18 ms·
USA Today has the best coverage of this I’ve seen. The NYT coverage of this is awful: https://www.nytimes.com/article/breonna-taylor-police.html https://www.nyt
by rayiner 6y ago
USA Today has the best coverage of this I’ve seen. The NYT coverage of this is awful: https://www.nytimes.com/article/breonna-taylor-police.html https://www.nytimes.com/article/breonna-taylor-police.html
A key fact is that the police shot Taylor after her boyfriend shot at the police, thinking they were intruders. While he was fully entitled to do that, the NYT doesn’t believe in gun rights so that’s a messy fact. To make the victim seem more sympathetic, the narrative under the heading “What Happened in Louisville?” doesn’t mention Taylor‘s boyfriend shooting first. Instead, you need to go down several paragraphs to learn that fact. Which leaves the whole article deeply confused: at first you think police just started shooting for no reason, and then later you learn they shot because they were fired upon. Which of course leaves the reader with little understanding of what police actually did wrong. Were they not supposed to shoot back when Taylor’s boyfriend shot at them? Is that the problem?
Obviously nobody expects the police not to shoot back when fired upon. What the police did wrong, instead, is failing to respect black peoples’ second and fourth amendment rights. This happened in Kentucky, where if you barge into someone’s house in the middle of the night you can expect to get shot. Police barging into people’s homes in the middle of the night unannounced is fundamentally incompatible with what the Constitution and Kentucky law gives homeowners the right to do: shoot at intruders in their home. And as such the practice of serving these no-knock warrants is an infringement of that right. It leads to tragic consequences under predictable circumstances where homeowners are just exercising their rights. And of course, it’s doubtful that officers display the same callousness to the possibility of armed homeowners when it comes to policing white neighborhoods. It’s another one in a long pattern of cases where black people are murdered for daring to exercise their second amendment rights.
- e40 6y agoI recently canceled my NYT subscription over the Tom Cotton op-ed. Really glad I did. WaPo and ProPublica have my money now.
- fourcommas 6y agoWaPo holds the distinguished title of being the first and only newspaper in the US whose editorial board endorsed the arrest and criminal charging of their own source.
- hetspookjee 6y agoI hold the WaPo in high regard and tend to read it everyday but I missed this entirely, and sounds rather shocking. Could you please source your statement?
- DFHippie 6y agoMe shouting at a cloud: "every day" means "all days" or, adverbially, "on every day"; "everyday" means "ordinary, common, expected". I know I'll get downvoted, but I see the conflation of "everyday" and "every day" everywhere and it's driving me bonkers. ETA: Note, they are pronounced differently. "Everyday" has a single primary stress on the first syllable. "Every day" has two primary stresses, one on the first syllable and one on the last.
- hetspookjee 6y agoThanks a( )lot! I didn't know this was a conflation. Learned something new here.
- fourcommas 6y agoSnowden passed his trove of classified info to two papers: WP and Guardian. Snowden never published any of his trove, he relied on these two papers to determine what was newsworthy and publish it. WP published various parts of the trove they deemed newsworthy, and ultimately won and accepted a Pulitzer for this. Then the editorial board signed and published a statement that said some of what was released from the trove actually wasn't newsworthy and were reasonable and legal defense programs. The editorial board recommended that because of this Snowden should be charged. In the editorial itself they acknowledge that the illegal behavior that was discovered can't be used as a defense in court. The WP was offered and accepted the responsibility to parse this trove and publish only what is newsworthy. They messed up and published a couple documents that weren't newsworthy. They never publish any kind of apology or correction for it, instead they indict their own source, and recommend he be charged for that! There's an unprecedented level of malice and incompetence displayed here. Look at the revolt in the NYT newsroom about the Cotton op-ed, and compare to literally not a word said in opposition to the WP editorial (which was written and signed by the editorial board, unlike the Cotton op-ed). The WP is rotten throughout, and shouldn't be held in even the slightest regard as a newspaper when they use their position to destroy the protection of sources that journalists fought for so long to preserve. https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/edward-snowden-doesnt-deserve-a-pardon/2016/09/17/ec04d448-7c2e-11e6-ac8e-cf8e0dd91dc7_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/edward-snowden-doesn...
- hkai 6y agoMay I ask why? I assume this is because many people think it is better that a left-leaning newspaper doesn't publish right-wing opinion pieces, but I would think that this creates a "bubble" and prevents readers from challenging their own opinions. A reduced version of this question would be: if Hitler/Xi/Kim were to publish an opinion piece in NYT, should they reject it or should they publish it?
