6 ms·
Early electric fans
- rrauenza 6y agoIf you're a fan of fans and of Technology Connections, there is an episode where he talks about older fans and why high is the first setting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hQ3GW7lVBWY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hQ3GW7lVBWY
- Animats 6y agoYes, a long discussion of the starting problems of electric motors. That was Tesla's real contribution to motor design - he came up with effective ways to get AC motors started under load.
- wwright 6y agoOh, I thought this was going to be about Tesla and Edison.
- Scoundreller 6y agoThere’s probably a component of that. Probably some where DC and others AC at varying frequencies of input.
- goldenkey 6y agoWould the blades being heavier/metal make these fans less efficient?
- perilunar 6y agoNo. Heavier blades would make them accelerate slower, but once up to speed the weight would make no difference. Thin blades can be less aerodynamically efficient than thicker ones, but plastic fans blades are not very efficient anyway. The biggest disadvantages of metal blades are cost and safety.
- freefal 6y agoWow, the combination of those heavy metal blades and the sparsely placed safety bars definitely doesn't look finger friendly!
- wyattpeak 6y agoI'd suspect those early cages were to prevent accidentally bumping into it, rather than child-safety. Child-safety is a pretty high bar, even if it's common today. You not only have to prevent someone accidentally hurting themselves, but more-or-less intentionally doing so.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoThe kids were already electrocuted by the Edison sockets.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoThe early home installations for electric power where mindbogglingly unsafe.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoI bet the cages nowadays were the result from a lawsuit. A lot of safety precautions (and warnings) are from that. I'm not knocking it, people do need to be protected from themselves (and accidents), I'm objecting to the massive damages lawsuits.
- jayd16 6y agoYes, it seems more like an open air blender than a fan.
- jroseman93 6y agoThis was designed in an era when safety was seen as the responsibility of the user, not the manufacturer. It was your responsibility not to stick your fingers in there, not the manufacturer's responsibility to prevent you from doing so.
- mikestew 6y ago
- fortran77 6y agoIt's amazing anyone from this era had all 10 fingers.
- blacksmith_tb 6y agoI grew up in the early 70s with one of these in my bedroom, probably from the 40s or 50s but still going strong. I never stuck my fingers into the blades, but I did like to toss crayons in and watch the pieces fly...
- Scoundreller 6y agoI took some 120mm fans out of some old servers my brother brought home from his tobacco factory co-op job. I’d wire them to weird voltages (e.g. 12V and -5V, or +5 and -5), cover my eyes with a jewel case and drop small screws in them to hear where it bounced around incredibly fast...
- blueblisters 6y agoI don't know about the torque on the desk fans. But modern ceiling fans have very low torque and kinetic energy: you will probably get away with sticking your hand into one of them with very little damage.
- lqet 6y agoMy grandparents had a completely open fan from the 60ies (although with plastic blades). You could stuck your fingers into it and it would just stop - it hurt a little, but no damage.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoI love this: "My interests are with original and unrestored desk fans made prior to 1916." Since they were invented in 1885 that is basically a 30 year window for a fairly expensive consumer good that probably sold in the neighborhood of a few thousand units. There is something wonderful about diving deeply into a particular kind of thing from a particular time. My Dad has a cap gun collection with a similar narrow window, he even has a book which identifies various cap guns, their makers, their relative rarity etc. Why cap guns? Who knows. He has it significantly easier though since they were stamped out in the hundreds of thousands, maybe millions, during a similar period and were made so that kids could get them (ie very inexpensively). It is a level of curiosity and dedication I can really respect.
- rrmm 6y agoConnoisseurship can make about anything interesting! That said I love fans. I especially love those big old fans that seem to have a speed setting of 'menacingly slow'.
- everybodyknows 6y ago> Why cap guns? Who knows. I know, because 11-year-old me owned one, back when selling them was legal. The reason is nostalgia, or a yearning for the brightness of the world we knew then. Artifacts bring the memories back, in a sweet flood. Experimentation revealed ways in which cap gun tech could be abused. We wanted a louder pop, so how about folding over the tape of caps to double up? Possible, but tends to jam. For a really loud "bang", how about setting a whole roll of caps down on the pavement edgewise, and hitting it with a hammer? Imagine the surprise when the hammer's head came flying back up, faster than it was brought down ...
- frosted-flakes 6y agoWait, they're illegal now? Where? I had those growing up in Canada in the early 2000s. If I remember right, we got them at the dollar store. And yes, I remember hitting a whole ring at once with a hammer.
