5 ms·
This is a really poor analogy. The position of captain of on a warship is almost entirely unlike that of a corporate board member and corporate board members of
by pvg 6y ago
This is a really poor analogy. The position of captain of on a warship is almost entirely unlike that of a corporate board member and corporate board members often represent external interests.
- Supermancho 6y ago> This is a really poor analogy. The position of captain of on a warship Trying to show viewpoints in the clearest and most concise way, is the height of discourse. Making a backdoor point by claiming "poor analogy" is basically noise on noise. It muddles both the original point and fails to make a coherent followup. Defining a different set of criteria for what to compare on, does not change the initial comparison in a meaningful way. Define an interpretation (which may get clarified) to focus in on an objection, then form a second viewpoint.
- pvg 6y agoWhat is the specific 'backdoor point' you take issue with? Comparing a thing to a thing that is not that thing is not 'the height of discourse'. The comment made a point, I made a different point. Which is not necessarily the height of but at least qualifies as discourse. I'm not sure what to make of an objection that ends with exhorting me to define an interpretation.
- Supermancho 6y ago> Comparing a thing to a thing that is not that thing is not 'the height of discourse'. That isn't what I said. I will re-quote, that which was stated plainly: >> Trying to show viewpoints in the clearest and most concise way, is the height of discourse. It's usually not worth it to engage with someone who ignores the content, which they are ostensibly criticizing. I will try to answer the main thrust of your post, as a courtesy (you may interpret it as a rehash). > What is the specific 'backdoor point' you take issue with? Creating a second interpretation of an analogy, rather than clarifying (or rephrasing) the point being made. > The comment made a point, I made a different point This is no different than posting "I disagree." AND "I think this..." but without clarity in why you disagree on the original point (not even sure you understand what the original point of the analogy was supposed to be), because you chose to piggy-back with similar terms by using a completely different analogy and implying that it invalidates an argument that was never articulated. This is disingenuous, at the core.
- kortilla 6y agoYou do know that analogies very often compare too very unlike things for the express purpose of their difference, right? “Don’t cut off your nose to spite your face” is very rarely compared with cutting off actual body parts.
- pvg 6y agoMetaphors, similes, idioms, etc are not the same thing as analogies. To make an argument by analogy the things you're analogizing have to be at least somewhat analogous. These plainly aren't. It's possible rayiner thought Siebel would become reddit's CEO. But other than that, it takes a great deal of weird intellectual contortion to compare 'captain' to 'board member'.
- kortilla 6y ago> To make an argument by analogy the things you're analogizing have to be at least somewhat analogous. These plainly aren't. Plainly to you, but perhaps your mind is just overly constrained when it comes to analogies? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analogy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analogy Captain is to ship as board member is to ______? Captain is to helm as board member is to ______? Captain is to first officer as board member is to _____?