- bagels 6y agoFor me it was not that it was a right/left opinion piece. It was a piece calling for the government to murder protesters which the editor solicited and published without reading. Nor was any context or commentary provided indicating such. (edit) You can also see, now, after the backlash, NYT agrees that it probably shouldn't have been published. Based on that review, we have concluded that the essay fell short of our standards and should not have been published. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/03/opinion/tom-cotton-protests-military.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/03/opinion/tom-cotton-protes...
- freshhawk 6y agoDo you actually believe the editor didn't read it? That is a pretty blatant and obvious lie to control the fallout.
- bagels 6y agoI actually don't believe it, but I have no evidence to support that belief. But it doesn't matter, because that actually makes it more reprehensible.
- kjaftaedi 6y agoThey published a story about the publication of the article and the events leading up to it. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/04/business/new-york-times-op-ed-cotton.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/04/business/new-york-times-o... The editor in question also resigned. Not saying it justifies the original publication, but I appreciate the way it was handled.
- asah 6y agoYou can re-subscribe: the editor who made this bad call has already resigned.
- dzonga 6y agoI cancelled mine in 2016. when they had biased reporting against Bernie Sanders. to me, a person from a 3rd world country staying in the states. was a shock. one of the biggest papers in the world, being politically biased. I was mad and sad.
- specialist 6y agoI canceled when they pimped the Iraq War. About every time I'm half tempted to finally forgive and move on, they reoffend.
- 9HZZRfNlpR 6y agoWhile there is no totally unbiased media, in America it's a feature not a bug. Heck, they even publicly endorse candidates which is extremely weird at least for me, someone not living there.
- unethical_ban 6y agoI still think that when it is a sitting US Senator, and you are in a position to know that many people may only look to you as the paper of record, it can be of public service to let the baddies have their say, for perspective - perhaps with the strongest condemnations from the editorial board. I generally believe the NYT has a better newsroom than Wapo.
- augustt 6y agoIt says there was a confrontation first, and then explains why under the big "Why did the police fire their weapons?" heading. Seems clear enough to me...
- rayiner 6y agoThe heading “what happened” purports to tell you the salient facts. The first paragraph proceeds in chronological order. Then it spends two paragraphs talking about stuff like how Taylor planned to be an EMT. And then it circles back to the shooting, and explains that the previously described “confrontation” was the boyfriend shooting at the police. Which totally changes your understanding of the narrative three paragraphs before. There is nothing clear about that.
- hkai 6y agoThere seems to be a pattern of similar reporting, and I wonder what are the reasons for that: - "Police started killing black transgenders now" means "police shot a person who has just killed someone, was suicidal and was pointing a gun at the police" - "A boy who played in the park was shot by police" means "a boy was pointing an illegally modified replica gun at people in the park". - "Police randomly shot an unarmed black man who was reading a book" means "a guy who was high and armed tried to pull a gun on a black police officer". (This last bit of fake news caused riots that left 1 dead) If you don't enrage the readers, then there's really nothing to discuss. We all agree that people should have the constitutional rights. Most people killed by the police are white. Blacks and whites are killed in equal proportions relative to the number of arrests by race. We all agree that the police makes horrible mistakes sometimes and should be punished. The media's goal is to make us disagree and hate each other.
- mydongle 6y agoYeah, remember when that one Muslim kid with the nasa shirt who supposedly got arrested for making a clock and brought it to school? Then when you actually finally see the photo of said clock, it literally looks like a fucking bomb. The US media is scum.
- anewdirection 6y agoNot to mention the tiny fact that he made nothing, only stripped off a alarm clocks case and added sketchy wires.
