4 ms·
My company tried to use Google Meet. With a group of around 16 people, Google Meet had all sorts of connection quality issues—people's voices cut out while talk
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
My company tried to use Google Meet. With a group of around 16 people, Google Meet had all sorts of connection quality issues—people's voices cut out while talking, sounded garbled, etc.
A week later, we tried Zoom instead. We could hear everyone clearly. We've used Zoom ever since.
I had some say in the decision to continue with Zoom, and I feel kind of bad about choosing it, but it's hard to argue with the results. We had similar issues with Slack video calls (although we still use those for small groups—not my decision!), Microsoft Teams, and a product from LogMeIn called Join.Me. Unlike Zoom but like Google Meet, these products are all based on WebRTC, and I'm starting to conclude that WebRTC is just a crappy technology for large-group video calls.
We admittedly haven't tried Jitsi. Perhaps I'm part of the problem, but I don't want to be the one to suggest a random product no one has heard of. Especially when that product is also based on WebRTC.
- gniv 6y ago> Google Meet had all sorts of connection quality issues When was this? Google Meet has gotten a lot better in the last few weeks.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoAbout two months ago, so maybe it would be better now.
- matwood 6y agoI made a note above that Zoom getting popular apparently lit a fire under Meet. It's gone from terrible to pretty good in a very short amount of time.
- Larrikin 6y agoA little bit more than a few weeks ago when lock down was in full effect when everyone realized that products like Skype, line video, and Google meet etc had all had these massive head starts but were left to languish and were all actually awful when it actually matters. The more I learn about zoom as a company the more I can't wait to delete it but all the comparable products have all been terrible in comparison.
- behnamoh 6y agoThe reason I'm not using Google Meet is because there's no guarantee about the continuity of the service a few years down the road. I think it's a reasonable fear about every Google product (except for search, gmail, and YT). I don't wanna rely on a service that gets discontinued by Google just like their other popular products e.g. Reader, Plus, Glass, etc.
- mpfundstein 6y agowhat does that matter now? its not that there is a high cost of switching...
- paulryanrogers 6y agoStrongly agree. It seems every few months or years the tide shifts and we all move to something else. And one may use different choices for different groups or larger or smaller audiences. No need to emotionally invest.
- marakv2 6y agoFor us, teaching children online, the cost of switching would be huge. I was on the team that chose zoom (which I now have reservations about, but that horse has bolted). During the initial discussions, Google dropping products was brought up and was our primary reason for not picking their product.
- bakul 6y agoIf it works well enough, it would be a fine choice to connect with your friends/colleagues while you are stuck at home due to the corona virus. A few years down the road there will be new products!