3 ms·
Oil and coal and nitroglycerin have caused similar destruction, yet you don't see comments like yours about them, so I find it specious to suggest that nuclear
by chc 16y ago
Oil and coal and nitroglycerin have caused similar destruction, yet you don't see comments like yours about them, so I find it specious to suggest that nuclear acquired its stigma honestly. At any rate, we have no better long-term option for power than nuclear AFAIK.
- sliverstorm 16y agoOf all peoples in the world, honestly I would cut the Japanese the most slack for being fearful of nuclear. We did drop two nuclear bombs on their cities, after all.
- chc 16y agoThat's a very good observation. If the fear of nuclear power came about because of the harm it had done, the Japanese should have hated it like crazy. And yet AFAIK they're generally much less cowardly than we are.
- joe_the_user 16y ago"Oil and coal and nitroglycerin have caused similar destruction, yet you don't see comments like yours about them.." Well, perhaps because my comment did not concern the very real dangers of these things but rather concerned the very real and irrational fear evoked by nuclear power. What does "honestly" mean in these circumstances??? ---> However nuclear power acquired it's stigma, the question is whether any proponents of it has a plan for removing that stigma.
- chc 16y ago"Honestly" means "without a strong effort to incite fear." People fear nuclear because they are told nuclear is scary, not because it has caused a relatively small amount of destruction.
- joe_the_user 16y agoReally? Is it just a matter of media mismanagement or something? People have "been told" to fear radiation AND people have been told not to fear radiation. Somehow the fear "stuck"? Why? And how do you propose changing that?
- tptacek 16y agoHe is (very reasonably) expressing frustration at your attempt to reify an irrational fear. If measurable increases in carcinogenesis merit public policy discussions, it is reasonable --- probably imperative, in fact --- that we begin our discussions with things that actually cause cancer. Before you get to talk about the cost/benefit of producing electricity without nuclear power, we have to ban red meat.
- Retric 16y agoIn my mind there is a significant gap between someone who get's cancer from choosing to eat red meat, and someone who get's cancer from a coal power plant 200 miles away. Each coal power plant in the US kills a little over 1 person per day yet because you can't track the death to a specific power plant nobody get's sued etc. PS: Economics suggest the appropriate action in such situation is to tax the Externality and let the market decide. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality
- neutronicus 16y agoRadiation is tailor made to be scary. The negative outcome for someone outside the nuclear industry has a name: cancer. The negative outcome for someone outside the coal industry (respiratory illness) is less well-defined, less likely to be attributed to coal, and less likely to cause someone to die unusually young. That last is important - old people and people with asthma die from air pollution. Otherwise healthy people can contract radiation-induced cancer. The mechanism by which nuclear plants produce negative outcomes (radiation) is also poorly understood and imperceptible, whereas one can see smog and kinda tell when it's a code red day out. It's not just that there's some destruction - it's that the destruction can't be understood, perceived, or planned for until it's too late. People's fear of nuclear power is irrational, but it doesn't necessarily depend entirely on propaganda.
- tptacek 16y agoYou can say exactly the same set of things about smog, the soot that blackens a grilled hamburger, the hamburger itself, and the breakdown products of the oil that fries the french fries that go with the burger.
- neutronicus 16y agoDo you mean in so far as those things are carcinogens?
- tptacek 16y agoThey are not only carcinogens, but carcinogens that (from what I can tell) are almost by definition worse than 100msv radiological exposures, in that radiological exposure is one of the purer sources of carcinogenesis we can measure, and 100msv is the floor of our ability to measure it. Compare that to eating four or more serving of red meat in a week (hardly a crazy amount in the US or Argentina); that corresponds to a lifetime cancer risk comparable to having been a former longtime active smoker. Smoking will reliably give you cancer. 100msv of radiation will give one out of some huge number of people like you cancer. Probably.