3 ms·
I really wish this article included the argument behind the claim that "+4°C world would support < 1 billion people". I can understand why it'd be a very differ
by SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
I really wish this article included the argument behind the claim that "+4°C world would support < 1 billion people". I can understand why it'd be a very different world, and why there might be a lot of struggles on the way, but the idea that it'll be literally impossible to grow enough food doesn't make much sense to me. Why couldn't we support the same number as today by planting slightly more heat-tolerant crops?
- baq 6y agothere won't be enough rain in places where things can grow. basically at +4C average the atmosphere is a completely different beast, it's not entirely clear if this amount of CO2 actually allows for clouds to form.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoDo you have a pointer to scientific analyses where I can read about this? It was my understanding that moderate increases in temperature tend to increase rainfall, and I've certainly never heard anything about clouds being unable to form.
- baq 6y agothis is recent: https://www.sciencealert.com/high-levels-of-co2-could-stop-these-cooling-clouds-from-forming-warn-scientists https://www.sciencealert.com/high-levels-of-co2-could-stop-t... though the question is not new. i'm pretty sure i've seen it in the original 1982 exxon research, but can't locate it at the moment.
- gus_massa 6y agoThe problem is not that the increase of concentration of CO2 cause a direct problem in the clouds, in that model the problem is caused by the increase of the temperature. Also, it's a problem that they get with a +8°C increase that is a lot, the double of the +4°C disused here.
- baq 6y agomy understanding is that they say that it's the +4-5C given only CO2 but actually ends up at +8C from the lack of clouds which provide shade and cooling.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI certainly can't justify the actual number, but we have very little in the way of drought tolerant crops. Most plants that produce a lot of calories - from potato to avocado - require plenty of fresh water. If there is suddenly a shortage of water for irrigation, and of natural rainfall, most crops will fail. I am talking about crops failing in Europe, the areas that are already arid are totally fucked. There are two possible remedies: cultivation of new drought resistant breeds, and glasshouses. Cultivation of neew breeds takes decated, even with GMOs. To date we have never demonstrated adding drought resistance to a staple crop to the extent that it would survive significant droughts. Could it be done if suddenly unlimited funding became avaliable? Who knows. Regarding glasshouses, they are technically capable of supplying food with massively reduced water usage, because evaporation can be cobtrolled. Per unit area, a glasshouse can be >10x as productive as a field. The challange is that they are massive and take a long time to build because of scale required. There is also a massive difference how advanced and effective a glasshouse might be. Your average glasshoe in a backyard isn't gonna cut the mustard. However, netherlands is the world's second largest exporter of fruit & veg and they are a tiny country, this is all due to glasshouses. Currently only a miniscule amount of your caleries come from greenhouses. We are talking about a decade-ish to cover enough agricultural land to make a difference.
- Udik 6y ago> If there is suddenly a shortage of water for irrigation, and of natural rainfall, most crops will fail. Are climate change scenarios predicting less rainfall on average? It seems that the total volume of precipitation is going to increase, not decrease. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2011/dec/15/climate-change-rainfall https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2011/dec/15/climate-...
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoThat's a good point, and that's an area I don't understand. It's important to look at length of dry spells, which will kill crops, rather than just average precipitation.
- 6y ago
- loopz 6y agoRapid warming may destroy/displace >= 90% of life as we know it. It's happened before and we have records of it below the surface. Also >= 10°C is seen as mass-destructive even if slowly introduced. We're not potentially heading there before a couple of hundred years, but the cascading nature of unknown effects doesn't make such scenario too unlikely and even a middle path will be largely destructive in the meanwhile.