- codezero 6y agocontext: I am a super liberal hippy. I'm really left, like, crazy. I paused reading your comment at "instead you need to go down several" because I wanted to test my current knowledge of this incident: almost nothing, I know, hard to believe, given the claim at the start. (I've been under a lot of stress at work, it's OK, I'm fine, thanks for asking though :) ) So I read the article... Here is the first paragraph under "What happened in Louisville?" "Shortly after midnight on March 13, Louisville police officers, executing a search warrant, used a battering ram to crash into the apartment of Breonna Taylor, a 26-year-old African-American emergency room technician. After a brief confrontation, they fired several shots, striking her at least eight times." OK - so, I feel like I completely understand this is a complicated situation, not one where the cops kicked down the door and started shooting. 1. "After a brief confrontation" This is an obvious "and cut-to," that is, I know lots of stuff happened here. I would expect a reader who isn't completely engulfed in polarizing furor to think about this for a second like I did. 2. Gunshots after a confrontation I think this might be contentious, or where this is all loaded up... When I see "a confrontation" followed by "eight gunshots" - I actually do assume there was some reason that a reasonable gun toting police offer might have to fire after a confrontation. To me, this sets a pretty clear context. Let me add some more that came in later paragraphs that helped crystalize my understanding and leaves me feeling like the article here isn't really as biased as you are reading it as, though, I am not accusing you of being biased, or misreading the article. I can't begin to know all the things that contribute to your thinking, and vice-versa! 3. no-knock warrant While this all sounded like a completely legal entry, and a normal police procedure, here are my personal "let me add some context to how I interpret this" thoughts. - If I were a POC (I'm not), multiple plain-clothed white men with guns just stormed into my apartment. This is immediately tense. Imagine how you would react. What's going through your mind as a civilian? Keep in mind, police should be trained to do a no-knock warrant. They should be experienced and cool as a cucumber. I want this in our operators who go into dangerous situations, in fact, I expect it. You can train for danger. There is no excuse for imprecision when you are dealing with life and death, especially if, when doing it, you aren't planning to deal with life or death. 4. Her home was searched not because of an actual crime she committed, but because it was a possible drop-off location for a package involved in a crime. This feels really weak. Investigate the location then. Stake it out. Find your target and gather more evidence. This sounds rushed, and desperate. Storming an intermediate source of evidence rather than waiting for a better opportunity? Welp, it's not my job so I honestly don't know. I'm not in law enforcement so opinions are like assholes, right? So in summary? I think NYT speaks to a reader who is open-minded and understands that context is important, and that these subjects are complex. Maybe I'm giving them too much credit? If someone can walk away from the article with your point of view, I must be, time to think about that. If anyone broke down my door, I would attack them. If I had a gun, I would shoot them, I wouldn't think twice. I sit here, and have no reason to believe someone should kick in my door unless they mean me harm. Let me grant other people the same right. I expect police to be professional. The details on how this went down are not professional. It think that is safe to say simply because of the outcome. The police were executing a warrant for a bad person who was not the person who died. How can we accept that they were in control of the situation, and if we cannot, or we think they couldn't have been, why would we send people into such a situation? I am very flexible when it comes to granting authorities protections and flexibility in interpreting the law. I actually, for most of my life, have had faith in the system. I can imagine a scenario where I think many objective individuals would agree a no-knock warrant would make sense, so I can agree that they might be useful. I can also agree that ill-equipped people given tools they don't comprehend, or are not thoughtful enough, or well trained enough to use, will ultimately abuse and/or misuse them.
- hkai 6y agoI also hate that there seems to be a point of view that the US police and justice system is the worst in the world. I can attest that in most of the other countries of the world, you can't point a gun at the police and get away with it. Most importantly, you can't even talk about this case in the media, you can't sue the government, you can't hire a lawyer to fight against the government, your family will be threatened and you surely won't receive a 5 million dollar settlement that all US shootings inevitably end up with.
- jussij 6y ago> I can attest that in most of the other countries of the world, I'm not sure to which countries you are referring. But in many countries around the world this problem is greatly reduced, if not eliminated only because these countries also have strict gun laws that stop this happening.
- josefx 6y agoIt is interesting that the presence of guns is regarded as something that makes police work a lot harder and dangerous in the U.S. compared to the rest of the world, while the training of new officers is limited to weeks instead of years.
- jussij 6y agoToo me it seems a fairly logical conclusion. A police office in the US has to assume the perpetrator will be armed with a weapon and that then leads to the 'shoot first ask questions later' approach to policing. Alternatively, places where guns are not so prevalent means that anxiety is greatly reduced. As an example the majority of English police (i.e. bobbies) do their patrol work while not carrying a gun.
- pstrateman 6y agoTo be clear, do you think either of the victims in this incident did anything wrong? I do agree that in many cases both sides did something wrong, but in this case I can't imagine how you can find fault there.
- zachrose 6y agoNot only was this a no-knock warrant in a country full of guns, but it was also executed by plainclothes police. Figure out how that’s supposed to work.
- loopz 6y agoImagine what may be done as long as grunts are just following orders.
- dx034 6y agoBut why? Why not wait for a fully equipped team with shields? Sorrounding the house until then prevents anyone from getting out. Unless there's an active shooting, there's no reason not to wait. And with proper protection, police can afford to first identify themselves as shots are extremely unlikely to be lethal. I always thought it was Hollywood's imagination showing plain clothes police officers performing raids. It's shocking to see that this appears to be common police practice.