- 6y ago
- tompic823 6y agoIt's fascinating that desk fans have had such a consistent design for over 100 years. Most surprising to me is that they've been able to oscillate for that long, too (since 1904!): > Direct current desk fans were added in 1899. After acquiring a patent from Charles Eck for an oscillating fan mechanism, R&M put into production their unique DC "lollipop" oscillator in 1904, followed a few years later by an AC version. A sheet brass disk in front of the fan was acted upon by the air from the fan causing the fan to oscillate back and forth. Stops on the base of the fan were contacted by a pin at the bottom of the lollipop shaft to shift the disc to the other side, resulting in the fan oscillating to the other side.
- oldlinux 6y agoThese fans were certainly a luxury item for the time. The average price listed there was about $30. Adjusting for inflation, that's the equivalent of about $750 today (https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=inflation+since+1911+for+%2430+USD https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=inflation+since+1911+f...). Put another way, it was a few weeks worth of the average salary for a railway or steel worker of the era (https://ahundredyearsago.com/2012/09/17/average-salaries-1912-and-2012/ https://ahundredyearsago.com/2012/09/17/average-salaries-191...).
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoEven Dyson's overpriced fans aren't THAT expensive nowadays. That said, I do think there is a market for quality products in a 10-20x price range, products built to last instead of built to be cheap and good enough for a couple years.
- lqet 6y ago> A sheet brass disk in front of the fan was acted upon by the air from the fan causing the fan to oscillate back and forth Is this an accurate description? Here is such a fan in action: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cm7DFuGaujg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cm7DFuGaujg It seems to work because the brass disk is blocking the air stream on one side, so the other side of the fan acts as a jet engine to rotate it, which is actually really clever.
- rrmm 6y agoThe quoted bit seems to take a very neutral stance on exactly how the brass disk is "acted upon". So it's probably correct no matter how things work just due to vagueness.
- jetrink 6y agoWow, that is more violent than I expected! I think both effects are at work. Thought experiment/hypothesis: If you detached the plate and merely held it in front of the fan blades, I think the fan would still rotate due to the decreased airflow on one side of the fan, but it would rotate less quickly since the force that moving air is applying to the plate would no longer be acting on the fan.
- lqet 6y agoYup, I posted the original comment to quickly, the airflow indeed also pushes the brass disk forward, thus rotating the fan! An extremely clever solution that seems to be very easy and cheap to manufacture.
- perilunar 6y ago> the airflow indeed also pushes the brass disk forward The force on the disk is caused by an opposite force on the fan blades, cancelling them out (since they are connected by the frame and the bearings), so it cannot cause the fan to rotate. The rotation is due simply to unbalanced thrust from the fan. The unimpeded side produces more thrust than the impeded side, so the fan turns to that side.
- deleted 6y ago
- Shivetya 6y agoOh wow, I have a six blade Emerson that works except for the oscillator[0]. Absolutely quiet in operation and moves a lot of air. Very heavy and based on the wire guard not super safe around many children, well at least not the ones who want to see what it will chop. In my case I chose it for the blade count and the old ship propeller vibe. There is a shop here in Georgia which does do repair work on fans and I hope to get this one up there one day.[1] You can find a good number of fans, restored and otherwise, on ebay. As with with any ebay suggestion it is best to build up a history to understand pricing. [0] https://i.imgur.com/Z1VglDL.jpg https://i.imgur.com/Z1VglDL.jpg [1] http://electrorestore.com/vintage-antique-fans-repair-service.php http://electrorestore.com/vintage-antique-fans-repair-servic...
- seesawtron 6y agoHere's an antique non-electric fan from the East India Company that still works: https://www.reddit.com/r/Damnthatsinteresting/comments/b41rm9/table_fan_of_1845_used_by_east_india_company/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Damnthatsinteresting/comments/b41rm...
- m4rtink 6y agoLast year we rode a local train in rural Kyushu on Hisatsu Line and while not air conditioned, they had these nice mechanical "orbital" fans inside: https://imgur.com/a/gjlh0Gs https://imgur.com/a/gjlh0Gs
- joncrane 6y agoBased on the scanned catalog page from 1911 and an inflation calculator, it looks like those fans set you back anywhere from the equivalent of $800-1000 in today's money. Is my math correct?
- MrRadar 6y agoNot too surprising. Keep in mind that at the time electricity was a luxury and there were very few home appliances that made use of it. The radio, the first piece of electronics more complex than a simple motor or heater that you might find in the "average" home, wouldn't come into widespread use for another decade.
- cat199 6y agoagree - the person who had this would be somewhat like the modern equivalent of a non-technical person with a fully IoT'ed smarthome running custom controllers and audiophile quality home theater room 15 years ago.. wealthy, and willing to spend to have the latest novelty
- Scoundreller 6y agoThe radio had more of a chicken and egg problem. Once there was a broadcaster, I’d assume there was suddenly a lot of radios. Fans came more gradually because of the physics infrastructure behind electricity. And fans were more of a luxury than a radio that can be used all year.