3 ms·
Presumably for the same reason you wouldn’t get a civil rights activist to replace the captain in a Navy boat. We need people fighting for civil rights, but we
by rayiner 6y ago
Presumably for the same reason you wouldn’t get a civil rights activist to replace the captain in a Navy boat. We need people fighting for civil rights, but we also need to create room for people from diverse backgrounds to do all of the rest of the work that needs doing.
- esperent 6y agoThey're not bringing in a new CEO. All people are asking for is _one_ outsider voice on the board.
- bradlys 6y ago> All people are asking for is _one_ outsider voice on the board. I'm curious what people think the end result of such a thing would be. Does having an outside voice actually contribute to better outcomes for the company? Is there a reason people couldn't just advocate for the current board to listen to other people in their time rather than having a dedicated "outside voice" position? I've seen outsiders come into companies before and fail miserably to accomplish anything because the culture is to not listen to an outsider. It seems like virtue signalling position to take (advocating for one outsider voice rather than systemic change). Who cares if you get a person who is an outsider on a board if it doesn't fundamentally change things. If you want fundamental change, you'll need to kick all those people out and/or shutdown the company. One person would be ignored. You know this is true because we all do this at work already. We've all encountered someone who is that "outside voice" in one way or another - they promptly get ignored in a discussion. "Here's Jim with his crazy ideas - again. :eyeroll:"
- dvtrn 6y agoYou know what? You’re right. Let’s call this what it is: pure virtue signaling. Now that that’s done, what’s next? How can we boost the signal? I like this particular virtue. I think it’s worthy and achievable and more people should be able to tune into it. Admittedly I’m biased as a person with a few differently complexities of melanin in my skin, that has been treated like an outsider in so many different ways, but hell if were signaling virtues let’s be upfront and own this shit and do some good with it. What’s to lose? The integrity of Reddit because they put a black man at the helm? Eh. Worth a shot in my opinion.
- dbuder 6y ago>What’s to lose? The integrity of Reddit because they put a black man at the helm? Eh. Worth a shot in my opinion. You have no skin in the game, sell all your possessions and put it all on black in Vegas, worth a shot in my opinion.
- pvg 6y agoDoes having an outside voice actually contribute to better outcomes for the company? US corporations seem to think so - zillions of businesses have outside directors, it's an established practice.
- rodgerd 6y ago> Does having an outside voice actually contribute to better outcomes for the company? Well, gee, I don't know, maybe having someone ask why it always takes being in the news before Reddit's management decide that it's a bad idea to host underage porn or literal Nazis, rather than, you know, treating it as a bad idea.
- pvg 6y agoThis is a really poor analogy. The position of captain of on a warship is almost entirely unlike that of a corporate board member and corporate board members often represent external interests.
- Supermancho 6y ago> This is a really poor analogy. The position of captain of on a warship Trying to show viewpoints in the clearest and most concise way, is the height of discourse. Making a backdoor point by claiming "poor analogy" is basically noise on noise. It muddles both the original point and fails to make a coherent followup. Defining a different set of criteria for what to compare on, does not change the initial comparison in a meaningful way. Define an interpretation (which may get clarified) to focus in on an objection, then form a second viewpoint.
- pvg 6y agoWhat is the specific 'backdoor point' you take issue with? Comparing a thing to a thing that is not that thing is not 'the height of discourse'. The comment made a point, I made a different point. Which is not necessarily the height of but at least qualifies as discourse. I'm not sure what to make of an objection that ends with exhorting me to define an interpretation.
- Supermancho 6y ago> Comparing a thing to a thing that is not that thing is not 'the height of discourse'. That isn't what I said. I will re-quote, that which was stated plainly: >> Trying to show viewpoints in the clearest and most concise way, is the height of discourse. It's usually not worth it to engage with someone who ignores the content, which they are ostensibly criticizing. I will try to answer the main thrust of your post, as a courtesy (you may interpret it as a rehash). > What is the specific 'backdoor point' you take issue with? Creating a second interpretation of an analogy, rather than clarifying (or rephrasing) the point being made. > The comment made a point, I made a different point This is no different than posting "I disagree." AND "I think this..." but without clarity in why you disagree on the original point (not even sure you understand what the original point of the analogy was supposed to be), because you chose to piggy-back with similar terms by using a completely different analogy and implying that it invalidates an argument that was never articulated. This is disingenuous, at the core.