- _bxg1 6y agoIt makes me so upset how distorted all media coverage has been of all sides of this overall topic, from the start. Even if, with the new information you provided, the basic conclusion is the same - "police overreach, especially when it comes to black people" - the details remain extremely important not just for the integrity of that conclusion, but even more so when it comes to forming opinions about where to assign blame and how to solve the problem at a systemic level. I'm mildly infuriated that this is the first I'm hearing these crucial details.
- CerealFounder 6y agoAre they? If a group of people feel preyed upon and these, plain clothes officers with weapons, no-knock entered, they got what they deserved period. The onus is on the enforcement to manage damage, not a citizen who doesn't even know its coming. The intelletualizing of this is ridiculous, its a common sense issue.
- _bxg1 6y agoYou clearly skimmed my comment without actually reading it. The police were obviously in the wrong. But the exact way in which they were in the wrong remains extremely relevant to all of the discussions going on right now, yet the media appears to have largely cut it out of the story because that makes for a snappier piece. If we want to solve these issues as a society, we need to be working off of good information.
- CerealFounder 6y agoAppreciate the response, but didn't skim it. The "details" are inconsequential here. Im not bailing out the media, because their job has morphed into an attention megaphone in order to survive. The reason details dont matter is that the core problem is police acting with impunity. The problem becomes even worse when you look it relative to the victims accountability in all these cases. Theres that video from two days ago of that (white) union chief screaming and spitting about "how deserve more respect and we are tearing them down" and it was accompanied by an array of tweets that said "He gets treated like a black guy for 2 weeks and he has a mental breakdown." I think this story even in it's detail loose state is an appropriate weapon to even the fight.
- newacct583 6y ago> Were they not supposed to shoot back when Taylor’s boyfriend shot at them? How about: they should be held responsible for the preventable death of this woman in a situation they directly and deliberately created? Is that not the problem? I don't think anyone is demanding a first degree murder conviction here. They didn't walk in with the intent to kill her. But they sure as shit did kill her, and it's all their fault that it happened. Sounds like open and shut manslaughter to me.
- hkai 6y agoI believe it's classical case where there is enough evidence for a wrongful death civil lawsuit (which will typically end with a 5-10 million dollars settlement), but there is not enough evidence to convict the officers (or the boyfriend) of a crime in a criminal case.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dvtrn 6y agoCharges were dropped against the boyfriend a week ago anyway[0]. [0] https://www.boston25news.com/news/trending/charges-dropped-against-breonna-taylors-boyfriend-police-chief-retires-fbi-joins-probe/MDUWBEGADNHSVKIWVV3G42BZLA/ https://www.boston25news.com/news/trending/charges-dropped-a...
- lalaland1125 6y agoQualified immunity would probably make that civil lawsuit much more difficult.
- Grollicus 6y ago> Obviously nobody expects the police not to shoot back when fired upon Well, I do. We had a case in Germany a few years back where the police served some kind of no-knock warrant, the guy (a Hells Angel) thought they were from a rival gang, shouted at them and then shot at them. A Policeman died, the guy dropped his gun immediately after police identified themselves. The Case made the news later because the guy got acquitted of all charges regarding the killing [1] but that's only secondarily relevant here. For me the main take-away from this should be that there's a difference between shooting back at night against a home invasion and shooting at the police. Just because the police see a situation where someone shoots back in a home invasion-scenario does in no way mean they can expect an intention to shoot at cops. Shooting back at invaders is legal, and the police should not react until they have ruled that out. [1] I suspect that's a german source, sorry. http://www.spiegel.de/panorama/justiz/0,1518,795678,00.html# http://www.spiegel.de/panorama/justiz/0,1518,795678,00.html#
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- MaxfordAndSons 6y agoThat's great that German police are trained to react that way. But American police are not. American police are trained to prioritize their own safety and survival above the safety and survival of suspects or even innocent bystanders. There's no consideration of intention or what information people are acting on - if there's a potentially lethal threat to the policeman, it must be dominated and suppressed. So yes, with a practical understanding of how American police train and operate, this outcome is completely expected.
- hef19898 6y agoIn the above case, the killed officer was already dead. Returning fire would have killed the suspect and maybe more officers. Not to safe if you ask me. Identifying themselves as police was the prudent thing, having done so upfront would most likely have saved an officers live.
