4 ms·
I miss the Techshop era, and access to CNC woodworking tools. Now that the documents from the TechShop bankruptcy are out, it's clear that the gym-type busines
by Animats 6y ago
I miss the Techshop era, and access to CNC woodworking tools.
Now that the documents from the TechShop bankruptcy are out, it's clear that the gym-type business model did not work at all. The business was kept going by finding new investors to pay for growth. It never paid for itself from membership fees.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoDo you happen to know approximately how much higher the dues would have to have been to be for it to work?
- Animats 6y agoWell, Human Made in SF has most of the old TechShop machines, and they charge $250 a month, plus they got subsidies under some job training program. TechShop was at $100, then $125, then, as "TheShop.build" (which, we find out in the bankruptcy litigation, was more closely associated with the original operation than previously believed) at $150. This is the SF bay area, though, and the real estate and labor costs dominated. The equipment wasn't really a big fraction of the cost. There are smaller nonprofit shops and hacker spaces, but they tend to have fewer and smaller machines and not enough working room. The surviving spaces are more into the college prep education business - it's where you send your kid to get their STEM ticket punched for college. Lots of kids working through the same canned projects. Some at the construction paper and scissors level, like advanced kindergarten. The fundamental problem with the gym model (pay by the month, come as often as you want) is that people who sign up for shop spaces show up too much. Some are there every day for most of the day, doing work. Gyms rely on only a small fraction of members showing up at any one time. At one point, TechShop had ten laser cutters cutting out Etsy stuff from opening til closing, and the laser cutters were booked weeks ahead. Then Etsy allowed outsourcing manufacturing, that stopped, and the Etsy crowd dropped their memberships.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoThanks, ah, that's an interesting insight re: usage patterns vs normal gyms, it makes a lot of sense to me that you might not have as many people holding the membership sort of aspirationally wrt attendance the same way you do at a fitness gym.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dahdum 6y agoI loved Techshop, I learned so much. The way they aggressively pushed people to invest in their last 2 years was a huge red flag for me though.
- at_a_remove 6y agoYeah. I lucked into something where they (foolishly) offered me all of the classes I could take in three months, so of course I hoovered each class but three up, but I paid attention to the instructors. I spent some time asking them how they liked teaching the classes and watched them pretty carefully, so when I found out that instructors weren't getting paid, I wasn't too surprised. I extended for a couple of months to finish up some projects, but that heavy push at the end is usually the sign of a Membership Death Spiral (if you look at it upside down, it's a pyramid). The folks I quietly warned did not listen and ended up having paid for something they'd never get. I heard of someone at another Techshop who donated some enormous, expensive milling machine to them in exchange for a lifetime membership. Whew. Still miss it.
- dheera 6y agoThe main thing I miss from Techshop is access to a laser cutter. There are an incredible variety of amazing, extremely professional-looking things you can build quickly from craft-grade plywood, a laser cutter, some wood glue, and your favorite wood finish.
- detaro 6y agoAccess to a laser cutter is probably also one of the easier things to find, since they're easy to run compared to many other machines.
- dheera 6y agoAny leads to one in the bay area? I have several friends with access to one which is fine for one-off jobs, but I don't want to keep bugging them to have to use them regularly. I'd rather have some kind of pay-per-hour system where I can access the building and cutter directly and not feel bad about using it regularly, and without having to interrupt friends' work schedules. Ideally it should be less than techshop's steep $170 a month since I really only need a laser cutter, and maybe for only about 3-5 hours a month.
- imtringued 6y agoI don't get it. CNC machines for wood are cheap. Rigidity requirements are fairly low. Some people even built their own CNC machines out of wood. Even a 3 axis CNC mill that does aluminum is reasonably cheap but you'll have to assemble the kit yourself. If you want to do steel then you might as well give up.
- cpwright 6y agoA minimax bandsaw costs about $2-3000. A sawstop around $3000. A jointer/planer combo another $5000. So you're all in for a complete woodworking setup for $10,000. But then you need a couple hundred square feet to put them in with sufficient room around them to store wood, maneuver and perform assembly. At $100/sf for a garage area, you are hitting $20,000. You generally can't just add 200 or 500 sf to your house, and moving is expensive. The space is more expensive than the actual tools that fill it.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoIf you want to have a space intensive hobby then you have to be able to afford the space. This requires either being rich or being somewhere space is cheap or some middle ground between the two. All hobbies have opportunity costs. If you have high culture related hobbies then you are probably going to want to be in a major city which comes with its own trade-offs. I do metalworking. One of my good friends does woodworking. We both live in <1500sf houses and do our hobbies in our basements (I specifically bought a house with a walk in basement for this purpose). The trade-off is that we can't turn our basements into bars, mancaves, TV rooms or sex dungeons. Oh well, just like any other hobby there is an opportunity cost. We both have more money sunk into random odds and ends hand tools, extension cords, lighting, fume extraction, etc. etc. than we do our big tools.
- mauvehaus 6y agoThose are all extremely high end tools though! By comparison, you can probably find a used Unisaw for $500, a used 14" bandsaw for $400, a used 8" jointer for $500-$800 and a used 12" planer for similar if you look around. Yeah, that's a small jointer and planer depending on what you're trying to build, but the point remains that you don't need to spend $10,000 to get started. And I know somebody is going to point out that the Unisaw is less safe than the SawStop, but the SawStop is only going to save you from cutting yourself. It won't save you from kickback; you still need to know how to use the saw safely. The technology isn't a substitute for training. If you can find a local makerspace that has a woodshop, you can trade capex for opex, get access to far bigger and better tools than you'd likely buy starting out, not have to pay for the space to put them in, and likely be able to get training in how to use them safely and effectively.