6y agoFrom what I've seen of those on the right, they see it as ideological capture of core institutions by the left. I can't really refute that.
- doorstar 6y agoHonestly I think this was inevitable despite any politics. It's been over 2 months now since the lockdowns began and and a lot of people who were told 'flatten the curve' are asking when the curve will be flat enough. > Mission accomplished only works when there is a vaccine, which is at least a year away. A year with little if any time spent with family and friends? A year where a trip to the market means putting on your virus armor? A year where our kids get little education, little outdoor play, little social contact? There's obviously concern about the economic damage of the lockdown, but with some justification there's also a mental health concern. What is the risk of covid vs. the risk of 'normalizing' isolation? When we all get out - can we pick up where we left off? I'm starting to wonder when I just give up. My spouse is a virologist so we are a lot more stringent than most - but I see the neighborhood kids out playing basketball everyday and I can't fail to notice that they are all doing fine. Maybe they are going to prove to be the smart ones.
- JPKab 6y ago"Maybe they are going to prove to be the smart ones." I'm glad you have the humility about potentially being wrong that the math-illiterate journalists don't. Instead, they have doubled down on their initial freakout. Most people, I think, treat this like poker. You get a few new data points, and you shift your chips to locking down. You get more data points, you start taking them out. Reasonable. The journalist crowd, and some of my relatives, went all in on the lockdown. They could either look at the new data, and chill out and admit they overreacted for 2 months, OR they can just try to shame me for not wearing a mask when I'm riding my bike on a trail in a massive, empty wildlife refuge.
- doorstar 6y agoUnfortunately the scientists are still pretty pro-lockdown too. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/06/08/upshot/when-epidemiologists-will-do-everyday-things-coronavirus.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/06/08/upshot/when-e... In my own home I think the difference is becoming stark ( and hopefully doesn't come to a head ). My spouse has worked with deadly viruses and sees risk risk risk. I'm the engineer, I'm the pragmatists, I look backwards and extrapolate from what has already happened. What are the chances of getting the virus during a barbecue with friends vs. the chances of dying in a car crash during the drive over? Can I believe that the virus "might" spread on surfaces without seeing a lot more cases than I'd expect? Healthy living doesn't just boil down to "not infected".
- JPKab 6y agoArticles that discuss the USA as a monolith are immediately problematic. There are 50 states, and 50 different philosophies on fighting the virus. Also, this: "Mission accomplished only works when there is a vaccine, which is at least a year away." No, we didn't sign up for a lockdown until a vaccine exists. Has anyone wondered why we don't hear about Wisconsin in the news? The Wisconsin lockdown was ended a month ago by the courts, against the state government's will. There isn't a spike in cases a month later. Why is that? Why isn't that being reported? In the US, I no longer hear about Sweden on the news either. What I do know is that the US media was vehemently against people congregating outdoors a few weeks ago, and then decided that the risk was worth it when people began to protest for a righteous cause they happened to agree with. They were acting like the world was going to end a week before when a bunch of rednecks were swimming together at the Lake of the Ozarks. Specifically, they talked about covid spreading like wild-fire at choir practices due to the nature of people yelling and projecting moisture droplets. They were totally cool with the yelling protesters though. (I support the protests and think they were right to ignore the virus while exercising their rights.) It's summer time, and my friends and neighbors just don't think it's worth it to not live their lives. It might be a dumb decision in the long run. We shall see. But the media is invested in an apocalyptic narrative. They report bad news, ignore good news. Their reporters, like the vast majority of journalists, are essentially mathematically illiterate, Nate Silver and his like aside. Twitter is filled with opinionated morons who I wouldn't trust to walk my dog, and these journalists are part of that club. Not listening to them anymore. From now on, I just look at the data. Edit: Ah yes, commence the down-voting by the fearful for not endorsing their strategy of pretending to be agoraphobic for 2 months. I might be wrong, and I admit it. But are any of you who are wiping down every package that comes into your house willing to admit you MIGHT be overreacting?
- joshuamorton 6y agoIf your look for news articles about Sweden, recent ones are about how the government is admitting it made a mistake. This is evident if you compare Sweden's mortality rate to it's neighbors (10x higher). > What I do know is that the US media was vehemently against people congregating outdoors a few weeks ago, and then decided that the risk was worth it when people began to protest for a righteous cause they happened to agree with. There's differences between going out in crowds without masks and with masks. There's also differences between just causes and mediocre causes. And as to your last point about Wisconsin: most places aren't Wisconsin. Socal, Florida, Texas and other major population centers are back over their early peaks. And these increases predated the protesting this past week. Things were on the upswing already.
- downerending 6y agoThis article mostly ignores the larger picture. Winning the COVID-19 fight by itself is not "winning". The real win is to minimize the total number of deaths (or perhaps adjusted life years) and general misery. We have a lot more information now with which to project the benefits and costs of locking down to various degrees. It's all a guess, of course, but it's becoming clear that the costs of locking down are quite harsh, in terms of collateral deaths, etc. Being smart is not "losing one's stomach to fight".
- octokatt 6y agoWe need to look at the costs of social distancing, sure. We also need to look at how a lack of centralized response means the good work done to socially distance was wasted in part because as a country the US never took this seriously at the same time. Look at the comments in here. People are saying a virus that has killed over a hundred thousand people in three months was “overblown”. We didn’t stop the spread, we don’t have a good plan to go forwards, and we’re going to keep seeing second waves. The US lost it’s nerve to fight, and opened up businesses early. Not allowed visits from grandparents early, opened up businesses early. That’s more than enough to undo the work we’ve done. We’re fucking up.
- anthonygd 6y agoI haven't seen evidence the US didn't take the lock downs seriously. The goal initially was to flatten the curve aka. reduce/delay the load on hospitals. It was successful to the point hospitals had plenty ICU capacity and they had to layoff staff. Unfortunately there was no step 2 for the lockdowns. It's been months now since epidemiologists acknowledged the US could not eradicate COVID-19 without a vaccine. I don't think any large country has been able to (China might be close?). Economists have all been clear that we can't lock down for another year. There simply is no fight to have at this point. Mitigating damage is the only option.
- downerending 6y agoThe fact that the virus (directly) killed 100K people doesn't tell you much of anything about the quality of our response. It ignores two crucial questions: (1) How many people were indirectly killed? And (2) How much better could we have done in terms of total damage with an available alternative? The answer to (1) is starting to look like "a lot". And most tragically, it could be that a large number of those were due to well-intended actions like locking down. It's within the realm of possibility that the right thing to do was pretty much "nothing". As in, the basic health procedures specified for flu season, etc. Reams of papers and probably shelves of books will be written studying this, so perhaps eventually we'll have some idea. In any case, as others have pointed out, the protests have pretty much wiped out the idea of locking down. The economic costs (think: people who will go broke and die from it) even more so.
- lostmyoldone 6y agoIf I understood it correctly, the risk of "exhaustion" was one of th drivers of the strategy here in Sweden. Apart from the fact that ordering a lockdown would have been impossible. Yes, the possibility was explored, but it was found to be without legal support. There is much I don't agree with concerning our handling of Covid-19, far from all having to with the actual strategy, which I find questionable this far mostly based on the lack of any discernable scientific consensus regarding a strategy touted as scientifically sound. I however do agree that considering an exhaustion/psychological adaption scenario, is something you have to do in a situation like this. One strategy I've seen referred to as effective is essentially periodically altering the level of lockdown, but the high virulence in conjunction with the long latencies in the feedback looks seems to make it really hard to employ for Covid-19, as the necessary period still seems to be on the order of months.