8 ms·
Reflecting dangerous soundwaves back to the police may be prosecuted as assault on a police officer, a serious crime (automatic felony in NYC, for instance).
by bitwize 6y ago
Reflecting dangerous soundwaves back to the police may be prosecuted as assault on a police officer, a serious crime (automatic felony in NYC, for instance).
- ashtonkem 6y agoThat really bugs me. If it’s a crime to reflect back onto the cops, why wasn’t it a crime for them to use it without justification?
- gimboland 6y ago~~without justification~~ FTFY.
- ashtonkem 6y agoThe past week has shown that cops are absolutely willing to use injurious force without even the slightest shred of justification, and then lie badly about it. In such a situation, it’s not clear why a group of people that acts this way should be given any equipment at all, let alone the legal authority to use it based on their own word alone.
- yeetawayhn 6y ago> The past week has shown that cops are absolutely willing to use injurious force without even the slightest shred of justification, and then lie badly about it. But you just said you couldn't prove this above... Which is it?
- ashtonkem 6y agoYou can’t prove a negative. You can however point out that no justification was given, or that the justification given was a blatant lie. Given that we live in a constitutional republic that provides rights to all citizens, any use of force on them that lacks justification is therefore unjustified.
- Talanes 6y agoNo, they said they could not prove themselves to have done nothing. I know those things feel equivalent, but they represent entirely opposite ends of perspective. In the scenario they have to prove themselves innocent, the cop needs provide no justification.
- yeetawayhn 6y agoNo, their claim isn't that they didn't throw tear gas at the police, but that they were justified in doing so.
- bitwize 6y agoThe cops can arrest you, throw you in jail and prevent you from contacting your lawyer before you get a chance to show you had justification.
- ashtonkem 6y agoAnd even if they don’t have justification for use of force, unless if there’s a super narrow precedent showing they shouldn’t have, they’re immune from lawsuit. And since qualified immunity dismisses lots of cases, very few new precedents are being created. The total effect is that if you have a device created after QI was invented by the courts, you’re effectively totally immune.
- hootbootscoot 6y agoOr why isn't it a crime to use it or any other permanent-damage-causing tech in the first place. Rubber/plastic bullets have cost how many eyes at this point? There IS NO justification for LE to use this stuff, as their charter in the case of protests is about maintaining peace and de-escalating any confrontational violence that may occur. The very notion of being a force confronting/opposed to protesters is WRONG, as they should be de-escalating things, and THIS is the greater issue. LE is waging war upon protesters instead of providing security services.
- CompanionCuuube 6y ago"Why is it a crime if I detain criminals but not a crime if the police do?"
- jakelazaroff 6y agoExcept in this case it's being used unlawfully on peaceful civilians, and the only reason there are no consequences is that the people using it are cops.
- CompanionCuuube 6y agoIn that case, it's a matter of proving to the courts that it was being used unlawfully on peaceful civilians.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoThat won’t work; the entity responsible for investigating such a claim is the same one unlawfully attacking peaceful civilians in the first place.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ashtonkem 6y agoThe clause “without justification” in my original comment matters a lot, do not ignore it. Cops might have the legal right to use force, but they must have clear justification for that application. Indiscriminate application of tools designed to injure people by the police should be a crime, but in practice it does not appear to be so.
- CompanionCuuube 6y agoIn that case be prepared to defend the claim of it being without justification. Which if it truly is as clear cut as you're making it out to be, should not be a problem at all.
- emsy 6y agoSad to see you downvoted for stating a possible (and in my personal opinion expectable) outcome of using the device.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoAgreed — I didn't read it as a moral condemnation as much a word of caution.
- tehjoker 6y agoPeople throw tear gas back at police all the time. shrug
- jakelazaroff 6y agoYes, and people are prosecuted for it. https://www.al.com/news/2020/06/alabama-protester-arrested-for-throwing-chemical-agent-back-at-police.html https://www.al.com/news/2020/06/alabama-protester-arrested-f... https://www.stltoday.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/ferguson-protester-who-threw-back-tear-gas-cannister-in-iconic-photo-is-charged/article_437076f9-a6a2-5f03-a2fb-d612611a504f.html https://www.stltoday.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/ferguso...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jascii 6y agoI'd seriously doubt any court will consider a defensive move like deflecting sound waves while under duress as an assault. On top of that,the effectiveness of a single point-source falls with the inverse square of the distance so the effectiveness of this "assault" would likely be minimal.
- sp332 6y agoA federal district court agreed that bleeding on an officer's uniform constitutes the crime of property damage. https://newsone.com/3159860/ferguson-man-charged-with-bleeding-on-cops-wins-appeal/ https://newsone.com/3159860/ferguson-man-charged-with-bleedi...
- jascii 6y agoThat's pretty absurd! And did get reversed in appeal.
- trhway 6y agomoney quote: " a reasonable officer could have believed that beating a subdued and compliant Mr. Davis while causing only a concussion, scalp lacerations and bruising with almost no permanent damage did not violate the Constitution,” the district court ruled in tossing out the case." With even federal judges like that i wonder what hope can be there at all.
- ashtonkem 6y agoNew York courts have suspended Habeas Corpus, despite indication from the DA office that they had no intention to charge the vast majority of those arrested for breaking the curfew. Another judge rubber stamped an subpoena against reason for mean but non-threatening comments against the FBI (“go to hell” I believe was the phrase), and a gag order preventing reason from talking about it. Do not underestimate the willingness of the courts to rubber stamp shocking abuses by the police. They are, after all, the ones that made up QI.
- seph-reed 6y ago"I'm rubber, you're glue. Whatever you say bounces off of me and sticks to you"
- fooey 6y agoYeah, they've been charging protesters who throw tear gas back at the police with assault with a deadly weapon Because the hypocrisy of American policing wasn't obvious enough already. > He also was arrested for what police say was “assault with a deadly weapon on a police officer” and resisting or obstructing an officer. The deadly weapon apparently was a tear gas canister that police tossed toward him and other protesters and alleged he tossed back in their direction. https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/06/06/protester-recounts-getting-attacked-by-police-dogs-tear-gassed-at-walnut-creek-demonstration/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/06/06/protester-recounts-ge...
- ColanR 6y agoAre the police legally allowed to assault protesters "with a deadly weapon"? Otherwise, it seems like a countersuit would be in order. "Police claim they were assaulted, therefore they admit to assaulting us."
- cmpb 6y agoSpecial training would be my guess at the suit defense tactic here. Police are trained to toss the item in such a way that it’s not considered assault, etc. Same reason police are allowed to use the giant screens in their cars while they’re driving.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rootusrootus 6y agoIs this really a question? Police are allowed to fire rubber bullets at you. Tasers. Pepper spray. You name it, they have lots of tools to use against citizens that are completely illegal for citizens to use right back.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoThat is not correct — it is illegal for anyone to attack you unprovoked, even a police officer. Without cause, they are not allowed to fire rubber bullets at you, nor are they allowed to tase or pepper spray you. The only reason they get away with it is that they are unwilling to enforce the law against themselves.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- seniorsassycat 6y agoPassive defence? It's the operators fault for pointing at a reflective surface, they should have received better training.