- gpm 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- berdario 6y ago> Obviously nobody expects the police not to shoot back when fired upon. I do. They should temporarily cover to safety, understand the situation, announce themselves and attempt to de-escalate. Only if gunfire persist after that, it's reasonable to use deadly force. That's the LAST thing they should do (because in fact, mistakes at that point will be final, with mortal consequences)
- Mirioron 6y agoDoes identifying work though? What's stopping an intruder from doing that? I just don't see how no-knock warrants like this are supposed to work.
- SauciestGNU 6y agoI imagine if they retreat to cover that would allow for a large response by uniformed police in marked vehicles, at which point it would be more clear who they are.
- alistairSH 6y agoI just don't see how no-knock warrants like this are supposed to work. This IS how they work. The police kick down your door, sometimes lob in a few stun grenades, then charge in like they're Rambo. Violence is a feature, not a bug, of this system. The reason no-knocks are used in drug cases is, ostensibly, to prevent destruction of evidence. But, police have come to rely on them (along with armored SWAT teams) for damn near ALL warrants, not just know violent drug offenders. It's high time we banned no-knocks. It's high time we introduced a higher bar to arrest-via-home-invasion. It's high time we held judges accountable for signing warrants. And, probably biggest of all, high time to end the war on drugs as it currently exists.
- masonic 6y agoClinton's ATF actually sought a no-knock warrant for the original Waco raid, but the judge denied it because the evidence sought (illegal machine guns) can't be quickly destroyed. They used no knock tactics anyway, including climbing into upstairs windows with assault weapons.
- arrrg 6y agoWhat you say is obvious is not obvious at all. I expect police not to shoot back if the situation is such that the person that is shooting back could reasonably act in self defense (as was here the case). Then I expect police to take the strategy of simply retreating and getting to safety. Obviously that’s associated with a higher risk for the police but to my mind that is a risk police have to accept if they want to be able to execute search warrants like that. It comes with the territory. The other alternative is to not execute search warrants in that way.
- GVIrish 6y ago> The other alternative is to not execute search warrants in that way. When you boil it all down, this is the answer. The main reasoning behind no knock warrants is to prevent evidence destruction. The harm of a drug dealer flushing some drugs down the toilet versus potentially killing innocent people isn't even in the same ball park. And really, how many flushes can some get in the 15-30 seconds that it takes for cops to rush into the house? Sometimes the argument is that no knocks are for armed and violent suspects but even then it's not clear a no-knock raid makes it any safer for anybody. Police could just as easily wait until someone leaves the house in the morning and execute the arrest with far less risk. Seems like no-knock raids should be outright banned for local law enforcement at the least.
- craftinator 6y ago> Obviously that’s associated with a higher risk for the police but to my mind that is a risk police have to accept if they want to be able to execute search warrants like that. It comes with the territory. I've spent quite a bit of time thinking about this as I'm a former service member who is generally kind of paranoid of people breaking into my safe spaces. In the Marine Corps, there's pretty much two tactical options we are trained to choose from when taking fire: either immediately assault the enemy with fire and maneuver, or break contact and find cover. An immediate assault should only be used if you know the relative size of the enemy, you're rules of engagement support an assault, and there's no hard cover available. Immediately returning fire increases the likelihood of getting your people killed, but retains the initiative, which is great if the enemy force is likely to advance on your position. There is no benefit of doing this if the enemy is just going to sit behind cover taking pot shots; better to draw them out and gain the cover advantage. All of that is to say that the police had NONE of those qualifications. There is literally no reason not to pull back. By returning fire, they put themselves in MORE danger, and for no reason. That is the reaction that untrained animals take, not a disciplined unit.
- pjc50 6y ago> nobody expects the police not to shoot back when fired upon This is often part of the "rules of engagement" that military personnel are expected to follow; not only because they're expected not to shoot civilians, but also peacekeeping situations where firing on the wrong forces could cause WW3, as well as the very basic check that the target isn't wearing the same uniform as you and shooting in your direction by mistake. It's not clear whether the police were firing at the gun-holder here and missed, or whether they were firing blindly through a door, wall, or into a dark area; that is also criminally irresponsible.
- dillonmckay 6y agoBlindly, it seems. The neighboring apartment had several bullets enter, as well. So, zero regard for the safety of anyone.
- trfhuhg 6y agoZero accountability -> zero regard.
- dx034 6y agoI don't think that a police officer thinks of accountability in this situation. It's a high stress situation and with no training all you can do is randomly shoot. Extensive training would be the answer.
