3 ms·
Everything in this article is wrong. The moment you question any of it, it becomes obvious it’s nonsense. In America at least, elite university’s are private so
by LatteLazy 6y ago
Everything in this article is wrong. The moment you question any of it, it becomes obvious it’s nonsense. In America at least, elite university’s are private so they don’t cost society. And even in state institutions, the amount that state(s) contribute has been falling rapidly. The USA has a private system run according to the whims of donors. You might think it “should” be a meritocracy as part of a wider fair society. I might even agree. But that’s not what it is. Complaining it’s bad at that when that isn’t what it’s for is... not even wrong.
And that’s before we get to the thrust of the article...
Pfft.
- EliRivers 6y agoAre you interpreting "cost to society" as "money that is paid by the state" and nothing more? I suspect many people have a broader definition of "cost to society" than just "how much money the public purse has to give to someone".
- LatteLazy 6y agoHow would you work out the cost to society of elite universities? I'm happy to consider other things. I should disclose that I think the US has very little society, the US is very much about individuals alone or in small groups, not a society as a whole. That's another side of the point I make above. In Europe these institutions are overwhelmingly publically funded and part of a wider social fabric. In the US the opposite is true...
- EliRivers 6y agoIf we consider the cost of something to be "that which has to be given up to have it", then part of the cost of smart people going to elite universities and being funneled into finance is that they don't get funneled into doing something useful [0]. Much as a number of very smart people get funneled into coming up with ways to sell advertising space on the Facebook. These smart people could have gone into any number of industries that are a lot more useful to society (which basically means "other people") than finance and selling adverts. [0] Harsh and hyperbolic for effect, but it makes a point.
- LatteLazy 6y agoThat's a fine measure of cost. But then we have to ask the same question: what is the alternative? * Those smart kids could go to state institutions. But then we would need to fund those institutions so they could get a comparable education to the one they would get going to an elite university. And we have been cutting those very funds for decades (and increasing the amounts spent on sport stadiums instead of educational facilities). So that won't work. * we could move them once they graduate from finance to socially useful professions like education. But then we'd have to pay teacher like we pay bankers and no one wants that. Everyone agrees education is important, but not important enough to fund teachers. Same for researchers or medics or social workers or defence attorneys. People going into finance are making a rational informed choice that we encourage. If we really want less bankers and more teachers, we should pay for it. There are plenty of disillusioned finance workers who would come over (I am one of them), they just don't want to be charged for making the world a better place...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mrcorona 6y agoIf we had chosen not to financialize a large % our economy, the fastest route to paying off school loans wouldn't be wasted talent in finance. We will pay for the poor choices we made in the 70s-80s until the process of dedollarization is complete.
- thatcat 6y agoThat's a false dichotomy, maybe they could work on decreasing the rate of climate change instead of increasing it.
- jgunaratne 6y agoIn developing countries many of the best and brightest leave. Society in those countries finds it harder to advance and improve without talent to drive innovation. In the developed world, the talent is there, but it's used inefficiently. Would society be better off if smart people directed their energy towards developing vaccines instead of high frequency trading? The writer of the article thinks so, but the incentive systems direct talent towards the latter activity.
- LatteLazy 6y agoI get the thrust of the article. I just think he's totally misunderstood the world. In America, if you are one of the best and brightest (or if you're not) you're on your own. No one will pay for your education. But then, when you're done, you don't owe anyone else. If you want to go do HFT, that's up to you. There is no social argument to be made there. In Europe, life is different. The same logic applies to his "meritocracy" soap box: if America was a meritocracy then... Oh wait it's not so why would I complete a sentence based on a false premis? And that's without getting into whether we actually need more vaccines or whether HFT is useful even if you don't know why...
- wobbly_bush 6y agoIn developing countries the best and brightest can't do much without a supporting eco system. For example, several Indians come to the US and get jobs as software engineers in the best companies. But the same employees wouldn't be able to produce similar work while working from India in the same companies (anecdotal evidence) as more is needed for a functioning team than just developers. This is the case for most jobs.
- IvyMike 6y agoTo me, the core of the article is this: > The upshot is that many of the country’s best and brightest are either exerting their talents trying to beat each other out in a zero-sum trading game, or exploiting legal and behavioral loopholes to part investors from their money. A lot fo these graduates make a lot of money this way, and I don't blame people who do it--but it does feel like a waste of talent and expertise.
- LatteLazy 6y agoFull disclosure: I weirdly strongly agree. I work in finance but I'm a really good teacher, I tutor, I did youth work before I turned 30, I hope to return to it one day. I should be a (socially useful) teacher., That said, society has decided that teaching is worthless. No one says that out loud. But it's 100% what we have decided as a society. That decision has been in place since I was in school in the 90s. Its spanned administrations, economic conditions, booms and busts. If we gave a shit about education, we'd fund it. But we don't. Everyone agrees its vitally important, until it's time to pay 1% more tax so a school can have a working fire alarm. I feel like the author is blaming macdonalds employees for the fact no one is ordering salad. But on a national scale. Why not just be honest and say it: people want Ez credit and low taxes and if their kids come home with lead poisoning from the school paint, they're OK with that. We'll, not ok with it, but not willing to pay a dime to prevent it... Its not Harvards fault or the fault of the "best and brightest" that we don't want the things we're meant to want. Expecting the best and brightest to throw their lives away and work shitty jobs because it would be nice is pretty fucking rich and cheap
- ikeyany 6y agoSociety values teaching quite a bit actually. People pay thousands upon thousands for private schools, tutors, and specialized classes. It's the citizenry that we deem worthless. That's why there's no money in public education.
- LatteLazy 6y agoYes, that's correct. I should have drawn a line between the two. But then of course, you're encouraging the exact thing the author objects to: private institutions for people who actually care (and have some cash to prove it)
- BlackNitrogen 6y agoI think working in the financialization industry is a form of destructive waste. That's the gist of the idea. But that judgement is a very subjective thing, because why is my software helping society any better? I'm making new and better ways to program robots. Sooo, could better autonomous systems lead to job loss? Potentially, sure.