6 ms·
This is a decent account of how much has changed, and he conveys the sense of alienation well. But what strikes me is that he talks about the whole thing like s
by wpietri 6y ago
This is a decent account of how much has changed, and he conveys the sense of alienation well. But what strikes me is that he talks about the whole thing like something that unaccountably happened to him. He didn't install botnets; he was arrested for installing botnets. Botnets that he somehow sees as part of the "true spirit of hacking", from the long-lost innocent age of 2009, when pure curiosity was the only motive. In reality, the botnets of the time were a) industrial-scale commandeering of other people's gear, and b) widely used for spam, DDOSing, and crime. [1]
I am perfectly willing to believe that his sentence was egregious, as federal prosecution is often more about a prosecutorial win than any real sense of justice. But given that he still seems unable to take responsibility for his choices, I could also be persuaded that having him away from a computer for a decade was perhaps on net the best thing for society.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Botnet#Historical_list_of_botnets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Botnet#Historical_list_of_botn...
- mcv 6y agoThat struck me too. A guy who installed botnets complaining about how "the true spirit of hacking" was lost. Botnets are a plague. Try cracking Windows 10 to make it play nicer, if you want to feel good about hacking.
- Drunkfoowl 6y agoKeeping in mind, this guy was installing botnets while interfacing directly with some fairly active hacking communities. He even says that his trophy book wasnt "everything" with the coy of someone who feels like they still have the edge. It's easy to jump to a conclusion that he fully intended to use the botnet maliciously.
- brassattax 6y agohe obviously hasn't seen WSL yet, or VirtualBox
- wuunderbar 6y agoFair points. For me it was just interesting to read about his views about himself (implicitly) and how he observed everything happening in the last decade. It's quite a unique and informative perspective as a sort of culture piece.
- fsloth 6y agoAll of his hacker ethos feels very superficial to me. I.e. get this or that gizmo under control etc. There does not seem to be a deep curiosity for CS or maths as such, rather a childish joy in opening other peoples locks and taking other peoples hardware under control. That was cool in the 70's when telecoms infrastructure wasn't commoditized. I understand how enticing it is to hack big co telephone networks, for example. Big, big machines with very strict access rights. 2009. Computing and communications infrastructure is commoditized. The world is literally swimming in computers. There is no unusual computing or telecoms capability you can harness by breaking into another system. It just means you want to break into the system instead of actually using your own. It's pedestrian and rude, like stealing someone's umbrella. Plus, he breached the implicit trust in him as an employer. 10 years is a lot, though, for bad taste and disappointing social graces.
- jonny_eh 6y agoThese days it's more interesting, and justified, to hack into your own hardware, that you legally bought and own.
- fsloth 6y agoYes. The direct analogue is trying to pick your own lock, versus picking a lock in someone else's property just for kicks.
- facorreia 6y agoNot even picking locks. More like smashing people's windows, grabbing food from their fridges while enjoying the satisfaction of being a l33t hax0r.
- ta17711771 6y agoA better analogy might be using the same encryption key Volkswagen and Audi were shipping as security to every car to steal a car...
- 6y ago
- VLM 6y agoWhat you're convicted for in a plea deal is usually a step or two down from what you actually did. So the prosecutor office can claim a large number of successful cases in exchange for lighter punishment. There's different stories for what you actually did, what they think you did, what they can prove you did, what they think they can convince a non-technical jury of what you did, what the DOJ/FBI traditionally self congratulatory press release claims, what the plea bargain deal was for. Usually those multiple stories are only minimally tangentially related at best. The somewhat overly self congratulatory DOJ US attorney press release from May 14, 2010 claims the guy got himself hired as a security guard to gain partial physical access, then did all this Hollywood style breaking and entering into secured locations he wasn't authorized to be in, removed the anti-virus from at least 14 machines, downloaded a password cracker from the internet, made an "instructional" video of the process. They couldn't prove he did anything TO the HVAC controller or nurses confidential access station, so the press release is full of "could have" and "would have" but kinda imply he sorta did but nothing bad happened and they can't prove nothing so... Now in contrast to the above, his plea deal was exactly two counts of transmitting a malicious code. No breaking and entering, the other dozen machines seem to have disappeared, nothing illegal was accessed or modified, nobody seems concerned he cracked the passwords solely what he did afterwards on two of the machines, etc. I can see how his description of what he did vs what he did time for vs what he actually did seems a bit dissociated.