- dx034 6y agoAnd zero training. Mandatory weapon training for some US police forces is shockingly short. Other countries train any police officer over months to be able to not only hit targets under stress but also to avoid shooting whenever possible.
- jki275 6y agoI'm not sure what you're suggesting about military "rules of engagement", but military personnel always have the right to defend themselves, including with deadly force, if they are attacked. I suspect you're missing something here or not communicating what you're trying to say very well -- military personnel aren't going to sit around and do nothing if they're being shot at, they're going to return fire, call for artillery on the source of the shooting, call for aircraft support to bomb the source of the shooting, call for a QRF team to help them destroy the source of the shooting, etc. Even "peacekeeping" forces are going to return fire if fired upon.
- save_ferris 6y agoNot to mention they wanted to charge the boyfriend with attempted murder after all that happened.
- dandanqu82 6y agoDid they not charge him with attempted murder? They initially arrested him after the shoot out.
- save_ferris 6y agoThey did, and recently dropped the charges[0]. 0: https://www.wdrb.com/in-depth/prosecutors-drop-attempted-murder-charge-against-breonna-taylors-boyfriend/article_b5456ea4-9c55-11ea-8b48-b353b3ec620c.html https://www.wdrb.com/in-depth/prosecutors-drop-attempted-mur...
- jacquesm 6y ago> Obviously nobody You mean you. I actually do. Without situational awareness the police should hold their fire lest innocent people be murdered. It isn't all that hard to understand, really.
- OGWhales 6y agoIt seems a ton of people took issue with that statement, meaning it wasn’t obvious at all.
- mcv 6y agoThis exactly. You cannot first say people have a right to own guns, a right to defend themselves with them, and a right to shoot intruders in their homes, and then give police a no-knock warrant to enter people's homes unannounced. You're asking police officers to get shot. It's an incredibly stupid and dangerous combination.
- thephyber 6y ago> You're asking police officers to get shot. Technically, police officers are the ones applying for the no-knock warrants which get other police officers shot. And police officers are the ones who pushed for more use of no-knock (something like 10x increase from 30 years ago) because they think it improves their safety (more likely it just allows them to prosecute warrants faster than waiting for the door and risking the suspect destroying evidence before opening the door).
- watwut 6y ago> Obviously nobody expects the police not to shoot back when fired upon. When police creates situation in which the other person has no reason to think they are police, where that person can reasonably think it would be legal to shoot, yes I do. That whole situation was created by police and they had time to prepare. So yes, I expect them not to shoot randomly. It is not reasonable to expect less from police then we expect from civilians.
- leephillips 6y agoWell said. I learned about this incident from the coverage in the NYT, and this was exactly my sequence of reactions. I remember thinking, “wait a second, did I miss something?” at one point, and re-reading the article from the beginning.
- roughfalls 6y agoThe reason USA Today's coverage is best is because the real reporting is coming from the local newspaper, Louisville Courier-Journal. They're a Gannett property so it ends up getting published through USA Today as well.
- DominikD 6y agoI don't think I've seen anything covered by NYT in the past few moths to a year or two that wasn't misrepresenting things. BLM coverage, before that epi coverage, before that many other things (remember how they portrayed Naomi Wu using pejoratives that edgelords use? I do.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jhowell 6y agoThe details are there. It seems you're complaining about their order as evidence of a conspiracy theory, "to make the victim seem more sympathetic." The only conspiracy is that people want those who are not typically victims of these injustices to be inclusive in their thinking about who deserves life and who should make that determination.
- mnm1 6y agoI absolutely expect them not to shoot back. They are the intruders and aggressors. This case is very simple. They broke in, they murdered someone, and they should spend the rest of their lives in jail because of it. What will actually happen is that they will get off because they were shot at while serving a warrant (despite breaking in unannounced) and the victim's family will have no other recourse due to qualified immunity. And the only reason the boyfriend's charges have been dropped is because the case is in the national spotlight and we're having riots now for weeks. Too bad the boyfriend wasn't a better shot. That's the only way justice could have been served here.
- dx034 6y ago> Obviously nobody expects the police not to shoot back when fired upon. They do it in other countries though. Equipped with vests, helmets and shields police forces have much more protection against gunshots compared to the shooter. Even if they're shot at, they have still multiple options to resolve the threat without killing the shooter. But that needs extensive training.
- dkdk8283 6y ago> While he was fully entitled to do that, the NYT doesn’t believe in gun rights so that’s a messy fact. This kind of reporting really needs to stop. There’s plenty of room for color in news and it’s used to its full potential. Wasn’t the FCC fairness doctrine designed to combat this?